A trend has emerged when the Penguins struggle as they did during Monday’s 4-2 loss to the Anaheim Ducks at PPG Paints Arena.

They’re not nearly as consistent as they would like, or need, to be.

The Penguins’ starts have been good — their first-period goal differential of plus-14 ranks among the NHL’s best — but far too often the wheels have come off in the middle 20 minutes.

“I think it’s our problem this year,” Evgeni Malkin said after the Penguins turned a 2-0 lead into a 3-2 deficit by basically taking a 20-minute nap. “We led by a couple goals. We tried to play casual.

Advertise with us

“We didn’t play right, and we lost the game.”

Malkin is more right than he probably knows.

The Penguins are now 15-12-6. In those 18 losses, they have a second-period goal differential of minus-18 (12-30). Overall, the Penguins have a goal differential of minus-4 in the second, which means the lack of consistency has been more pronounced in their losses.

For context, the Ducks entered Monday’s games as one of the league’s worst second-period teams, lugging a goal differential of minus-13 (31-44), but they seemed to have little trouble in the middle 20 Monday night.

Adam Henrique, Kiefer Sherwood and Ondrej Kase scored to turn what looked to be a lopsided win for the Penguins into one of their more frustrating defeats this season, one that probably calls into question how much progress this team has actually made.

Advertise with us

But even though Anaheim — which has now won 11 of 13 to resuscitate its season — was opportunistic in the second, the Penguins were also entirely too charitable. Consider:

• Zach Aston-Reese took a penalty just 13 seconds into the second period, which led to Henrique’s power-play goal. Sidney Crosby followed that with a tripping minor less than a minute after Henrique scored.

“Then it snowballs from there,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said.

• Sullivan isn’t wrong, and the Penguins’ offense actually went into a deep freeze. Nobody had a shot on goal for a span of 12:21 between Bryan Rust’s first-period tally and Marcus Pettersson’s zero-threat wrister from 56 feet at 6:53 of the second.

No forward had a shot on goal in a stretch of 17:23 that lasted until Aston-Reese’s tip attempt at 11:55.

Advertise with us

• Meanwhile, Sherwood scored off a terrible turnover from Jake Guentzel — that earned him a second-period spot on the bench — and Kase popped in a rebound off a faceoff late in the period.

“We didn’t have a very good second period,” Matt Cullen said. “We put ourselves in a good spot after the first. We came out flat in the second and paid for it.”

The problems for the Penguins were familiar: puck management, specifically at the blue lines. Guentzel made the most egregious error, but he was hardly alone. The Penguins had 12 giveaways to just two for the Ducks in this game, including five in the second period alone.

“It’s an important part of the rink,” Sullivan said of his team’s play at the blue lines. “It’s something we talk about almost daily. It’s not always about trying to score or making plays. Sometimes it’s about making sure you don’t feed your opponent’s transition game because you become high-risk.”

Guentzel did that when he made a careless pass at the offensive blue line, and the Ducks took it the other way. Jack Johnson stepped into a check and lost track of Sherwood, who smartly used the Penguins’ other defenseman on the ice at the time, Olli Maatta, as a screen.

Advertise with us

“It just snuck through some legs,” Casey DeSmith said of the goal. “He kind of pulled it on the other side of the defenseman and shot it through some legs. It’s really hard to pick it up sometimes when it does that. At the same time, it’s a straight shot, so I hate getting beat like that, obviously.”

The second period became even more painful for the Penguins when they recovered nicely in the third. They outshot the Ducks 13-7 overall, held a 7-1 edge in five-on-five scoring chances and a 3-0 lead in high-danger chances, but the only goal was Ryan Getzlaf’s empty-netter late.

There was a terrific chance to tie it, too, whenever Kase and Josh Manson took minor penalties 1:43 apart early in the third, though the Penguins couldn’t beat Ducks goaltender John Gibson despite firing seven shots on the Whitehall native.

“We would’ve liked to have scored in the third period when we got those back-to-back power-play opportunities,” Sullivan said. “We’ve got a chance to tie the game there.”

Again, Sullivan is 100- percent correct. But the takeaway from Monday’s loss shouldn’t be the power play failing to score on two chances despite generating seven shots. Play the percentages there. It’s fine.

Advertise with us

The concerning part should be putting together a consistent effort, both inside of 60 minutes and beyond. Despite thrusting themselves back into playoff position with their current 8-4-2 stretch, the Penguins still have failed to win three in a row since that lengthy, Canadian trip back in October.

If the Penguins are to become the team they think they can be — and that’s Stanley Cup contender capable of hanging around with Tampa, Toronto and Washington — then sooner rather than later they must develop more of a consistent approach.

“Obviously we’d like to be more consistent,” Cullen said. “That’s something we talk about. We haven’t found our consistent, 60-minute game. We’ve been able to win some games without playing our best hockey, but that eventually catches up to you if you don’t string together solid games.

“We’ve shown stretches of playing some really good hockey. When we do that, we get results. It’s frustrating. We’re all frustrated with it.

“Those are two points we’d really like to have here at home. We have to find a way to continue to build. We’re not there yet. We’re in a decent spot, but we need to get there.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.