For the first time in 1,110 days, the Stanley Cup playoffs will continue without the Penguins.
Their 2-1 overtime loss Monday night to Washington ensured there will be no three-peat, no third consecutive parade down the Boulevard of the Allies.
“I think we had a great chance to do it again with the team we have, the way we were playing,” Kris Letang said. “I don’t think we got dominated by that team. But we have to tip our hat to that group. They capitalized on the chances they got. In a few years, we’ve done some great things, but we expect more.”
This Penguins team was flawed from the start — think back to the blowout debacles in back-to-backs early in the year, or floating around the playoff margins around Christmas — but seemed to come into the playoffs with a legitimate chance to make another serious run at a Stanley Cup.
Where, then, did it go wrong? Here are a few places to start when discerning why this year turned out to be different:
1. Lack of scoring depth
Read More
When Bryan Rust was asked after the defeat whether or not the Penguins got enough secondary scoring in this postseason, his response was a terse, “What’s it look like?” The answer, obviously, was no.
The Penguins got just 12 goals from forwards other than Jake Guentzel, Sidney Crosby and Patric Hornqvist this postseason. That accounted for 28.6 percent of their overall scoring. Last year, for comparison, their bottom-nine scored 60 percent of the Penguins’ postseason goals (46 out of 77). Without true scoring threats all the way down the lineup, the Penguins couldn’t take advantage of matchups as well as in years past and became, contrary to what Mike Sullivan often preaches, a much easier team to play against.
2. Key players had a postseason to forget
Specifically, Phil Kessel and Evgeni Malkin. Both appeared to be playing at much less than 100 percent — we may find out specifics at the Penguins’ locker clean-out day later this week — but neither made his presence felt in the series against the Capitals.
Kessel had just one goal the entire postseason, coming in their 5-0 blowout Game 4 win against the Flyers. He had four assists against the Capitals, all coming on the power play.
Malkin just never looked the same since returning from the lower-body injury that kept him out of Games 1 and 2 of the Washington series. He had one goal, on the power play, in Game 4. Like Kessel, he was a minus-4 in what turned out to be a pivotal Game 5 loss.
Malkin and Kessel were both tremendous for the Penguins in the regular season but didn’t do much to distinguish themselves in the playoffs.
Mike Sullivan talks about losing to the Capitals in overtime
3. Derick Brassard never really clicked
Brassard actually seemed to be fitting in a bit better over the final few games, but he was doing it on the Penguins’ fourth line with Conor Sheary and Tom Kuhnhackl. That’s not the role the Penguins envisioned him playing when they pulled what felt like a coup just before the trade deadline.
Brassard was supposed to be a matchup nightmare as the team’s third-line center but never really caught on in that role. Despite ample time together, he and Kessel didn’t seem to have much chemistry, and it’s possible the adjustment from Ottawa’s defense-first system to the Penguins’ up-tempo attack was a bit tougher than anticipated.
Brassard, too, didn’t make his presence felt in the playoffs. By midway through the Washington series, it was pretty evident Riley Sheahan was the Penguins’ third-best center.
The Penguins have Brassard under contract for one more season at a very affordable $3 million. It’s certainly possible an offseason and training camp with the team does wonders to help Brassard fit better, but he wasn’t the immediate difference-maker the Penguins hoped he would be at the trade deadline.
4. Defensive issues kept cropping up
For whatever reason, this team was always a bit leakier defensively that its predecessors. Odd-man rushes were an issue dating back to October and came up again in a big way this series.
In 2016 and 2017, the Penguins gave up 2.28 and 2.29 goals per postseason game, respectively. This year, that number shot up to 2.83.
They gave up four goals or more three times in each series and allowed a number of key scores — maybe none bigger than Evgeny Kuznetsov’s game-tying score in Game 5 — on plain-and-simple defensive breakdowns.
5. Matt Murray wasn’t great in the playoffs
Murray had some moments during this playoff run, and even against the Capitals, where he looked every bit like the goalie that backstopped the Penguins to back-to-back Stanley Cups. He kept the Penguins in it for most of Game 1 and was excellent in Game 6 after a questionable opening goal from Alex Chiasson.
But there were too many of those shaky goals this time around. The Chiasson goal Monday gave the Capitals life. An even more dubious Matt Niskanen score in the third period of Game 3 tied the score and set the stage for Alex Ovechkin’s winner.
In the two Stanley Cup runs, Murray had a combined even-strength save percentage of .935. This postseason, it was .914, second-worst among goalies left in the playoffs.
Murray was probably good enough to give the Penguins a chance to win, as Sullivan said Monday night, but wasn’t good enough to mask other deficiencies.
6. Those two long Cup runs finally caught up to them
Eventually, playing 49 extra playoff games over the last two years was going to take its toll. The Penguins seemed out of gas by the end of the Washington series, just a step late to loose pucks, and second slower getting back defensively.
There’s a reason it was such a massive accomplishment to repeat last year, and why winning a third in a row would be even tougher. Playoff runs are long, grueling processes, and the Penguins expended a lot of energy over the last two.
7. The Capitals were good, too
Really, this is the primary reason the Penguins’ season is coming to an end. They played some really good games against Washington — specifically Games 3 and 5 — that didn’t result in wins. That’s not necessarily any fault of their own, but a credit to the Capitals for putting together their best postseason effort of the Ovechkin era.
They got scoring from up and down their lineup and successfully limited the Penguins’ chances, and Braden Holtby played perhaps the best postseason series of his career.
“He was solid,” Crosby said. “He made some key saves.”
The Capitals also got big goals in big moments, usually a feat reserved for the Penguins in this rivalry: Ovechkin in Game 3, Kuznetsov and Vrana in Game 5 and, obviously Kuznetsov’s overtime winner.
“I think it’s timely goals by them,” Carl Hagelin said. “Last game we have the lead going into the third, they get a pretty easy goal with Kuznetsov. When Ovi scored with a minute to go there in Game 3, also when we had puck control in their zone. They found a way to score the big goals. That was the difference.”
Love our Penguins coverage? Consider subscribing.
Support journalism. Subscribe today.
Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.