Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Welcome to my Thursday Penguins chat. Let's get started ...

Dr. House: Jason... this early in the season what is your favorite line to watch? Also... how do you see the Sprong experiment working out in the next few weeks?

Jason Mackey: Hey Dr. House, good question. So far it's been Hagelin-Malkin-Kessel. I know, I know. That's not a very original answer, but it's hard for me to say anything else. They've been spectacular together. And I'll admit: I thought Sullivan would maybe try Malkin and Kessel apart, but they've been so good together, separating them wouldn't have made any sense.

dave: Have the past couple of games proven that Sprong needs to be on one of the top 2 lines?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Potentially, Dave. And I see your point. I do believe that Sprong has to play with skilled people to be successful. But the problem here is that the Malkin line has been absurdly good, and Sprong really didn't mesh all that well with Crosby, at least not this season. Ideally, Simon is an excellent fit there. Something I would like to see is Sprong with Brassard and Rust. It's a third line, yes, but it's three guys who have produced offensively given the right situation. Problem, though, is then your fourth line is Sheahan-Cullen-Hornqvist; I'm not sure if I'm OK with Hornqvist being on a fourth line.

MA: What is up with Brass? I was really pulling for him but ,injuries aside, it doesn't seem like he is fitting in.

Jason Mackey: I'm worried about that, too, MA. I think that's a fair point. If you include every game Brassard has played for the Penguins -- meaning playoffs included -- he's produced five goals and 17 points in 34 games. That's not good enough, not for someone who makes what he makes and his pedigree. His points per game (.50) in those 34 games is only slightly better than what Riley Sheahan produced (.42) before the trade. ... I'm willing to give it more time -- I've liked him on the wing -- but I think it's absolutely fair to wonder if he's the right player for this team.

JT: Any trade rumours? Or Trades you think that make sense. Yes, the team is playing well, but some games are so shaky.

Jason Mackey: Honestly, no. ... That might be the rumor. I really don't think GMJR wants to do anything right now. He always gives it about 20 games, which is fair. But I'm not sure if this team has shown definitively what it needs. Just when you think you have a bead on 'em, they do what they did Tuesday. Which is why it's probably smart to wait and let the water find its level.

Advertise with us

Guest: who is out tonight with Tanger probably back in?

Jason Mackey: Juuso Riikola will sit, assuming Kris Letang plays.

Guest: Part 2 : I know it is many months away but who is your top pick to go out when Schultz comes back?

Jason Mackey: I think, ideally, Chad Ruhwedel would return to being the No. 7. That's how this team was constructed. But, as you said, a lot can happen between now and then.

Matt: ZAR-Brassard-Sprong

Advertise with us

Matt: Mackey, when Brassars returns, I say top 3 lines need to be Guentzel- Crosby-Horny

Matt: Hags-Malkin-Kessel

Jason Mackey: Thanks for your input, Matt. I think we'll wait and see. You have to scratch one of the following, though: Sheahan, Cullen, Simon and Rust. Who would go?

Jip: Curious about the Blue Lives Matter flag that found its way onto the ice for the ceremonial puck drop honoring the first responders. Was that something the Pens organization planned or knew about ahead of time? Have they commented at all on its presence given its controversial associations?

Jason Mackey: No, I'm sorry. Nobody has commented on why that was there.

Advertise with us

HB: Why has Riikola not gotten a chance over Johnson or maatta

Jason Mackey: Well, he did get to play last game and for a couple before it, but I get your point. A couple things here. One, the organization made a bold move getting Johnson. I'm not sure they're willing to call it a failure -- that's what they would be doing by healthy scratching Johnson, or at least saying it's not going well -- after < 10 games. As for Maatta, I think they're trying to let him relax and regain his confidence. Yanking him out again doesn't do that. Sometimes I think you need to let people play through things and let them figure it out.

rob: When Schultz is back, do pens rock with 8D? What's your opinion?

Jason Mackey: Not at all. They're stay with six. Sullivan has publicly stated he doesn't like going 11/7 let alone 10/8. I don't know any coach who would want to do that, although I'll acknowledge that Sullivan has, at times, reduced his forward group to 10.

Guest: How much longer does Sprong get before we bring in the reinforcements (ZAR)?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Well, they play different positions, so I'm not sure I would immediately associated one with the other. But I get that someone like, say, Rust can play both sides. I think you need to give Sprong more time. He made progress Saturday in Vancouver. The Penguins really aren't weak on the left side, and that's all ZAR does. He doesn't play center or right wing ... or at least the Penguins don't have any interest in him playing either of those two positions.

Loose Cannon : It seems to be a waste of money and talent having Horny on the 3rd or 4th line,what do you see happening with Horny this season,what is your ideal situation for him

Jason Mackey: I think ideally he plays next to Sid. But I see why Sullivan made the change. I don't think those two together are going to be a constant, and they're better in the playoffs. I think they need to find a secondary option with Crosby, either Simon, Rust or Sprong, then alternate them. ... As for Hornqvist, it's tough right now with Malkin and Kessel playing as well as they have together. If that gets stale, then there's an easy place to put Hornqvist. I just think it's exacerbated because Hornqvist and Crosby really didn't click, and Malkin and Kessel have been humming along.

Guest: Matt Murray starting?

Jason Mackey: They canceled their skate, so we won't know anything until 5 p.m., when Sullivan talks at Barclays Center. I'd put it at 60/40 Murray.

Advertise with us

Runaway: What happened to the Golden Triangle on the new Pens third jersey?

Jason Mackey: I'm not sure, honestly. It's kind of a mashup, and I don't think it was received terribly well with fans ... perhaps because of this. I don't think they saw it as an essential part of the sweater.

HB: My response to the statue question from last week I think it’s a malkin and Crosby statue and if they win another cup then you add Kessel and for every cup just add another player until it’s an elaborate giant statue.

Jerry k: Whose game do you think will deteriorate fast towards the end of their careers, Crosby or Malkin?

Jason Mackey: I'd say Malkin ... but good question. I think Sid's is more adaptable to older age ... assuming his body cooperates. The skill that Malkin has, taking over games and that extra gear ... I don't think he's in danger of losing it, but I think when things do go, that might be the first.

Advertise with us

Rob: I meant like rocking the 6 and having 2 as healthy scratches! Sorry for the miscommunication.

Jason Mackey: All good. Yeah, when Schultz comes back, they're going to stick with six. I think it's still TBD who those six will be, but I really, really doubt Sullivan would ever go 11/7, unless he was absolutely forced to.

J: I have a theory on the Ryan Reeves experiments: the Pens were trying to re-create/ counter the Tom Wilson effect that frees up a lot of space for Ovi and Kuznetsov. It just didn’t work. What do you say?

Jason Mackey: I think you're onto something there. However, I don't think the Penguins ever intended to play Reaves on the top line. It wouldn't have worked, either, because Wilson is a better skater and hockey player. But I do think the Penguins had visions -- or maybe Rutherford, I should say -- of Reaves playing 8-10 minutes a night, getting in hard on the forecheck, knocking people around, creating space, chipping in a little. Essentially having a real role. But for a few reasons, obviously, that never happened.

Dr. House: Do you think if Mario came out of the owner’s box fit and healthy that he’d be our 3c?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Sure. And I could almost guarantee he'd have more than five goals and 17 points in 34 games. ... Not a crack on Brassard, either. Mario's the greatest who ever played, in my opinion. He'd still score 20-30 goals ... or at least I like to think that he would.

STL: Jason, I think to increase excitement, it's not so much about actual scoring but about more scoring chances. I feel like now teams just collapse on the area in front of the net and it is so hard to get shots through. Wanted your thoughts about two things: 1) What about widening the rink by a few feet, give the great playmakers more room to create plays and 2) Need to do something to discourage the players from blocking shots. What about minimizing their equipment instead of messing with the goalie equipment? Is there another idea?

Jason Mackey: Were it up to me, I would make blocking shots illegal. Lay down in front of a slapper? You're gone. I don't wanna pay money to see Craig Adams get hit with pucks. I wanna see exciting plays and exciting players with speed and skill. I'd be OK with either solution, but I think the answer might be even simpler.

K : What do think the lines look like by Christmas? Does Simon stay on Sid’s wing? Does Brass ever stay healthy or will he be moved?

Jason Mackey: If I had to make a prediction based on what I've seen, I don't think Simon stays on Sid's wing, and I think they try to trade Brassard for a defenseman. That caveat with that second thing is that they probably need another D to get hurt before they admit they need someone else. ... On Sid's wing, I think it'll rotate. Simon might get some reps, but I don't think he's going to achieve Guentzel-like status there.

Advertise with us

Guest: Is Hagelin-Malkin-Kessel the new HBK line? And if Hagelin walks in free agency this summer, who’s the ideal replacement on that line? ZAR? Someone from free agency?

Jason Mackey: I don't know about HBK because that was more a third line that waaaay over performed. Hagelin-Malkin-Kessel is just two superstars with the perfect third wheel. They're good, but they're expected to be good. ... As for Hagelin, first, I think the Penguins try. But I also think he'll want to go to market. ... If they lose him, maybe Di Pauli, if he develops enough this year. It could be ZAR, but I'm not sure he provides the same element as Hagelin; it might not be a perfect swap because of the different in speed. Di Pauli has the wheels. Need to figure out if he can do everything else. If not, try to go get someone.

Jake: Jason - have you tried my milkshake from the Milkshake Factory yet?! Do you like it?

Jason Mackey: I have not Jake, sorry. I do want to, though.

me: Does it seem like they've had more bad line changes this season than last season?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I don't know about more, but they did struggle with that against the Islanders on Tuesday. Not sure why, either. ... I don't think it's out of the ordinary. The Penguins -- and really all hockey teams -- have momentary lapses of good sense. I think that's what you saw more than anything.

Pens4Life: Do the players like to get those western road trips out of the way early in the season like this?

Jason Mackey: I wouldn't say "get out of the way." They do like them, and they're fun trips. I think they like for them to be strategically placed -- I.e. to get something out of them. And this year they hit the jackpot. Western Canada was a good bonding experience. Western U.S. in January will be a terrific snowbird trip, get out of Pittsburgh in the dead of winter, break up a long season.

Pens4Life: Did you not go on the recent Canada trip?

Jason Mackey: I did not. My wife gave birth to our second son two weeks ago. When we did the travel schedule, we knew it would be too close to her due date ... so Matt went. I was supposed to go to Toronto, but Teddy was actually born that morning.

Advertise with us

Pens4Life: You often mention about how hockey players are a different breed of athlete in terms of being down-to-earth. That said, there certainly have to be instances when some players don’t particularly get along personally, but they park that and it’s all business on the ice. Not naming names, but are there any players on the Pens who don’t necessarily mesh personally or get along off-ice?

Jason Mackey: Honestly, no. There are degrees of friendship. Obviously Geno is better friends with Phil or Hornqvist than, say, Chad Ruhwedel. But there's a really good back-and-forth between guys. If there's any dislike there, they really, really keep it to themselves.

Guest: Grant has looked like a ghost out there...any chance they bring up Blueger or someone else in WBS to play center while Brassard is out? Rather see a prospect get a chance....

Jason Mackey: Grant is a good player. Scored 12 goals last season. He should be doing better, but I see what you're saying. He hasn't done much. I wonder if he wouldn't be a trade candidate. Not sure if he's fitting in here. Might be better elsewhere. The problem with going to Blueger, though, is you want him to keep playing. If he has Grant's role and everyone is healthy, he won't.

Pens4Life: With Schultz out, what are the chances JR adds another top 6 d-man anytime soon? Saw this rumor and wanted to know what you think: https://www.pensburgh.com/2018/10/24/18018108/pittsburgh-penguins-trad...

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I'd love to know where the Penguins would get $5 million (or the prorated portion) to fit Edler. That ain't happen.

Jason Mackey: *won't.

Guest: I know it’s early but do you think it’s time for someone besides Crosby/Malkin/Kessel to start producing more? Sheahan, Rust, and Sprong have essentially been non existent so far this season.

Jason Mackey: I think Rust could be producing more. Sheahan? Eh, I don't know. Maybe. But he's a fourth-liner playing fourth-line minutes. How much more are we looking for here? I think their depth scoring has been good enough. I do think those three have more to offer, but I'm not sure it's been a problem thus far.

DIlly: Jason - MM keeps talking about how if he was coach, he'd have the Penguins trap and attack off the rush instead of trying to be the fastest team in the league still (which they obviously aren't). Do you think Sullivan can/will adapt, or is he starting to fall into the same mold as Bylsma where he refuses to change because something worked in the past?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I don't disagree with Mark. Several teams have caught up to the Penguins, and pure speed is no longer something that puts them in this small, exclusive club. That being said, I think they already have adapted some. And, no, to address your question, I don't see the same sort of stubbornness coming from Sullivan. The dude's a hockey geek -- in a good way. He loves this stuff. He loves the challenge of trying to figure something out, however it must be done. If Sullivan thought the Penguins could win by playing five defensemen at once, or putting skates on your hands, if it's inside the rules, I think he would do it.

FP: When Schultz returns, does GMJR waive Ruhwedel or does he keep him as the 7th and move out someone like Maatta?

Jason Mackey: It depends on what Riikola does. If Riikola sticks, then you maybe have to consider keeping eight -- assuming everyone is healthy. If Riikola doesn't, there's your answer. It's my belief they're worried about crossing that bridge when they come to it.

MA: 68, 87, 71,29 for sure get retired but what does it take for 58? Another cup?

Jason Mackey: I'd retire 58 now. I think he's there.

Advertise with us

Guest: Do you think there’s any other “found gold” in the pens system or upcoming like they got w Guentz, sheary etc and Riikola

Jason Mackey: Eh, honestly, no. Miletic has been good -- but now is hurt. Angello, Lafferty, yeah, some. But not to that level. Wish I could give you a better answer, but I think that has run its course.

Guest: Jason, what about Adam Johnson as a Hagelin replacement? What does the team think about him?

Jason Mackey: Maybe. He has the speed. But the corner stuff, defensive work, a smidge of physicality, being a really good PK guy ... I'm worried if Johnson is going to be OK with that (sizable) amount of responsibility.

Pens4Life: Every athlete claims they never pay attention to what's said in the media. I call BS, but do you know if anyone in the organization reads these chats?

Jason Mackey: I don't know about these chats specifically, but they do read. Usually via the clips email the organization sends out with everything we've written. Also, and probably more so, they know what we tweet. Beware the burner accounts!

Guest: How much does Mario get involved with the organizations team decisions ? How often does sid?

Jason Mackey: Very little, honestly. And it's why the organization loves him and Burkle so much. They empower people to do their jobs, whether that's Morehouse, Rutherford, Sullivan, etc. Then they leave them the heck alone. They hang out and socialize, sure, but they rarely dictate what they think should happen, especially not with hockey.

DIlly: Thanks for taking the time to chat each week!

Jason Mackey: My pleasure, Dilly. I love doing these things, trust me. Thank you for participating.

guest: Did you get to talk to Kunackle when he was in town? I always wonder if players like him miss being here with this organization and with his friends.

Jason Mackey: I did, yes. Here's the story: http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/penguins/2018/10/30/Penguins-Tom-Ku...

Jason Mackey: The Penguins liked Kuhnhackl a lot. The media, too. He was a really good guy. But I can also see why the organization wanted to upgrade that spot. When you look at the other teams the Penguins are competing with -- Washington, Tampa, Vegas, Winnipeg, etc. -- they were deeper; the Penguins didn't get enough from Kuhnhackl or his line. But as a person, yes, he's absolutely missed. Great personality.

Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it. Thanks so much for participating. Until next week ...