They were the first hockey team in nearly 20 years to win consecutive Stanley Cups, thus their adoptive season-long mission to become the first team in nearly four decades to turn twice into thrice.

With a roster still bursting with world-class talent, they had every reason in the world to “3elieve!,” the operative Penguins slogan the organization had plastered indiscriminately across everything from infrastructure to T-shirts.

But on the night they exited the playoffs prematurely after a 2-1 loss, the night “3elieve!” turned into “3eleave,” none other than the Penguins’ perpetual post-season punching bag, the Washington Capitals, presided over the bitter end of Pittsburgh’s long-running post-season pageantry.

In their 44-year history, the Capitals’ most frequent opponent in both the regular season and the post-season has been the Penguins, who beat them nine times in 10 playoff meetings stretching back to 1991, often with excruciating particulars. All five of the Penguins’ Stanley Cup championships had come with severe Capital depreciation as part of the narrative.

Advertise with us

“It’s pretty emotional; it’s hard to speak about right now,” said Washington’s fleet forward Evgeny Kuznetsov, who broke free of the Penguins defense and rammed the puck past Matt Murray five minutes into overtime to end the playoff series. “We got a turnover and a good transition, but you don’t really think about what you’re going to do — just do something. I don’t have the words for it. It’s hard to speak. I’m not expecting myself to score the game-winning goal.”

The Capitals had almost habitually come into these Penguins appointments not expecting anyone to score a series-winning goal.

Only last spring, the Capitals sprang from the dead by taking Games 5 and 6 to tie the best-of-seven series, only to have the since departed Marc-Andre Fleury hand them a fine 2-0 skunking in the nation’s capital for Game 7.

A year earlier, the Penguins chased them from the postseason with an overtime goal in Game 6.

Love our Penguins coverage? Consider subscribing.

Advertise with us

Support journalism. Subscribe today.

The first indication that something different was afoot Monday night came when fourth-line Capitals forward Alex Chiasson collected a loose puck in the right faceoff circle and whistled it between Murray’s left elbow and the near goal post for a 1-0 Washington lead 2:13 into the second period.

The Penguins and every other team in the National Hockey League are always hyper-wary of Alex — Ovechkin, not Alex Chiasson.

Chiasson hadn’t scored a goal in more than four years, but there it was in the Pittsburgh net, a clear omen of potentially historic karmic inversion.

Not until Kris Letang, the longtime Penguins defensive stalwart who had been roasted over the previous 48 hours for a critical defensive lapse in Game 5 (Kuznetsov cashed in that one as well), clattered the tying goal off the stick of Washington center Chandler Stephenson more than nine minutes later did the Penguins regain any equilibrium.

Advertise with us

“We knew this was going to be a tight series and that they’d be waiting for mistakes, and they capitalized when we made them,” Letang said in a Penguins dressing where reflection seemed impossible, their wounds too fresh. “I don’t think we had our best game tonight. I think we had a great chance to do it again with the team we had I don’t think we got dominated by that team, but we have to tip our cap to that group.

“For a few years, yeah, we did some great things, but we expect more.”

That was pretty much the exact strain of forced rhetoric that might have been avoided by a myriad of factors, none perhaps so painfully obvious as a shot by Penguins forward Tom Kuhnhackl in the fourth minute of overtime. Kuhnhackl rifled the puck to the far side of brilliant Washington goaltender Braden Holtby, only to hear it ring off the far post, triggering a raucous collective gasp and moan from the Penguins’ 531st consecutive sellout.

“I didn’t even see it,” Kuhnhackl said. “I just shot it as soon as I could. I used the [defenseman] as a screen and I just kind of heard the reaction of the crowd. I saw it on the Jumbotron. Very disappointing. If that goes in, everybody’s happy, and we go back to Washington.”

You had to wonder how long it would take an extremely accomplished, supremely prideful club to adjust to not being Stanley Cup champions, something they’ve been since June 11, 2016, something they are not as of 10:02 p.m. Monday.

Advertise with us

“I don’t know,” Kuhnhackl said. “This is new for most of us. Obviously, we’re really disappointed right now, and it’s hard to find words.”

Despite the flash flood of disappointment triggered in the fateful Game 6, the home crowd had seized within minutes on what these Penguins have accomplished, chanting “Let’s Go Pens!” as Sidney Crosby led them into the series-ending handshake line.

So the Lemieux practice facility in Cranberry will just have to hang the same five Stanley Cup images on the side of the building for another year, the city will just have to pocket its parade expenses until at least next June, and the rest of us will just do what we did in those 45 out of the past 50 summers when the Penguins didn’t win the Stanley Cup.

No dynasty died here this week. General manager Jim Rutherford, his eyes misted as he awaited the elevator from the press box, knows he’s still got a fabulous nucleus and a vast stable of hockey talent to unleash in October.

That’s a thought that should soothe plenty of hockey souls.