Mike Sullivan after Penguins’ OT win in Edmonton
EDMONTON – Sidney Crosby vs. Connor McDavid proved to be worth the price of admission Tuesday at Rogers Place. The other guys on the card traded plenty of haymakers, too.
Crosby and McDavid both scored during a fun, back-and-forth night that featured 10 goals in regulation, a few lead changes and Crosby making one heck of a statement by stick-handling through Oilers center Ryan Strome then whipping a backhander past Cam Talbot, his highlight-reel goal giving the Penguins a 6-5 victory in overtime.
“I think he showed tonight who is the best player in the world,” Patric Hornqvist said.
During their current 10-day cross-country tour of Canada, Crosby, his teammates and Penguins coach Mike Sullivan have been asked repeatedly by the media up north about whether the speedy Oilers center has blown by Crosby to become the NHL’s leading man.
The echo chamber first started last Thursday in hockey-mad Toronto, a day or two after Crosby modestly told NHL.com that McDavid was an “easy pick” based on “the awards and the accolades he's gotten.” McDavid has claimed the last two scoring titles and was named the league’s MVP in 2016-17 – and built a compelling case last season, too.
UNBELIEVABLE. CROSBY IN OT. pic.twitter.com/dq15URr2aw
— NHL GIFs (@NHLGIFs) October 24, 2018
The question persisted after the Penguins arrived in Alberta. Sullivan said Crosby tunes out the “noise” and is driven solely by being the best Crosby he can be, not by stacking himself up against others. But it was clear from the opening faceoff Tuesday, when Crosby and McDavid squared off, that this wasn’t just another game for Crosby.
Read More
Crosby fired five shots on goal, won 80 percent of his faceoffs and finally put the puck in the net – twice. He also played with a little more swagger against the humble, young superstar angling for his mantle.
“Everybody understands, players especially, when there’s more eyes on the game or when there’s big challenges ahead,” Crosby admitted afterward. “Yeah, you try to be at your best, whether it’s a rival or opposing center or opposing defenseman. You get up for those.”
McDavid came to play, too, tallying a pair of points in the third period.
Crosby scored his first goal of the season on a power play midway through the first period. Kris Letang intentionally fired a low shot wide of the net in the direction of Crosby, who, parked just outside the blue paint, casually deflected the puck over Talbot’s left pad.
During one thrilling end-to-end shift in the second, McDavid made a sweet centering pass from the behind the net to Kailer Yamomoto, but Matt Murray kicked his right leg to keep the one-timer out. Going the other way, Crosby broke in all alone on Talbot but couldn’t squeeze his backhand shot between Talbot’s shoulder and the crossbar.
McDavid got on the board early in the third period when he dribbled a stoppable shot through Murray. The goal was his fifth in seven games against Pittsburgh. Less than two minutes later, during another Oilers power play, McDavid set up a Leon Draisaitl go-ahead goal on a 3-on-2 rush after defenseman Brian Dumoulin got caught in the other end.
With the game tied, 5-5, and just over six minutes remaining, McDavid got a step on the Penguins and cruised in on Murray, who stretched out to stymie McDavid’s backhander.
“That was a huge save,” Sullivan said of Murray, who stood tall while facing 46 shots.
And once the game went into the 3-on-3 overtime, Crosby took over to win the thing.
While finally getting Crosby going was significant for the Penguins, it was also important that a couple of Penguins’ role players cashed in.
Entering Tuesday’s game, the Penguins had gotten 15 of their 20 goals from Letang, Phil Kessel, Evgeni Malkin and Jake Guentzel. Against the Oilers, Hornqvist scored his first two of the season and defenseman Jamie Oleksiak chipped in with a pair of goals, too.
After Draisaitl and Alex Chiasson scored early in the second period as the Oilers seized a 2-1 lead, the Penguins tied it up when Malkin found a hard-charging Oleksiak jumping in on the rush. The 6-foot-7 defenseman deked then slid a shot between Talbot’s legs.
Moments later, Hornqvist buried a centering pass from Dominik Simon for his first goal of the season. He gave the Penguins another lead, this one 4-3, when a puck ricocheted off his skate and past Talbot. After a brief review, the officials deemed it to be a good goal.
“We have a few guys who haven’t yet scored yet, and I’m one of them,” Hornqvist said after Monday’s practice in Banff, presciently adding, “Just work hard and the chances are going to come. Once you get one goal, I think it’s going to come a little easier after that.”

But the Oilers scored their fourth and fifth goals, both on the power play, early in the third period and threatened to run away with the game, if not for a few key saves from Murray.
It was a particularly rough night for defenseman Jack Johnson, the newcomer, who was on the ice for all five Edmonton goals. But there were numerous lapses from others.
“I don’t think it was as much fun to coach as you guys enjoyed watching it,” Sullivan said.
Added Johnson: “It was kind of a rollercoaster of a game. In the second period, things loosened up for us. Defensively, it wasn’t our best game. We know we have to tighten up. But it’s always nice to win, and a special player made a special play at the end.”
The Penguins, who with the win improved to 4-1-2, continue their four-game Canadian road trip Thursday against the Calgary Flames before finishing Saturday in Vancouver.
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.