The Penguins lost to Tampa, 4-3, on Thursday night at PPG Paints Arena for their seventh loss in eight games. The Kings and Blues are the only NHL teams with fewer than the Penguins’ 17 points.

It has been an ugly stretch of hockey, no doubt. And I know what the standard approach has been in recent years when this team has struggled:

“It is early and this Penguins team has won back-to-back Stanley Cups recently; they will work their way out of it.”

“They are still one of the best teams in hockey, and they are still a legitimate title contender.”

Advertise with us

“They will turn it on at some point, so no need to be concerned!”

Sound about right?

They may find a way to pull it together and get to the playoffs, but that’s about as far as this team will go. They are no longer a championship-caliber team, and it’s time to face that fact.

The Penguins aren’t the best team in hockey, or even close. They are no longer faster than every other team, and speed is no longer their advantage on most nights. They no longer strike fear in the hearts of opponents, either. And they’re not as deep as Jim Rutherford and Mike Sullivan told us they’d be.

It is pretty clear that more secondary scoring and goals that come from people beyond the stars and top two lines are glaring needs. But the Penguins also need some younger legs. That’s why Rutherford’s trade for Tanner Pearson may be exactly what the doctor ordered, as Pearson brings some speed and youth and is a player mired in an offensive slump who might flourish with a change of scenery.

Advertise with us

The Penguins’ defensive depth also appears to be a total of four players, which is about two short of what it takes to win. The Jack Johnson signing hasn’t necessarily worked out yet. They still have great high-end talent, but most of those stars are all 30-somethings now, and the league is full of stars who are 25 and younger.

Now on Thursday, the Penguins played the Lightning without Sidney Crosby and Derick Brassard, and that’s a significant blow to their depth down the middle. Brassard, though, hasn’t provided anywhere close to what the Penguins were hoping when Rutherford traded for him at the deadline last season.

Against the Lightning, the Penguins gave up four goals, and they all came when Tampa Bay was on the power play. Three of those goals came in a span of 91 seconds. Predictably, Penguins players blamed the loss on the fact that they couldn’t stay out of the penalty box.

“We played well. We lost the game because of the PK. That’s it,” defenseman Kris Letang said.

Patric Hornqvist even went with “We were the better team 5-on-5.” I’m not sure that is meaningful given that they allowed the Lightning to have seven power plays.

Advertise with us

The Penguins are kidding themselves and are borderline delusional if they aren’t going to acknowledge the bigger picture. These recent losses have come in a variety of ways (poor defense, poor play at goaltender, lack of offense, close defeats, blowouts).

That adds up to a team that isn’t playing hockey very well — or a team that just might be painfully average.

Hornqvist also talked Thursday about how the Penguins have been through this the last few years and have always turned things around and found their way back to the playoffs.

It’s a great thought, but those teams were different, younger and better. And Thursday was just the latest chapter for a team that might not be good enough as currently constructed.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com

Advertise with us