Talk heated up Friday morning linking the Penguins to Ottawa Senators center Derick Brassard, who would immediately slot in as a premium option at third-line center.
But figuring out a way to get this done will be incredibly difficult. It could turn out to be a gulf too far to cross for the Penguins, who’ve gone 16-4-1 since Jan. 1 with Riley Sheahan as their third-line center.
The cost to acquire Brassard is extremely high — believed to be a first-round pick, a top prospect and another piece.
The Penguins, meanwhile, have roughly $1.65 million of salary-cap space, according to capfriendly.com, although general manager Jim Rutherford has suggested a couple times recently that the accurate amount of wiggle room is actually less.
Pittsburgh continues to have interest in Brassard but money/cap space is an issue for Pitt. Need to find a way to get cap space... https://t.co/1OoLU7wBSI
— Pierre LeBrun (@PierreVLeBrun) February 23, 2018
A couple things would have to happen for the Penguins to land Brassard:
• Rutherford would likely have to be OK losing Daniel Sprong in a deal, in addition to their first-round pick in this summer’s draft. Hard to see Ottawa settling for anybody else in the Penguins prospect pipeline, aside from perhaps goaltender Filip Gustavsson.
Read More
• Secondly, the Penguins would need to create a significant amount of salary-cap space, and their ways of doing it aren’t great.
To make a Brassard deal go, the Penguins would probably have to send out either Conor Sheary ($3 million cap hit) or Matt Hunwick ($2.25 million). It might be easier said than done.
Pens were in on Grabner. I suspect Rutherford was reluctant based on probability some of the assets needed could be used in Brassard talk.
— Darren Dreger (@DarrenDreger) February 23, 2018
Sheary has 12 goals in 58 games, including just three in his last 29. Sheary is generously listed at 5-feet-8, 175 pounds, and was recently relegated to a fourth-line role.
Oh, and he’s rarely produced anywhere besides Sidney Crosby’s wing.
Ottawa actually has a few young wings, and getting Sheary probably wouldn’t change the balance of their team in a huge way. Brassard is a tremendous player, a proven playoff performer, and the Senators would have no reason to accept a return on which they were only so-so.
But for the sake of argument, let’s move on to Hunwick, who may be a less attractive option to carry this deal through.
Hunwick is 32 and has experienced his share of struggles this season. He has one goal and five points in 35 games, was a healthy scratch for a long stretch, has a sub-50-percent possession mark (48.82 five-on-five) and a scoring-chance percentage (47.89) that’s among the lowest of his career. Hunwick is also signed for two more years at $2.25 million per season.
Obviously none of that is attractive, hence why we’re still here.
Even so, let’s keep this strawman going ... you know, because it’s that time of year.
Say the Penguins somehow convinced the Senators (and their ever-frugal owner Eugene Melnyk) that Hunwick was Benjamin Button and could qualify as a key piece in their rebuild.
The Senators would have to take back in the neighborhood of $2 million of Brassard’s salary simply to get this done — $1.65 million plus Hunwick’s $2.25 gives you $3.9 million going out, while Rutherford has traditionally kept about a $1 million buffer.
Wouldn’t the Senators have better options than having to eat that much?
Sheary could make the deal a little bit more workable, but this is contingent on Ottawa’s defense-first team — general manager Pierre Dorion is on record saying coach Guy Boucher isn’t going anywhere — taking a player whose strength is hardly on the defensive side of the puck.
Yet none of that has stopped the constant and fervent obsession over Brassard, despite Sheahan (8-15–23) having nearly identical numbers to Nick Bonino (9-14—23) through 60 games when comparing year-over-year.
A few sources regularly within the churn of the NHL trade deadline have admitted the Penguins acquiring Brassard will be tremendously difficult, if not impossible, but they also cautioned to never rule out Rutherford, who has specialized throughout his career in fitting square pegs into round holes when it comes to stuff like this.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.