Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Hope you're enjoying the offseason. Have a chance to chat this week, so I figured I would. Plenty of stuff to ask about. Fire away, and I'll be back at 1 p.m. to answer. Thanks.
Lane Tooth: Is it at all likely that the Penguins have not re-signed RFA G Tristan Jarry yet because they are trying to orchestrate a trade?
Jason Mackey: I do think it's possible ... but probably not likely. Weird why Jarry hasn't signed, but it could be any number of things. I do think they'll listen on Jarry, and you could see something happen if GMJR gets the right deal for a LW.
Lane Tooth: What is your favorite NHL rink to cover games at while on the road for the PPG?
Jason Mackey: Love these ... actual rinks .. Montreal has to be up here. Love MSG, although it's tough with the Rangers as bad as they are. ... Canadian rinks, in general, are awesome. ... The Saddledome especially. It's so weird and dangerous. Terrific food in Boston, Carolina, Dallas and L.A., some of my favorite media meals. Favorite cities are probably Montreal, Manhattan, San Jose, Washington, Nashville and Vancouver.
FR: Read your article on Conor Sheary. Was he really that surprised that the Penguins traded him? He has to be aware of his overall play these last two seasons?
Read More
Jason Mackey: He said he was. Do I believe him? No. He had to have done the math and realized how many guys the Penguins had for a limited amount of spots and crossed that with how he's played the past two years. But what else do you want him to say? "I knew I was a goner." Never happens.
Lane Tooth: How confident are you that Daniel Sprong will be a top 6 forward for most if not all of this upcoming season?
Jason Mackey: I think Daniel Sprong will play an important role. Top-six forward? Eh. Don't know about that. I think you may see Sprong with Brassard on the third line, and I'd be fine with that. With Crosby, I think there's some (fair) concern that Sid will spend entirely too much time defending, digging pucks out and, in general, as the responsible one. Might be an argument to use Hornqvist there.
john: How serious do you think Sullivan is considering Brassard as a top 6 winger? or is that something that Jim just kind of threw out there? I'm not sure moving him to the wing would improve the top 6 all that much, but I think it would weaken the bottom 6 and create some really weird lines. Their biggest strength is having Sid, Geno, Brassard down the middle, It's unparalleled depth. Which allows them to have Sheahan, who just isn't an aggressive playmaker, properly slotted on the 4th line. And given how Sully likes a responsible player on each line I find it hard to believe he would play Kessel or Sprong with Geno and Brassard, which would likely mean Rust in the top 6 as a RW and that would create a trickle down. Like I said REALLY weird lines.
Jason Mackey: I think Sullivan will take a look. Why not, right? But I don't think it's how this team is best constructed, and all Rutherford did was say it was an option they would consider. I'd keep Hagelin. I think he's more valuable to the Penguins than trying to screw around with another trade; he meshes well with Malkin and really fits nicely if you want to play Geno with Phil. To your point, though, yes, it does create some weird lines and remove their depth down the middle. Take a look. And unless you're blown away, just keep things status quo.
FR: How would you rate what the Penguins have done so far in the offseason with regards to the trades/signings they have made? What, if any, Penguins on the current roster may not be on the team when the puck drops on the new season? Does Rutherford have another trade in him?
Jason Mackey: I think Jim will look around. The guys you're looking at are Hagelin, Brassard and Jarry. They could upgrade their LW spot, and Hagelin is on an expiring contract and likely to go elsewhere, for more money than the Penguins can pay him. If the Penguins can lock up some term there, great. If not, no biggie.
vinny: Any new rumors about Pens trading Phil Kessel. Hope Not!
Jason Mackey: Vinny, you're a couple months late, pal. ... Nothing. All quiet on the Phil Phront.
Krugerrand: Barry Trotz wins the Stanley Cup. He resigns 11-days later. Then, 3-days later signs with another team in the division. Have you ever seen anything like that in Major League sports?
Jason Mackey: It was definitely strange. I don't think I have. And then, to top it all off, the Islanders, Trotz' new employer, watch John Tavares leave for Toronto. Craziness.
Harold: Hi, Jason, looks like Tristan Jarry is the last unsigned RFA. Any updates on his new contract? Also, with all of the goalie movement in the offseason, it looks like most of the teams with needs have already addressed them. Do you still think it's a possibility he will be traded?
Jason Mackey: Hey Harold. I think it's possible. It would make sense on a lot of levels. Jarry is a starter, not a backup, and needs deployed as such. Would imagine other teams value his services. But, you're right, there aren't many more open jobs. I also think the Penguins want pretty decent return here. If they keep him and Murray gets hurt again, then GMJR looks smart. If GMJR lets Jarry go because he feels he has to and Murray gets hurt, he knows he'll get roasted by you guys and us.
Nate: Is it fair to say that GMJR was exposed some once he lost Botterill? Every move he's made since then has been either a disaster (Reaves, Niemi, Hunwick) or very, very questionable (Brassard, Johnson, Cullen). I think JR is a HOFer and appreciate what he's done but these past two offseasons are making me think the shine might be off.
Jason Mackey: Well, GMJR without Botterill picked up Sheahan and Oleksiak for pennies. Those moves worked out OK. I'm with you that his summer last year wasn't great, but the Hunwick and Niemi signings are different than Reaves. He wanted Reaves used a certain way, and it didn't happen. If anything, you could question whether Sullivan wanted Reaves, because he didn't really play him like a guy he wanted on his roster. But GMJR wanted someone to come in, play fourth line minutes and fight some. Reaves did that. It would be absurd to expect goals out of the guy. Anyway ... Brassard, Johnson and Cullen either haven't started or are in the process of being evaluated. How can you call Johnson a bad move when he hasn't even played a game with the Penguins? Cullen 2.0 as well. I'd say take 'er easy and see, but GMJR is a smart GM, whether Botterill is here or not.
Kenny: This offseason has been an unmitigated disaster. Brassard has always played center but now they're talking about using him as a top 6 winger, the Johnson contract is going to be an anchor for half a decade, and Cullen is better suited to be an assistant coach rather than a 4th line center. I'm glad they won these last two Cups because it sure seems like they're doing nothing but shooting themselves in the foot. Am I wrong?
Jason Mackey: Kenny, easy with the optimism. Try to tamp down those expectations a little. ... Breathe, man. Brassard was really hurt. Johnson could be much better in a different environment, and they're not asking Cullen to score 35 goals. Plus, he takes better care of himself than most of his teammates. All he needs to do is score 10 goals, kill some penalties, provide some leadership and help a few kids. It's not a huge job description. A lot of people seem overly negative about the Penguins moves, but I don't see it that way.
WallYer: I know mock trades are hard to evaluate, but let me know what you think. PIT-CGY-TBL/WPG. PIT gets Killorn/Perreault. CGY gets Jarry and Paquette/Dano. TBL/WPG gets Hagelin, Bennett and Cond. 2020 3rd (PIT). If Pens make final in 2019 or 2020, it's a 2021 2nd. We get a better LW, TBL/WPG get cap space for next season and CGY get their young future goalie.
Jason Mackey: My head hurts trying to figure out what the heck you just did there. How much time did you spend constructing that ball of wax?
HB: Will the penguins have the cap space to sign Guenztal next year and what kind of money do you think he will get, Hornqvist money?
Jason Mackey: Yes, they will. They're making sure of that. And, assuming he produces as many (including the team and Jake) expect, yes, Hornqvist money and then some.
john: What are your thoughts on locking this defense core up for so long at so much money? Aside from Johnson I like them as a whole and they all provide value. But there is no flexibility there and not much room for significant growth. It seems strange to commit so much term and money to a group that might rank between 10-15 in the league. I'm not sure it's the best group to win now or in the future.
Jason Mackey: First off, I wouldn't rank them 10-15 in the league. Although I guess if you're basing it off last year that's fair. But I think Letang can be a lot better. Dumoulin is becoming a star. Schultz had a down year. Maatta showed growth. Bottom line, I think this group can be top five or, at worst, top 10, and I would have no problem with the stability there. The problem is they underperformed in several ways last year, offensively and defensively.
HB: A question about the prospects camp would bellerive been invited if he wasnt hurt?
Jason Mackey: Yes, he would have been.
Monday Morning QB: Objectively, who is more valuable to the pens, Hags or Brass?
Jason Mackey: Hagelin, although I'd say Brassard has the possibility of becoming more valuable if he can find his stride.
HB: Another question about Bellerive if the penguins didnt sign him last year would he been able to enter the draft again at this past draft?
Jason Mackey: Believe so, although I'm not 100-percent positive.
KH: Does ZAR crack the lineup this season
Jason Mackey: Yes, I think he does. The more I think about it, the more I'm intrigued to see him at 3LW. Lets Sheahan play 4LW if you want Cullen at 4C. I think ZAR can handle it offensively, and it might help Sprong a little as well. Problem would be Brassard. He's generally done better with faster guys, and that's not the strength when you talk about ZAR and Sprong.
Guest: Ruhwedel seems to be the odd man out now with the extension of Oleksiak and signing of Johnson. Does he get traded or kept around as the 7th d-man?
Jason Mackey: He'll stick around as the No. 7. That's what he is anyway, a very good seventh defenseman.
Krugerrand: Do you have any thoughts on Fleury's 3-year, $21 million extension?
Jason Mackey: Not really other than I'm happy for him. I understand why Vegas did it. They may have overpaid, but that's where their franchise is right now. They need to secure the face, and they have the means to do it right now. Deal might suck at the end of it, but that's a risk you have to take. I don't question for a second what they're doing, though.
Jason F: Do you get the sense that GMJR is done for the offseason, or is there still a chance for some other moves? Hate the idea of playing Brassard on the wing, so I'd like to see them go after a left-winger, but I don't get the sense that anything out there makes sense. Thoughts?
Jason Mackey: I think they'll entertain the idea of getting a LW, but I don't think it's something Rutherford feels like he has to do. I think it might take Jarry to do it, for one, and the Penguins would have to be darn sure of the return. I don't think you'll see Brass on the wing, as I said. Doesn't make enough sense to me. But if they stayed with Hagelin at 2LW, I wouldn't have a huge problem with that. Effective player. Slow starter. Prone to droughts. But responsible. Fast as anyone. Well-liked. Very good PKer.
Krugerrand: In the unlikely event that Bell sits for some regular season games, do you think the Steelers would rescind the franchise tag? Would that depend on other factors such as team record, backup performance? (sorry, but Ed and Gerry haven't been around)
Jason Mackey: Haha. Wait, seriously, Ed and Gerry are on vacation (or whatever they're doing) so you're asking the Penguins guy a Steelers question? That's incredible. Please ask Ed a hockey question during his next chat and tell him I told you to. Gerry as well. Ha. ... Bell won't sit. Way, way too much $$$ to make.
Isitoctoberyet?: Any news on the trade front? Rumors are the only things that keep the dog days of summer moving.
Jason Mackey: No news. Most GMs are on vacation, up at their summer cottages or both. This tends to be a slow time of year when it comes to that stuff.
Love our Penguins coverage? Consider subscribing.
Support journalism. Subscribe today.
Matt: The penguins need a backup goalie. Suggestions on backup goalies the Pens could be eyeing up? DeSmith and Jarry did not cut it last season and i don’t think Sully really liked having to rely on them when Murray went down.
Jason Mackey: The Penguins are perfectly fine keeping DeSmith and/or Jarry. Disagree with you on Sullivan's desires. I think he likes DeSmith. Likely more than he did Jarry, which is why you saw DeSmith with the NHL club in the playoffs.
Nickleby: Jason, If Sheahan was the answer for third line center last year, the Pens wouldn't have pursued Brassard. Now the idea of Brassard playing wing is being discussed. Your thoughts please?
Jason Mackey: I don't love it, but I get why Rutherford is saying it. It reinforces them trying to find a fit for Brassard, something that could help his trade value. Could also make Hagelin appear expendable. Lastly, I think it's worth a shot. I just don't think it's worth it because he's never done it, and it screws up your lines too much.
Plus/Minus: Geno was the team leader in plus/minus last year. Why does he seem to draw criticism for his defensive zone coverage so often?
Jason Mackey: First off, Geno wasn't the leader. Schultz was. But I think Geno takes some heat because he's prone to lapses. Whether it's frustration or just a lack of focus, sometimes Geno just done some boneheaded stuff in his own zone. Does this mean he's a bad defensive play? No. I'd say inconsistent. He also plays a style -- same for his line, especially when it includes Phil Kessel -- that is conducive to affording other teams opportunities.
Dave : What is the current window of competitive opportunity for the Penguins, in your opinion? My guess is 3 to 4 years based on age of Sid and Malkin.
Jason Mackey: I think that's fair, although I've always hated those fictitious windows. We don't know. Neither Crosby nor Malkin has shown signs of slowing down, so why are we putting an timetable on it? However, I realize I'm being overly grumpy with it. 3-4 years is fair, maybe one more if they're lucky.
Dave: Do you have a guess as to why Johnson was scratched in the playoffs if it wasn't because of his play, as GMJR indicated?
Jason Mackey: My understanding is it was because of his leaked trade request and how much that ticked off Torts and other people in the organization. At that point, the relationship between Johnson and the organization was basically irreparable.
Sophia: Who on the the current team can you see transitioning into more of a leadership role as time goes by? Dumoulin? Maatta?
Jason Mackey: Dumoulin, for sure. Not sure on Olli. He's such a good kid. So likable. And he improved a lot. He's just not a rah-rah type. Watch him work, and he works his tail off. He's just never going to be overly vocal amount it. I'd put Murray in that category -- of the future leaders. Perhaps even Rust. If ZAR develops the way they think he will, he's got some toughness and swagger to him that guys will respect.
4 million per year: Which defensive pairings, defensively, do you think the Pens' opponents genuinely have concern/fear with?
Jason Mackey: I'm not sure what you're asking. Which pairings do opponents want to avoid? Probably the top one when Letang is playing well, but I think that's what most teams would say about any other team in the league.
Fake News: What are your thoughts on reporters/beat writers using nicknames for the players like Haggy, Rusty, or Horny in their reports/articles? I recall a recent article that addressed this very topic.
Jason Mackey: Someone wrote an article on that? I don't care. It's none of my business what Dejan or Josh or Bombulie do. I like and get along with all of them. I try to use names when addressing players, but sometimes I slip up, too. It's just so prevalent about hockey. But I don't care what other outlets do. Doesn't affect my ability to do my job.
Guest: Do you think JR will make another trade before training camp, for either Skinner or Pacioretty?
Jason Mackey: Ultimately no. But I do think he will keep an eye on the trade market and check on things that interest him. That's pretty much par for course when it comes to how GMJR does business.
Geoff: Do the Penguins lack a true sniper for Sid / Geno? I can't help but think of James Neal scoring 40. Heck even Blake Comeau was on a 20 goal pace with Geno because he could one time Geno's passes. Kessel can distribute and create on his own, but isn't great at finding a soft spot and sniping a one timer. Are we maximizing 87 and 71's playmaking potential?
Jason Mackey: They're both coming off (Sid in 2016-17) some of the best offensive year of their career, so I would say they're fine. And if the Penguins use Guentzel and Kessel as Crosby and Malkin's wingmen, man, I really don't think that's something to complain about. You don't need a true "sniper" with those guys, either. Malkin needs to shoot more, not constantly be giving the puck up to a so-called sniper. Crosby is at his best around the net and playing off of another player ... not passing to a so-called sniper and getting out of the way.
Guest: If you were Coach Sullivan, what would your lineup look like? All the way down to the D.
Jason Mackey: Guentzel-Crosby-Hornqvist ... Hagelin-Malkin-Kessel ... ZAR-Brassard-Sprong ... Sheahan-Cullen-Rust. ... Dumoulin-Letang ... Johnson-Schultz ... Maatta-Oleksiak ... Murray-DeSmith.
Guest: What hope do we have that Sullivan will actually play Sprong and put him in his best position to succeed? I have no idea why the coaches see Simon as a better player than Sprong? He played a lot more last year and didn’t do anything particularly well. Sprong May fail but he has a lot more upside and should be given as long a leash as Simon if not more. And yet Sullivan hates him it seems...
Jason Mackey: As I understand the Simon thing, it wasn't all Sullivan. Sid wanted him in there, too. But I do have faith Sullivan will play Sprong because that's what his boss wants, and his boss has made no bones about it. GMJR wants Sprong in, and you have to use him in a top-nine role to maximize return. I think the biggest thing will be determining with which center he best fits.
Craig: Are the Pens out of tradable assets? I am defining 'tradable' in the sense that they have a logjam at a certain position or player makes too much money and still has trade value.
Jason Mackey: I don't think so. I think Hagelin could be seen as a trade-able asset; they could replace him internally -- it would involve using Simon -- and other teams should want what Hagelin can do. Jarry would be an attractive piece to a team with goaltending need. I could see someone wanting Brassard as well.
Dave : Hypothetical question: which non-HOF former Pen would you place onto this team? Kovalev, Larry Murphy, Lemieux's caddy, etc.?
Jason Mackey: Murphy is in the Hall of Fame, FYI. ... This may sound silly, but I wish they had someone like Phil Bourque. Being dead serious. Good player but just a hell of a lot of fun. I think this team needs to be looser than it is, and Bourque would help with that.
kent: don't u think that Brassard at 3C is more valuable than a top 6 LW?
Jason Mackey: I do, yes.
Jason Mackey: I think Brassard will be much different this year, for the record.
Old Duder: Recently read an SI article about PGA Tour Pro Justin Thomas. The article mentioned he has a lot of friends in other professional sports which includes "several Pittsburgh Penguins". Was wondering if you knew which players that might be. Either way I think that's pretty cool.
Jason Mackey: Interesting. I didn't know that. I'll have to ask around, but -- no surprise here -- many of the Penguins are big-time into golf. Not shocking that they know a player or two.
Matt D.: By all means the Penguins top 2 draft picks this year (Hallander and Addison) have real potential. Do you think these picks, along with Bellerive, will make an NHL impact before the end of the 87 / 71 window?
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I could see that, although maybe at the tail end. I think those guys are at least three years away. I said earlier the window is probably 4-5 years, although I had window talk. I could see them making it up here before Crosby and Malkin are gone, for sure.
Guest: Do you think the hold up in signing Jarry is because he wants a one-way deal and the Pens are only offering a two-way deal?
Jason Mackey: It could be, but Jarry has very little leverage in that regard.
Kenny: "If GMJR lets Jarry go because he feels he has to and Murray gets hurt, he knows he'll get roasted by you guys and us." When was the last time you roasted GMJR for anything, Jason?
Jason Mackey: The Niemi and Hunwick signings. Leaving his team with five defensemen. I'm sure there are others, but the dude won back-to-back Cups. What exactly was I supposed to pick apart?
Joe: Will Rutherford ever consider a re-tooling? I.e. trade some bigger pieces (Kessel, Letang, etc) in order to replenish young talent. Or will he always be about win now?
Jason Mackey: He'll always be in win-now mode, and that's more than a Jim thing. That's from Burkle and Mario on down. The organization wants to maximize what they do Cup and playoff-wise while Crosby and Malkin are here. No shame in that.
Dave: Jason, never get a chance to join your chats, so while I have the option I just wanted to say thanks so much for your great coverage, last year especially. I lost my Dad at too young of an age, too, and know just how paralyzing it can be. Your hard work is appreciated and admired.
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Dave. I appreciate that. I work hard. That's something my dad taught me, and I hope every day that I'm making him proud. He was my hero. Still is. And I miss the hell out of him.
Uncle: How have you been spending your offseason? You hitting the gym and the weights preparing for the upcoming season?
Jason Mackey: Ha. I have been hitting the gym and running but only because I (sort of) enjoy it, and it keeps me sane. Taking some time off. Being a dad and a husband. We're moving, so there's that. Going to Virginia Beach the week after next. Unplugging a bit.
Chris Roy: Jack Johnson has all the physical gifts and he's extremely competitive. What is lacking in his game that the advanced stats all point to being.. well..pretty bad?
Jason Mackey: Some of it has been playing on so-so teams. Last season, as I understand it, was a lot of confidence. Also trying to do too much and likely too much being asked of him. If he's asked to play a simple game, take fewer chances and play safe, I think we could see a different Jack Johnson.
paul: why do people always give Rutherford the benefit of the doubt with his moves because he won two cups? Impact players like Sheary, Rust, and Guentzel were all Shero's doing. and more importantly -- why ignore the 20+ years of terrible track record in Carolina?
Jason Mackey: He did win a Cup there and do plenty in a small market that never spent to the cap. I don't understand crushing the guy for that. GMJR has made some really good trades since taking over (Scuderi-Daley, Perron-Hagelin). He's not above criticism, sure, but I don't understand being overly negative about the guy's career. He's going to be in the Hall of Fame in relatively short order.
Guest: Do you think it was hard for GMJR to see some of the essential cup guys walk this summer? I know it’s a business and it had to be done but Sheary and Kuhnhackl were pivotal parts of the back to back wins.
Jason Mackey: I don't think so. Kuhnhackl didn't score. They need more goals from that spot. And Sheary was too inconsistent, and they couldn't promise him a meaningful role. Plus, sending his dollars out was necessary for the other stuff Jim wanted to do.
Guest: With Guentzel getting huge money next season, I don’t see Brassard sticking around. Would he walk or would it be better to trade him?
Jason Mackey: I think he'll walk. He'll probably get more elsewhere, both in money and role. And, as you said, they're going to have to pay Guentzel.
Guest: Do you agree that Murray had a mediocre to poor year last year and are the Pens worried about his availability and ability to rebound. This was his first full season as the starter and he was either injured or very inconsistent. I like him but I’m not sold on him as a long term starter despite his unbelievable playoff runs
Jason Mackey: I think Murray was inconsistent last year. There were times when he was really good, but he didn't put together any sustained stretches of good healthy or, outside of one or two, dominant play. Are the Penguins concerned that he can do that? No. But he would be the first to tell you that he can be better than he was in 2017-18.
Guest: Your comments on Johnson about him needing to play more simply echo the constant comments about Letang. Has he ever learned to play more simply or tone down the risk-taking? No. At age 31, neither Johnson nor Letang is going to change their game. It’s incredibly risky for JR to take the position of signing someone like that for FIVE YEARs on the hope that they can get him to change his game
Jason Mackey: Fair point. But unlike Letang, who needs to produce offense to be effective, Johnson doesn't. He's a bigger body. He should be hitting people, making a good first pass, killing penalties and playing responsible hockey. Not taking as many risks should come more naturally to him. I think he deserves a chance to see if he can change. Say what you want about GMJR, too, he has done an excellent job getting out from under bad deals. Who's to say it can't happen again?
K: Are Maatta and Dumoulin lifers on this team like Letang or do they get traded are some point in their careers?
Jason Mackey: As of now, I think they are lifers. Or at least the Penguins would like them to be. Obviously if they don't produce, then that could change. But I think the belief is they're still getting better and only scratching the surface of what they can do.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That's gonna do it for this week. Thanks so much for participating. I'll be in touch for our next chat. Talk to yinz then.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.