Carl Hagelin was an incredibly popular player inside the Penguins dressing room for his personality, attitude, ridiculous speed and the positivity he brought to the group. On a team that doesn’t lack for star power, how well Hagelin did everything other than score was what endeared him to his teammates.

Hagelin wasn’t blessed with the hands of a 30-goal man, but he was responsible defensively, killed penalties and served as a disruptive force on the forecheck, so much so that he helped the HBK line become a thing and later locked down a regular spot alongside Evgeni Malkin and Phil Kessel.

Which is why general manager Jim Rutherford’s willingness to trade Hagelin for Tanner Pearson, formerly of the Los Angeles Kings, reverberated the way it did inside the Penguins dressing room early Wednesday afternoon, shortly after the deal was announced.

“Honestly, (Rutherford’s) sending a big message to the group,” Patric Hornqvist said following Penguins practice at the UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex. “We need to be better.”

Advertise with us

The Penguins are 7-6-3 and have lost six of seven. They were two points shy of the Metropolitan Division basement entering Wednesday’s games. There’s no more pushing this off to the side, pretending it’s not real.

So while Rutherford knew when he made the deal that it would almost assuredly affect the Penguins’ chemistry, he also figured that might turn out to be a good thing.

“I’m sure it’ll affect the chemistry in the room,” Rutherford said. “He’s a very popular guy. But I’m not sure how strong the chemistry is right now, based on what I’m seeing.”

Think about that statement for a second. Rutherford is there, on record, openly worrying about the Penguins’ chemistry a couple months after they lost very little via free agency. It’s hard to imagine that Conor Sheary, Tom Kuhnhackl and Matt Hunwick were responsible for this.

It’s also the first time anyone associated with the team has admitted there might be a problem with cohesion. Defense, goaltending, secondary scoring and overall team play have come up. Not chemistry.

Advertise with us

To acknowledge a need for a shakeup, and then act on it, means the Penguins — who Rutherford insisted are focused on continuing to push for a Stanley Cup — are taking this very seriously.

“I don’t think we’re playing the way we want right now,” Kris Letang said. “I don’t think we’re happy about results. And I think these things happen in those circumstances.”

Even to guys like Hagelin, who was a vital piece to the Penguins after arriving from Anaheim for David Perron in January 2016, a key move on their first Stanley Cup march.

While Hornqvist said that Wednesday was “a tough day for me and my family” given how close he is to Hagelin, a fellow Swede, the reality is that it was tough on every Penguins player.

“Obviously, we’ve been through a lot together,” Brian Dumoulin said. “He’s been with this group for a little while now, especially for the Cup runs. He’s a great friend and obviously a tough guy to replace in the locker room.”

Advertise with us

The natural succession here is to wonder whether Rutherford is done. That much is still up in the air.

If the Penguins figure it out, sure. Rutherford started this season happy with the team, and that hasn’t changed. But if they don’t, then yeah; pretty much anything is on the table.

“We’ll see how it goes,” Rutherford said.

Perhaps the GM is trying to do something the Penguins have routinely done during their past two Cup runs and something that’s prevalent throughout his personal playbook by taking a former first-round pick and buffing out a few scratches.

The 26-year-old Pearson was drafted by the Kings in the first round (30th overall) back in 2012 and could probably use a change a scenery, the same as Hagelin in Anaheim, Justin Schultz in Edmonton, Trevor Daley in Chicago, Jamie Oleksiak in Dallas and Riley Sheahan in Detroit, among recent reclamation projects.

Advertise with us

Pearson has no goals in 17 games and is a minus-9, but the Penguins are confident he can help them address their secondary-scoring need, which is only growing larger.

“He’s off to a slow start,” Rutherford said of Pearson, a native of Kitchener, Ontario. “He maybe lost his confidence a little bit, but he’s had a good career. He’s able to play with their top guys. He’s pretty much consistently been a 40-point guy. I believe that a change will be good for him.”

Like Hagelin, Pearson has seen top-six time throughout his career and has a Stanley Cup on his resume: 2014 with the Kings.

In 2016-17, Pearson had a career-high 24 goals in 80 games. Pearson also has a couple more years on his contract, where the Penguins probably would’ve lost Hagelin to free agency come July 1.

“He’ll be a good fit for us,” Rutherford said of Pearson. “He’s a little younger than Carl. He’s locked into a contract for a couple more years that we like ($3.75 AAV through 2021). He’s a good all-around player, and I believe that he’ll help us.”

Advertise with us

It’s a big gamble, though one Rutherford has never been afraid to make. If these players can’t see that, Rutherford could be left with more problems than simply trying to salvage this season.

“The way things have gone here in the first part of the season, it's obvious that we had make a change,” Rutherford said. “I feel bad. Carl Hagelin is a popular guy. I like him a lot personally. He was part of winning the Cup.

“But at the same time, we’re not tracking toward winning a Stanley Cup right now, and changes are necessary.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG