Mike Sullivan is, by almost any measure, the most successful coach in Penguins history.

He’s the only one to win two Stanley Cups, and his regular-season record here through the first four weeks of the 2018-19 season was 136-68-24.

While virtually every coach has a shelf life, by the end of which his players have ceased to respond to his instructions and motivations, there’s no indication Sullivan is approaching that.

Or will at any point in the reasonably near future.

Advertise with us

When the time finally comes that he does move on, for whatever reason, Sullivan might well be hailed as the finest coach the franchise ever had.

But because his tenure is in progress, it’s not possible yet to say precisely where Sullivan will settle in future ranking of Penguins coaches. After all, it’s possible — though hardly likely — that he might go Full Creamer someday and not realize that, say, his team must get two points, not just one, out of its regular-season finale to qualify for the playoffs.

Sullivan, then, is not eligible for inclusion on the list of the 10 best coaches in franchise history that will appear in the next two installments of the Penguins Spotlight. These guys, however, are:

10. Red Kelly — He was inducted to the Hockey Hall of Fame on the strength of his work as a player, not a coach, but Kelly was the first to guide the Penguins to a berth in the Stanley Cup playoffs. That’s something they had failed to accomplish under Red Sullivan in the previous two seasons.

9. Bob Berry — He inherited a 38-point team and picked up a footnote in hockey history by being Mario Lemieux’s first NHL coach. Berry helped to establish discipline and focus among his players but not enough to qualify for the playoffs or to prevent then-owner Edward J. DeBartolo from demanding he be replaced in 1987. Even if he hadn’t been a solid coach, Berry would deserve a place on this list by virtue of his epic “Circus performers” rant after a frustrating performance by his team at Maple Leaf Gardens in Toronto.

Advertise with us

8. Kevin Constantine — After Lemieux retired for the first time in 1997, general manager Craig Patrick brought in Constantine to transform the Penguins into a defense-oriented team. It was an effective, if not especially exciting, style that kept the team’s run of postseason appearances alive.

Kevin Constantine during a Penguins workout in April 1998. (Lake Fong / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

7. Marc Boileau — With the likes of Pierre Larouche and the Century Line trio of Syl Apps, Jean Pronovost and Lowell MacDonald at his disposal, Boileau guided the franchise’s most entertaining and offensively potent teams in the pre-Lemieux era. Of course, he also was behind the bench when the Penguins became just the second club in NHL history to lose a best-of-seven playoffs series after winning the first three games, falling to the New York Islanders in 1975.

6. Herb Brooks — His letter grade would be an “Incomplete,” since Brooks coached just 57 regular-season games after stepping in from a scouting position when Constantine was fired in December 1999. Brooks was a visionary and innovator who preached the importance of skating and whose favorite catchphrase — “The legs feed the wolf” — captured his philosophy perfectly. His preferred style of play would have been an ideal fit for today’s NHL.

5. Dan Bylsma — Winning a Stanley Cup just a few months after he replaced Michel Therrien in 2009 was an incredible accomplishment and could have earned Bylsma a spot near the top of this list — if he hadn’t lost to a lower-seeded opponent in each of the five springs that followed. Without that Cup in his first season, those stumbles might have dropped Bylsma, whose regular-season winning percentage of .668 is the best of any Penguins coach, into Pierre Creamer/Ivan Hlinka territory.

Next week: The countdown to No. 1.

Dave Molinari: dmolinari@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG