It ranks among the bigger trades Jim Rutherford has made during his two-plus decades as an NHL general manager. It was almost assuredly the most complicated.

Yet here we are, more than nine months after the Penguins general manager acquired Derick Brassard from Ottawa, and the results haven’t been close to what anyone expected.

Brassard has just six goals and 18 points in 42 games (regular season and playoffs), while the Penguins as a team are just 28-23-7 in those games. There’s been multiple lower-body injuries to Brassard, difficulty adjusting to a third-line role and fewer minutes plus a weird illness at the start of training camp.

Coach Mike Sullivan has tried nearly every winger he has with the 31-year-old center, who as recently as 2015-16 produced 27 goals and 58 points with the New York Rangers. However, not a single one of them has stuck.

Advertise with us

It doesn’t sound like the Penguins are ready to admit failure here, but they also aren’t happy. The Penguins gave up a ton to get Brassard. So far, he has yet to prove that he can be the right third-line center for their team.

“He should be a fit,” Rutherford said. “He’s played some of his best hockey [this season]. He came in and had a good camp. He played well until he got hurt again. Since he got hurt, he hasn’t seemed to be able get it back on track.

“It’s there. Will it come back or how long will it take? I don’t know. But we need him to be better.”

Derick Brassard

Yes, the Penguins absolutely need Brassard to be better. Whether or not that will actually happen is the primary topic of this week’s column.

2. A simple glance at the standings should tell you that the Penguins need results. They’re 25 games into the season and only two points clear of the Eastern Conference basement. As captain Sidney Crosby said after Monday’s practice, “I wouldn’t say it’s early anymore.”

Advertise with us

Which means, in theory, that Sullivan — even more than usual — needs to find lines that work, that score, that have productive shifts.

Brassard and Phil Kessel have done little of that over the past two games, but Sullivan is bucking a recent trend of his and trying to remain patient. He’s sticking with Brassard and Kessel. For now.

The coach has had an itchy trigger figure during much of his tenure here, but he seems intent on figuring out, once and for all, whether Brassard and Kessel can actually play together.

On Tuesday against Colorado — which is riding an 11-game point streak and arrives here as one of the best teams in the NHL this season — it’s likely Brassard and Kessel will get another chance to make it work, with Zach Aston-Reese on the left side.

For Sullivan, it’s always a delicate balancing act between short-term results and long-term development.

Advertise with us

“There’s always a fine line,” Sullivan said. “We’re trying to find combinations that bring success. We’re trying to allow combinations to work through the process. We’re also trying to evaluate whether or not we thinking it has potential to find traction.

“When’s the right time to split up a line or when’s the right time to allow guys to stay together and work through things? I think [it’s] the coaches’ instinct just based on what we see. It’s something that we discuss daily with our group. We’ll make decisions daily based on what we see.

“It’s not like our coaching staff is hesitant to make change because we’ve certainly made a fair amount. It’s a matter of whether or not we think it’s the right thing to do at this time for the group.”

3. To be fair to Brassard and Kessel, they really did look good together last Tuesday against Winnipeg. However, the next night in Colorado was ugly.

Brassard was on the ice for one five-on-five shot on goal and 11 against. They combined to produce one five-on-five scoring chance. One!

Advertise with us

Saturday against the Flyers showed tepid progress, with four five-on-five scoring chances produced. But only one of those qualified as high-danger, per naturalstattrick.com, and the eye test didn’t exactly scream that they were a threat to score.

After the game, Sullivan said essentially that he and his coaching staff would go back to the drawing board and revaluate some things.

At practice Monday, however, Sullivan didn’t return to the Kessel-Evgeni Malkin pairing that many expected, the one that was the Penguins’ best early in the season. He kept things status quo.

With a horde of reporters gathered around his dressing room stall after practice, Brassard mostly danced around the Kessel topic.

“We played one or two games,” Brassard said when asked whether he felt his line was close to breaking through. “The lines are always changing pretty much every game. We had some guys injured who came back.

Advertise with us

“When you say my line, yeah, for [Tuesday] it’s Phil, me and Zach. Who knows if we’re going to finish the game together. Who knows what’s going to happen in the future. I’m just going to try and focus on [Tuesday] and make plays with those guys.”

4. Something interesting about Brassard that may indicate how he truly feels about playing here: He routinely slips in comments like this, about the lines changing or his limited ice time.

You know how you change it? Give the coach a reason to keep your line together or play you more.

5. Sullivan insisted Brassard doesn’t need to change his game to become more like, say, Nick Bonino, who thrived on going to the tough areas of the rink, playing solid defense and making smart passes.

It doesn’t mean it won’t work, but Brassard isn’t the same type of player. He’s a speed-and-skill guy.

Advertise with us

More than anything, for Sullivan, it’s about cooperative play. It’s about Brassard and Kessel working together, and the coach said that doesn’t solely fall on Brassard, who has one point — a goal — in eight games since returning from a three-week absence because of a lower-body injury.

“It’s hard to just identify one guy on a line and say, ‘He’s the reason.’ ” Sullivan said. “When you look at line combinations, they must have cooperative play to have success. The game’s too hard out there. Teams defend hard. It takes cooperative effort for lines to have success both offensively and defensively.”

6. Strip this down to its core, and I don’t think it’s overly complicated.

Sullivan is sticking with Brassard and Kessel right now because he has to. And because Malkin and Kessel haven’t produced much together, either. It’s the perfect time to ride it out.

The optimist in me wants to say that Brassard and Kessel will be fine. They’re both skilled, and sooner or later this will work.

Advertise with us

Only they haven’t clicked yet, and how much longer can the Penguins afford to wait?

7. I asked Brassard flat-out Monday whether he thought he had any chemistry with Kessel.

“Yeah, there’s chemistry,” Brassard said. “We just have to make plays.

“It’s hard to score in this league five-on-five. You might have two or three chances a game. You have to try and capitalize on it. We’re just going to try and do our best [Tuesday].”

While I understand what Brassard is saying, we’re talking about two guys who combined make $13 million per season — although they only cost the Penguins $9.8 million because the Maple Leafs and Golden Knights are picking up part of their salaries.

Advertise with us

Creating offense is hard, but elite players — as Kessel and Brassard are paid — should be able to do it. At least ones that are capable of playing together.

8. Much like Kessel in the postseason, there have been some mixed messages regarding Brassard’s most recent lower-body injury.

“He’s trying to get back to that point since he’s come back from the injury,” Sullivan said of Brassard. Rutherford’s comments were similar.

“I don’t think the injury has any issue,” Brassard said of a lower-body injury that forced him to miss nine games.

I do think it’s possible for both of these things to be true. Brassard is working his way back and doesn’t want to make excuses for his lack of production. Sullivan and Rutherford want to protect the player.

Advertise with us

“Before he got hurt, he was playing really good hockey for us,” Sullivan said of Brassard. “There was a lot that we liked about his game. He’s trying to get back to that point since he’s come back from the injury.”

It should be noted that Brassard was playing left wing at that time — he had three assists in a blowout win at Calgary on Oct. 25 — and may actually profile better there on the Penguins.

Unfortunately, though, that job isn’t available right now. Jake Guentzel has found his groove, and Brassard must figure it out at third-line center. Or potentially move on.

“I think he’s got to play his game,” Sullivan said. “I think he has to hang onto pucks in the offensive zone. I think he has to support the puck down low in the offensive zone when his linemates are fighting for it or have it.”

But mostly, it’s what Rutherford said: The Penguins simply need Brassard to be better.

Advertise with us

9. Moving on to other parts of my conversation with Rutherford …

The Penguins have dropped eight of 12 since his epic rant before the game at Washington on Nov. 7, the one where he basically started threatening to break up the team.

In a subsequent conversation we had at UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex, Rutherford said he would be monitoring what happens to determined whether or not he ultimately thinks this group has become stale.

I asked him Monday where he stood with that idea.

“I don’t know if stale is the right word at this point,” Rutherford said. “It just seems that once a week we have at least one or two players that contribute to a good effort in the wrong way and cost us games. That’s what happens when things aren’t going right.”

Advertise with us

10. That said, Rutherford sees signs of progress that the Penguins are almost out of it.

Look at enough analytics, and they’ll paint the same picture. For example, the Penguins are controlling 57 percent of the five-on-five scoring chances over the past six games. The Penguins have done a lot of good things. They simply haven’t gotten on a winning streak, which they need to do.

“I really feel that there’s a lot of positive signs that we will start to win,” Rutherford said. “But, we can’t afford to have individuals have off-nights when our team is working well enough to win games. That’s what we have to come out of at this point.

“We went through the real bad stretch where we weren’t playing well, but we did deserve to win a couple of those games. We didn’t. Then once we got through that stretch, we started to play better as a team.

“We’re at that point now, but it doesn’t do you any good if you don’t win. We’re good enough to win.”

Advertise with us

11. I think that’s mostly fair, although that “real bad” stretch was … well, really bad. I don’t know how many of those games the Penguins legitimately deserved to win.

Definitely not the Maple Leafs (5-0) or Devils (5-1) at home. Probably in Washington (2-1). Not at Ottawa (6-4) or at home against Tampa (4-3, four power-play goals allowed).

Whatever. I will agree with Rutherford on the idea that the Penguins need to pick up points. I think there was a period of the season where you could focus more on the process and ignore the results. We’ve passed that. They need the results. Otherwise …

12. I believe Rutherford must be cognizant of when it’s time to call this a transition year.

It’s not now, mind you, but I don’t think it would be the worst thing in the world if the Penguins just admitted it wasn’t going to happen and set themselves up appropriately for the rest of the Crosby/Malkin Era.

Advertise with us

If this year turns out to be a failure on the ice but winds up sustaining the rest of the championship window, I hardly think anyone is going to look at the Penguins like they blew it.

But again, we’re not there yet. Just something I think Rutherford is keeping in the back of his mind.

13. My sense now is that I do think Matt Murray was dealing with a legitimate, physical injury. Previously, I had thought his current absence was more mental than anything.

That said, I think the timing of his lower-body issue could’ve been worse. Good time to step away for him, maybe unplug a little and clear his head.

In my opinion, goaltending is one of the things that has held the Penguins back recently. The individuals having off-nights Rutherford mentioned above absolutely involves the goaltenders allowing too many soft goals.

Advertise with us

Getting the good version of Murray back will do wonders for that, but Rutherford knows that, as a whole, the guys getting paid to stop the puck need to be a lot better.

“In order for us to get to where we want to get to where we want to get to — and that’s playing into June — we have to get that consistent goaltending,” Rutherford said. “I believe we have the guys to do it.

“I’m a big believer in Matt Murray. You don’t do what he did in the first two years and end up not having the ability to be a good goalie in this league.”

14. Murray skated before practice Monday, and I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s back with the group soon. He looked excellent, at least in the limited, individual drills I watched.

There seems to be little concern over the physical side of things with Murray, even though his injury history is not short.

Rutherford is mostly concerned with Murray regaining his mental edge.

“There’s something to be said for the mental aspect of the game and dealing with all situations,” Rutherford said. “He definitely has it. He was the key goalie to winning the two Stanley Cups. That’s what he has to find as he goes forward.”

15. Touching on a few other topics …

It would be impossible to write something like this and ignore Tom Wilson’s illegal perfectly fine hit on New Jersey Devils left wing Brett Seney from Friday night.

Here are a few things I know are true:

• It was extremely late.

• As such, there was no reason whatsoever to make the hit.

• Wilson has, well, a bit of a reputation for doing things that the NHL Department Safety deems illegal.

It was, at minimum, a careless play by Wilson, who was given a match penalty but no supplemental discipline for the hit. In my opinion, it showed someone who isn’t close to receiving the message the league is trying to send.

16. I almost can’t blame him for the last part. The NHL doesn’t do nearly enough to show it takes head injuries seriously, even though, as a society, I’d like to think that we now do. Or at least more seriously than we once did.

Why should he change when the people in charge aren’t forcing him to by allowing such plays to go unpunished? Or by cutting short a previous suspension?

If parents looked the other way when their kids misbehaved, or they eased off punishments for no clear reason, don’t you think those same kids would continue to flout the rules?

17. My biggest problem with the Wilson situation, however, doesn’t involve the league. It has to do with Wilson’s teammates and the Capitals organization.

Nobody thinks anything is wrong. Nobody thinks there’s a trend here. Nobody thinks he’s failing to get the message. They all think everyone else is crazy.

It did take a while, probably too long, but eventually the Penguins stopped siding with Matt Cooke, realizing that hitching their wagon to how he was playing, and the pain he inflicted, was a bad idea.

18. Dominik Simon has a pretty idea what it takes to mesh with Crosby right now.

“Get him the puck, and he’ll score,” Simon joked with me before Saturday’s game against the Flyers.

While it’s tough to argue with Simon’s logic, there’s definitely been more to it than that.

Remember last postseason, when Simon got chance after chance to play with Crosby and seemed in over his head? Not anymore.

I’ve been very impressed with what Simon has done on the Penguins’ top line this season, to the point that, when Hornqvist returned against Philadelphia, I didn’t question for a second the decision to leave Simon there.

19. “I just think this year’s Dom’s brought more consistency to his overall game,” Sullivan said. “He has great offensive instincts. For a guy who’s not overly big in stature, he’s really strong on the puck. He’s strong in the battle areas. We think one of his greatest assets is his ability to play in traffic, the give-and-go game down low. That’s an area where Sid thrives.”

Some of this simply has to be maturity. It may be easy to overlook, but Simon is just 24 years old. Saturday’s game was just his 63rd in the NHL. Reading off Crosby is hardly an easy task.

Full credit to Simon: Where we’ve seen Sprong fail to elevate his game, Simon has seemingly taken the next step.

“You learn every time you’re on his line,” Simon said. “Definitely helps to play with him more, then you know where he’s going. He’s such a smart guy. It’s really nice to play with him because he’s always in a good spot.”

20. Simon is currently on pace for 13 goals and 43 points, respectable totals for someone who has not yet logged a full NHL season.

Dig a little deeper, and Simon has been driving play quite a bit. His five-on-five shot rate of 56.5 ranked third on the team, while he was No. 1 in scoring-chance (60.3) and high-danger (63.4) percentages among regulars.

Some of that is being strong on pucks. It’s also thinking the game the way Crosby does and getting the mental side of thinks to connect with the physical side.

Not saying Simon is immovable like Guentzel might be on Crosby’s left wing, but the results have been markedly better than they used to be.

“It’s a lot of different things,” Simon said. “It’s not just shooting and passing. “It’s about reading the game, playing smart and putting pucks behind them. It depends. Little stuff.”

Little stuff that seems to be adding up to bigger stuff.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.