DALLAS — Eligible for induction into the Hockey Hall of Fame for the first time in 2015, Penguins assistant coach Mark Recchi kept busy by, of all things, furniture shopping.

A year ago, Recchi was lucky. The call from chairman Lanny McDonald came early in the day, while Recchi was in a meeting. The waiting, Recchi insisted this past week, really was the hardest part.

“I just kept telling myself, ‘Stay busy, stay busy,’” Recchi recalled. “Whatever I could do to keep my mind off of it.”

Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford has been experiencing something similar, as there’s a very good chance he could receive the same call Tuesday when the Hockey Hall of Fame’s Class of 2018 is announced.

Advertise with us

Nobody knows for sure whether Rutherford, 69, will get in, although his three Stanley Cup wins along with a lifetime of positively influencing the game of hockey should have him in prime position. There’s also a palpable enthusiasm for Rutherford’s candidacy when you talk to those closest to him.

“Forget about the Cups,” Penguins president/​CEO David Morehouse said, “what he’s meant to the game, the example he sets for the game is enough to warrant the Hall of Fame.”

“I always felt he was greatly underappreciated in the challenges of not just the hockey team but of building the entire product,” said Winnipeg Jets coach Paul Maurice, one of Rutherford’s closest friends and former coaches. “I think it’s appropriate that he wins a couple Stanley Cups, and people start to realize that he’s a very, very gifted man.”

Take a look at Rutherford’s resume, and there’s little doubt he belongs in the Hall of Fame:

• Rutherford is only GM to win the Stanley Cup with multiple teams since the 1967 expansion.

Advertise with us

• His three Stanley Cup titles in the salary-cap era (2005-06) are tied with Chicago’s Stan Bowman for the most by a GM.

• Only seven GMs since 1967 have won the Cup three or more times. Four — Sam Pollock, Glen Sather, Bill Torrey and Lou Lamoriello — are in the Hall of Fame. The others — Ken Holland and Stan Bowman — are still active.

Rutherford’s standing among his peers might be that of a ruthless, eager and effective trader — which he is — but there’s a great deal of respect, too.

“He’s very well thought out and always has a plan and purpose for what he does or says,” said Nashville’s David Poile, at 68 the third-oldest general manager in the league behind Rutherford and Lou Lamoriello (75) of the Islanders. “He’s one of the best GMs ever in the history of the game.”

That’s an easy conclusion to draw simply by focusing on the numbers listed above and combining them with successful playing and junior hockey managerial careers, but those closest to Rutherford took turns identifying some of the less-obvious ingredients that have contributed to all of his success.

Advertise with us

Love our Penguins coverage? Consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.

Here are the three biggest:

The laughter

Early in Maurice’s tenure as Hurricanes head coach, he recalled one particular game, in New Jersey, when he was a stressed-out mess. He and Rutherford were sitting in the stands when they spotted the Devils mascot, in half-uniform, running through its routine.

Advertise with us

Somebody said something, and the next thing you know, they lost it.

“It might’ve been the hardest I laughed in about three years,” Maurice said. “I remember we won the game that night. It’s a good reminder to me; sometimes I have to relax.”

The anecdote underscores something else about Rutherford and why he finds himself on the cusp of the Hall of Fame: The guy is flat-out funny, and it has drawn him closer to those with which he works.

Rutherford’s specialty is busting chops with an extremely dry sense of humor and flashing what Recchi called a “[expletive]-eating grin.”

“When he first messes with you, you’re like, ‘What? Is he [ticked] at me?’” Recchi said. “He gets that grin of his, then you get talking to guys, and they’re like, ‘He’s like that all the time. You’re cool.’”

Advertise with us

That levity has shown up in some key situations, too. Like 2014-15, when everyone got the mumps, defensemen couldn’t stay healthy, and the Penguins barely made the playoffs. Or throughout several smaller moments over the course of the past three postseasons.

Morehouse said Rutherford’s calm and light-heartedness at crucial moments has been something that has permeated the organization — in a good way. Not just on the hockey side, either.

“In 2014-15 and the beginning of 2015-16, I think he did his best work,” Morehouse said. “That’s something that most people don’t think about, most people don’t see. I got to see it from the inside. It was truly extraordinary.”

The honesty

For Penguins coach Mike Sullivan, one of his favorite Rutherford traits is the honesty.

Advertise with us

“No fluff” is a descriptor Sullivan has used often to describe his boss, and he’s right. Rutherford is unique in the sense that he doesn’t beat around the bush; if he plans to do something or thinks a certain way about something, he’s perfectly willing to articulate that.

Even the Hall of Fame, which some people might say they’ve never, ever thought about … well, Rutherford isn’t about to lie.

“Nobody’s going to buy it if I said I never thought about it,” Rutherford said in early April. “But I didn’t think about it until just recently. I grew up in a small town. I was happy to be able to make it to the NHL. I played 13 years. I was one of the fortunate ones who got to keep doing what I loved doing. I loved being in the game.

Maurice joked about the cleanliness of Rutherford’s desk — there is, amazingly, very little on it at all times — but pointed to several slips of paper Rutherford would keep with reporters’ names on them.

“One time I said to him, ‘Are you calling all those guys back?’” Maurice recalled. “Jim said, ‘Every single one.’ And that was how I started to learn how to deal with the media.

Advertise with us

“He’d say, ‘These guys have a job and a time line. Whether you like what they say or not, part of your job is to handle that.’ Every day there would be four or five slips on his desk, and he wouldn’t leave until he got it all done.”

Whether it’s media or those around him, Rutherford’s authenticity has resonated. It has made him many lifelong friends in this game and garnered him universal respect.

“If I was ever in a situation where I had one phone call,” Maurice said, “it’s to Jim Rutherford because you trust that he has your best interest at heart.

“He’s a very, very caring human being. At his core, it might be what makes him great.”

The feel

Advertise with us

Maurice basically was Rutherford’s version of Billy Martin — fired twice in Carolina. Each time, Maurice left Rutherford’s office with a thought.

“Nobody likes getting fired, but I left the office going, ‘You’re right. It’s time. I’ve dropped as many F-bombs as I can.’” Maurice said. “I was still a good coach but not the right fit, and he knew that.”

Rutherford’s feel and intuition come from the personal relationships he has developed with people over the years, and they’ve manifested themselves in the moves he has made — the majority of the time turning out to be precisely the right ones.

For Morehouse, he cited Rutherford’s decision to put his ego aside and fire the coach he had recently hired, Mike Johnston, which led to Sullivan’s promotion.

There’s also deals for Carl Hagelin and Trevor Daley, and that’s only with the Penguins.

Advertise with us

“He’s a magician with that sort of stuff,” Morehouse said.

Added Maurice, “He has a wonderful knack of making the right move to get exactly what that team specifically needs. I think that comes from him caring so deeply about the people he works with.”

For Sullivan, one of the things he has absorbed from Rutherford is his listening ability.

“He’s the best listener I’ve ever been around,” Sullivan said.

Come Tuesday, these men will be the ones listening, along with Rutherford, hoping that a Toronto area code pops up on his phone.

Advertise with us

“I think it’s his time,” Recchi said. “I think it’s wonderful. I think he’s earned it, deserves it, and I hope [this] week that he gets that exciting call.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.