Something remarkable happened before Game 5 of last year’s playoff series between the Penguins and the Washington Capitals.
Then-Washington defenseman Kevin Shattenkirk admitted what most rational thinkers had long suspected: The Capitals’ horrifying postseason history carried significant psychological weight in their locker room and impacted the team in tangible ways on the ice.
Instead of dishing some silly cliche like, “The past has nothing to do with us,” Shattenkirk spoke the truth as he saw it, with his team trailing the series three games to one.
“With the history in this locker room, [with] what’s happened in the past,” he said, “it can cause you to grip your stick a little bit tighter, cause you to just not make the normal plays that we’re capable of making.”
You NEVER hear those kinds of words in a locker room. But you know what? I wondered if they might be cathartic. Spoken truth often is.
Love our Penguins coverage? Consider subscribing.
Read More
Support journalism. Subscribe today.
It felt to me like the Capitals might finally be coming to terms with the obvious. And finally addressing the right questions.
Were they, in fact, as then-Washington Post columnist Tony Kornheiser so memorably put it decades earlier, “choking dogs?” The evidence seemed overwhelming. And while the sentiment was stated harshly, well, spoken truth often is.
After the Capitals stormed back to force Game 7 with a convincing win, winger T.J. Oshie added to what was becoming a very public therapy session.
“I think mentally was the biggest reason we weren’t achieving what we wanted to achieve,” Oshie said. “Mentally, we weren’t able to stay focused.”
Coach Barry Trotz after the same game: “We’ve grown through our past a little bit, I guess. We’re having fun now.”
Maybe, just maybe, Trotz and Alex Ovechkin were headed to a conference final for the first time in either man’s career. And maybe a do-or-die victory against their nemesis would be the most fitting way, or the only way, to exterminate the Ghosts of Playoffs Past.
Then came Game 7. And wouldn’t you know it? The ghosts had front-row seats. Marc-Andre Fleury — a man who’d stared down demons of his own — made a phenomenal save on Ovechkin, just like in Game 7 eight years earlier, and the Penguins prevailed for the ninth time in 10 series between the two.
The best team in Capitals history was cooked. They would have to settle for yet another Tony (Kornheiser) Award in lieu of a shot at the Cup.
So here we sit, a year later, with the same two teams and the same old question: Can the Capitals perform the monumental feat of overcoming their past and the Pittsburgh Penguins in the same series?
First, let’s be like Shattenkirk. Let’s speak truthfully: Psychology is absolutely a factor in this series and in sports overall. To deny as much would be delusional.
Sidney Crosby on Penguins-Capitals rivalry
The Penguins aren’t free of potential pitfalls. Their swagger might suffer, for example, if they are without Evgeni Malkin for much more than a game.
Some might dismiss the importance of the mental side on account of there being no stat, no analytic, to measure its impact. But if you’ve played a sport at any level, even in the backyard, you know it’s real.
Confidence. Fear. Intimidation. The past. Those are all real.
Don’t tell me there is no psychological component to Penguins-Capitals or Steelers-Bengals (Steelers always win, sometimes via miracle) or Steelers-Patriots (Patriots always win, sometimes via Al Riveron) or any number of rivalries through history.
Athletes use sports psychologists as freely these days as they use trainers or nutritionists. If a stigma regarding mental coaching still exists, it’s only in the minds of morons.
Fleury saw a sports psychologist after a multitude of playoff meltdowns. It worked. Or something did. Never forget that he stole the Capitals series last spring.
Listen to Fleury’s successor, Matt Murray, talk about his inner approach sometime. He told me last year he talks to “some people” who professionally guide him in that area.
“You know, you spend all this time working on your body as an athlete,” Murray said. “But I think your mind is just as important, if not, I think, even more important.”
Which brings us to the other goalie in this matchup, Braden Holtby. Where is he mentally? Where will he be after Game 1? Those are questions that could decide the series.
The Penguins damaged Holtby last year, knocking him from the box in Game 2 and seeing him stop just 88.7 percent of their shots. His numbers were better in the 2016 series, but he allowed four goals in the decisive Game 6.
In early February this year, the Penguins again forced Holtby to make the skate of shame, driving him from the net with six goals on 33 shots. That kicked off a disastrous month, during which he lost his job to Philipp Grubauer (keep that name handy).
Soon enough, things turned again. Holtby replaced Grubauer after the Capitals lost twice against Columbus, and he will take the ice for Game 1 Thursday riding a white horse.
Will he be a mentally stronger goalie for having been reduced to rubble? Is he somehow reprogrammed in a way Fleury was last season? He is a study unto himself.
Could be the Capitals are in a different place, too, having roared back to win four in a row against Columbus. Maybe this time, the Penguins won’t be so deep into their psyches that it would take the Jaws of Life to pry them loose.
On the other hand, if you believe Penguins paranoia starts at the top, signs are not encouraging. Capitals owner Ted Leonsis apparently is going to great lengths again to keep Penguins fans out of his arena.
The Capitals blog Russian Machine Never Breaks reports the team is preventing season-ticket holders from reselling tickets purchased through an exclusive presale.
The site obtained an email that read in part: “We plan to create an amazing atmosphere in the building where we want all fans Rocking the Red in ALL CAPS.”
OK, great. But it’s really not Penguins fans the Capitals need to keep out of their building. It’s the Ghosts of Playoffs Past.
And they can be awfully persistent.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com or Twitter @JoeStarkey1.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.