The way Antti Niemi figured, Pittsburgh would be perfect. He’d resurrect his NHL career here while providing a reliable backup option for Matt Murray, simultaneously making the Dallas Stars look dumb for buying out the final year on his contract.
Things did not exactly work out that way.
Or remotely close.
Niemi was bad. Like, Ponderosa-steak-bad. In three starts, the 34-year-old played to a 7.50 goals-against average and .797 save percentage. By late October, the Penguins had seen enough and placed him on waivers.
Florida claimed Niemi but didn’t keep him long. He wound up with the Canadiens and was expected to back up Carey Price on Wednesday at at PPG Paints Arena. Before the game, Niemi reflected on his short time with the Penguins.
“The whole thing,” Niemi said, “was something that nobody expected.”
Read More
Certainly not Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford, who signed Niemi to a one-year, $700,000 contract on July 1, hoping Niemi could rediscover the form that helped him win 30 or more games four times between 2010-2015, dreaming that Niemi could potentially play “30 to 40 games for us.”
But Niemi looked nothing like that. Or the guy who backstopped the Chicago Blackhawks to a Stanley Cup in 2010. Or someone who had ever played the position in his life.
“I don’t think I played great,” Niemi said.
Figuring out why is tougher for Niemi.
“I’m not sure,” Niemi said. “That’s a good question. It was a tough start. Tough games. You know how it goes not winning games.”
To his credit, Niemi has found a decent fit in Montreal. He’s given up more than three goals just once in 16 games — to the Penguins on March 15 — and was 3-0-3 with a .950 save percentage in six games between Feb. 22-March 13.
“I’m really happy where I am right now,” Niemi said.
It’s a space that, ironically, only Tom Barrasso has shared.
Niemi played his three former teams consecutively March 13 (Dallas), March 15 (Pittsburgh) and March 19 (Florida). The last goaltender to do that — play his last three employers, in chronological order — was Barrasso with Carolina on Dec. 14, 16 and 18, 2001, against Buffalo, Pittsburgh and Ottawa.
“It was an interesting week,” Niemi said, “facing all my teams from this season.”
The Niemi Experiment is one Penguins fans probably have already forgotten, or at least wish they had. Chances are Niemi doesn’t think about it, either.
But it was strange, right? The back-to-back issues. The defensive struggles. Niemi playing some of the worst hockey of his life.
“It was surprising for such a short time,” Niemi said.
What specifically?
“Everything,” Niemi said. “Losing games … everything.”
Love our Penguins coverage? Consider subscribing.
Support journalism. Subscribe today.
Murray encouraged by return
The Penguins undoubtedly would’ve preferred for Matt Murray to have been searching for action Tuesday rather than having it thrust upon him, but that’s also not how things worked out.
Murray was busy in stopping 36 of 39 shots against the Islanders, doing everything he could to keep the game competitive.
The result was troublesome — losing another road game, in a tight division race, to a team that was 1-7-4 in its previous 12 — but how Murray played was not. Especially when you consider how he felt.
“I felt pretty solid considering how much time I missed,” Murray said. “I didn’t feel all that rusty. I thought I played pretty well and felt pretty good for the most part.”
Encouraging signs
Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said both Zach Aston-Reese (upper-body) and Dominik Simon (lower-body) skated Wednesday morning.
Aston-Reese missed an 11th consecutive game against the Canadiens, Simon his sixth in a row.
The return of Aston-Reese is worth watching because of what he could potentially do next to Sidney Crosby.
Aston-Reese had four goals and five points in the six games before he was injured, playing a physical game and thriving around the net.
“Zach’s a guy that we’re excited about getting healthy because we think he can help us win,” Sullivan said. “He’s a good, 200-foot player. We can utilize him in a lot of situations. We thought he was really improving with each game that he played. It was unfortunate that he got hurt when he did because we thought his game was really coming. We’ll make decisions accordingly when he’s healthy, but he’s a guy that we’re excited about.”
Line it up
The Penguins used the same lines and defense pairings as Tuesday’s game in Brooklyn, with Casey DeSmith in goal. That meant Matt Hunwick was a healthy scratch for the ninth consecutive game.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.