Besides helping to transform the Penguins identity into one based on speed, pressure and resilience, coach Mike Sullivan also has placed a huge importance on beating Metropolitan Division teams.

Sullivan’s Penguins have gotten the results, too, with a division-high 57 Metro wins between 2015-18.

But as this season’s slow start has dragged on, the Penguins are having trouble capturing that same sort of magic.

They’ve won just 2 of 8 Metropolitan games thus far — they’re 2-5-1 — and there’s a fairly obvious reason why: The goaltending the Penguins have gotten hasn’t been good enough.

Advertise with us

While the Penguins are taking five more shots than they’re allowing (35.9-30.9) in division games, Matt Murray and Casey DeSmith — Tristan Jarry hasn’t started against the Metro this season — aren’t stopping nearly enough of them.

The save percentage by Penguins goaltenders is just .874 (216 of 247) in division games, and it’s a far cry from what opposing goaltenders are doing to them (.923, 265 of 287).

“Super early in the year, obviously,” DeSmith said after allowing three goals on 25 shots Saturday in a 4-2 loss to the Philadelphia Flyers at PPG Paints Arena. “We have a good division, and it’ll be a battle all the way until the end of the season.”

While goaltending has been tough to ignore, other parts of the Penguins game have been just fine inside the Metropolitan Division.

The power play has gone 6 for 24 (25 percent), and the penalty kill has clicked at 83.3 percent (20 for 24), which is actually the same clip as the Penguins have hit on the entire season, ranking sixth in the NHL.

Advertise with us

They’ve trailed after the first period only twice in eight games and have outscored their opponents, 12-10, in the first period — meaning starts aren’t a huge issue.

Individually, Jake Guentzel has six goals in eight division games, while Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin have three apiece. The Penguins do need more than the one goal they’ve gotten from Phil Kessel inside the Metro, while Patric Hornqvist has zero goals within the division.

“We have such a good group in here, so many good guys, and I think this group has what it takes, for sure,” said DeSmith, who has, by a long shot, been the better of the two goalies inside the Metro, with a .912 save percentage compared to .837 for Murray. “I don’t think anybody’s panicking.”

Maybe not, but there’s certainly ample evidence that labels goaltending as the Penguins’ Achilles heel here:

• They’re actually allowing fewer five-on-five shots-against per game against the Metro than they are against the Atlantic, Pacific and Central (25.0-26.6). Ditto for scoring chances (19.1-21.6).

Advertise with us

• They’re also controlling 60.1 percent of five-on-five scoring chances inside the division, which would lead the NHL if that was over 25 games and not eight.

• The problem, again, is the save percentage. It stinks. Five-on-five, Penguins goalies are stopping just 88.5 percent of shots against Metro teams, which would rank dead last if considering the entire season.

• Penguins goaltenders are also coughing up an alarming number of high-danger goals — 14 in eight division games compared to 18 in the 17 games outside the Metro. Five times their high-danger save percentage has been 80 percent or lower.

After the Flyers loss, when the Penguins made too many unforced errors and DeSmith didn’t make enough high-danger saves, Kris Letang addressed his team’s current state.

While not specifically talking about the lack of goaltending the Penguins have gotten in division games, Letang said it’s not the time to make any sort of snap judgments about how things have gone.

Advertise with us

“I’m not going to base everything we’ve done on one game,” Letang said. “You don’t base your progress on only one game, either. Just going to forget about it and go back to work.”

If the Penguins can get their division figured out, as they did when they went 57-25-6 (.682 points percentage) during that three-year window, they should be OK.

The question is how long will that take? There’s only six more division games through January, so that provides a small respite when it comes to four-point games. But it also denies the Penguins the opportunity for more movement in the standings should they get hot.

That’s probably why Sullivan had the sense of urgency he did after watching his team allow three breakaways, blow two leads and give up a key short-handed goal against Philadelphia, a recipe that ultimately resulted in the Penguins beating themselves, another key opportunity against a division team wasted.

“It’s not that we gave up a lot of chances, but the quality of the chances were so high, and the mistakes that were made … we don’t have the ability to recover from them,” Sullivan said. “It’s hard to win that way, when that’s taking place on the ice. We can’t give up three breakaways and think we’re going to win games consistently.”

Advertise with us

Certainly not when you’re stopping just 87 percent of shots the way the Penguins are inside their division.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.