ARLINGTON, Va. — When the Penguins lost to the Capitals in the Eastern Conference semifinals, the prevailing sentiment was Pittsburgh’s puck-management was a problem, that it fell short of expectations and became too big of a problem to overcome.

That’s not wrong, but we’re learning now that there was maybe more to the story.

Now holding a two-games-to-one lead in the Stanley Cup final, Washington has been especially good defensively, almost surprisingly so, adept at forcing teams to adjust in the neutral zone and causing plenty of turnovers along the way.

Vegas is the most recent team on the list, although Tampa, Pittsburgh and Columbus could probably commiserate with some of the stuff the Capitals — of all teams — have done, a defensive improvement that actually started late in the regular season.

Advertise with us

“With our system — I’m not going to go into detail — we just talked about having numbers and layers and making it difficult,” Capitals coach Barry Trotz said Sunday at Kettler Capitals Iceplex. “A lot of the man-on-man coverages you see get broken down, there are big gaps, and we just wanted to make sure that we didn’t have gaps.

“This game is about mistakes, and those mistakes can lead to scoring chances. So we wanted to have levels of insulation. We wanted to insulate certain areas of our game, and we did it.”

What the Capitals are doing is basically employing a 1-1-3 trap, the last part of that a wall at the blue line that has caused issues for teams dating back to the Columbus series.

The same for many strong defensive clubs — even the Penguins when they’re playing the way coach Mike Sullivan wants — it’s never just about the two defensemen. It’s about forwards tracking back to help and eliminating time and space for the other team.

In addition to getting strong goaltending and terrific performances from their six defensemen these playoffs, the Capitals have actually gotten solid defensive help from their 12 forwards.

Advertise with us

“The good players around the league, they want to have time with the puck, they want to be able to see their plays,” right wing Tom Wilson said. “If you smother them and the forwards are tracking back, pushing them into your defense ... it's just kind of a group mentality to make life difficult on them.”

The result has been making four really fast teams look somewhat slow and also forcing them to make mistakes as they struggle to adjust.

Former Penguin David Perron cited too many blind passes into the slot, a problem that also plagued the Penguins. Careless plays are routinely being picked off and turned the other way, resulting in the odd-man rushes that became so problematic in the Eastern Conference semifinals.

Better puck support is one of the biggest ways to combat what the Capitals want to do. Basically playing closer together and lessening risk. The Penguins talked about that, but a consistent solution never materialized. They weren’t able to get through the neutral zone the way they wanted often enough.

“When you play a wide game, it's not going to work against Washington,” Vegas coach Gerard Gallant said. “They do a good job in the neutral zone, they work hard, and they compete hard. But when you play that support game and you're making short, little plays, you got support coming across, you got your defensemen joining, you're going to have some opportunities. We just didn't do that enough [Saturday night in Game 3].”

Advertise with us

Love our Penguins coverage? Consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.

It seems kind of crazy, no?

A team with Alex Ovechkin, the best pure goal-scorer of his generation, along with Evgeny Kuznetsov, Nicklas Backstrom, T.J. Oshie, John Carlson and others has finally found sustained success in the postseason because it figured out how to play defense.

Then again, the Penguins experienced the same thing in the early 1990s because of Bob Johnson, and even Sullivan improved the Penguins’ defensively responsibility in 2016 and 2017.

Advertise with us

But for the Capitals, this shut-it-down defense has become almost a source of pride.

“Offensive teams have certain tendencies, certain routes that they take through the neutral zone, plays they like to make,” former Penguin Matt Niskanen said. “So if you can be on top of them and turn over some pucks, stifle them, make it hard for them to gain entry with possession, that frustrates skilled players.

“You ask any skilled player, they want to have the puck with possession and speed. So if you can be in their face, just standing in the way, it's amazing what that does. Make them move the puck sooner than they want to, hold the blue line, make them dump it and then you have numbers back for good breakouts. We've done a good job with that.”

The Capitals are allowing 28.6 shots per game this postseason, which is actually second to the Penguins’ mark of 26.6. Washington has allowed 25 or fewer shots on goal in 10 of its past 16 games dating back to the Penguins series.

In addition to limiting Phil Kessel to no goals and nine shots and allowing zero goals to the Penguins’ bottom-six, the Capitals allowed Tampa to score just four goals in the four games Washington won, including none in Games 6-7. The Penguins accumulated just seven five-on-five goals in their six games against the Capitals.

Advertise with us

The defensive transformation tracks back to around the 64th or 65th game of the regular season, Trotz said, whenever he wasn’t happy with the results the Capitals were getting and called a meeting to address a few things.

“We just knew there was another level we could get to,” Trotz said. “We worked on it for a big part of the last quarter of the season, and it started showing results.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.