In June 2015, after the Blackhawks won their third championship in six seasons, The Washington Post declared that a “third Stanley Cup heralds a Chicago Blackhawks dynasty that may not be over.”
Three summers later, after the Blackhawks missed the playoffs, The Chicago Tribune said, “If the window isn’t closed, it’s closing.”
Life comes at you fast when you’re an aging contender in the cap era.
While the sharp decline of the Blackhawks has been, to some degree, the result of some unusual and unfortunate circumstances, they serve as a cautionary tale as the Penguins chase championships today.
As long as Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin are considered two of the best players in the world, and as long as they are flanked by secondary stars such as Phil Kessel and Kris Letang, the Penguins will be determined to add more Cups to their collection. And, if they at least keep coming close, not many will knock them for being relatively short-sighted.
But eventually, their championship window will close, and given the style of play in today’s NHL, chances are it won’t shut gently.
Read More
Thursday, our Jason Mackey looked at the next wave of prospects in the pipeline. Today, let’s examine the long-term outlook of the franchise, which is largely being powered by veterans who are nearing the end of their primes — if some haven’t arrived already.
The Penguins are expected to have eight thirty-somethings and one soon-to-be-42-year-old on their NHL roster when the season opens. That doesn’t sound too worrisome until you start matching names with those ages.
Crosby is 31. Malkin is 32. Letang and Patric Hornqvist are 31, and Kessel will join them two days before the season opener.
According to The Athletic, the previous 13 champions had average ages ranging between 26.5 and 30. This year’s Penguins team, even with Matt Cullen making it at 41, would land somewhere in there. Given that, and considering the point totals put up by Crosby, Malkin and Kessel last season, the window should still remain wide open.
But with their stars on the wrong side of 30, when might that change?

There have been a few notable studies in recent years that explored when an average NHL player's performance begins to decline.
A University of British Columbia study four years ago found that the performance of forwards peaks between 27 and 28 and between 28 and 29 for defensemen. Rob Vollman concluded most players peak at 24 or 25, decline gradually until 30 and can fall off a cliff any point after that. This study suggests scoring drops off around 29.
If there is a consensus, it’s probably that 31 is usually over the hill.
That being said, these studies and others like them largely looked at average NHL players. And there are plenty of examples of extraordinary ones playing well and/or putting up points at 35 and beyond.
They were different eras, sure, but Gordie Howe topped 100 points at age 41 and Wayne Gretzky did it at 35. Want a more recent example? Joe Sakic 11 years ago at age 37. Nicklas Lidstrom won the Norris at 40. Al MacInnis and Chris Chelios did at 35 and 34, respectively.
For a Pittsburgh connection, look at Mario Lemieux, who won his final scoring title at 31 and probably would have won at least one more if not for the injuries that forced him into his first retirement.
Injuries, of course, are increasingly more likely once players hit their 30s, which brings us back to the current state of the Blackhawks.
Their goalie, Corey Crawford, missed all of 2018 with an injury, and star winger Marian Hossa sat out the season with a skin disorder that may end his career (they traded his contract to Arizona this summer). That’s two key players from their Cup runs who they were without last season, though Hossa’s unfortunate ailment is especially fluky.
You had other cornerstones such as Brent Seabrook, Duncan Keith and Jonathan Toews, who were in the Chicago lineup but did not perform at the lofty level we have seen from them previously.
Throw in the fact that the Blackhawks have made a few questionable moves since their last Cup, and that’s how they found themselves in last place in 2017-18. That said, with Patrick Kane still scoring goals and an infusion of youth, their window may still be ajar.
The Penguins, after losing in the second round last spring, enter this season as one of the top contenders to rep the East in the Stanley Cup final. But will they still be formidable in, say, 2020-21 or 2021-22?
Crosby, Malkin, Kessel, Letang and Patric Hornqvist are all under contract with sizable cap hits through at least 2021-22, so the Penguins are obviously banking that they’ll still be going strong for a few more years. If a couple of those guys sharply decline or succumb to injuries as they advance in age, it may be difficult for them overcome.
That’s why it’s important for general manager Jim Rutherford and the Penguins, who sacrificed a number of high draft picks in their past championship chases, to keep finding hidden gems like they did with forwards Jake Guentzel and Bryan Rust and taking on the right reclamation projects, such as top-four defenseman Justin Schultz.
That’s easier said than done, even if Rutherford has made it look simple.
It would also be beneficial if youngsters such as Guentzel, defenseman Olli Maatta and goalie Matt Murray continued to ascend to help out the older guys.
The Crosby-Malkin era will end eventually, and when it does it might not be pretty, as we saw in the early 2000s. But, barring disastrous injuries or plummeting production from those two guys, the window should be open for at least a couple more runs.
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.