Fifth in a 15-part series leading up to the start of Penguins training camp:
For a franchise that won back-to-back Stanley Cups while touting a pair of No. 1 goaltenders, it may feel strange to read that the Penguins have questions at hockey’s most important position.
But they do.
Significant ones, if you think about it.
Can Matt Murray stay healthy? If he can’t, what’s his future here?
Who’s the backup? And are either of those two guys — both short on NHL experience — ready to bite off even more this season?
Read More
Also, let’s not forget, how about the team as a whole playing better defense? Believe it or not, 2017-18 was arguably the Penguins’ worst defensive season of the Sidney Crosby/Evgeni Malkin Era, and the problems were definitely not narrow in scope.
There are reasonable ways of attacking all of those things, and the Penguins have obviously tried. But in 2018-19, the same as really any year for any NHL club, much will be determined by the answers to those questions and, ultimately, what happens in goal.
The most pressing and basic question is the first one: Will Murray enjoy a run of good health? When he’s been healthy, and when he’s been able to string together starts, the results have been terrific. He’s absolutely one of the league’s best.
The problem is he’s been the NHL’s most frequently injured goalie since he broke into the league.
Keeping Murray healthy is certainly tricky. What are they going to do, keep him in bubble wrap? Probably not, although it might be worth at least getting an estimate.
For a second consecutive season, Murray has spent significant time on some preventative maintenance, increasing his strength and flexibility to withstand the rigors of an NHL season.
There was also plenty in play this past season that Murray couldn’t possibly have prepared himself for, the biggest factor being the sudden death of his father, James, on Jan. 16.
It’s easy to chalk Murray’s so-so year up to some personal turmoil, and there’s probably some legitimacy to that. But also remember that, after his dad’s death, Murray actually enjoyed a run of good health and went 8-1-1 with a 2.51 goals-against average and .923 save percentage from Jan. 30 to Feb. 24.
Until, of course, a stray Olli Maatta shot in practice concussed Murray, and the Penguins franchise netminder was never really the same, save for a few flashes during the Flyers series.
What to make of Murray’s injuries? The hard part here is that it hasn’t been any one thing. Three lower-body issues. One upper-body injury. Two concussions plus a broken thumb sustained at the World Cup of Hockey. Seven total.
Murray — who prefers to play out over his toes, in the thick of the action — knows his style predisposes him to injury, but don’t look for him to change anytime soon.
There’s not much the Penguins can do, honestly, except maybe keep the crease clear more consistently and say some prayers.
If Murray can’t stay healthy, the Penguins could have a tough decision to make. His $3,750,000-per-year contract expires in 2020, at which point Murray will be a restricted free agent. Certainly don’t expect the Penguins to walk away from someone with so much potential (not to mention his name on the Stanley Cup twice), but a mega-extension isn’t certain, either.
Bottom line, Murray needs to show he can play a stretch of games without injury. If he does, there’s little question what will come next.

The backup situation
They’ll tell you it’s an open competition between Tristan Jarry and Casey DeSmith.
It’s not.
Late last season, DeSmith supplanted Jarry as the Penguins’ preferred backup. Not necessarily because he’s a better goalie, but more because he’s better-suited to play that role.
Jarry’s results were too scattershot when he had to wait awhile between starts, many in the organization felt. It’s the same sort of feel Fleury needed and one of the reasons he struggled with sharing time. DeSmith was low-maintenance, his chill demeanor providing a perfect fit.
Should DeSmith falter, the Penguins won’t hesitate to go with Jarry; however, look for DeSmith (6-4-1, 2.40 GAA, .921 SV%) to begin the season as Murray’s backup and Jarry to start in the minors.
Beyond this year
That’s an interesting topic to tackle when it comes to the Penguins’ two potential backups.
Jarry signed a two-year extension this summer worth $675,000 at the NHL level, and it becomes a one-way deal next year.
DeSmith will be an unrestricted free agent after the season.
If DeSmith spends the whole season with the NHL club and appears best-suited for backup duty, the Penguins will likely be forced to trade Jarry — either that or perform the incredible unwieldy task of carrying three goaltenders.
If DeSmith struggles and Jarry shines, then the Penguins might have to get creative while devising workloads that put Murray and Jarry in positions to succeed. Those, however, are problems for another day.
Pittsburgh sports news in my inbox? Yes, please.
Get the PG Sports Feed newsletter each weekday here.
Numbers to note
3.02: Penguins’ goals-against per-game, their worst mark since 2005-06 (3.78).
.944: DeSmith’s save percentage in four January starts. He won three of them and played to a 1.77 goals-against average.
1.95: Murray’s goals-against average in the playoffs from 2015-17, nearly a goal better than his 2017-18 regular-season mark (2.92).
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.