Jason Mackey: OK, folks. Sorry for the delay. Stupid flu shot. But at least I can get sick now. And away we go ..

Guest: What type of an injured player is sid, does he sit up in the box or stay hidden?

Jason Mackey: It's tough for us to tell. When players do sit in the press box, at home, we often don't see them. But knowing Sid, I would imagine he probably watches the game waaaaay too intently.

Neal b: Who do you think the next trade victim is. And where to ?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I don't think there will be one, Neal. Wrote about this yesterday. Rutherford, for now, seems to content to roll with what he has. If they did anything, I think it would probably involve Maatta, Rust, Sheahan or Sprong, but again, I don't think that's on the horizon. Just aren't the deals out there right now.

Matt in Cleveland: Why not give Jarry a game or so, can't be worse?

Jason Mackey: I guess technically it could. ... I understand why Sullivan is playing DeSmith tonight. I don't agree with it -- as I wrote today -- but I do understand it. I wouldn't understand playing Jarry. DeSmith has been fine. Do we really think Tristan would be that much better? I don't. And it could show other NHL GMs that he's less than what they thought. Unnecessary risk, basically. And, again, I think they need to get Matt's head right and get him back established at the go-to guy. Bringing up Tristan only further muddles that process.

Steven: Does Riikola have a Euro assignment clause like Plotnikov did? Seems odd that they keep him around as a healthy scratch when they've sent down Grant to keep him sharp.

Jason Mackey: I honestly don't know, Steven. That's a good question. My sense is that the answer is no, but I don't feel comfortable saying that for sure. I can tell you this: I think the organization feels Riikola is really close to being a top-six guy. They like Grant, but I think they think less of him than they do of Riikola.

Advertise with us

MA: We’ve seen some of the players use those smelling things during games and horny uses Vick’s under his nose, on TV we never see if Sid, Geno, Tanger or Phil using any of that. Do they use any of that stuff ?

Jason Mackey: I don't think so. I think Malkin has used the smelling salts at times, but nothing like Hornqvist. That's crazy what he does. Smelling salts aren't all that big among Penguins players.

Monday Morning QB: Considering the lack of production from the bottom 6, when is it time to stop blaming chemistry and start changing strategy/gameplan? The style that works for the top two lines clearly isn’t working for the bottom two. If their role is depth scoring, is there any chance they change their approach to it? Or just keep steady and hope something finally clicks…

Jason Mackey: I don't know what, really, they could change, to be honest with you. It's not like Sheahan and Rust have taken the approach NOT to try and score. They need to do it. ... I think holding onto the puck will help. Ditto for the Penguins' breakouts and simplifying. But sooner or later the people you have there just have to produce. Otherwise you need to put new people in those places. That said, I think Rust has added more than Sheahan in terms of an all-around game if we're going to talk about that.

Mario: Happy Thanksgiving Mackey. What are your favorites for the Thanksgiving meal? Turkey, stuffing, yams, and mashed potatoes here.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Thanks, Mario. Same to you. I'm simple when it comes to Thanksgiving: Turkey with gravy, preferably dark meat; stuffing and mashed potatoes, for sure; maybe a veggie or two ... only because I feel like I have to; yams or sweet potatoes are meh for me; and of course, pumpkin and apple pies.

Ken: Without knowing specifically what hole they’d be filling, who would be the first D and F recall at this point?

Jason Mackey: I would say Teddy Blueger (F) and Ethan Prow (D) are the next men up.

Christian: Hi Jason, happy Thanksgiving! Do you think the Pens trade their first round pick this year regardless of where they finish?

Jason Mackey: I think they'd like to avoid it. And if they're struggling, then they're not going to throw good money after bad, if that makes sense. ... But if they're in it, then, yeah, I think they would have no hesitation doing that. Mandate is to win now.

Advertise with us

KenniCrosby87 : Not a question, just here to say happy thanksgiving.

Jason Mackey: Happy Thanksgiving to you as well!

DTrain: Does Määttä have a future with this team? I like him, appreciate the struggles he’s gone through to get where he is, but I feel like he’s the perfect guy to move, given his likely perceived value around the league is higher than his actual value. Thoughts?

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think he has a future with this team. When he's going, I think Olli is absolutely a top-four defenseman. Think back to the beginning of last season. He had a heck of a start. I understand he's been different this year, and his skating ... well, ain't great. But he works his tail off, is a quality person and smart and is capable of giving them decent minutes back there. ... I think one of the reasons you've heard his name bandied about in trade rumors is because he might still hold value with other GMs and they could (potentially) move him.

Reggie dunlop: History tends to repeat itself, with star players on no movement contracts, are the coach killers back to their old tricks? There is a precedent...

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I don't think so. The stars have performed. Look at the Penguins, and it's hard to take issue with anything Crosby, Malkin, Kessel or Letang have done. Heck, they've been about their only four good players thus far, no? Them and Hornqvist.

Christian: Do the pens have interest in Puljujarvi? If so do you think the Sprong could fetch him?

Jason Mackey: I don't know if they have interest. Would probably depend on the ask. But I don't think Sprong one-for-one would get that done.

Guest: Next trade. When is it, and who is it?

Jason Mackey: I don't think anything is on the front burner. ... Seems like we're going to get a lot of these, so let me link yesterday's 20 Thoughts, which addresses the whole next trade deal: http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/penguins/2018/11/20/Penguins-strugg...

Advertise with us

Bob: Hi Jason! What's your favorite Turkey Day dish?

Jason Mackey: I'm in it for the turkey, mostly the dark meat, and the gravy. Maybe some stuffing, but honestly, I could just eat turkey for days. Also love the turkey legs. Get at least one every year at my in-laws, and it's awesome.

K: GMJR seems to have backed up on his threats of a shake up. Why is that? Is it because the team has shown signs of turning it around? Or is there simply no good enough deals out there? Will we see another trade? I know January is a favorite time of year for him, as is deadline. A shakeup at the deadline to prepare for playoffs perhaps?

Jason Mackey: I think it's more the lack of deals that make sense for GMJR. He made his one with Pearson. I'm starting to see what they saw, too. Plus, they knew they were going to lose Hagelin. ... It's just a tough time of year, and the Penguins don't have a ton of assets right now that other teams want. And everybody thinks they're still in, thus some really high prices. ... I think Jim's going to wait and see what happens.

Guest: I find Sullivan’s defense of his aggressive offensive system to be hilarious considering he’s icing a grinder fourth line with no speed when he previously preached having four speedy lines that can score. But you guys didn’t ask the right questions of him...it’s not about having a less speedy team that’s the issue, it’s about not having the right defenseman (like Daley) who can quickly move the puck out of the zone. We don’t have that and are missing Schultz. Has anyone ever asked Sullivan about that problem and is he adjusting his system to accommodate that? Also, his system requires excellent goaltending because it also gives up high quality chances to the opposition. Why doesn’t he feel he needs to adjust the system when his goaltending has been terrible?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: So you want us to ask Sullivan why he didn't trade for a mobile defenseman like Schultz? Also, I don't see what our questions have to do with how the Penguins play hockey. FWIW, I've asked Rutherford about defensemen. He has either declined to talk about specific areas of need or say the same stuff Sullivan does: That they think they're fast enough; why they're not right now is more a matter of execution ... and fixable.

Jason Mackey: Also, Sullivan was asked this stuff yesterday. He addressed it, and it's in today's story ... in addition to GMJR talking about it in 20 Thoughts. ... But I know, we're not asking the right questions. ... Sullivan has adjusted his system, specifically on the breakouts. He's actually tried to tweak a lot of stuff. One thing he can't do is hop over the boards and make his players play responsible hockey, at least not all of them at once, and that's been a problem.

guest: Hi Jason, Happy thanksgiving to you! thanks for doing this today. I am trying to keep a positive attitude about the Pens but I am starting to think this just may not be their year and their window is closing.

Jason Mackey: I wouldn't say their window is closing. They still have Crosby, Malkin, Kessel, Hornqvist, Letang and Dumoulin locked for a while. That's pretty darn good. Could this year just be lost soon, and they need to use it as sort of a San Antonio Spurs-like transition year? Yeah, I think that's fair. But I do think they can pull out of this. The question is just: How long will it take?

Mario: What is wrong with Matt Murray? Where are the spectacular plays we are accustomed to from him? Where do the Penguins go from here in the net?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think mentally he's in a tough spot right now. Dude really lacks confidence. What the Penguins are doing, and what they will continue to do is this: They're going to use Casey DeSmith for now, hope to start winning some games, then go to work on Murray's confidence. I think right now they're valuing wins more than Matt's mental side or confidence. To me, you're losing without him, you can lose with him. I'd like to see them get Murray re-established as the No. 1. But I can't criticize Sullivan for going the route of just wanting to win a [darn] game.

Harold: Hi, Jason: Thanks for the great work in covering the Pens and for the weekly chat.

Jason Mackey: Thanks, Harold. I appreciate you participating.

RC: Why don't you think Sprong is getting a chance? I know he is not fully developed, but at least let him show you what he can do offensively. He played a few games with Sid, but that was it. Ever since, he has played with line mates who are also underperforming. Wouldn't a game or a few games with Geno allow him to really show his offensive abilities. If they really wanna move him, it'll at least boost his value..

Jason Mackey: The boost-his-value part is interesting. That would seem to be the biggest argument for playing him with skilled people. But as I understand it, the reason they haven't played him with Crosby or Malkin is multifaceted. I don't think Crosby or Malkin wants to do it, Sullivan isn't thrilled with the idea, and Sprong with Malkin would take shots away from Malkin. Malkin has also been very good with Kessel. I wonder more why Sprong hasn't been given a shot to play with Brassard.

Advertise with us

Guest: Has the organization considered sitting Sheahan and Grant and calling up two faster players from WBS to play on the fourth line? Grant can be waived without going through waivers again and there is an extra spot on the roster with Cullen on IR. They aren’t getting it done so why not try some younger, fresher legs? Blueger for example is good at winning faceoffs

Jason Mackey: They have sat both. Didn't do much, but they did sit Sheahan for a game, and Grant been in and out all season. I agree with you that they should give Teddy Blueger a look. Why not? They say he's ready. What are we clinging to here?

guest: Is it just me or is the arena lacking atmosphere this season? And there seems to be alot of empty seats when watching on tv. Do the Pens do anything to work with the corporations who most likely have those expensive seats in trying to make sure they are used every game?

Jason Mackey: The atmosphere has been lacking, I'll agree with that. I think part of that comes with how they've played at home, too -- not good. It also hasn't been a terribly exciting brand of hockey. When you're struggling the way they have, fans are going to do other things: Whether that's sell their tickets, go get a beer during play or flip through their phones. If the Penguins are winning and playing exciting hockey, this market has proven that the fan atmosphere can be tremendous.

Harold: Based upon the ineffective, slow footed performance by Maata and Johnson in particular, are there any new rumors on any changes to the defense that GMJR may be planning?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Nope. I would expect both of those guys to stay in the lineup. And I don't disagree with it. They would be criminally overpaying for a top-four defenseman right now. If they're going to use Johnson in a third-pairing role, watch, the results are magically going to get a whole lot better.

The Fan: Of the Kings, Blues, Blackhawks and Oilers, which team has made an upgrade in coaching?

Jason Mackey: None of them, honestly. Maybe the Kings, I guess. Never been a huge John Stevens fan. But I think it's ridiculous that Yeo, Q and McLellan all had to pay for awful roster decisions made by their general managers.

FR: In his question answer article earlier in the week, Joe Starkey says Rutherford is more to blame for the current state of the Penguins more so than Sullivan? What do you think?

Jason Mackey: Do I have to pick one or the other? I'd put it on the players, to be honest with you.

Advertise with us

Reggie dunlop: In hindsight, should have Rutherford resigned Bonino? He was a warrior and had proved he could play with Kessel.

Jason Mackey: Eh, I have a tough time saying that. If Brassard had turned out to be the player he was projected to be -- you can't argue with the thought process in getting him -- then we're not having this discussion. GIven his financial situation at the time, I don't fault GMJR for avoiding giving a four-year contract worth $16 million to a guy who was 29 with one 20-goal season on his resume. FYI, Bonino has two goals in 21 games. It's not an upgrade over what they currently have.

Bob: Can you ask Matt Vensel (or his editor) what the score of Wednesday night's game against Dallas was? His article said that Sid returned, Malkin played (after taking a stick to the head Monday and sitting out practice, and Riikola returned to the lineup. :)

Jason Mackey: It is strange that it's written in the past tense. Normally that's only done around puck drop. I will look into it. Thanks.

Nick: At trade deadline who do you see being dealt ?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: It's still waaaay too early for that, Nick, and this team has so many more issues. They might be non-competitive by then, or they might have a completely new need. It's just tough to say right now given how these first 19 games have gone.

ER: If this continues, can you see #LoseForHughes becoming a reality, and the Penguins selling off some pieces they wouldn't expect to move?

Jason Mackey: Ha. No, it's not going to get to that. Funny hashtag, though.

KM: Is there any indication that Geno is dealing with some sort of a nagging injury? Obviously the whole team is struggling, and he is still putting up points, but it feels like the turnovers are worse than usual.

Jason Mackey: No, there's no indication. And, honestly, those stupid turnovers aren't unique to Malkin in 2018-19. They're a part of his game. Same with the stupid penalties. But you kinda have to take the good with the bad.

Advertise with us

Tom: Being you are around the players off can you give insight To some personalities?

Jason Mackey: That's a bit of a broad question, Tom. Anyone specifically you're curious about?

Steven: Jesse Marshall in The Athletic had a good piece on the failings of the Penguins breakout, and how Sullivan said he would change that. Have you noticed anything different through the last 2 practices in that ergard?

Jason Mackey: Yes, I've been at all of them, and they've worked on breaking out in crowds ... that might be the best way to put it. I actually asked Jack Johnson about that this morning. I think this quote might help: "It was working on breaking out from a scrum or not a clean breakout. Everyone getting available out of a scrum in the corner. Once the other team’s in the offensive zone, you want to try and get them stopped, get the puck stopped, get the players stopped, then dig the puck out from there. You have to be able to break the puck out from those defensive scrums. Not every breakout is going to be a clean breakout. It’s just the way it is. There are going to be good dumps by the other team. The other teams are going to carry it with possession. You have to find a way to break the puck out."

Jeff: At what point do the Penguins look at Jack Johnson and say "Okay, maybe this was a mistake"? Hopefully Jim Rutherford knows that Peter Chiarelli loves collecting vastly overrated defensemen.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Jack Johnson has been fine. Has he been great? No. He's also been used wrong. Play him on the third pair, and let's see. And also, even the games where he has been bad, I don't understand why all the Penguins' problems are his fault.

guest: Do you think part of the problem with the chemistry is a disconnect between the older and younger players? The younger players feel too much pressure to produce for the older players? with the cup runs the young players came up in groups so had each other but now they seem to be kind of on their own.

Jason Mackey: I don't think so. I think it's a pretty inclusive room. I think they all feel pressure, but not anything out of the ordinary. I think right now you have a group of guys slumping, too many at the same time. They've been doing different things poorly. The goaltending hasn't saved them, the same for the secondary scoring. They have little cushion, and they're screwing up so much and so frequently that it's costing them. I don't think it has anything to do with the age range in the room or that meshing well.

Average Joes: Hi Jason, every Penguins insider from every publication predicted the Pens would win the Metro and almost all had them winning the Cup. No one even hinted that a struggle was possible. What on-ice aspect do you think was overlooked/missed/overestimated by those closest to the team that led to the slow start?

Jason Mackey: I know me personally, I probably didn't take seriously enough to gradual slide from 2015-16 to 2016-17 and 2017-18 when it came to speed/possessing/playing with the puck. ... Also, the back end. I think we may have over-estimated their depth and how much they could address the loss of Justin Schultz. But this? Some of this has also just been a crazy cavalcade of problems.

SidFan: Thoughts on this:

Jason Mackey: No problem. Here you go:

Hatrick Pornquivst: I think you chats should have a weekly Jeff Jimerson question. So to start it off - is that his only gig, and it pays well, or is it just a hobby done for free nachos and season tickets? either way - I'm cool with it.

Jason Mackey: Ha. I don't know about the perks of the job, to be honest. But he does have a band, I know that. Believe it's called Airborne. Don't know if that's after the Vitamin C supplement or not.

SidFan: thoughts on these lines: Guentzel-Sid-Hornq Pearson-Geno-Sprong Simon-Brass-Phil Rust-Sheahan-ZAR

Jason Mackey: I don't like Sprong with Malkin one, because it's never actually going to happen so it's a waste of our time. But also because Sprong will take too many shots. Do you want Malkin deferring to a 21-year-old with four goals in 40 NHL games? I don't. I'd go Phil with Geno. Brassard, Simon and Rust were very good in the preseason. I like that. I'd also like a look at ZAR-Sheahan-Sprong. I think there's some potential there.

LA Matt: Is it time to just roll the dice with Murray? In other words, play him for five games in a row to get out of this funk rather than in one game, out the next?

Jason Mackey: That's what I would do, Matt, and it's what I wrote about for today's paper. You're losing without him. What's the difference if you lose with him? Let him find his game.

The Fan: Much was made of the cheering going on in the press box by the Jacksonville media in the earlier stages of the Steelers game. Why is that viewed as a sin among others in the press box? It seems many journalists these days like to think their friends with players, coaches and general managers. Why not cheer for them when they perform well?

Jason Mackey: I don't view myself as friends with any of the players, coaches or members of the front office. Do I hope they respect me for my work ethic, accuracy, ability to do the job? Sure I do. But it's a professional relationship and some are different than others. I think that's a big misconception by fans. We are not fans. I don't care if they win or lose by 50. Makes zero difference in my way, and that's how it should be if you want honest, objective coverage. If you want EVERYTHING IS GREAT ALL THE TIME, read the team's coverage.

Matt in Cleveland: If the Pens don't bring up Jarry to see if he can have a better save pct than .877 because it screws up Murray's mind, maybe the Pens should have hired Hitchcock!

Jason Mackey: Mike Sullivan is not the problem. And, um, Mario Lemieux isn't firing Sullivan for Ken Hitchcock. I think he just threw up in his mouth thinking about it.

LA Matt: Despite the two cups, does Rutherford deserve some blame for the team's current problems? In other words, it seems like he brought in too many round pegs to fit in square holes and vice versa.

Jason Mackey: Sure. I think that's fair. His work the past two summers hasn't been good enough -- Niemi, Hunwick, Reaves, etc. They don't have enough depth right now ... or at least it looks like they don't. That doesn't mean Jim should be tarred and feathered on the spot, but thinking he's included in criticism of the team is more than fair.

Bob: Do you want my turkey legs?! No one in my family eats them!!! It's a shame they go to waste every year.

Jason Mackey: Who doesn't like turkey legs? C'mon, people.

Guest: Do you think the team would ideally like to move Kessel for some younger players, forward and D, if it looks like they’ll be out of the playoff hunt?

Jason Mackey: No, I don't. I don't think his teammates would like it. I don't think the fan base would like it. He's also been one of the best and most consistent point producers this season. But GMJR needs to make good business decisions and arguably more of them. If he gets an offer for Kessel where he can turn Phil into a couple younger players who are cost-controlled, then yeah, I think that would be smart to entertain. However, there's no indication that deal is there to be had.

Joeco: yours thoughts on this...it seems to me the penguins are in a chase the puck vs go where it's going to be... they seem behind the eight ball on both ends....

Jason Mackey: It's not wrong, but that's a really narrow depiction of what's going on. They need to be smarter with the puck. If they don't give it away -- looking at you Olli Maatta -- then they obviously would have it more.

Steven: In Friedman's 31 Thoughts he just put out, he talks that the Penguins were trying get Brandon Montour. I obviously see the desire to get Montour, but can you confirm that desire at all, and what the Penugins were willing to give up to get it done?

Jason Mackey: I've been doing this and covering the skate, and I'm not going to go knocking on doors over interest in Brandon Montour on a game day ... but I have no reason to dispute Elliotte's reporting. He's one of the best, if not the best. What I can you now, though, is this: JIm expresses interest on a lot of guys. Doesn't mean he's aggressively making offers all the time. But he's on the phone a lot with other GMs, and lately I know he's been checking even more than normal. So it doesn't surprise me.

Mario: If Rutherford is going to stay quiet and not pull the trigger on a trade, what is going to happen with Sprong? I would still like to see him with better players on his line and see him moved from the dreaded 4th line. But doesn't seem likely due to HCMS. Could Rutherford pull rank and instruct Sullivan to play Sprong on another line?

Jason Mackey: Yeah, he could. And I don't think we're far off from that. I think it's been a bit of a back-and-forth with those two. Rutherford wants Sprong to play with more skilled people and can accept if it's not with Crosby or Malkin. Sullivan hasn't view Sprong as one of the club's best 12 forwards a decent amount of the time lately. I feel like something has to give here. Either play him with someone like Brassard or trade him.

Guest: Do you think JR might be interested in trading for a veteran backup goalie like Ryan Miller in Anaheim?

Jason Mackey: No, I don't. I think they're fine with the goalies they have. They have bigger fish to fry.

Gus: Jason, I cannot wrap my head around the similarities that are starting to come to light between Bylsma and Sullivan - ignoring top talent (Sprong, Pouliot, Bennett) and instead playing average 4th liners (Adams, Talbot, Rupp, Grant, Cullen, Wilson, etc). I also feel that Sullivan, like Bylsma, is unable to change his game plan as other teams catch on. Sullivan was all about speed, but we are no longer the fastest team in the NHL. I know he has 2 Cups, but I think Tocchet played a large part in those. I think with Quenville on the market, he has to be on a shorter leash?

Jason Mackey: He's not, and I wouldn't get rid of HCMS, either. I wouldn't even think about it. Sullivan has tried, trust me. And it's not a matter of being ill-equipped. It's execution, and the Penguins are costing themselves by being sloppy. ... Also, you're describing pretty much every hockey coach ever when you saw they trust some safer players more than the risky ones. Perhaps it comes from the hockey-ism that fires coaches like every other day.

Mark: Craig Custance in The Athletic earlier this week wrote an article saying there is a whisper if the Pens do not turn it around, they may "work" to get into the chase for the #1 pick to choose Jack Hughes. He didn't outright say they would tank it, but.....What are your thoughts on this theory?

Jason Mackey: What would they do, rig the lottery system? Throw games while having a payroll at the cap ceiling that includes a couple of future Hall of Famers? C'mon.

GuestSC: Freddie Tiffels seemed to be highly ranked on the organizational depth chart. Things apparently did not end well. Can you shed any light on what happened there?

Jason Mackey: I think Tiffels wanted to play in his native Germany and didn't see a clear path to the NHL with the Penguins' big club. Simple as that.

Jeff: Is Riley Sheahan cooked? Sure seems like it.

Jason Mackey: He's not adding much, I'll give you that. Offensively, you can't even say that he's getting a bunch of chances and getting robbed. Right now anyway it looks like they were very smart to only do a one-year deal with him.

Guest: Do you think Murray seeing less game time is in part due to his attitude towards the situation? https://pittsburghhockeynow.com/pittsburgh-penguins-16050-2/ It's hard just getting bits and could be reading into it, but he also denied a request to talk to the media last week and the in linked article his responses seem a bit curt. Does it seem like behind the scenes he isn't handling the situation as best as he could be and that is frustrating Sullivan? Seemed liked last game was a good transition to get him back into the net

Jason Mackey: Hard to say. Murray being uninterested in talking about anything isn't unique. He's done the same through successful playoff runs, too, so I don't know if I would read too much into that. I was there for all of it and found it quite humorous. And yeah, he said last week I think it was that he "had to be outta here in 8 minutes and couldn't stick around." This was amid a run of gamedays (where he doesn't talk) and off-days (where we don't have access to him) so you think this would be the time, but he didn't want to talk. I don't fault him. I think he's ticked off at a lot of things, and I think he should be. Does that mean he's not handling it right? I don't know. Nobody made me the judge of handling stuff right or wrong. I just think the guy needs to play better than he has.

Guest: Sidney Crosby one for one for Connor McDavid, who says no? :P

Jason Mackey: Me, for one.

guest: HIndsight is easy and maybe a change of scenery has been good, but it looks like they should have kept Sheary, he is producing more than any of our bottom six. I think they miss his youthful excitement.

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think that's a reasonable point. Don't know what you got 'till it's gone right? He seems to be doing quite well in Buffalo. Good for him. ... Although given his slumps and inconsistent performance over the past two seasons, I can see moving him, too.

Norm: Jason, do the Pens still have their 2019 #1 pick? And if so, do you think they go after the best available forward, defense man, goalie?

Jason Mackey: They do, yes, but I don't think you can target one position. Need to take the best player available given the dearth of talent right now in their system.

Reggie dunlop: Bonino is +12 though and he isn’t playing with anyone as dangerous as Kessel in fake country and western land. Didn’t they just pay Jack Johnson 16 million?

Jason Mackey: They did. They also play different positions, have different contract lengths and came up for free agency at different times.

guest: It seems Jack Johnson is the unluckliest player, he is on the ice for goals but usually seems to be in the right position and at least covering his man which is more than I can say for some of his teammates. Case in point in Buffalo game when shot goes off his skate, he was on his man in the crease.

Jason Mackey: Guess I agree with some of that, but there's also awareness involved. I'm not sure if I would read anything into that sequence good or bad. Just fluky. My stance on Jack has been if he's a third-pairing guy, I'm cool with it ... and we'll worry about length of contract later. I stand by that.

Dave: Doing a little math, with 63 games to go, the Pens need 82 points to get to 100 (and presumably make the playoffs.) That comes out to winning 65% of the possible points. I know it means turning things around quickly, but that is not out of the realm of possibility for this team--that is more their typical points percentage under Sullivan. Given that, and how muddled the Metro is, do you think that is giving management some patience in not making more wholesale changes?

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think some patience absolutely is in order. I know it looks bleak at the moment, but the division is a mess; it would be different if they played in the Atlantic.

Josh: Friedman just reported on his 31 thoughts that the Penguins wanted to get their hands on Montour from the Ducks, but it didn't work out. He also added that someone who might fit the Pens profile is Silfverberg. He mentioned that entering Saturday's game, 41 of the 46 goals scored game from top 6, suggesting that Silfverberg can be good top 9 addition.

Jason Mackey: I need to have a talk with Elliotte about holding that stuff until after my weekly chat. Ha. (I'm kidding, by the way. I would never actually do that.)

Pens4Life: Jason: What is the personal relationship like between Sid and Geno? Superstars sometimes clash, but I’ve always wondered how those two get along off the ice? Do they hang out, or does each do his own thing?

Jason Mackey: They don't clash at all. They actually get along very well, and it's fun to see them chat and goof around with each other. ... To be fair, Crosby -- one of the world's nicest humans -- would get along with a wall. But no, they genuinely get along.

Pens4Life: In your 20 thoughts this week, you mentioned Maatta’s “five on five shot share of 456.00…” What does that mean? Never heard that stat.

Jason Mackey: Should be 46.0, first off. Secondly, it's Corsi. A measure of puck possession. The number of shot attempts the Penguins have when Maatta is on the ice five-on-five.

Pens4Life: What's Dupuis up to these days?

Jason Mackey: He's in Montreal being a dad. I've tried to contact him a few times with little luck. But last I heard he was coaching his kids and catching up on a bunch of stuff he's missed. This is something I did last year: http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/penguins/2018/04/03/Penguins-Pascal...

Guest: Will we see Blueger at all this season? And if Cullen retires and Sheahan doesn’t come back, will he be a full time member of the team next season?

Jason Mackey: I would think yes on both of those accounts. I'm surprised Blueger isn't here already, to be honest with you. He deserves a chance.

Norm: Yea Jason, how about an article on Jeff Jimerson. We see him every home game and he never disappoints. It would be nice to know a little about him.

Jason Mackey: That's actually a great idea, Norm. I'm going to dig into that. Maybe talk a little music with him. Thanks.

Malkin_theBeast: Hey Jason, are you out of some Pens news match coverage because you have to spent more time with your new babies at home? Your colleague V is good but I like yours better, you're doing such a good job! ^_~

About the Pens team, do you still believe they can still turn this season around for a playoff berth? If yes, what should they do?

Jason Mackey: Thank you for the kind words. I do appreciate it. We've been managing just fine with the little one. My wife is the real MVP, to be honest. ... I do think they can turn it around. Guys need to start scoring, though, and they need to be a lot more responsible than they have been in several areas. Getting Crosby back will help. Goaltending needs to be better.

Guest: What are the chances of a Sprong for Dylan Strome swap? Two struggling players in serious need of scenery changes.

Jason Mackey: I can't say definitely no, but I have a tough time thinking someone would give up the third overall pick one year for someone who was taken in the second. Seems a bit uneven.

Gus: You said "Mike Sullivan is not the problem." Can you please elaborate? Obviously the Pens are low on prospects and players who we can trade, so something needs to shake up. It seems to me like Sullivan has lost the team. Quenville looking like a good option.

Jason Mackey: Because Mike Sullivan is trying like hell to get this fixed, and he's a very good hockey coach. Is it Sullivan's fault the Penguins bottom-six can't buy a goal or that Matt Murray has struggled? He also didn't hurt Justin Schultz.

Kim: Hi Jason - Happy Thanksgiving!

Jason Mackey: Thanks, Kim. Same to you!

Kim: What aspect of Riikola's game does he need to work on the most? Thanks!

Jason Mackey: He needs to work on timing -- how quickly he makes plays on the smaller ice. That has caused him some issues. Basically just adjusting to the North American game.

MA: What are the chances the pens keep Kessel after his deal is up?

Jason Mackey: Very minimal, I would think. They're probably going to need to put that money elsewhere.

I'm back: GMJR traded Hagelin to shake up the players in the room. Might GMJR have hired Craig Patrick to shake up the coach in the room. Craig had a habit of jumping behind the bench when the situation calls for it.

Jason Mackey: If GMJR hired Craig Patrick to coach instead of, say, Joel Quenneville, I have a big problem with that, but that's not what he did. I think he hired Craig Patrick as another (smart) set of eyes. Nothing more, nothing less.

Steven: Did you ever get a chance to watch Sprong in the AHL? The legend of Sprong has far exceeded anything he has ever shown in the AHL. Do you have any contacts of other team's pro scouts who have an opinion on him?

Jason Mackey: I did, Steven. And there are definitely warts to his game. But many people around hockey do believe he should be capable of scoring at this level.

Amy : Why did the penguins seem to want to push the pace in OT vs Sabres the other night? By pushing speed seemed to lead to a sloppy shift change and an easy goal 3 on 3 for the sabres.

Jason Mackey: Because they have the talent to do so, honestly. But there's a difference between pushing the pace and being sloppy, and I think that's what you saw against the Sabres.

Guest: If the pens miss the playoffs this year how much is this a hit to Sid and Geno’s legacies ?

Jason Mackey: It depends on what happens after it. If they miss and they use it as a way to reset, nothing. But if they miss and do nothing to fix their problems, then obviously it's a pretty big dent. They're still squarely in their primes.

Tom: Curious about brassard, Kessel, olesiak

Jason Mackey: What about them?

Guest: What do you Think...Murray for Fleury swap.

Jason Mackey: And Vegas would do that ... why?

Amy : Do you think Columbus will hold the division lead by the end of the season? Maybe win a playoff series...beside the penguins, what other teams aren’t playing to their potential in your opinion

Jason Mackey: I don't think they will at the end, no, although I could see them winning a round. Boston has struggled, although the Bruins have been hurt. L.A. has been bad. The Blues and Blackhawks, too, in my opinion.

May See Gray: I haven't read through the questions but....Daniel Sprong. We have seen some flashes the last couple of games but nothing superb. Why won't Sully put him with Sid or Geno? What did he do? I understand wanting him to earn it but I call BS- he must have insulted someone's mother or said 'I'm better than Sid' or something. Aside from the fact that he doesn't seem to know where to go when he doesn't have the puck I see no reason to keep him off the top lines ;P

Jason Mackey: I don't think Sid or Geno want him there, to be honest, and it's more of a stylistic thing. With Malkin, Sprong would be the No. 1 shooter, and they don't want to do that with Malkin, unless we're talking Kessel. His game is oil and water with Sid.

May See Gray: Why is Derek Grant still here?

Jason Mackey: I would use Teddy Blueger, but they do like what Grant adds on the PK and they think he can maybe add some offense. I have my doubts.

Max: Any chance Bluegar gets a chance over Sheahan

Jason Mackey: Not at we sit here today. I think he should, but they seem content to keep running Sheahan out there.

May See Gray: Would love to see Rust get back into form but do you know why he's been out of it in the first place? Is it just a slump or did he have an injury I don't know about?

Jason Mackey: No injury to my knowledge. Confidence was an issue earlier. He's also been tremendously unlucky. He has done some other things to help. I think Rust is due a hot streak here soon.

Guest123: Jason I know this is a stupid question but would Rutherford ever consider bringing Flower back?

Jason Mackey: No, I think that ship has passed, and there's no way Vegas would ever do that.

Charles Grimbauer: Hot take: It looks like Sully has put on a few pounds- would his team respond better if he was in shape enough to keep up with, say jack Johnson?

Jason Mackey: I don't understand your question. ... And I also don't think Sully's weight has anything to do with how his team has played.

guest: I love Sid, but we have been looking for a RW for him since Marian Hossa. Maybe it's time for Sid to be less stubborn? And now it might cost us a young guy with upside, Sprong, just bec Sid doesnt want to play with him.

Jason Mackey: I don't think it's a Sid issue. He was good with a lot of wings -- Guentzel, Sheary, Hornqvist. Sid was great when he went out of the lineup. On my list of concerns for this team ... Sid ain't on it. They have wingers who can play with him.

guest: Is Geno going to ever learn to play more disciplined? Dont get me wrong, when he's into it hes a load, but he's to careless in his own end and with penalties.

Jason Mackey: Maybe not. Got this before. But I think you just have to live with the bad. These issues are not new.

guest: why is desmith playing tonight? whats the point?

Jason Mackey: I'm a little surprised. I thought he would go with Murray. But I think Sullivan thinks DeSmith gives them the best chance to win a game, and that's what they need to do more than anything -- get a win and get their confidence up before worrying about anything else.

Alex: Is Matt Murray the next Cam Ward?

Jason Mackey: I think it's too early to start thinking about that.

guest: whos killing penalties now that cullen is out and hagelin gone

Jason Mackey: They've given ZAR some additional time, and he's been good. Rust, too. Even Jake Guentzel has been asked to do some of that stuff.

Charles Grimbauer: Do hockey players read? I know video games is massively popular, and fishing, and golf, but what about intellectual endeavours? I know Dumoulin is a 'foodie' but there's gotta be someone who reads poetry on the side, right? They can't all just be 'jocks'..

Jason Mackey: They do some, but yeah, video games are probably much more popular given the demographic. I don't know of many Penguins anymore who are huge readers, but I don't think that's terribly unique in society today.

Guest: When is the trade deadline?

Jason Mackey: End of February, usually.

Grumblepuff: A lot of the time I see Simon doing really impressive stuff, making savvy plays but he also seems to fly under the radar a bit. It feels like there is untapped potential there and they're hoping Sid can find it but Simon has to have some agency as well. Thoughts?/

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think Simon has actually improved a decent amount this season. He does a lot of stuff -- small areas, wall plays, give-and-go game -- that's subtle, and I think he has actually been decent with Crosby when given the chance.

Guest: Is Cully’s injury a real injury? Seems more like they want him out of the way a bit to give new young guys a chance.

Jason Mackey: I think it's a real injury. Matt Vensel saw him with an ice pack on his right leg/ankle in Ottawa, the game before he went out.

Guest: Of the next 5 games, which team do we have the best chance to beat? Injury depleted Boston? Maybe Dallas tonight using their also injury depeleted defense and backup goalie?

Jason Mackey: I think tonight is a very good chance. Boston, too. Would be great for them if they could get two of the next three in some form or fashion.

Jason Mackey: OK, folks, that does it. Thanks so much for participating. Hope everyone has a Happy Thanksgiving!