Want to know the biggest difference between Casey DeSmith and Matt Murray right now, the reason why the Penguins think DeSmith – for the moment – is their best option?
Look no further than the late stages of the second period, when Evgeni Malkin attempted a mindless cross-rink pass in their zone that was picked off by Arizona Coyotes winger Clayton Keller, who went in all alone on DeSmith with a chance to make it a one-goal game.
DeSmith denied Keller and also got a chunk of Brad Richardson’s quick centering attempt toward a teammate who was standing alone in front and staring at a vacant net.
Moments later, after another extended Penguins rally led by Sidney Crosby, Dominik Simon dished a pretty pass to Patric Hornqvist, who hammered it home to make it 3-0.
Maybe Saturday’s 4-0 win ends up being a different outcome if DeSmith doesn’t bail out Malkin and his mates there. But as has usually been the case early this season, he did.
“When you get a big save like that, you feel like you’ve dodged one,” Crosby said.
Read More
Murray, meanwhile, has too often gotten tagged on plays like that in his nine starts.
Keller’s sudden breakaway was a high-quality chance that probably goes in a third of the time. So, in a vacuum, it would be hard to blame any goalie for giving up a goal there. But Murray hasn’t been making timely saves like that this season, other than his three starts during their perfect Canadian road trip last month, when he made about 30 of them.
Since the Penguins came back across the border, Murray has allowed at least four goals in three of four starts. He got pulled from two of those games, both of them here at PPG Paints Arena. As a result, the two-time Cup-winner’s goals against average ballooned to 3.87 and his .886 save percentage was 36th among qualifiers entering Saturday.
So, after DeSmith was again reliable in Wednesday’s last-minute 2-1 loss to the Washington Capitals, Penguins coach Mike Sullivan gave DeSmith a second straight start.
“That always feels good, to get a vote of confidence like that where you kind of get a chance right away to bounce back and be there for the guys,” the 27-year-old goalie said. “I know everyone played so well that game, so giving up one in the last minute like that was heart-breaking for everybody, especially me. So tonight felt good for that reason.”
In addition to praising DeSmith when asked before the game about that decision, Sullivan said that this has “also given Matt an opportunity to spend some time with [Mike Buckley], our goalie coach, to work on some areas of his game that we think will help him improve.”
Sullivan added that Murray is “going to be a huge part of this team moving forward.” And Crosby made a point to say after the game that “we’re confident in both guys.”
But right now, as the Penguins try to get rolling again, DeSmith is their best option.
While his size – he’s 6 foot – and playing style lead to more frenzied scrambles than when the bigger, more robotic Murray is in between the pipes, DeSmith still plays with poise.
He stopped a dozen shots in a scoreless first period and got some help early in the second when rookie defenseman Juuso Riikola made a skate save while DeSmith was down in the crease. DeSmith made 16 saves in that period, none bigger than the one on Keller.
Early in the third period, with the game under control, DeSmith kicked out a point-blank one-timer by Michael Grabner after the Penguins lost track of the Coyotes winger. DeSmith turned aside 10 more shots in the final period for his second shutout of the season.
“This was a team shutout. This was a team win,” he said. “Everyone needed this.”
As he took off his leg pads after the game, DeSmith flashed a grin while telling a reporter he was hoping for one more shot late in the game so he could get his save total to 40.
So, yeah, he’s feeling it right now.
“As long as I keep playing well and keep playing my game and getting results, confidence just keeps building,” DeSmith said. “I happen to have some [confidence] right now.”
In his six starts this season, DeSmith is now 3-1-2 while allowing a stingy 1.65 goals per game with a .948 save percentage that would rank among the best in the NHL.
“He was phenomenal. He was on top of his game. He has been the last couple games,” said defenseman Brian Dumoulin, who got his first goal of the season Saturday. “He makes those big, timely saves for us. He keeps playing like that, we’re going to win a lot of games.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.