BROOKLYN, N.Y. – Sidney Crosby, with the game on his stick, didn’t see it coming.

With the Penguins and the New York Islanders tied, 2-2, in overtime Thursday, Phil Kessel picked off a pass and sent Crosby away on a breakaway against his former Penguins teammate, Thomas Greiss. When Crosby reached the hashmarks, the Islanders goalie pounced.

Greiss’ aggressive sprawling poke check – which was reminiscent of the guy he backed up in his lone Penguins season – denied Crosby of his second overtime winner in nine days.

“I guess he didn’t expect that,” Greiss told reporters in the Islanders locker room.

Advertise with us

Moments after surprising Crosby, Greiss made a spectacular glove save on Kessel to force a shootout.

“We like our chances when those two guys get open looks like they did,” coach Mike Sullivan lamented. “They’re elite players that have great finishing ability. So those were two big saves.”

Greiss then denied all three Penguins in the shootout. His stand-up save on Kris Letang’s low shot, after Josh Bailey got a goal on the third Islanders try, gave the Islanders a 3-2 win.

The Penguins and Islanders, who faced off two days earlier at PPG Paints Arena, played a tight game for 63 minutes. They crammed most of the action in a thrilling final few moments. Both teams were tentative in overtime until Greiss stopped Crosby on his breakaway. Then Matt Murray made a diving blocker save on Jordan Eberle's rebound try.

With less than 10 seconds left in overtime, Crosby dropped the puck to Kessel and took two Islanders with him, allowing Kessel to curl unopposed to the net. He fired from between the hashmarks a wrist shot ticketed for a top corner. But Greiss grabbed it with his glove.

Advertise with us

"We had a good couple of chances in overtime and we should score,” Evgeni Malkin said.

In the shootout, Malkin missed the net then Greiss stopped Crosby again. Then Bailey scored to put Letang on the spot. Letang, back in the lineup after sitting out Tuesday’s 6-3 loss with a lower-body injury, tried to put it through Greiss’ legs. But Greiss stayed upright this time.

And so the Penguins, who went 4-0 on their Canadian road trip, lost two in a row to a young Islanders team that is trying to find its identity after losing John Tavares in the offseason and hiring former Washington Capitals coach Barry Trotz.

The Penguins believed they were the better team for at least the first two periods of Tuesday’s 6-3 loss at home. But the high-quality shots the Penguins put on net and the skittering pucks they sent through the crease didn’t carom their way often that night. Meanwhile, seemingly every single break the Islanders got they put in the back of the net.

Murray, who was chased from Tuesday’s game after surrendering four goals on nine shots, was back between the pipes Thursday and was steady, turning aside 24 of the 26 Islanders shots.

Advertise with us

Dominik Simon got the first goal of the night on a power play 6:20 into the first period. With time on the man advantage dwindling down and the second unit on, Jake Guentzel drove the right wing and put the puck on net. Simon, following him up, flipped it past Greiss.

Simon, who again played on the top line alongside Crosby and Guentzel, extended his point streak to five games and scored goals in back-to-back games against the Islanders.

“He’s getting better with each game,” Sullivan said. “He’s getting a little more confident. He’s a good playmaker. He’s strong on the puck. That’s a great goal on the power play. He stayed with it to get his stick on the puck in that situation. … We really like how he’s tracking.”

After an uneventful first 11 minutes of the second period, Kessel cruised in on a breakaway after an Islanders puck-carrier biffed it in the neutral zone. Kessel, from his sweet spot at the bottom of the right circle, snapped a rising shot but Greiss grabbed it with his glove.

Jamie Oleksiak, the 6-foot-7 defenseman, was all alone with the ex-Penguin moments later after Malkin forced a turnover at the Islanders blue line. Greiss stopped that one, too.

Advertise with us

Greiss went 9-6-3 with a .908 save percentage as Marc Andre-Fleury's backup in 2014-15. He has spent the last four seasons with the Islanders.

The Islanders tied it, 1-1, on a breakaway of their own while the Penguins were on the power play. Casey Cizikas banked a pass off the boards past Letang to Bailey. The streaking forward gave Murray a little head fake then slid the puck through his widening five-hole.

New York took a 2-1 lead midway through the third period. Johnny Boychuck carried the puck in from the right point and directed it toward the crowd gathering in front of Murray. The pass caromed off the inside of the right skate of Anders Lee and past a stunned Murray.

Pittsburgh quickly tied it on the power play. Malkin ripped a one-timer from the right circle that hit off the stick of defender Adam Pelech and snuck through the legs of Greiss.

The goal extended Malkin’s point streak to nine games. Malkin, who was earlier in the day named the NHL’s second star for the month of October, has 17 points over that span.

Advertise with us

Both of Pittsburgh’s goals came on the power play. But the Penguins felt they had plenty of good looks at even strength, too. But that pesky Greiss guy kept getting in the way.

"I think their goalie played well, but they play hard. They have a lot of big bodies. They play really well without the puck. They defend hard,” Letang said. “It's tough to create chances, but when you have chances you have to bury them. Their goalie was pretty good tonight.”

The Penguins will be back in action Saturday when they host the Toronto Maple Leafs at PPG Paints Arena. They shut out the high-scoring Leafs, 3-0, in Toronto two weeks ago.