Jack Johnson is expected to spend a third consecutive game on the Penguins’ top defense pair Saturday against the Arizona Coyotes at PPG Paints Arena.
While there’s been no shortage of fans and analysts who’ve criticized the move to sign Johnson — a 31-year-old coming off his worst NHL season — to a five-year deal worth $16.25, the Penguins seem to feel differently.
They’ve been mostly happy with Johnson’s play, and they easily could keep him next to Kris Letang for the foreseeable future.
“That’s when he’s played his best,” Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on Friday. “He played extremely well there.”
There’s at least some validity to what Rutherford is selling, although don’t expect many Penguins fans at this point to buy it.
Over the past two games, Johnson has produced a shot share of 57.1 percent during five-on-five play, according naturalstattrick.com. That’s significantly better than Johnson’s 2018-19 season mark of 47.6, and he’s not been on the ice for a five-on-five goal-against.
Read More
Johnson’s scoring-chance and high-danger chance percentages have also gone up.
With Letang, Johnson has helped the Penguins to a five-on-five scoring-chance percentage of 60.0 compared to a season mark of 51.2. His high-danger chances have risen to 56.3 percent from 45.4.
For those who hate those kind of numbers, know this: Playing next to Letang, from a statistical perspective, has been an improvement on Johnson’s season as a whole. Really his entire career, although a two-game sample size is obviously not large enough.
It also stands to reason that those numbers are naturally going to be higher because we’re talking about playing next to Letang, who has some of the best shot- and scoring-chance-related numbers on the Penguins.
Meanwhile, detractors have no problem pointing out Johnson’s flaws.
He’s a minus-116 since making his NHL debut in 2006-07, worst among all NHL defensemen. This season, Johnson is a minus-7, last among Penguins blueliners and second-worst on the team (Riley Sheahan, minus-8).
Johnson’s five-on-five goal (minus-98) and shot (minus-836) differentials among defensemen who’ve played at least 10,000 minutes since 2007 — as far back as Corsica.ca will go — are also dead last, and he hasn’t been on the ice when a five-on-five has been scored in six games.
The question to ask, then, is this: Does any of that matter to the Penguins?
Perhaps not, at least judging by their actions of using Johnson — who has a goal differential of minus-8 this season, sixth-worst among defenseman who’ve played at least 200 minutes — on the top pair.
Or maybe they’re looking at a completely different set of numbers, which is possible given how NHL teams take pride in mining their own statistical data.
For those on the outside, putting Johnson on the top pair does seem like a strange move, and maybe it is. But it’s more of a move made to try and achieve balance than anything else.
Brian Dumoulin remains one of their best defenseman — a solid No. 2 if Letang keeps playing the way he’s been — and they’re spreading their assets. The problem becomes filling that spot next to Letang.
On Saturday against Arizona, Jamie Oleksiak — who’s tied for the team lead in goals by a defenseman with four — will be a healthy scratch. The second pair will likely be Brian Dumoulin and Chad Ruhwedel, the third Olli Maatta and Juuso Riikola.
Riikola is the closest thing they have among that group — it’s likely Maatta’s skating would become a problem — and he’s played just seven NHL games.
The same as his coaches, Rutherford remains perfectly fine with the work Johnson has done — even if others might disagree. And playing him on the top pair is something that could easily stick is helps balance things out.
“It’s about finding the right fit,” Rutherford said. “At this point, [playing Johnson on the top pair] may be the best way to go to balance out our defense.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.