The Penguins power play put the puck in the other team’s net 68 times in 2017-18, a season total that ranked just 21st in franchise history.
Now, the Penguins have had some pretty talented scorers over the years (there’s your early favorite for understatement of the week). But their relatively low PPG total a season ago has everything to do with how the NHL has changed, with speed and skill being prioritized over the brawn and buffoonery that put many more men in glass boxes.
So, while those 68 goals were 51 fewer than what Mario Lemieux and the 1988-89 squad buried to establish the current franchise record – heck, even the 16-win team in 1983-84, the one that was perhaps intentionally so bad it landed them Lemieux, had more – the case can be made that we just witnessed the best power play in Penguins history.
In fact, if you favor cold, hard efficiency, there isn’t much to debate.
The Penguins scored on 26.2 percent of their power plays last season. That impressive rate ranked first in the NHL, best in franchise history and among the highest power-play percentages this millennium.
Previously, the most efficient Pens power play was back in 1995-96, with Lemieux quarterbacking on the left half-wall. Fellow Hall-of-Famer Jaromir Jagr and Ron Francis each eclipsed 50 power-play points. Fans at the Igloo loudly encouraged clever point man Sergei Zubov to consider shooting. And Tomas Sandstrom (!) added 17 power-play goals.
Read More
The current group is comparable in terms of collective firepower.
Phil Kessel mans the left side, across from Evgeni Malkin, and both have lethal shots that keep goalies on their heels. Just outside of the blue paint is Patric Hornqvist, screening and shoving and whacking any puck that enters his zip code. Kris Letang is often the lone point man.
And then there’s Sidney Crosby, floating around the right side between Malkin and the goal line. He does a bit of everything – running the show down low, ripping one-timers from acute angles, creeping in for tap-ins and rebounds, chasing down loose pucks to keep possession.
That quintet really found a groove last year, Kessel’s third in Pittsburgh. Kessel, whose vision and execution as a power-play passer last season was eye-opening, led the league with 42 power-play points. Crosby and Malkin were tied for third with 38. Hornqvist ranked third with 15 power-play goals, trailing only Patrik Laine and Alex Ovechkin.
Plus, the Pens had (and still have) the luxury of trotting out capable PP producers in Jake Guentzel and Justin Schultz on their second unit. If he finally gets comfortable, Derick Brassard will make it even better.
The best way to prevent the Penguins from scoring on the power play is to not let them get it set up in the first place. But Mike Sullivan’s staff has gotten creative with their zone entries, which our Jason Mackey wrote about last spring, and that unpredictability created more zone time.
The Penguins scored a PP goal in 46 of 82 regular season games, and that success rate of 26.2 percent powered them to home ice in Round One.
Since 2000-01, only one team has had a higher power play percentage. That was the Capitals in 2012-13, who scored on 26.8 percent of their man-up opportunities. Only four other teams topped 25 percent over that span (the Capitals three more times and Red Wings once).
What did those power plays do for an encore? Well, it’s not impossible, but history says last season’s efficiency is probably unsustainable.
Four of the five previous teams that topped 25 percent had their success rate drop by at least three percent the following season. The Capitals saw theirs plummet from 25.2 percent in 2009-10 to 17.5 in 2010-11.
The exception is Ovechkin and the 2009-10 Capitals, who were at 25.2 percent a season after posting the exact same PP percentage.
Regardless of whether the Penguins come close to their 2017-18 mark, it’s safe to assume the power play will be a strength for them.
The penalty kill, however, is a concern after it fell apart last season.
The unraveling started soon after the Penguins gave up defenseman Ian Cole in the Brassard deal. They got the job done against the Flyers in the first round, but the Capitals scored a PP goal in four straight games.

The Penguins, looking to regroup, brought back veteran center Matt Cullen. Newcomer Jack Johnson might also be a factor on the PK.
The primary candidates among forwards to kill penalties (when in the lineup) are Cullen, Riley Sheahan, Carl Hagelin, Bryan Rust, Derek Grant and Zach Aston-Reese. Crosby and Guentzel could get sprinkled in, too, especially late in power plays, when opponents may have tired legs.
On defense, Brian Dumoulin and Olli Maatta will be regulars. Jamie Oleksiak, assuming he is indeed the sixth defenseman, should get plenty of play, too. And then there’s Letang, who may or may not play fewer minutes this season. One way to trim them would be to use him less on the penalty kill. If Johnson proves reliable, it opens up that option.
Goalie Matt Murray, if he’s in the lineup more regularly, can help the Penguins in this area, as well. His save percentage of 86.9 while killing penalties ranked 22nd among goalies who appeared in at least 35 games last season. That statistic probably says more about the guys in front of him. But no doubt Murray could have stopped a few more pucks.
Still, all that being said, only three teams had a better PP-versus-PK goal differential than the Penguins, who were plus-15 last season.
This season, their power play will likely experience some regression. But their PK might improve, too, which could make it a wash. If they are around plus-15 again, the Penguins will probably be cool with that.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.