Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Welcome to my Thursday chat. Let's get this thing started ...

james: Could DeSmith be a valuable trade chip? I know it's risky but you need to see if Murray can be your goalie going forward

Jason Mackey: I really don't think so, James. I could see them trading Jarry before DeSmith. They've been really happy with Casey. Matt is a bit of an unknown at this point. The feeling on Jarry is that he's still not ready. With Casey being as cheap as he is, you keep guys like that around.

Steven: What is the plan going forward with Bill Guerin? I don't have a particularly high opinion of him, given the rosters he's created in the AHL as well as his mishandling of the veteran rule this year (which lead to the Elliott/Sexton trade). Does the organization think highly of him as a potential replacement?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I don't think so, Steven. I don't think the organization has anything against Guerin, per se; however, if Rutherford were to leave, I really don't think Guerin would be the replacement. I think they would conduct a search. I think they think Guerin still has some work to do before he's ready. I also don't think GMJR is anywhere near ready to leave, either.

Hockey Fairy Princess: Hi Jason. Love your work. I’m a relatively new hockey/Penguins fan, so maybe I’m missing something, but I’m puzzled how the Head of the Department of Player Safety for the NHL (George Parros) can have a stake in a company called Violent Gentlemen which sells a hat that says “Make Hockey Violent Again”. And, don’t get me wrong, I like a decent/justifiable hockey fight just like any HFP, but this just seems like bad optics for the NHL. Don’t you think it’s ironic that the person responsible for player safety also has a stake in a company which sells products promoting more violence in hockey? But, maybe this is the explanation for some of the decisions that come out of that department. Just wondered if you knew about this connection and what you thought about it. Thanks!

Jason Mackey: I can't imagine Parros has any stake left in the company, which is sort of detailed here: https://www.sportsnet.ca/hockey/nhl/ex-nhler-parros-focuses-on-violent.... However, I think it's fair obvious how big of a misstep this is for the NHL. Having one of your biggest goons run the Player of Safety? It almost seems like a joke, except it's not. Of course Parros sees some things as perfectly OK that others would deem criminal. I can't give you a good explanation, honestly, other than the league is woefully behind the times with injury stuff and how it promotes itself, and this is a big part of that. Why not have a three-person panel? Or at least someone who practiced good sense while he played? It's nuts.

Doley: I realize it's a long season and you can't play each game like a Game 7. But what's the process for choosing not to put forth an effort, like last night? It is a collective decision, is it more left up to each guy individually, etc?

Jason Mackey: Ha. I don't think they plan it, believe me. It's the same as it is for all of us. I don't wake up Tuesday and say, 'I'm going to write like crap Friday.' Sometimes it just happens. Over the course of 82, you're going to have bad ones. The problem with the Penguins this season is they've happen more frequently than is acceptable, and they're simply not able to string anything together. Last night was just sloppy. Too many defensive miscues, careless managing the puck, like the other team just wasn't going to do anything to them, and they got burned.

Advertise with us

Kim: What is going on with the power play units? It use to be we could almost guarantee a score on it and now it's like holding your breathe hoping the other team won't score a shortie? Which coach is responsible for it? Recchi? And why not play a second defenseman with Letang on the first pp unit?

Jason Mackey: It is mostly Sullivan, BTW, with some input from Gonchar. Their biggest issue, to hit one of your points, is too many passes/making things overly complicated. There's a lot of skill, sometimes these guys can be their own worst enemies. As for adding an extra defensemen, it's a good question, especially with Hornqvist out. Sullivan has said it's because they believe in the No. 1 group, which is sort of obvious. I think they think they can get by without ... and probably need the offensive production that using Guentzel > Maatta would bring.

Icing Man: Steelers lose to an awful team and might miss the playoffs, and many call for the head coach to be fired.

Jason Mackey: Where's your question, Icing Man?

james: How will the pens cope with Hornquist on IR? What do you see the lines as?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I wouldn't change anything. I'm not sure you could: 19-87-59 ... 14-71-81 ... 46-15-17 ... 38-7-39. ... I like Rust in a third-line role, and I'd rather have Brassard at wing. I wanna see if Sheahan can be my third-line center or if I'm going to have to go get one of those again.

Icing Man: Should we expect Sullivan to come under similar criticism as Tomlin, given the Pens play to date?

Jason Mackey: People have been critical of Sullivan all season. Some of it is reasonable -- nobody should be above criticism given how things have gone -- and some of it is not. But like Tomlin, Sullivan is in absolutely, positively no danger of losing his job this season.f

RandomHockeyGuy: While the team is tied for 3rd in the Metro, the just lost to a badly struggling team playing who played the night before, and still continue to make the same mistakes from early in the season. Any sense that Rutherford is again frustrated/disappointed, and looking to do something else with the roster to try and get this team going in right direction?

Jason Mackey: I don't know if I would characterize it is "frustrated" or "disappointed," but I do think Jim is watching close because there could be some areas where his team is deficient. Getting something from Rust changes things quite a bit, so that's good. But there's not exactly a trade to make that will guarantee them getting their heads out of their [butts] against the worst team in the league. That's not something you can fix with a move.

Advertise with us

Kolin: Do you think the pens are over the brassard trade? Are they ready to give him up?

Jason Mackey: I think they're looking critical at where he fits on this team, if it all. I think that's why you saw a lot of him with Kessel, which didn't work. Now him at wing. I don't think they're at the NOT A FIT stage. It's more MIGHT NOT BE A FIT, and we're going to find out here in the next little while, if that makes sense.

Guest: Any fun stories from the Dads trip? I noticed a woman in the group pic the pens posted. Was there a mom on the trip?

Jason Mackey: Not that I saw, and I wasn't in Chicago. So, I'm sorry, but I don't know if I'm much help. It was cool to see all of them outside the dressing room at Nassau Coliseum, having a beer or two (the dads, not the players) and celebrating a win with their kids.

Guest: Have you you been liking brass - sid - Guentz ?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I like it, actually. I'm not willing to punt on it because of one crappy game for the whole team. I'd go right back to it on Friday.

MA: How do you solve a problem like Geno?

Jason Mackey: There's only so much you can do, although I would keep Phil there. I think they both want that, and I'm gonna hope that helps him snap out of whatever this is. And I'd also make sure he's healthy.

dave: I can't take Malkin anymore. On the GWG last night, he actually SKATED AWAY from the guy that made the pass! He takes dumb penalties, makes lazy passes that get intercepted, and now, he's not even scoring. There have been at least 3 or 4 losses this season that have resulted from one of his mistakes. If it would insult him too much to make him a healthy scratch, what can they do?

Jason Mackey: Just ride it out. I hear ya, Dave. He was terrible last night. I think Sullivan probably needs to sit him down, talk to him and find out what's going on, too. Is he healthy? If he is, he needs to take waaaay more ownership than he has and play much more of a responsible style. What he's done the past couple isn't gonna work.

Advertise with us

HC: What strategic benefit was there to have Derek Grant on the ice last evening with under 3 minutes in the game and the Pens down by one?

Jason Mackey: None whatsoever, IMO. But I don't coach the team. Sullivan likes Grant and thinks he does a good job forcing turnovers, playing a responsible game, etc.

FR: Hey Mackey. Do you have any indication that Sullivan may be thinking of making any lineup changes or bringing up players from Wilkes Barre or sitting some players?

Jason Mackey: I have no indication of that, no.

Guest: What becomes of the 3C situation if Brassard stays on the Sid line?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think they would see if Sheahan could fill the void. If he can't, maybe they give Dea or Blueger a shot. But most likely they would have to go out and get somebody, perhaps for one of their defensemen. Because of money, that would probably have to be Maatta or Oleksiak.

matt: casey has been a nice surprise. But he has only won 4 games out 9 when games are decided by two or less goals...he is great very solid on medium and low danger shots, and can make an amazing save or two a game....but do you really believe the penguins cam make a playoff run with him....i think they need to give murray a half dozen starts in row and let him regain his confidence...thoughts

Jason Mackey: Is this Matt Vensel? He loves that first stat you just cited on DeSmith. Assuming it's not ... they need to start Murray and go from there. Yes, I'd like to say you allocate a chunk of starts to Murray to get right and make sure he's OK for the playoffs, but if you give him six starts and he stinks and loses all six, there might not be playoffs. My feeling is you play him this weekend, see what happens, then see how your goaltending shakes out. No sense looking too far ahead here.

Mike: Are the Penguins interested in trading for Jonathan Quick?

Jason Mackey: He makes $5.8 million per season ... so, no.

Advertise with us

Cassandra: Already starting with the trade Jarry talk I see?The Pens are honestly quite low on goaltending prospects since Gus is in Ottawa via the useless Brassard trade for one.Secondly DeSmith is an UFA who’s more than proven he can be a number 1 so why would he sign a deal to stay with the Pens unless he knows he will eventually the starter since Murray is out every 3 weeks with mysterious ailments.For someone you said isn’t ready Jarry won 14 games basically being a fish out of water and has actually worked on improving his game unlike some folks.

Jason Mackey: I don't understand your logic, Cassandra. I would understand re-signing DeSmith ... and for him, I think it might be a pretty good opportunity. Plenty of offense here. Starter might be hurt ... has suffered through poor performance. Of course, like you said, if he's gonna get paid, then obviously he's going to do that. But we don't know for sure whether that's going to happen. Re: Jarry, I think the organization is a little fed up that his development has slowed, and he tends to space out for periods of games. He's sort of the opposite of consistent at this point. Maybe that changes and they view him as the goalie of the future, but we're not at that point.

Steven: With Sprong doing his usual gig of looking great in his first game in a new situation before regressing to his mean of having no offensive IQ, when will the ridiculous idea that Sullivan hated him go away?

Jason Mackey: I'm not sure, but I've got a pretty good sense of how you feel about Sprong, Steven.

AlJohn: What is up with this team? It seems that they can’t get on a roll or sting a bunch of good wins together. I realize it was the blackhawks last night who we never beat but they aren’t the hawks of old, we really should have beat them. Also, has Malkin been body snatched?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Yeah, the reason Evgeni Malkin hasn't been since in a while, eh? They need to figure that out. Also, you said it and they've said, they can't see to get total traction. It sort of defies logic. Just such a malaise last night. Blackhawks absolutely out-worked them. That shouldn't happen given what the Penguins have already been through.

Rutbuster: Why has there not been any criticism laid on good old GMJR by the media such as yourself? His FA moves have been awful the past two years. Just because he is chummy with the media shouldn't skew your objectivity.

Jason Mackey: I'm a beat writer, not a columnist. Sometimes I analyze things, but if I can't prove it with numbers, it's not really my job to provide takes. Occasionally I do a little more, but I think you're looking for something like this, no? Here's a column from Joe Starkey that I'm guessing you missed: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/joe-starkey/2018/11/14/Joe-Starkey...

JC: You mention Tomlin and Sullivan are in no danger of losing their job, I understand Sullivan not because this is the first bad stretch since his losing

Guest: There’s been rumblings the Pens might be in for trades for muzzin or Pietrangelo you think it’d work?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: For accuracy's sake, Friedman wrote that he could see the Penguins checking on Muzzin, and the Hockey News listed the Penguins as a potential destination for Pietrangelo. ... I don't think either is even close to possible.

Mike Sullivan after Penguins’ 6-3 loss in Chicago

JC: You mention tomlin and Sullivan being safe, but why? I mean I understand Sullivan but tomlin should have been let go a long time ago.

Jason Mackey: I can't speak to Tomlin. I just go by what Ed and Gerry report. As for Sullivan, it's because his boss has zero interest in firing him and has told me as much. I'm pretty comfortable with the source.

RandomHockeyGuy: Do you believe Sullivan and Rutherford are truly satisfied with the play of Jack Johnson, or are simply avoiding saying anything negative because, well, there's enough negative evidence on Johnson's game already? His advanced stats (Corsi, Scoring Chances against, etc) are as bad as they have been historically, and he has been on the ice for more goals than any other Penguins defenseman at even strength, with almost 100 less minutes than Letang/Dumoulin. Really seems like Hunwick 2.0 that GMJR is going to have to find a way to fix.

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I honestly think that they extremely happy with him ... and he's been fine when he's playing third-pairing minutes. Do you commit to those guys for five years? No. But I'm not going to preemptively crush GMJR for a long contract that has to this point had no effect on the team. Jack's a third-pair guy. Those at his age cost around $3.25 million per season. ... As long as he is where he should be, I don't see what the huge problem is here.

Advertise with us

Facts: So much negativity after one loss, it's kinda insane. It's amazing to me that so few apparently look at advanced stats, which show the Pens playing a much, much better game than 90% of the league. Do you think advanced stats will ever become more often referenced by the audience?

Jason Mackey: I'm not sure. I don't want to criticize my readers or people who have no use for analytics. I understand them and see their value, but I also don't think they're everything. I think there are human elements to this that people overlook, too. I do think people needs to chill sometimes about the reactions to stuff -- it being soooo bad after losses. Guys and girls, it's a long season. It will be OK, I promise.

Christian: Jason, does this team need different players at certain positions or is it more so they need to play better consistently? During games and when they are playing well sometimes it still feels like their vulnerable to falling apart. Definitely not back to all the way.

Jason Mackey: I think they have the players, Christian. Or maybe I should say that they have capable players. Do they play better as a group? I don't have a crystal ball. But I don't think that GMJR has assembled rotten team. ... It's a challenge with Brassard. Injuries have hurt, too. Evgeni Malkin is on another planet at the moment. Those really aren't 100-percent roster issues, only part.

J: Tanner Pearson is an ok player, but he's a third line player who looks out of place with Phil and Geno. Phil and Geno look pretty bad together without Hagelin in there doing all the dirty work. I'd rather see Rust on that line as a poor man's Hagelin. What do you say?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I'd be fine with that. I did like Rust with Sheahan and ZAR, though. The problem with playing Rust on the second line -- and again, I think you have a point -- is that he's going to see tougher matchups. Part of why Rust has been what he's been is because he can usually take advantage of those third-line matchups.

JC: Hi Jason thank you for your articles I have been looking for a authentic Mexican Restaurant in Pittsburgh area? Any suggestions? Do you think the Pens go for big name by trade are they looking D or a top 6 guy or both? Do you sense something big is going to happen? What is your guess or who would you like to get via trade one big trade and one smaller? Thank you Good day

Jason Mackey: It's technically Spanish, but you'll still enjoy it: Mallorca on the South Side. ... If you want fun but basic and local, my wife and I are big Mad Mex fans. ... I don't think they know, honestly. I think Rutherford is still evaluating things, seeing where Brassard might fit, if someone wants one of his extra third-pair defensemen. I also think there's a possibility they do nothing. It's tough to predict any which way at this point.

Christian: Which player has played consistently well throughout that season that hasn’t been talked about enough this year?

Jason Mackey: I don't know if there's anyone I would put in that category right now, honestly. Although Crosby has been playing some of the best hockey of his career, and we've been distracted by their team-oriented woes.

Advertise with us

jack in NY: very disappointing loss last night. What has happened to Malkin and Kessel? they have become invisible and a liability (with penalties, defensively). Their play in the tough areas has been abysmal with giveaways, giving up on pucks etc

Jason Mackey: Can't disagree there. They've been bad together since late November.

Officer Sorrows : Marcus Pettersson has had some quality individual plays - including a few on Patrick Kane - in his time here. Are they general impressed with his play? Seems like a good return for a guy who did nothing here, could potentially be a long term LHD.

Jason Mackey: Absolutely. They've been very impressed and pleasantly surprised by him. Vensel talked to Rutherford the other day about this. Check out his story: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/penguins/2018/12/11/Penguins-GM-Ji...

Jets: You seemed pretty confident Chicago was trash and that was a good game for a Murray return. What does that mean for the Pens that they were outplayed?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: It means they're not as good -- or focused -- as maybe they thought they were. A game they absolutely should not have lost last night.

Malkin_TheBeast: Hello Mackey, is your family Irish? Thanks for your advice about Malkin... but it seems it didn't work... do you see an injure involved in his poor play recently, like during practice does he seem bother by a part of his body? The evidence he's not skating as fast as we've seen him during the first month of the season... if he's only slow because he has no conviction these days... then it's good start, I mean it means he can still redeem himself and play elite like he can!

You're the best, maybe last chat before Christmas, Happy's one! ^_~

P.S. I don't know about the city of Steel, but here Quebec city, it's -15C...colddddd!

Jason Mackey: Yes, there's definitely parts of Irish. Irish and German. ... I've seen nothing to tell me Malkin has been injured. Looks the same in practice and what little we see of him after -- usually leaving the facility as we're in the dressing room.

HB: On the 3man PK who’s going to fill Coles role more Dumoulin or Johnson I’ve seen then be both there?

Jason Mackey: They've been kind of rotating. I think they would like for Johnson to do it, but Dumoulin is capable as well. I don't think they want Maatta there. That hasn't ended well.

Dave: Who do you see next for trade? We desperately need a defenseman... brassard?

Jason Mackey: Boy you guys love the trades ... TRADE EVERYONE! ... Yeah, I would think Brassard would be the next to go if they did something ... if they came to the conclusion that he's just not a fit.

Guest: I was shocked Murray didn’t start last night. Would’ve been a good chance to get him going esp since Desmith had played a lot of games in a row. What do you think was the thought process on that?

Jason Mackey: I think they wanted to get Murray maybe a little more time, maybe give him his first game back at home. I think they also just wanted to finish the trip on a positive note and not have Matt feel like he's rushing to get back. I was surprised by it, too, though.

Jerry: Hi Jason. Something I’ve always wondered about: when the Penguins broadcasters are used for national coverage, for example the NBC NHL channel, are they aware of that? And if so, do they change anything in how they announce the game, or do they cover it the same way? How does the network decide which team’s announcers to use?

Jason Mackey: They usually know, if they watch NHL Network, but no, they don't change anything. ... Believe they usually take the home broadcast whenever they pick up one of those games.

Guest: Who’s the odd man out on defense when Schultz comes back?

Jason Mackey: Could be Oleksiak. Or maybe someone's hurt or traded. It's too early to give you anything definitive on that, honestly.

Officer Sorrows : How safe is our 2019 1st? While I’m 100% on board for risking the future to win now, I don’t see much I’d deal my first for (barring us getting a young player in return). This draft class is quite stacked and I like a lot of the prospects in the 15-25 range (I mean 31st overall!)

Jason Mackey: I would think it's very much in play, assuming the Penguins are in playoff position. Let's say, for the sake of argument, that they go in the tank. Then Jim might try to keep it. But if they are pushing for a decent playoff spot and are one piece away, then absolutely it's in play.

Harold: Hi, Jason, with Casey's solid play, is there any word about a contract extension?

Jason Mackey: No. I wouldn't be shocked if Casey wanted to wait until July 1 to see what he could get at market. If I were advising him, that's what I would tell him.

Bob Sackamono: Hey Jason! Did you miss me?!?!

Jason Mackey: Of course, Bob. Hope you're well.

Guest: Will someone be moved this summer to clear cap to sign Jake/DeSmith/Brassard? If so, who?

Jason Mackey: They're not going to sign Brassard, first off. ... And they could move someone, but it would probably be a defenseman and it would probably come before the summer.

Bob Sackamono: What is your position with all the rumors that mike tomlin and mike sullivan are switching professional coaching jobs. I mean I have no doubt that Sully could really turn the steelers around, but what is your take about tomlin?

Jason Mackey: I think he could do great things for the Penguins. They could not live in their fears, defend every chip of ice, have a next (defense) man up mentality, etc. One perk: There's no clock management in hockey.

Eric : In your opinion do the penguins make the playoffs?

Jason Mackey: Yes. But right now I don't see how they compete for anything more than winning a round or two.

jack in NY: In terms of D surplus, who would you rather keep, Maata or Oleksiak? I would keep Oleksiak.

Jason Mackey: It depends on why I'm deciding. I honestly might entertain trading both if it got me enough. Again, it depends on the return.

Jimmie: The Steelers seem to have a policy that when a starter returns from injury he gets his job back, even if his replacement plays well in his absence. Will the Penguins use the same policy toward Murray?

Jason Mackey: I didn't know the Steelers had such a policy. ... I think Murray is gonna get the benefit of the doubt because he's won two Stanley Cups. That's not an explicit policy, but that's just the respect most teams give their players who have done something such as that.

JC: Disregard comments, connection went down and question didn’t get out the way I wanted sorry

Jason Mackey: No worries.

Old 97s: Great band in town Saturday night. Too Far To Care is their best work. Check it out sometime

Jason Mackey: Love the Old 97s. Got into them while I was living in Virginia ... same time as I learned about the Drive-By Truckers and Jason Isbell.

HB: Blues are looking to have a fire sale do you think their are players that can help this team and are obtainable to trade for?

Jason Mackey: David Perron! No, I'm kidding. I've seen the Penguins as a destination for Pietrangelo. I don't see it happening because of money and assets needed. But after I answered that question, I started thinking: Why not at least call, right? Maybe Armstrong will take some money back. Who knows? ... I don't see many options down there, though, honestly.

FR: Have you had a chance to talk to Murray to see if he feels good and is ready to get back into net and be the goalie we all know he can be? I think he's going to come back strong. What do you think Mackey?

Jason Mackey: I have not had a chance to talk to Matt one-on-one. Maybe tomorrow morning, although it won't be on the record. Do I think he can come back and be all that you think he can? Of course I do. He's done it. Why couldn't he do it again? He does seem to be in a much better place, so that's good news for yinz folks.

JohnAl: Is there any movement on Ron Francis potentially joining the Penguins front office?

Jason Mackey: It's my understanding that Francis has a personal situation tying him to the Raleigh area. Believe care for one of his kids. That was the issue at the time of his Carolina split, anyway.

Rutbuster: Thanks for the link! At what point do you think the Penguins should stop trading 1st and 2nd round picks? This team has gotten really old with no viable prospects in a league going young. Do you think Jim is aware that he needs to build up the system?

Jason Mackey: He's plenty aware of how his system looks, but he's also not overly worried about it. His bosses want him to win now and maximize the Crosby/Malkin window. He wouldn't be doing that if he held off on making moves because he wanted to keep picks. If they're contending, you're going to see Jim operate the same way. Only if they're out of it, I think, will he worry too much about holding on to those picks.

Guest: What’s going on with Geno? Seems like he’s missing Hags...his play has been meh since then and there always seems to be two opposing players on him and he can’t seem to do anything. It can’t be a precipitous drop in ability since he was great in October...is he injured? Tired of Sullivan’s style of play? He seems to be cheating for offense maybe due to lack of confidence in himself or his linemates? Can you ask him?

Jason Mackey: He would have to be available and physical in the room for that to happen, and that happens only about once a month these days, maybe every three weeks. He talked for like 90 seconds after the Ottawa game, but I wasn't on the trip. ... I think he's cheating some, yes. And I wouldn't rule out him being hurt. Also Hagelin. ... There's a combination of things that they need to get figured out. I'm not sure it's as simple as one thing.

Harold: Is it time for the Pens to move on from Malkin while he still has value? He could probably bring a tough, shutdown defenseman and a top-6 forward in return. The contrast between Sid, who is giving 150% every night and Malkin is huge.

Jason Mackey: It is ... right now. Not all the time. Malkin's in a slump. It doesn't mean you trade him. For business reasons and practical purposes. It would be a huge, ridiculous overreaction. He could show up Friday and again be one of the top handful of players in the NHL. He'll be fine.

Guest: Why does Sullivan continue to play Maatta and Olek together? They’ve had problems especially getting pucks out of their own end. I liked Maatta and Riikola better. Why is Riikola still sitting for Olek?

Jason Mackey: And for Pettersson. They like the Pettersson-Johnson pairing a lot, and I think those two stay in. They like what Oleksiak brings from a physical standpoint, and you're not going to healthy scratch a guy who makes more than $4 million for any extended stretch. Maatta also hasn't been that bad.

Cosmo K: Jason, I feel I'm very much in the minority beyond Pens mgt, but I think way too many have given up on 19... He's a very skilled player who didn't lose his skills after being traded for. He's not close to being a bust, just needs more time to contribute. I do not want to see him traded, but do understand his value in that regard. This might be an unanswerable question, but what do the Pens need that he can't contribute? I think he is underrated... As always, your work is very much appreciated!

Jason Mackey: Cosmo, he's played 47 games with eight goals and 8-13-21, I believe. That's more than a half-season. I like Brassard, too, but how much larger of a sample size do you think we need here before it's time to call a space a spade? I'm OK with a little longer -- at wing -- but not much.

Aljohn : The Maatta - Riikola pairing was very good before Riikola was inexplicably put on nacho patrol. Maatta - Oleksiak has been not good. When does Oleksiak get some nachos so Riikola can play?

Jason Mackey: Juuso Riikola is apparently the best defenseman ever, and his lack of playing time is the direct explanation to last night's loss in Chicago. ... I would send Riikola down before I would yank Oleksiak out of the lineup in favor of him.

sz in az: Craig Morgan had an interesting article in The Athletic about the effect the loss of Jason Demers, possibly for the season, has had on the Coyotes. They were on an upward swing when he was injured, and have been trending downward since. He noted that the loss threw their whole D-corps into chaos, and they haven't been able to find pairings that clicked, plus it's had an effect on the locker room. Do you think the loss of Justin Schultz for such a long time has had the same effect on the Pens? When he was hurt, things seemed to be clicking really well, and they have just kind of fallen into inconsistency since then.

Jason Mackey: Schultz was hurt in the fourth game of the season, so I think I might pump the brakes on the "clicking really well" and "fallen into inconsistency since then" sort of talk. They played a high-scoring game on opening night, a stinker against Montreal a couple nights later, a pretty decent game against Vegas, then he was hurt. No trends had developed any which way. ... Do I think they've been hurting since the loss of Schultz? Absolutely. He's a $6 million-a-year offensive defenseman. Every team in the league is gonna struggle to address that sort of loss.

Guest: Do you think JR and Sullivan see what the rest of us do—that this team is not a true contender for a Cup? They might eke into the POs because the Metro is so bad but they’ll do little. They need either several roster moves and better goaltending, or they need to just tank to get a lottery pick. This team has too many 30+ vets and it seems they are missing the youth and speed they brought in in 2015-17, which they don’t have in the pipeline anymore

Jason Mackey: They have some options -- Blueger, Di Pauli and Johnson -- but they seem hesitant, for whatever reason, to use them. I think they think this team can be better than it is, and they would like to avoid a HUGE trade. They're evaluating right now whether that's accurate.

8771588130: Rutherford must have been pleased for Rusty to do what he did last night. Is he looking to add at this point or subtract because I think Johnson needs to go after that debachole last night on the 4th Goal I think Maatta needs to stay too what do you think Jason

Jason Mackey: Let me get this straight: So we're blaming Jack Johnson on the fourth goal ... which, even if it's right, and he's certainly culpable ... and ignoring that this bunch sleepwalked through a loss to the worst team in the league? At a time where they need points? I don't care if Jack Johnson took off his skates and mooned Patrick Kane. There's sooooo much more to it than that. And even if he's truly awful -- which if you read this chat that's probably the conclusion you'll come to -- what are you gonna do? Do you think other teams are clamoring for the defenseman in his 30s who (you say) sucks and has four more years on his contract? Who's taking that?

Dave: Do you think they think brass is a fit???

Jason Mackey: I think he could be a fit at wing.

james: You mentioned possibly moving Jarry if his game doesn't progress. Can they? Do they have a goalie of the future if Murray continues to falter? Wish Filip was still in the fold

Jason Mackey: Yeah, that one hurts. And no, they don't. It's Matt, Casey or signing someone. So, maybe it does make sense to hold onto Tristan. But I question how OK the Penguins would be right now if Tristan was their one and only.

Guest: What do you Guentz will sign for with the pens?

Jason Mackey: I could see around $6-$7 million. Basically Nylander money, but if I'm the Pens, I could probably get a little discount because of Jake's regular-season struggles -- it's better this year -- and how much his production has been reliant on Sidney Crosby.

Guest: Everyone saying “we need a defensemen” but we have 9! And thinks will improve when Schultz comes back....right?

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I don't understand it. They have goal-prevention issues, yes. And their defense could stand to get upgraded. But, shoot, they could sign Nicklas Lidstrom in his prime, and they still might struggle at times to keep the other team from scoring.

Guest: Hi Jason! It seems like a safe bet to land a C note down at the Casino on both Eastern wild cards coming from the Atlantic. Whaddya think the magic points number will be for third in the Metro?

Jason Mackey: Division's a little rough this year. I'm thinking maybe 102?

Jerry: Pretend for a moment you’re the GM - who are you protecting in the next expansion draft?

Jason Mackey: Thinking Crosby, Malkin, Rust, Jake, Letang, Dumoulin, Maatta and Schultz. ... Or maybe Crosby, Malkin, ZAR, Rust, Jake, Simon, INSERT YOUNG FORWARD HERE ... Letang, Dumoulin and Schultz. ... Although I do think it's crazy early, Jerry. So much can happen.

Jmoney: Is this a good year for a soft rebuild? After seeing the hawks and kings falling apart after winning multiple cups it seems like we are starting down a similar path

Jason Mackey: I don't think they should be thinking like that. Late Monday night it sounded like they have a lot of stuff figured out. Yes, last night's loss stinks, but it shouldn't kill their entire season, IMO.

J: This team isn't a contender, and there's not one quick fix. We're also not that far away because we have top players and reasonably good depth. In my opinion, we need some young legs. What kind of resources would we have to part with to get a top young center-- say someone that has been or would be drafted in the top 3 picks? Crosby and Malkin are still elite, elite players. But I could see Crosby in 3 years doing an incredible job in the 2nd line center/ Ron Francis/ role if we had a guy to bring along. I'd rather punt on this season, shed salary and accumulate enough resources to get one more young star next year. Is that do-able?

Jason Mackey: You want to get the first, second or third overall pick? That's a heck of a lot of tanking at his point. ... How, then, are you also saying this team isn't a contender and there's not one quick fix ... then you're proceeding to give me a quick fix?

Lord of Carson: Is it fair to question why Oleksiak is playing ahead of the Finnish flash?

Jason Mackey: Absolutely. Juuso Riikola can walk on water. I don't know why Mike Sullivan isn't playing him in a hockey game.

Mike Tomlin: Obviously.

Jason Mackey: Damn X-ray machines.

Lord of Carson: Since Brassard seems to be headed to wing, would Shaehan and a combination of Maata or Oleksiak be enough to bring back a 3rd line center?

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think it would. I think that's reasonable. However, are you also moving Brassard? You might want to also keep Sheahan around because he is a capable No. 4.

Man on fire: I have perhaps a different take on Cullen. To me he bailed and hurt somewhat the Pens chance to 3peat. I got though that from reports he was doing it for his family. Completely understand. But now essentially he washed out at MInny he is back, mainly due to perhaps the only GM that would sign him did. So Matty, just how important was that family in Minny thing? Would much rather had taken a flyer on someone like Duclair than have brought him back, and the return seemed strange. Am i being too jaded thinking this way?

Jason Mackey: I think so, yeah. I also think you're blaming a 42-year-old fourth line center for way more than he's responsible for. He's a bit part. Good or bad. Everything I've heard about Anthony Duclair and chemistry issues ... I question whether that would've been another fit. And it's not like it was an either/or, ya know? They could've afforded Cullen and Duclair if they really wanted.

Guest: Who is likely playing their last season as a penguin? Will this roster look different next season?

Jason Mackey: Absolutely it will. Brassard will be gone. Cullen, Grant, Ruhwedel, maybe DeSmith. Maybe Sheahan. I think there will be a pretty decent amount of turnover this summer.

Jerry: Jason, which player is the best at making himself available to the media, which one provides the most thoughtful (i.e. not canned) responses, and which one is like Bigfoot - heard of but seldom seen?

Jason Mackey: Phil and Geno are the last category, obviously. ... Sid is pretty much always available. He's tremendous. Pearson is really good. Maatta, Oleksiak, ZAR, they're all cooperative. Cullen always provides thoughtful responses. ... I love Malkin's honesty and what he's willing to say when he does talk.

JohnAl: 8-13-21 in 47 games while playing through a buggered groin for part of that and coming from pretty much the polar opposite system is perfectly acceptable for a player you're paying 3 million dollars to. What more are you expecting from Brassard?

Jason Mackey: To click with anyone whatsoever for a stretch of games. To be something of a factor on the second power play. He's a $5 million-a-year player, mind you, hence why they had to give up more to get him with Cole and Gustavsson and Reaves. It's not just about the cap hit.

John: Why does Kessel insist on not even looking toward the net on the PP, passing back to Letang at the blue line and insist that somehow passing the puck back and forth between him and Kris Letang will somehow score a goal - before the eventual pass intercept and SHG.

Jason Mackey: Are you actually expecting an answer on this? Do you think Phil would give me insight on this if I asked? Phil needs to shoot more, plain and simple. Too cute. It's a common theme for the whole group on the power play.

Puck Bunny: Do you think part of the problem is that the younger talent on the team hasn't experienced how to win "gritty" or "dirty" games? They all kind of came in on the cup runs and got contracts because of their help with winning cups.

Jason Mackey: Eh, I don't know about that. You can criticize Bryan Rust for not scoring -- he's pretty much who you're talking about, right? -- but I'm not about to criticize his effort or willingness to play and win gritty games.

The Price is right: Ignoring salary cap issues, what would it take to acquire Casey Price (if Murray cannot find his old magic)? Who would we have to give up as far as players. I was thinking Sprong and Cole as starters...

Jason Mackey: That would be hilarious if the Penguins offered Marc Bergevin Daniel Sprong and Ian Cole. Think he'd take it? What a negotiating strategy by GMJR!

sz in az: Thanks re: Schultz. For some reason, I thought he was hurt later than that, after/during the Western Canada trip.

Thanks for doing this every week--your work is appreciated!

Jason Mackey: My pleasure. Thanks for following along.

Kevin: I've heard Charlie Coyle's name out there, any chance that he would be a realistic option the Penguins look at?

Jason Mackey: I don't believe so, no. I haven't heard that.

Man on fire: U surely jest Jason suggesting Shaehan as your 3rd line center? THe man went 79 games without a goal before. Good players dont have that occur. Ever. At best he is a somewhat ok 4th line center.

Jason Mackey: I would give him a chance. Not saying it would happen. Just that I would give him a chance. He went 79 games without playing with Kessel, I'd like to point out.

bill from Va: Ouch seems like the Hawks are to the Pens as the Raiders are to the Steelers. Do you think Malkin is in it to win it this season? something seems wrong. Nice to see Rust break out but sometimes it seems the Pens dont have a 3rd or 4th line but 2 5th lines ....great job Jason your chat is a highlight of my week

Jason Mackey: Ha. Thanks for that, Bill. Yeah, I think Malkin is in it to win it. Motivation isn't an issue. Discipline and not getting hacked off mid-game is something he needs to get better at. That has gotten him a couple times.

PENSFANINBVA: Is Maatta on the chopping block???

Jason Mackey: Geez. Not even the trade block. Went all nuclear on poor Olli.

Guest25: What’s up with the Zuccarello stuff and What about Bonino??? They could use him in my opinion

Jason Mackey: OK, we're going to put an end to INSERT PLAYER HERE trade speculation without linking a credible report. If you have it, link it. Otherwise, we're moving on.

james: Is it possible to reduce the number of high % goals the pens allow/face? They seem to hand excellent opportunities to teams on a consistent basis. I think they could really take a big step forward with improvements in this area alone

Jason Mackey: Absolutely, folks. I think it's possible to reduce the number of goals but also chances. That's a big part of the Penguins' problem right now. They're not having the puck enough, they're making some dumb mistakes, and they're allowing these chances. Their goaltenders -- when they've struggled anyway -- have then failed to make some big saves when they've needed to. Absolutely this is correctable.

guest: 102? No way Jason. No club other than Washington is winning consistently. I'm going with 93.

Jason Mackey: Look at what was required to get third the past couple of years. Hasn't been lower than 98 in a while, if ever.

CJ: Do you think Riikola should get sent down to WB so he can at least play regularly. With that said is he waiver exempt? Thanks

Jason Mackey: Yes. He can be sent down, and I think he needs to be sent down to get some games. He's not getting any better right now, and they need him to develop more.

Guest: The team has been moving away the last couple years from the speed and skill and rolling four lines formula. Do you think there’s some disjunction between what the front office is doing and the players they’re signing and how the coaching staff wants to play?

Jason Mackey: I don't think so. I think part of it is circumstance. Their signings haven't worked out, so they're forced to adjust. I do think there's been a disconnect with Sprong and Reaves, but I don't think that's anything terribly unique to this regime.

normie: Jason, since you nailed the out come of last Friday's game in your Thursday chat, how do you think the outcome of the game against Boston will go?

Jason Mackey: Did I? I don't remember what I wrote. ... I think they win. I'm gonna say 3-1.

FR: How are press conferences generally run? Are there questions you are not allowed to ask? Are you always at every post game conference?

Jason Mackey: I'm at every postgame press conference unless I'm not on the trip ... like last night in Chicago. At home, they're in the media room. Sullivan comes in, there's a mic that's passed, etc. On the road, Sullivan appears outside of the Penguins dressing room. There are never questions we're forbidden from asking -- they couldn't do that if they tried -- but they are obviously allowed to answer however they want. So we can ask. Doesn't mean it's getting an answer. Make sense?

AlJohn: You mean you give up a 4th liner of no real value, a rental D who generated a 3rd on the market and a goalie prospect when you have a 24 year old #1 goalie. The cap hit is the important part because it is what you’d have to replace with if you moved him. Brassard has constantly been moved around, not had particularly consistent linemates and is trying to adapt to a completely new role. But yes, let’s trade him. That’ll be a totally worthwhile trade

Jason Mackey: I'm not saying I 100 percent would. But I would entertain it.

Guest: Jason Mackey more like Jason Snarky

Jason Mackey: Sorry. A little fired up today.

Guest: Jason, what will it take to see Guentzel get his shot off a little faster, as that looks like the difference for him both last year and this year. He is most effective when he shoots fast and he is delaying a little. Why doesn’t this come out in film and via coaching?

Jason Mackey: I can't say what they've worked on behind the scenes. I do think, with Jake, that some of it has to do with confidence. The faster he's thinking the game, the faster the shot gets off.

Ebert Morknorkman: Pens win if 72 plays last name, different team without his heart in th lineup

Jason Mackey: Agree there. Need to get him back.

MA: Who do u think was biggest loss Pens have suffered from the cup teams? Was personally shocked that we gave Kunitz, i know he’s not doing well now but he always played so well w Sid and was a great leader.

Jason Mackey: I think Bonino. While I agree with you -- and might also include Fleury -- I don't know if they've addressed the loss of Bonino yet. He meant so much to them and played such an important role.

Guest: Letang holds the puck too long on power plays, let’s the puck out of the zone on sloppy stick work, and cannot get the puck through. His reads are poor. Why do the pens keep doing the same thing and expecting a different result. He has poor instincts with a man advantage.

Jason Mackey: I don't really have a huge problem with what Letang has done on the power play. As a whole, I think they've gotten too cute at times, and this is a part of it. But it's not just a Letang issue.

FlowerPower: Do u think Malkin needs a spark or something because man he has not played good

Jason Mackey: I think Sullivan needs to have a chat with Malkin ASAP.

Guest: Why wo the pens keep putting letang in a bad position where he makes poor decisions on the power play, he lets the puck out with sloppy stickwork, and he has no defensive conscience, plus he typically does not get pucks through. This is a killer on the pp and with the goalie pulled.

Jason Mackey: Well, they don't really have another good option. Maybe Maatta? That's kinda it. But again, it's not just Letang on the SHG allowed.

Guest: Kessel seems to do things only his way. He has had a dozen great opportunities this week, but he has not elevated the puck at all. He keeps bumping shots into goalie pads along the ice. Is he that stubborn, or unavailable to coaching?

Jason Mackey: I think Phil likes to play the game a certain way, his way, which most of the time works out fine. But, yeah, it does get ugly sometimes when it doesn't work. This also isn't new.

Alan Smith: Will they ever consider trading Kessel. Can't skate with speed, can't pass or set others up and has never hit another player with any force ever.

Jason Mackey: Kessel can't skate with speed? Don't know if I agree with that one. Yes, they would consider it. But only under special circumstances. Say, if this season goes south. Maybe then. But it would have to be for the right return.

Guest: Do the pens have player issues or coaching issues? There are obvious things that are not happening and changes are not made. Who is that on? And why don’t simple tings

Jason Mackey: I don't think they have either, to be honest with you.

Guest: Are the problems the pens are experiencing over and over again on the coaches or the players? The same problems and no different results. Over passing, poor clearing attempts, no shots through, turnovers, not going to the dirty areas, not shooting high. All keep happening...why?

Jason Mackey: Things have actually improved. I wouldn't let one loss -- even if it was really bad -- cloud that.

Guest: Maata has been way better on the pp than Letang. Moves well, moves the puck, gets shots through, less sloppy, and has a v effective slap pass. Why doesn’t he get more pp1 time?

Jason Mackey: Letang adds more on that unit with his athleticism, keeping pucks in, getting hit shot through, etc. Maatta would be a safer option, I agree, but the offense would be limited.

Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it for this week. Thanks for participating. Let's do this again next Thursday.