For much of Monday, it looked like the Penguins were in position to exhale a bit. In the morning, Sidney Crosby skated with his teammates, a sign he could return soon from an upper-body injury. At night, the Penguins built a three-goal cushion through 25 minutes against the Buffalo Sabres, getting contributions from a few key players.

It turns out the Penguins took too depth of a breath.

They squandered the advantage they had worked so hard to earn and lost in overtime to the Buffalo Sabres, 5-4, at PPG Paints Arena, the Penguins’ fourth consecutive defeat and ninth in the past 10 games.

“You can’t go into a prevent defense,” Jack Johnson said. “That usually prevents winning. We have to do a better job of staying after them.”

Advertise with us

Like so many of the Penguins’ losses this season, had this been a normal start to the season, nobody would’ve batted an eye. Lose a November game to the Sabres, even if it’s ugly, forget about it. It’ll be a distant memory by April.

But the Penguins (7-8-4) are at a point where points do matter. They need wins. And they can’t afford to cough up third-period leads, which they did for the first time this season when Sabres captain Jack Eichel ended it with his goal 45 seconds into overtime.

“We’re making some mental mistakes, and it’s costing us,” Derick Brassard. “We just have to stick with it. We’re facing adversity right now. We’re trying to come out of it as a team.”

One lesson the Penguins will take out of this one is to keep their foot on the gas. A lack of confidence has permeated the Penguins right now, and that’s absolutely applicable to protecting leads.

“On a couple of goals they scored, we made a couple of mistakes,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said. “They ended up in the back of our net. It just seems like that’s the way it’s going right now.”

Advertise with us

The Penguins, though, insisted there were plenty of positives to pluck from this one, their seventh defeat in 10 home games thus far.

Among them:

• Brassard scored a beautiful goal in the first period that showed off his speed and skill. If Brassard, who also saw time with the top power play, can integrate himself into the Penguins lineup, that would be big.

• Tanner Pearson had a goal and an assist in his best game since coming to Pittsburgh via trade.

The line of Pearson, Evgeni Malkin and Phil Kessel was a threat all night, and Pearson set up Kessel for a pretty goal late in the opening period.

Advertise with us

• The Penguins played on their toes for the first half of the game, dictating tempo and actually using their speed as an advantage.

“We certainly have to clean up some areas defensively,” Sullivan said. “But there was a lot to like in this game as well.”

One strange trend that has popped up this season is the Penguins struggling in three-on-three overtime, an area they used to dominate. Six games this season have advanced past regulation, and the Penguins have won only two of them – against Washington on Oct. 4 and Edmonton on Oct. 23.

But focusing too much on overtime would be ignoring the bigger picture: The Penguins are in a funk, a really bad funk. They have just one win in November, a 4-0 victory over the Arizona Coyotes on Nov. 10, and they’re tied for the fewest points in the Eastern Conference.

Less quantifiable is how the Penguins have looked doing it. The second, third and fourth goals the Sabres scored were not pretty.

Advertise with us

Zach Bogosian scored from 41 feet, and fellow defenseman Casey Nelson snuck one through from 48 feet after it ticked off Johnson’s skate. Center Casey Mittelstadt’s goal, from the left circle, came from 28 feet out.

Defensively, it continues a trend for the Penguins of allowing opposing teams entirely too much, whether that’s in front of their net, off the rush or shots with a little distance to them. The goaltending has also not been good enough when it’s needed to be.

“We obviously have to clean up a few things in our game,” Brassard said. “It’s not a lack of effort.”

Monday’s loss did produce a point, which was different than the third-period, moral victory they took out of the Ottawa game Saturday or all that talk about five-on-five play two nights earlier in a loss to Tampa Bay.

But with American Thanksgiving looming, which is traditionally the time where 80 percent of the NHL playoff picture tends to take shape, reality should be starting to set in. If they want to ensure this is not a lost season, the Penguins must start figuring out how to win games, not lose them.

Advertise with us

“We’re well-aware of the position we’re in,” Sullivan said. “None of us are happy with it. We have a proud group. I do think we’re getting better in a lot of areas. We’re not getting the results, but we very well could have in a number of games,

“We have to clean up some areas where I know we’re capable of being better. Then we have to make sure we don’t get down on ourselves and we keep the right attitude and the right energy around the rink so that we can pull together.”

Around the boards

Buffalo won in Pittsburgh for the first time since April 23, 2013. … Sabres have won six in a row for the first time since 2010. … The Penguins’ second, third and fourth goals came from a total of 24 feet, a sign they’re getting the “blue-paint goals” Sullivan has been wanting.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.