The Penguins have met the Washington Capitals in the playoffs 10 times and have famously won nine of those series. Five times, those victories were part of runs to the Stanley Cup. Here’s a look at some of the team’s best playoff moments from nearly three decades of dominance in the lopsided rivalry:
1991 — Artie party: The Capitals joined the NHL in 1974, but their rivalry with the Penguins didn’t start cooking for almost 20 years. Neither team was particularly strong in the 1970s or ’80s, leaving little to stir their passions. But that started to change in the early 1990s.
The teams met in a playoff series for the first time in 1991, and things got nutty pretty quickly. Following a 4-2 win by the Capitals in Game 1 of the Patrick Division final, the offensive floodgates opened for both groups in Game 2. The Penguins’ Mark Recchi and Washington’s Dino Ciccarelli scored two goals each en route to a 6-6 tie through regulation.
That set up Kevin Stevens to become the rivalry’s first true hero in overtime. The big power forward skated in on the Capitals goal on a rush, took a perfect pass from teammate Ron Francis and deposited it the net for the game winner.
The Penguins won the next three games to eliminate Washington in five on the way to their first Stanley Cup a few weeks later. Beating Washington wouldn’t be quite so easy the following year, though.
1992 — The Capitals’ first choke job: Ciccarelli looked poised to beat the defending champion Penguins by himself. The future Hall of Fame winger scored four goals in leading the Capitals to a 7-2 blowout win in Game 4 of the teams’ first-round series the following spring. The victory staked Washington to a commanding 3-1 lead in the series and put it one win away from avenging the ’91 defeat.
Read More
The Penguins weren’t done, though. Bob Errey scored twice to lead a 5-2 victory in Game 5, and Mario Lemieux buried the Capitals with two back-breaking power play goals that finished a 6-4 victory in Game 6.
The Capitals never recovered and completed their collapse with a meek 3-1 loss in the rivalry’s first Game 7. Ciccarelli didn’t score in any of the last three games, becoming the first of many Capitals stars to falter against the Penguins when it mattered most.
2009 — *That* save: The burgeoning Sidney Crosby-Alex Ovechkin rivalry was the dominant story line when the Penguins and Capitals advanced to face each other in the Eastern Conference semifinals. For the first time, the two faces of the post-lockout NHL were going head to head, and the hockey world couldn’t get enough.
In the end, though, a goalie made the most memorable play of the series.
After six hard-fought games, the Penguins traveled to Washington for a decisive Game 7 and made a big mistake early. Ovechkin slipped behind the defense less than three minutes into the game, leaving Marc-Andre Fleury alone defending the Penguins net. And he said no in a big way.
The huge glove save electrified his teammates. Crosby got the Penguins on the board about 10 minutes later to initiate a flurry of goals that overwhelmed the Capitals in a 6-2 victory. And a few weeks later, Crosby won his first Stanley Cup when the Penguins beat Detroit in another seven-game thriller. Ovechkin, meanwhile, is still wondering what would have been.
2016 — Bonino, Bonino, Bonino: The Penguins looked like they were going to completely blow it. Holding a 3-2 series lead in the Eastern Conference semifinals and hoping to avoid a Game 7 on the road, they’d jumped out to an early 3-0 lead in Game 6 behind two goals from Phil Kessel and one by Carl Hagelin. Then they proceeded to give it all back.
First T.J. Oshie got Washington on the board with a power play goal late in the second period, and Justin Wilson and John Carlson followed with markers in the third to tie the game, 3-3. The PPG Paints Arena crowd quickly went from joyous to anxious as regulation faded into overtime.
That’s when Nick Bonino saved the day. The center followed a Hagelin shot toward Washington goalie Braden Holtby and jammed a rebound into the net for the game- and series-clinching goal.
Bonino would go on to score another overtime winner against San Jose in the Stanley Cup final, but single-handedly crushing the Capitals might be the Penguins moment he’ll be remembered for most.
2017 — Operation Shutdown: The rematch in the Eastern semis a year later followed a hauntingly similar script. The Penguins won three of the first four games to put the Capitals on the brink of elimination, but they couldn’t close the deal. Washington sent the series back to Pittsburgh with a solid 4-2 victory in Game 5, then dominated Game 6 to establish a big head of steam heading into a deciding Game 7.
Fortunately for the Penguins, they still had Fleury.
Playing in place of the injured Matt Murray, the Penguins’ Stanley Cup-winning backup played the game of his life. He stopped all 29 Capitals shots, including this rocket by Ovechkin late in the second period.
On the other end, Bryan Rust and Patric Hornqvist scored to give the Penguins more than enough offense to advance and rip out the Capitals’ hearts yet again.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.
Love our Penguins coverage? Consider subscribing.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.