OTTAWA – The list of issues plaguing the last-place Penguins is long yet seemingly still growing, especially after a 6-4 loss to the lowly Ottawa Senators. The lack of secondary scoring. Injuries to key players. Sloppy coverage in the defensive zone. Alarming apathy at times.
And, yes, some of those were factors Saturday at Canadian Tire Centre in the latest Penguins loss.
But perhaps the most persistent problem is the play of goalie Matt Murray, who has won two Stanley Cups but probably couldn’t stop one if you were to slide it his way right now.
Murray got his second straight start Saturday despite allowing four goals in Thursday’s loss to the Tampa Bay Lightning – the seventh time in his first 10 starts he gave up at least that many.
But after just 20 minutes, Mike Sullivan had to yank Murray before he made it eight of 11.
Asked after the game if he thinks Murray’s confidence is shaken, he replied, “I’m sure it is.”
Read More
“He’s a human being, you know? He’s a proud guy and he wants to do well,” the sullen Penguins coach said, adding, “There’s always that fine line of trying and making sure you don’t try too hard, because that can be counterproductive. When you go through a stretch like we’re going through, I don’t think Matt’s different any different than a lot of our guys.”
Now Sullivan must seriously mull whether the Penguins, their season potentially on the brink already after their eighth loss in nine games, can go back to Murray anytime soon.
The night started well for the Penguins, who were without Sidney Crosby for a second straight game but got back Derick Brassard after he was sidelined the previous nine games.
Kris Letang got the first goal of the game on a Penguins power play. His point shot missed all the shin guards in front of the net and beat goalie Craig Anderson under his glove.
But the Senators quickly responded with three goals on Murray in less than five minutes.
Brady Tkachuk hammered home a rebound after Murray couldn’t corral an acute-angle shot. Two and a half minutes later, Mark Stone redirected a Thomas Chabot point shot past Murray. Then, with 70 seconds left in the first period, Mikkel Boedker made a pretty pass through Letang to Matt Duchene, who steered the puck past Murray’s outstretched right leg.
“When you give up three goals like that, it’s a tough mountain to climb,” Sullivan said.
After allowing those goals on only 10 shots, Murray was replaced in the second period by Casey DeSmith. It was the third time in three weeks Murray was pulled from a game.
Murray now has a porous .877 save percentage this season while coughing up 4.08 goals per game. The 24-year-old hasn’t won a game since that 9-1 blowout in Calgary on Oct. 25.
“I’ve just got to play the game. Everyone is going to make mistakes out there, including myself. I’ve made plenty of them,” Murray said. “So I’ve got to learn from them and move on. You’ve got to keep your confidence. At a time like this, it’s easy to be negative.”
DeSmith, for once, didn’t fare much better, giving up three goals on 15 Senators shots.

With just under four minutes remaining in the second period, Stone stole the puck from Olli Maatta in the neutral zone and beat DeSmith on a breakaway for a shorthanded goal.
Just over a minute later, Cody Ceci snapped a shot from the right dot over DeSmith's right shoulder, making the score 5-1. That play looked a lot like a few others Saturday, the Penguins scrambling inside of their zone and losing track of a Senators shooter yet again.
The Penguins got goals from Zach Aston-Reese and Matt Cullen early in the third period and continued to make things interesting with a few frantic moments around Anderson’s net. But Duchene put an end to the suspense when he beat DeSmith five-hole on a breakaway.
With six attackers on, Patric Hornqvist scored with 3:04 left, but that was all she wrote.
“Too bad they got that sixth goal there,” said Hornqvist, who got about a dozen stitches after his shot in warmups pinged off a post and into his forehead. “It’s hard to come back again.”
A case could be made they were the better team in three of their previous four games. Saturday’s dud, though, looked like some of the ones the Penguins slogged through after returning from last month’s 4-0 road trip through Canada, which feels like it was a year ago.
The Penguins played like a slower team. They too often lacked a coordinated effort on defense. They could have capitalized more on the power play. And they took too many penalties.
“I’m not going to sit here and just pile it on our guys,” said Sullivan, who vowed to continue to look for positives as the losses mount. “I know this a terrific group of people and they’re good players and they care and we’re going to work together to find a way to get the results.”
With the way the Penguins are struggling right now, it would be great if one of their goalies could steal a game or two, instead of giving them no chance, as was the case Saturday. But too often it was their opponent who saw their goalie grab one of that night’s “Three Stars.”
Sullivan and the puzzled Penguins have been trying to find a way to get Murray going – two weeks ago, they gave DeSmith three starts in a row and told Murray to go work on his game with goaltending coach Mike Buckley – figuring they will need him in April and May.
At this rate, though, they’ll be done playing then for the first time in a dozen years.
The Penguins have a bunch of other problems to solve to prevent that type of disappointing finish, as Saturday’s loss, their latest one to an inferior team, showed once again.
But if they can’t get solid goaltending on a consistent basis, none of that might matter.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.