Poll a panel of experts, and the Central Division would more than likely emerge as the NHL’s toughest.
Inhabited by current stalwarts such as Winnipeg and Nashville, as well as past powers such as Chicago (three Stanley Cups since 2009-10) and St. Louis (398 regular-season regulation wins since then, ranking fourth), the Central is certainly no slouch.
But among the many things that Washington winning its first-ever Cup five days ago day did — erasing those many playoff foibles, cementing Alex Ovechkin’s legacy — was settling a divisional debate.
The toughest place to play isn’t the Central. It’s the Metropolitan Division, which has now emerged victorious three years in a row, the first division threepeat since Edmonton and Calgary combined to win four consecutive Cups out of the Smythe Division in 1987-90.
“The Metropolitan Division is a strong division,” Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford said Monday. “It’s going to get better, too.”
We’ll get to that shortly, but first let’s take stock of all the success the Metro has had in recent years.
Read More
Since it was formed in 2013, three of the top five teams in terms of playoff wins reside in the Metropolitan Division: the Penguins (NHL-high 46), Capitals (36, tied for second) and Rangers (tied for third).
Furthermore, a Metro team has not played for the Stanley Cup just once — 2015, when the Lightning beat the Rangers in the Eastern Conference final in seven games.
During that same time, two Central teams have played for the Cup: Nashville in 2017 and Chicago in 2015, winning it all.
The current playoff format means that more than likely one team from each division will make the conference final, but Central teams have petered out early more frequently than they’ve made runs, falling in the conference finals to the Golden Knights (2018), Sharks (2016) and Kings (2014).
Why has the Metropolitan fared better?
Some of it is the Penguins-Capitals effect. During the regular season, Washington has certainly held up its share of the bargain; the Capitals’ 243 regulation wins during the regular season are more than anyone else, while the Penguins are third with 239.
But it also could be a style-of-play issue that has been echoed throughout the league. When the Rangers were winning during the middle part of the decade, they did it with speed. Ditto for the Penguins of 2015-17.
The Capitals weren’t able to get over the playoff hump until they retooled their roster, changed their identity and started to employ a faster pace of play than the heavier game most would identify with the Capitals.
Currently, the Devils have caught up — and then some, Penguins fans might argue. Columbus is close. The Islanders have been streaky when it comes to offense, but they have scored 1,188 goals since 2013, which ranks better than all but five teams. (The Penguins lead with 1,248, and Dallas, fourth with 1,206, is the best Central team.)
Love our Penguins coverage? Consider subscribing.
Support journalism. Subscribe today.
Speed and playing fast have become paramount in today’s NHL, and a case could be made that the Metropolitan Division has done both extremely well.
Equally as important has been goaltending. The Metro has been the best there, too.
Since 2013, Metropolitan Division netminders occupy four of the top seven spots in terms of regular-season wins. That doesn’t include Matt Murray, who has won the most Cups.
Murray and Marc-Andre Fleury (a Metro goalie in four of five years) are actually the only notable division netminders without a Vezina Trophy; Braden Holtby, Sergei Bobrovsky (twice) and Henrik Lundqvist have all won it.
Puck possession really doesn’t paint a decisive picture either way, but special teams does. Metro teams occupy six of the top 15 power-play spots since 2013, five of the top 15 when it comes to killing penalties. Central teams hold just three and two spots, respectively.
Rutherford isn’t a fan of division rankings — “It’s very difficult,” he said. “Teams have injuries, different things happen. It’s not always an indication of the best team” — but he also doesn’t expect the Metro to get any easier.
For one, Rutherford brought up the idea of Lou Lamoriello taking over the Islanders; you’d have to figure he’ll have them doing more than just scoring goals in spurts. And soon.
The Flyers remain a mishmash, incredibly tough to predict, and the Rangers and Hurricanes — despite having a decent amount of young talent — are the only two teams with zero shot of competing for the division crown.
But when your top teams are those who’ve hoisted the Cup three years in a row, it’s not really a debate when you talk about the toughest place to play.
“As always,” Rutherford said, “it’ll be a very competitive division.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.