Penguins GM Jim Rutherford gets three-year extension

It is fitting that on the day Jim Rutherford officially signed on to remain with the Penguins through the primes of franchise pillars Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin, Rutherford spent much of the morning talking trades.

Then, during a late-morning news conference intended to trumpet his return, Rutherford broke the news that he was about to shake up his squad.

“Everybody wants to win a championship, and I still believe we can,” he said. “Whether we come out of it this year … or whether we have to make some changes and do it next year, I still believe we have a window here.”

He added, stunning reporters: “We’re going to start making changes to this team here — probably within the next hour. I’ll be talking to you guys in an hour.”

Advertise with us

Rutherford, true to his word as always, was soon back to discuss dealing Carl Hagelin to the Los Angeles Kings for forward Tanner Pearson, a move that reverberated through a stunned Penguins locker room Wednesday.

The morning trade of the speedy playoff hero overshadowed the news that the Penguins had extended the contract of their veteran general manager, whose past wheeling and dealing helped the franchise win the two most recent of its five Stanley Cups, to a three-year extension running through 2021-22.

Rutherford’s previous contract was set to expire after the season, which was apparently news to David Morehouse, who found out a few weeks ago.

“I actually didn’t even know he was up,” said Morehouse, CEO and president of the Penguins. “A reporter asked me and I didn’t realize he was up. … I went to see where his contract was. Time flies when you’re having fun.”

Once the situation got on Morehouse’s radar, it came together quickly.

Advertise with us

“I knew in November of 2015, that we wanted to extend him,” he said. “We knew he was the right guy from the day he stepped into the office.”

When Rutherford was hired in June 2014, he took over a talented team that had underachieved, winning just one Cup despite the presence of at least a couple of future Hall of Famers. He quickly assessed the Penguins’ shortcomings and began making moves that helped them get back to the top.

Rutherford's boldest was dealing for mercurial winger Phil Kessel after the GM's first season in Pittsburgh. He also acquired via trade Patric Hornqvist, Justin Schultz and Hagelin — all key contributors during both Cup runs — and promoted Mike Sullivan to head coach in December 2015.

Not a bad run for a hockey lifer who was on the verge of retirement in 2014.

“I remember that day when I was thinking about starting to take it easy and instead of working, five years ago when I got the phone call from David,” he said. “And that was probably the best phone call I ever got in my career.”

Advertise with us

Morehouse responded, “It’s the best call I’ve ever made, so it’s good to hear it’s the best one he ever received. We were very fortunate when Jim expressed interest. His body of work speaks for itself. If I had to mold out of clay what we needed at that time, I think he was the perfect fit. And he’s been that ever since.

“Any questions about his age or vitality, he’s answered himself.”

Rutherford, a 69-year-old native of Beeton, Ontario, is the only general manager since the 1967 expansion to lead multiple organizations to a Stanley Cup. Currently in his 25th season in that leading role, he ranks eighth in NHL history among general managers with 850 career wins and 1,834 games.

Rutherford, who won a Cup with the Carolina Hurricanes in 2006, earned two more with the Penguins in 2015-16 and 2016-17. After winning the former, Rutherford was named NHL general manager of the year.

“We think Jim Rutherford is one of the best general managers in all of sports and, during his tenure in Pittsburgh, arguably the best GM in the NHL,” Penguins co-owners Mario Lemieux and Ron Burkle said in a statement.

Advertise with us

“His goal every year is to win the Stanley Cup and that kind of commitment to excellence is what drives us all. Jim is already a big part of Penguins history with back-to-back championships, but his goal is to achieve even more.”

Morehouse said Rutherford will “someday soon be in the Hall of Fame.”

He added that his general manager is also a Hall of Fame person whose straight-shooting style has made him a natural fit in Pittsburgh.

“He’ll tell you what he thinks. He’ll tell you when he disagrees with you,” he said. “You don’t have to read between any lines with Jim Rutherford.”

Rutherford said that when he was first hired in 2014, he didn’t envision sticking around this long. He cited the way he has been treated here — by ownership, players, fans and even media — as a primary reason for re-signing.

Advertise with us

Rutherford loves winning, too, which brings us back to his current squad.

“Despite the fact that it hasn’t been a happy couple weeks for the Penguins as a whole, I am very happy to say that I’m staying and I’ll do my best to fix what our problems are,” he said, later adding, “I don’t think and I hope we’re not [done contending]. … We’re struggling. But for the most part, I still believe in this team.”

Despite the Penguins’ sluggish start, the feeling is obviously mutual.

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com