Jason Mackey: Hi folks, Greetings from wonderful Dallas, a great NHL road city. Let's do this chat thing over a burger from my hotel. A Marriott, of course.
Erik: I love you JM, but can you please stop pumping the Matt Cullen horn? The Penguins maximized Cullen, who at this stage of his career, is no longer useful. He's getting crushed from a possession standpoint and his production is down significantly. I just don't see how he could helped a true contender.
Jason Mackey: Erik,
Jason Mackey: Thanks for the kind words. I'm not pumping the Matt Cullen horn because I need a hobby, although I do. I'm pumping it -- whatever that means when it comes to horns -- because it's realistic enough to report it. I'll say this about Cullen's 2017-18 season: Minnesota isn't a great. While I've seen the same numbers you have, players fit differently with different teams. Pittsburgh is a better fit for Cullen, and he knew it before he made his decisions, which was mostly done for family reasons.
Jacob: There is a lot of talk about GMJR being not so quick to jump on a move. Do you think there will still be a move made at the deadline? Sheahan has looked pretty good playing along side Reeves. Also based on the way Cole has played of late do you maybe see him staying and someone like Hundwick on the way out?
Jason Mackey: I think they will do something. Do I think they will add a big-time 3C? Probably not. Especially after what I heard this week. They're warming to Sheahan, especially when you cross that with what it would cost to get a legitimate third-line center. May be better to re-evaluate in the offseason. Sheahan has helped his stock by improving his play with Kessel as well.
Jason Mackey: As for Cole, yes, I do see him staying. The indications I've gotten are the Penguins are less interested in trading Cole because of how well he's playing ... especially when you consider the other options they have right now.
jIM: Jason What is the deal with Cole? Is it style of play, personality or something else. They seem to be dying to get rid of him?
Jason Mackey: They didn't think he played particularly well early on. I disagree, but my opinion doesn't matter. There have also been issues with Cole and Sullivan. Not that it's untenable, it's not. But more with him being a UFA and not playing great (in their minds) ... plus with Cole pretty much wanting to be traded to somewhere he'd play, that's where the trade talk came from. Now he's playing and playing better than anyone else they have ... so the idea seems to be -- at least for now -- to keep him and get everything they can out of him.
copall: What do you think, was Fleury wiping away sweat or tears during his video tribute the other night?
Jason Mackey: Tears. Absolutely tears. He cried and sort of expected to cry. His wife did, too. Fleury loved it here, and Tuesday was as emotional for him as it probably was for you.
Lukas: Assuming the Penguins keep their 1st round pick. What position do you think they'll look to select first? Other needs to address in the draft?
Jason Mackey: Good question, Lukas. Will obviously depend on the draft, but if you look at their organizational depth, they definitely don't need a goaltender. Defense is probably their weakest spot, although not to take one and ignore a very good forward. That said, if I had to pick one, I'd go defenseman.
James: Hearing some rumors about a Matt Cullen trade back to Pittsburgh. Didn’t he choose Minnesota? Do you think he would want to come back?
Jason Mackey: Gee, wonder where you heard anything about Matt Cullen and coming back? Yes, he wants to come back. He doesn't want to abandon Minnesota, but he loved it here, would do it again but also doesn't want to just run out of Minnesota. He made his decision for family reasons, very little to do with hockey. He hasn't been a great fit there, and they may choose to move him on their own accord. Cullen would not turn it down, trust me.
Steven: Any indications as to who the 4C options might be? I saw the Penguins were scouting Buffalo quite hard, any idea what they were looking at over there?
Jason Mackey: Reinhart would be a solid fit, although not necessarily as a 4C. They've done due diligence on Evander Kane, too. Not saying that's why they were scouting Buffalo, just that GMJR considers all options. Suppose Larsson, but I'm not sure he'd add much.
Lukas: Do you see any of the Penguins current young guys making a contribution similar to what Guentzel did last year in the playoffs?
Jason Mackey: Absolutely. Sullivan does a great job integrating young players into the lineup, and Crosby handles them well on his line. I'd be an idiot (more than usual) to say that would be impossible. Simon and Sprong could easily break out and contribute the way Guentzel did.
Alex: Does Jordy Bellerive and his rapid emergence (72 points in 51 games) in the WHL make Sprong expendable? Does it make getting a rental center at the TD more acceptable?
Jason Mackey: Good for Bellerive, but he isn't going to change their views on Sprong, a second-round pick, or influence in any way what they do at the deadline.
Alex: Over/under on how many more days until GMJR starts wheelin’ and dealin’ ?
Jason Mackey: 7
HamOnTheCob: Any chance the Pens move a goalie? If so, which one, where to, and what’s the return?
Jason Mackey: GMJR told me no. Doesn't want to talk goalies with anybody. I'll go ahead and believe Jim. He's a straight-shooter, and I have no reason to think he's lying ... although if I was him, I would.
Guest: Sprong played ok when he was called up....more than fine defensively, and he has a wicked shot. I really don't understand why he hasn't been called up again after all the injuries. Do you?
Jason Mackey: On one hand, consistency. He didn't have enough of it. Also, I think they think he can be an elite player, and they're not giving to live with mediocrity from him. Third, I'm suspicious of how this coaching staff (read: Sullivan) feels about him. He's not a typical Sully guy. A little brash. Plays a game that doesn't necessarily fit what Sully likes to do. I'm more confident I'm right with Nos. 1 & 2, but I wouldn't rule out No. 3.
saneman: is there a chance Pens could just consider Cole THEIR rental and not trade him since he offers a type of play that adds a different dimension to their D corps and makes it more versatile? Is Hunwick tradable or do they something more daring by trading a Dumoulin type player to get a good forward in return and free up cap space(akin to those early 90s trades where you traded quality to get quality)?
Jason Mackey: There's a very good chance Cole stays. Got that one before. ... As for Hunwick, no. He's a 32-year-old defenseman in the first year of a three-year deal that pays him $2.25 million per season, and he hasn't been good at all here. Not exactly marketable.
Quality 3C: I understand I may be among the most popular to be named players in Pittsburgh. A couple of imposters have been brought on board. And some players who have seen better times (Letestu/Cullen) and are past their prime have been discussed. But I've been hearing my name in rumors since July 1. I'm beginning to think I'll be playing elsewhere. Jason, why should I believe GMJR is really going to successfully trade for me after all this time?
Jason Mackey: You've proven elusive, Quality 3C. And you've occupied my chats for far too long. It may be time to say goodbye. I hope.
Guest: Did you notice a marked improvement in play (faster) against LV once Kuhn and Rowney were out? I did. It seems obvious that the slower grinders should be replaced by faster kids from WBS. The team clearly should not be playing all four of Kuhn, Rowney, Reaves and ZAR at the same time. Sullivan keeps saying they want to play fast, a speed game, yet his actions belie that by playing too many plodders. Agree?
Jason Mackey: No. Reaves scored a goal, for one. And his line with Sheahan and Aston-Reese was actually pretty decent. You're taking 50 minutes of play against a Western Conference team and applying it to the Penguins' entire season. I'm OK with having a fourth line that's a little heavier and not as fleet of foot, but your top three lines have to score. Notice when the Penguins have been getting more of that lately that they've been winning? Funny how that works.
Guest: Jason, you seemed pretty convinced our only move by the trade deadline will be Matt Cullen. Is it really that bad out there for 3Cs and LWs?
Jason Mackey: There's more to it than that, but prices are high. One, they like Sheahan. They've been warming on him. Two, they don't have great assets to trade. Sheary was hurt. Hagelin has actually been pretty good. Who else do you deal to make room money-wise? They're weighing the assets they could keep by committing to Sheahan versus what they'd have to give up to get someone. Can understand why they would think the upgrade might not be worth it.
Mike Johnston: Jason, As a student of coaching, I'm beginning to conclude that NHL coaches are like symphony conductors: it's really about the players. Why for 3 months, these Pens looked just like they did when I coached there. And MS had no solution whatsoever. He made the same comments "get to our game", "play north south" "be hard to play against" , but to no avail. Then comes January, and the Pens begin their push. Am I wrong? Look at the Jersey game last Saturday. MS was helpless again.
Jason Mackey: I think there's some truth to what you're saying, Mike. Hello, by the way. You're a good man. Given what this team has accomplished, I think what we're seeing is the futile task of trying to get them to care in October, November and December. Looks like we're out of that period, thankfully.
HB: If Phil kessel 2x time Stanley cup champion wins the scoring title do you think they will give him the hart trophy?
Jason Mackey: It's an interesting question. He's been their most consistent player. If MacKinnon comes back and make a run, I think I'd have to think long and hard about that; he's that valuable to the Avs. But Kucherov is on a loaded team. Also, Malkin. What if Malkin keeps this up? Could change the calculus a bit.
guest: Do the owners have any say in how player discipline is handled for the league? There needs to be changes and it seems maybe owners need to get involved to protect their players. How does Oshi get a small fine for what he did to Letang? And Reaves was on the ice for that so player deterrence does not work. Suspensions is only thing that will work.
Jason Mackey: Reaves' presence is a completely different discussion. Believe owners would have a say, but only over-arching when it comes to the NHL Department of Player Safety. They didn't get to weigh in on the Oshie hit, for example.
HamOnTheCob: Cole is playing great. Has he (A) cemented his spot on the Pens roster or (B) bolstered his stock for a likely trade? If he stays, which other D is likely on the move?
Jason Mackey: Cole has played great. As long as he's playing, I think there's a good bet he stays. One bad game and Sullivan yanks him, that might change things. If he stays, I'm not sure anybody would be on the move. They could trade Ruhwedel for something small, but why? With the injuries they've suffered, and with as much as Hunwick has struggled, it might not be the worst idea to keep 8. Also, the guys in WBS (Corrado, Trotman) aren't exactly knocking down the door.
copall: Are you concerned that Shultz hasn't scored much at all this year? I don't think he has scored a goal since early November.
Jason Mackey: Funny you ask, talked to Justin about this the other day. Gonna write it soon. He alluded to lacking confidence, and I don't blame him. The lack of power-play time takes an obvious hit in his points, but he hasn't produced much five-on-five, either. So, to answer your question, I'm not concerned, but I do think there's work to be done when it comes to his offense.
HB: Do you think we will see sprong soon I know his last couple games left a lot to be desired but he a scorer and maybe putting him with malkin would be good
Jason Mackey: I do think we will see Sprong again this season at some point, but it doesn't look like it'll be Friday. Looks like Sullivan is loading up his top six and putting Malkin back with Kessel. I agree with the Malkin fit; I think it's worth exploring. But for several reasons that I mentioned earlier, management doesn't seem to be in a rush to bring Sprong back.
HB: When the pens won the Stanley cup for the first time were the fans as crazy as the philly fans Sunday?
Jason Mackey: I was 7 at that time, so my view on the world was a little different. But I hope -- and can probably guess -- that they were more civil than that.
HB: With the team playin better as of late does cole still get traded he’s definitely better than hunwick olesiak
Jason Mackey: I don't think so. As I sit here today, I think they'll keep him.
Jason Mackey: He's better than the other two by a lot right now.
John: The consensus lately seems to be that because Sheahan is playing well maybe an upgrade at 4C is the way to go. Do you think the opposite could be true? That because sheahan seems more comfortable at 4C and is capable of elevating less skilled wingers, that they may go all in for a skilled 3C? Which would give them the depth Sully craves and the ability to not hide the fourth line (Kuhnhackl, Rowney, Reaves should NEVER play together).
Jason Mackey: I believe what I wrote this week in my 20 Thoughts: that it looks at this point like they're cool with Sheahan as the 3C and will potentially add to the No. 4 spot. Agree with you on 34-37-75 as a line. Not much there. That, though, will be a moot point for a bit with their injury situation.
Pens4Life: Do you have all or some of the players’ cell phone numbers? In your article the other day you mentioned Fleury called you before he came to town. Just curious if you’re able to call or text the guys when you want, or if you always have to go through the Pens’ media relations folks if you want to talk with someone.
Jason Mackey: I have some, not all. A few emails, too. I texted and talked with Fleury because Vegas media relations was non-helpful. They would not give me access to Fleury postgame, when I was planning a trip to D.C. Sunday. If the shoe was on the other foot, I'm confident the Penguins would've accommodated the request -- from a beat guy of the major metro daily in town, a non-negative story about a player. So I went another route. I've texted and emailed with some. Would rather not name names, but you also need to respect privacy; it's certainly not a regular thing. Only when absolutely necessary.
Pens4Life: Do you and your PG colleagues read each other’s work? Do you read, say, Ed and Ray’s Steelers pieces and Brink’s Pirates reports, and conversely do they read your Penguins columns? If so, do you offer and receive constructive criticism?
Jason Mackey: Sure. I try to read everything in the PG. I'm from here, grew up reading the PG, have idolized Ed (and Gerry, Gene, Ron and Dave) for basically my entire life. There's nothing I can say that they don't already know, believe me. So I keep my mouth shut. But I read the paper every day -- in print -- and love it. Wish I could do it more but like all of us, just sometimes a little busy.
Pens4Life: Ian Cole stay through the end of the season at this point?
Jason Mackey: I think so, at this point.
Tony: Do you think Jacques Martin will get another opportunity at a head coaching job in the NHL?
Jason Mackey: Eh, the league is skewing younger with head coaching jobs. I don't know if that's even something Jacques wants at this point. At his age, my sense is that he's pretty happy where he's at. Could be worth asking him, though.
Kim: What do you think Matt Hunwick's future with the Penguins will be?
Jason Mackey: I honestly don't know, Kim. Wish I had something better for you, but it's sort of TBD. He hasn't played well enough to crack the top-six; he's not tradable; and they have him for two more years after this one. I'd imagine somebody will get hurt again at some point -- Penguins defensemen always do -- but what that leads to ... who knows?
Pens4Life: Do you think another Sprong call up is imminent?
Jason Mackey: Not imminent. That's a strong word. And they would have done it for today's practice. But I do think he'll get another shot.
HB: My idea for the allstar game that I forget to mention last week keep the 3on3 and fan vote the captains but then have the captains draft there team make for new combinations that we want to see
Jason Mackey: You lost me at "keep."
John: Do you think that the Vegas win convinced Sully that when the injuries hit Guentzel has to play with Sid and Phil with Geno? That in those situations spreading the talent out just dilutes all 4 lines? I.E kuhanhackl top 6 RW. And that they should roll two dominate lines
Jason Mackey: I don't know if the Vegas win did specifically, but I think Sullivan is just handling his team the way most coaches do. Yes, he would like balance. But if there are injuries, then he's aware he's going to fare better by playing his best players together.
Mike in Kennedy: It would be bold and risky. It would be like the Recchi for Tocchet trade. What would you think about GMJR trading the hard-to-coach Kessel now while his value is at a maximum (though not sure how his contract would affect his value)? Possibly acquire a talented young center for 3rd line and insurance against a Crosby or Malkin injury. Can you think of a Cup-contending team in desperate need of scoring that might be a trade match involving Kessel?
Jason Mackey: They've won 11 of 15, could challenge for the division lead, and Kessel is one point shy of leading the league in points. I really don't think that's in the cards. ... Offseason could be a different story, but you would need to be 100-percent convinced Sprong is ready. I'm not there yet. No even close. No need for the Trade Phil talk right now.
Befuddled: Jason, I know sullivan pushed all the right buttons, and won 2 cups, etc. But in the world of what have you done for me now.. Why would you insert Khun into a top 6 role when you have Daniel Sprong languishing in WBS, Simon started great and has since cooled some and didn't even see a shift in the 3rd period against NJ. This feels like off ice issue. Ian Cole, he ticked off Sullivan and was benched in favor of Hunwick, Ian Cole is not a top tier D, but the guy is way better then Hunwick. DeSmith, he got shelled against NJ, he made 2 mistakes only got 1 goal in support and still put up over a 92% save percent game. Arguably our best goalie as all 3 play right now, yet he is sent down. Not understanding Sullivan's decisions right now. I can go on. Kessel-Malkin are arguably the best duo in hockey right now, I get the balanced attack thing, but the
Jason Mackey: I'm going to let Mike Sullivan lose a playoff series first before I start typing away, asserting that he's an idiot. ... What if Sprong needed more time? ... So Sullivan and Cole have have had run-ins; do you think that's the first time in the history of pro sports that has happened? ... He rode the hot hand with DeSmith, he turned into a pumpkin, now Jarry is here.
John: Ok last comment. I don't understand the Sprong defensive fears from the staff/front office. I thought on the puck he was easily one of their better players. Using his speed and size to hound the puck carrier in all 3 zones. He does need to improve positional discipline away from the puck. But guys like Reaves, Sheary, and others make Sprong look like Pavel Datsyuk defensively. Sheary has always been brutal defensively, but gets leeway (as he should because of what he brings in other aspects). I think Sprong deserves the same latitude.
Jason Mackey: You make some good points, John. I think Sheary gets that latitude because he's helped win two Cups and has scored consistently for pretty long stretches. Sprong has done neither of those things. It's different. It just is.
guest: Hi Jason, you beat the team to Dallas, what are your plans for the day :)
Jason Mackey: Gonna finish this, maybe take a nap, go for a run, get some BBQ tonight, see some of the city and try to watch the Stars game. Any suggestions?
Jason C: Hello Jason hope you are well Sir and as always thank you for having this 1 o’clock Chat! So is there any names you are hearing about of interest for the Pens Trade wise? Is there anyone you think to keep an eye on from your prospective?
Jason Mackey: If anything, rumblings about guys they're interested in has cooled; they might just roll with Sheahan as the third-line center. Matt Cullen is one to watch.
Chad in WV: Would it make sense for the Penguins to move Feaves before the deadline. I love having him, but with the healthy scratches and low minutes I think it’s doubtful he returns next season. Do you think they try to move him?
Jason Mackey: They would have to get decent return. I don't think they would be against it, Chad, but they wouldn't do it just to do it. Given how this year has gone, and the way the NHL is trending, I can't imagine teams are clamoring for Ryan Reaves right now.
GD fan: Jason, Saw the news today about John Perry Barlow and thought of you instantly. Can you say a few words about what he meant to the Dead and what a great man and father he was? THanks, bro. Keep on Truckin!
Jason Mackey: Didn't know a ton about JPB personally. Did love a lot of his writing, though. He wasn't Hunter, but who is? A very important piece to latter-day Dead.
Guest: Settle a bet Jason - My wife says you were an extra in a Jean Claude Van Damme film, but I say that makes ZERO sense. What is the truth? If I win, I get a new fishing pole. If she wins, we have to go see Smashmouth in concert! YUCK!
Jason Mackey: Better start remembering the lyrics to "All-Star." Me, my dad and stepmom went to one of the extra shoots at Civic Arena. My dad got picked to be one of the dudes holding a board or whatever it was when JCVD ran through the crowd. Don't know if the shots ever made it, though. You could win on a technicality.
Lukas: Do you think the Penguins would have any interest in claiming either Jooris or Kruger off waivers to add to their center depth?
Jason Mackey: I don't. Kruger makes too much. Don't know why they'd grab Jooris. A struggling player on the Hurricanes going to the two-time defending Cup champs who've won 11 of 15. Doesn't make a ton of sense to me.
TEAM FAN: In this very chat, last summer I predicted that the Golden Knights would be a good team this year and you poo-pooed the idea completely. Care to eat crow now and apologize, Mr. Mackey...if that is your real name?
Jason Mackey: It is, and I will. I thought they would struggle. I was wrong. Absolutely. Excellent call by you.
1971: Too bad about the death of John Parrie Barlow. In your opinion, what is the choicest lyrical nugg he ever wrote? For me it has to be Mexicali Wind.
Jason Mackey: Is that like a cross between Mexicali Blues and Black-Throated Wind? Ha. I'll go "Cassidy" and "We Can Run."
Guest: Can the PENGUINS 3-PEAT? SAY "YES"
Jason Mackey: Yes.
PGH 2011: Lately, DK SPorts has been getting a lot of bad press nationally. My friend is thinking of applying there. Can you share a bit about some of the mental and verbal abuse you suffered while under their employ? I'm hoping your experience will help my friend to see that she shouldn't work at DK Sports. Thank you, Jason.
Jason Mackey: Not saying anything negative about my former employer, especially not here. I work at the Post-Gazette. I love it. Paper treats me very well. I'm not about to embarrass myself or it. Best of luck to your friend. ... I will say -- because I think transparency is important here -- that Dejan and I are friendly at PPG Paints Arena, and I ignored interview requests for the Deadspin story. I've moved on, wish no ill-well toward Dejan or his site and would simply like to focus on my work here. Thanks.
Jason Mackey: ill-will*
jerry g 4ever: Jason, when you travel covering the Penguins and you happen to go to a state where marijuana is legal, I'm sure you love to catch a buzz and go to a jam band bar or something like that. What is the choicest state to cover the NHL in due to its very kind rules regarding the magical herb? Rock on, fellow dead header!
Jason Mackey: Don't smoke, sorry. Actually had a conversation with Dana Heinze about this recently. About how we both barely drink when listening to the Dead, wanting to experience the music our own way.
syd da kid: Who are the top 3 players in the NHL currently, in order? THanks. GO PENS
Jason Mackey: This is really hard. Crosby and McDavid are there. I can punish Sid for a slow start point-wise. But how do you not include Kucherov, who leads the league in points? Or Kessel for how darn good he's been. Or D men like Doughty, Hedman and Karlsson. This one has me, not gonna lie.
Jason C: Do think the Pens Call up Sprong with all the current injured players for tomorrow?
Jason Mackey: No. I think he would've been here today for practice.
INFO NEEDED!: Are any current NHL players competing in the Olympics this year or are they all staying with their NHL teams?
Jason Mackey: They're not allowed. Staying with their teams.
Better: Based on what you've heard, do you think the Penguins will make any trades before the deadline? If so, will it just be minor tinkering or a significant change?
Jason Mackey: I think they will do something, but I think it will be minor. Potentially adding a fourth-line center.
Jason Mackey: Without sending any out, about $500,000. GMJR likes to keep about $1 million in reserve. They have $1.4 million in space right now. Could bend a little there, but not much on the reserve.
Numbers Game: I've seen different numbers on how much salary the Penguins can add at the trade deadline, given their current payroll and NHL rules. What's your best guess at the number?
MaySeeGray: I'm interested in what is going on with Justin Schultz. Last year he could not be stopped. This year he has dealt with injury and hasn't really been noticeable since he's been back. That's probably a good thing but I wonder if he has been shooting less or is still injured or has been covering for his other defensemen? Thanks for any feedback.
Dan: Tampa and Boston biggest headaches getting out of the East ? How do you rate the West...Nashville Winnipeg Vegas ??
Jason Mackey: He's not attempting a bunch less shots, although some. He's also not getting as much power-play time. I think there's some legitimacy to the injury stuff; he hasn't been able to get in much of a rhythm. Then you have the partner. He's traditioally been better with Ian Cole than Olli Maatta, and I'm surprised they haven't gone back to that yet.
Jason Mackey: I would put Vegas ahead of both of them, honestly. Maybe Vegas, Nashville and Winnipeg.
Glass half empty: The Penguins are second in their division but they've played 2 or 3 more games than the first, third, fourth and fifth place teams. Some of those teams will move past the Penguins when the number of games evens up. There's still a lot of ground to make up.
Jason Mackey: I'm not sure I understand your question.
Derick: How long until Matt Murray passes Marc Andre Fleury talent wise?
Jason Mackey: Are you looking for an exact number of years? I also considered talent something you had or didn't.
Devin: Are the Pens in danger of losing another goaltender in the Seattle expansion draft? And if so which would the Pens protect Murray or Jarry?
Jason Mackey: They could be. They would protect Murray. He's their No. 1. He's won two Cups. Simple as that.
Guest: is it possible that the Pens select Bode Wilde in the draft this year? he's a solid player from U of Michigan. Are you hearing any rumors regarding the draft/scouting?
Jason Mackey: I have not. And you typically don't this time of year, especially not as they would relate to a precise player a team might take. A lot can (and will) happen between now and then.
Scott: With his recent demotion to the 4th line in Chicago, do you see GMJR making a call to Stan Bowman about Saad?
Jason Mackey: Maybe he checks, but I don't know how that works with the money. Saad makes, what, $6 million? Who goes out to do that? I think it's just too tough with the contracts they already have.
Guest: Would the Grateful Dead be remembered as fondly as they are today by Dead Heads like you if it weren't for JOHN PARRY BARLOW?
Jason Mackey: Absolutely not.
Logan: Cullen has been connected to the Penguins by four insiders/writers: You, Bob McKenzie, Elliote Friedman, and Micheal Russo. What percent of chance do you see Cullen coming back to PIT? Any moves other moves beside a Cullen trade?
Jason Mackey: Right now, nothing besides a Cullen trade that I'm hearing. More that the Penguins could stand pat on a third-line center.
Benny D: I know you won’t get any questions on centers but: Derek Ryan (CAR), Boone Jenner (CBJ)... either of these guys a possible fit?
Jason Mackey: I don't think so.
Kris : I know you are probably sick of talking about this but I love Matt Cullen. I miss Matt Cullen. I’d give up (well maybe not a full limb but maybe a finger?) to get him back. What has to happen to get him back? Would the Wild let him go?
Jason Mackey: Only if you gave up a finger.
Devin: Are the Pens in danger of losing a goalie in the Seattle expansion draft? If they feel like they are which one will they protect Murray or Jarry?
Jason Mackey: They would protect Murray. He's their No. 1 and has won two Stanley Cups. You don't get rid of that.
Erik: I could see Gustavsson being part of a deadline package, got to think he's at least 3-4 years away from seeing the NHL. You?
Jason Mackey: I think that's fair, but Rutherford has said he doesn't want to trade any goalies. I believe him. Maybe I'm wrong. But his stock -- assuming they believe in him, which they should -- will only increase.
Benny D: Who will finish the season with the most points for the Pens: Kessel, Malkin, or Crosby?
Jason Mackey: I said Phil yesterday when I was on with Starkey, but I'm going to change it -- it's my chat, I reserve the right -- to Crosby.
TK: Can you explain why Simon is playing with the big club while Sprong is in WBS?
Jason Mackey: They still want Sprong to develop. Work on his all-around game. Defense. Consistency. I think they're holding him to a higher standard than Simon.
Erik: Is there any speculation surrounding Derick Brassard? If I could pick one guy from the "available list" of potential trade options, it would be him.
Jason Mackey: There's speculation every week in this chat, but he makes $5 million. Who goes out to make room?
Erik: I've hard TSN report that OTT is interested in Jarry, potentially for JB Pageau, any truth?
Jason Mackey: I have not heard that, but I also can't really speak to what Ottawa wants.
Harold: Looks like the Pens have very few back-to-back games the rest of the season. Do you think Murray plays most of the remaining games, with Jarry and DeSmith rotating between WBS and Pittsburgh to stay fresh?
Jason Mackey: Yep. And Sully will probably ride the hot hand.
CAfan: Not that it matters at all but it is laughable to me that some "power rankings" have the Pens as low as 14th. Is it possible that others are under estimating this team?
Jason Mackey: Why are you reading that stuff? Has to be something better out there. Never understood "Power Rankings." In any sport.
Erik: Given the ages of the Pens' core ranging from (30-31), do you agree that they should continue to have an "all-in" approach this season? The health is never guaranteed with this core, and this year, they all are presumably heathy and playing at a high level.
Jason Mackey: It does have an all-in approach. Every season is like that. The Penguins spend to the cap every year. But they're not going to do something stupid just because of some made-up thing.
Cindy: Jason, what’s going on with Simon? He was great with Sid for awhile but ends up being benched against VGK ( even tho Pens we’re down 2 forwards). Was he just a flash in the pan?
Jason Mackey: It was one game. He's a rookie. Cut the kid some slack. He wouldn't be the first rookie to have a bad game, I'm pretty sure. If he has three more, then we have a problem. But I'm willing to give him a chance to bounce back.
Paul: One name nobody mentions that i have thought could fill 4C and come pretty cheap is Desharnais on NYR. Good faceoffs, speed and decent hands.
Jason Mackey: Especially with them having a fire sale, I think you make an excellent point. Price is right. Like the player. Depends on the ask.
Martin: Will Mike Sullivan stop being so stubborn and give Reaves more than 6 minutes a game?
Jason Mackey: Agree with you there. If the guy's on your bench, play him. That's not a revolutionary concept, IMO.
Just a Box of Rain: Are we a grateful hockeytown?
Jason Mackey: Yes.
Bob Sackamono: My dog used to chase people on a bike a lot. It got so bad, finally I had to take his bike away.
Jason Mackey: Good one, Bob.
Albert: Jason, I believe you mentioned in a previous article that the Pens aren't actively pursuing a 3rd line center as much as they are a 4th line center. I believe Sheahan is improving each game, and with a little more scoring touch, would be ideal for the position. What's your analysis on his play? Do you think he resigns here?
Jason Mackey: I think it's a little early for that, but I have been encouraged by his play. Think about what a third-line center is counted upon to do. Sheahan does all of that stuff except score goals. But if he's able to help that line produce offense, then I think they could live with his lack of goal-scoring, especially if he's able to function with Kessel.
Matt: How likely do you think it is that Matt Cullen returns to Pittsburgh in a trade, this season (obviously)
Jason Mackey: I think it's pretty likely.
SAAD: Are players of my ilk going by the wayside like fullbacks in the NFL? What happened to the NHL in the last 3 years?
Jason Mackey: I don't think so. Look at Hornqvist. He's about to earn a serious contract. I think those types do have to be on good teams, with players who can generate some offense for them.
Logan: Can you see GMJR making a move more Pacioretty or Kane? What assets would we have to move if so?
Jason Mackey: I think the prices are too high. For Kane I believe it's an NHL player, a first-round pick, a high-level prospect and another pick/prospect. One, that doesn't work financially. Two, I don't think it makes sense for them. Believe the Pacioretty ask is similarly high.
Guest: Jason, your chats used to be way more interesting. You have yet to mention John Parry Barlow. You should have led off with that, bud!
Jason Mackey: This is the fourth time that has been brought up.
Alex: Although Hagelin has been playing better as of late. Do you see him being bought out this offseason if his goal scoring stays so low? 4 million a year for (I️ think) 12 goals over a 100 game period is not conducive to a happy balance sheet.
Jason Mackey: Hagelin doesn't have to score goals to have value ... but he does have to score more than the two he had at one point earlier this year. He adds value by creating turnovers, killing penalties, playing good defense, working off his linemates. $4 million might be a little high, but the way he's played of late, there's definite value there.
Logan: Who plays 4C tomorrow? Simon? Dress 7D?
Jason Mackey: Believe it's going to be Teddy Blueger.
Jason Mackey: Or at least it looks like he's getting recalled. If they don't go Blueger, probably Sheahan with Guentzel moving to 3C. Or Rowney if he's healthy. Not Simon. Sully doesn't like him there.
Karl: If Hagelin can just turn it on after Christmas, why not turn it on in october?
Jason Mackey: A fair point. Not that easy, though, Karl.
Alex: What do you think is the max amount of assets (roster players, prospects, picks, etc) that GMJR is willing to move at the deadline?
Jason Mackey: I don't think there's a set number to say ____ . Every situation is different.
Jared Werth : If the pens can’t get Callen do they have a plan B?
Jason Mackey: In that case, I'd like to see them get Cullen.
Joe D.: Any chance the Pens waive Hunwick for the purpose of sending him down to WBS to free up some cap space for acquisition of a 3C/4C?
Jason Mackey: Hunwick is on a one-way deal. He'd make the same amount of money in WBS.
Albert: Do you like Rust as one of Crosby's wingers? It seems like he has the speed and forechecking ability to really complement the Kid. Thanks for doing these chats and answering our questions! If any of mine are redundant, I apologize, but I'm sure you're very used to it unfortunately.
Jason Mackey: I do. More important, Crosby does, for the speed Rust brings. To play with Sid, you have to be able to skate. Rust could stand to finish more, but he has been doing that of late.
Guest: Pageau for Sprong and a 2nd
Jason Mackey: Ottawa wouldn't do it.
Guest: Pageau for Sprong, 2nd. Fair deal?
Jason Mackey: No.
Jason Mackey: Pageau also makes $3.1 million. You've moved no NHL salary and are appropriately $1.7 million over the cap.
Scott: No offense chat moderator, but so far I have seen nothing but Cole and Sprong questions. And questions from the same people. I throw a name out there (who happens to be a Western PA guy), and nothing? I don't think I will offend anyone with my question about GMJR perhaps trading for Saad. Quick, Jason... need your hot take on this.
Jason Mackey: Scott, I answered your question about Saad. I answer every question -- as long as it's not offensive -- in the order it was received. We've had a lot. I'm going as fast as I can. I don't think Saad is a fit because he makes a lot of money ($6 million, I believe) and the fact that he and Hornqvist play similar games.
tj: I saw Guentzel and Rust were on the top line with Crosby today. Guentzel and Crosby were magic together. Why has it taken this long to reunite the two? Guentzel no longer has to play center.
Jason Mackey: I think they wanted to have Guentzel on the third line to help the offense there. But right now, with injuries, Sullivan seems intent on loading up his top-six. I agree with you. Guentzel should be playing with Crosby. They've been very good together.
B: Jason, I know he has been injured but could you see the pens making a run for Chris Kreider? I think he would be a good fit for the pens system
Jason Mackey: I don't see that. Rangers wants picks and prospects for a rebuild, but they couldn't fit Kreider under their cap. Couldn't come close. I'm not sure he's worth that hit (4.625 M) either.
Ryan: I would love the Pens to re-sign Hornqvist. IMO there are not many players in the league that get those dirty goals a team needs to have in the postseason and to have a great pp. Are the Pens have plans on extending him. I think he may be irreplaceable.
Jason Mackey: They're going to try, Ryan. They have tried. Seems he wants to go to July 1 and see what he can make. I respect that. But I do think the Penguins will do everything they can -- within reason/sanity -- to keep him.
Scott: Oh look... another Sprong question from someone who has already asked about Cole. zzzzz....
Jason Mackey: Scott, I've already answered your question twice now.
Guest: In a cage match between Goalie Interference v Icing for the title of least comprehensible/most inconsistently enforced rule, which would you put money on?
Jason Mackey: Oh, goalie interference. It's such a hot mess right now.
IceBurgh: If you were to guess, when is Horny gonna be healthy?
Jason Mackey: I'd say about two weeks.
Guest: Do you think the committee that chose the NHL Top 100 regrets not including Malkin? Or is that mostly just people here in Pittsburgh thinking they were nuts to leave him off the list?
Jason Mackey: No, they're definitely nuts for leaving him off, and plenty of others outside of Pittsburgh agree with us. I do think they regret it. It's just awful, a horrible decision.f
guest: could Minnesota trade Cullen to another team, or does he have no trade clause?
Jason Mackey: They could. He does not.
guest: How does that Las Vegas game rate for you in terms of best games ever at the arena? Watching on tv was emotional and exciting, can't imagine what it was like to actually be there.
Jason Mackey: Non-playoff game at PPG Paints Arena, it's No. 1. It was amazing.
tj: In the coming years, do you ever foresee a situation where Fleury could be back as a Penguin? Wouldn't it be a momentous occasion to welcome Flower back as a Penguin?
Jason Mackey: He should be back whenever they retire his jersey.
guest: Reaves finally got some minutes in the LV game and looked pretty good. I don't understand why he has not been given more of an opportunity this season. He has to be really discouraged and bummed he isn't still on a St Louis team that is having a great season.
Jason Mackey: Yes, I can kind of sense that from him. He was a much better fit there. Say what you want about hating having Reaves (and most of you do in this space), but he can be a useful player in certain systems. I'm not sure what the Penguins do is one of them.
RPK: Do you still think Maatta is still having a stellar season. I see is a lot of turnovers in the defensive zone.
Jason Mackey: He's tapered off, but I still think he's having his best season as a pro. These haven't been his best games, though. I think that's fair.
Bill: Any updates on injuries? Did Kuhn or Rowney practice today?
Jason Mackey: Here's the latest on injuries: http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/penguins/2018/02/08/Conor-Sheary-in...
Rose: Hi Jason just heard rumor Blueger will be the call up from WBS he's been great here I hope you get to interview him and have a story
Jason Mackey: I saw that, too. Good for him. Good kid. Will be interesting to see if he debuts Friday. I think he's earned it.
Scott: Nobody WINS going to see a Smashmouth concert...
Jason Mackey: Truer words have never been spoken.
Paul: What are your thoughts on David Desharnais as a fit for 4th line center? Good FO%, decent speed and hands. Smallish but could be cheaper to acquire than others.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I agree, Paul. I think that might be a reasonable add. Everything checks out, like you mentioned. I do think they would rather have Cullen, but if he's not available or they can't work something else out, DD is not a bad option to address fourth-line depth.
Benny D: Fleury’s return was quite the spectacle... outside of the playoffs, the closest comparison I can think of was Mario’s return from retirement. Were you at the game Jason and does that seem like a fair comparison? keep up the good work, thnx
Jason Mackey: I was not at that game, Benny. But I did get my driver's license that day. So I think it's fair to say that was a huge, huge day all-around for the city of Pittsburgh.
Alex: If Sullivan wins a third Stanley Cup in a row *knock on wood*, does that put him in the conversation for one of the “best coaches of all time”
Jason Mackey: It should. And we'll still get people here who think he's an idiot.
Benny D: the NHL is lousy at marketing their product... I find it unfathomable that Fleury’s return was not the nationally televised game; not to mention none of the Pens vs. Oilers games have been nationally televised since Connor McDavid came into the league. What gives?
Jason Mackey: You and me both. Totally agree. Said as much on Calgary radio. THAT is the kind of stuff you need to hook casual fans. Plus McDavid vs. Crosby, Matthews vs. Laine, etc. Show the best your product has to offer. Instead we're stuck with Buffalo vs. Detroit or some other barf-worthy game.
Hanrahan: Worst smelling Penguin?
Jason Mackey: It's team policy: Don't smell the players.
Chuck_in_DC: Is it hard to type with burger juice and fixings hitting your keyboard?
Jason Mackey: It is not. I finished my burger. Very good.
GUEST : Did you cry watching the Flower's emotional return Tuesday night?
Jason Mackey: I did not. But I was happy for the guy. Try to remain objective. It's hard when it's one of the nicest human beings and fun-loving people any of us has ever met.
Bill: Teddy Blueger reportedly coming up... he could suprise some people and make a case for full time job... thoughts?
Jason Mackey: I don't think he's a surprise. Gotta see what you have, right? I think he's earned it. Will he stick? Who knows. It could. Not likely, but he could.
yahooo!: You should head over to NOLA after the game and catch some Mardi Gras parades. You are too close to miss that action
Jason Mackey: No thanks. Early flight to St. Louis for practice on Saturday.
Titan for life: Was your Cullen guess in the 20 article based on anything more than just your opinion?
Jason Mackey: Yes.
MA: Why haven’t they called anyone up after the injuries in the Vegas game? Who’s going to be 4th line C?
Jason Mackey: It's likely Blueger. Sounds like he left Providence.
SZ in AZ: Here's a journalism question. Don't worry--I'm not going to ask you to dish on your former employer. You are someone who has worked in more traditional journalism (print with emerging online presence is how I would define that now) and in a strictly online, multimedia format. Which do you prefer? What are the advantages and disadvantages of both from the perspective of a writer?
Jason Mackey: Thank you for asking a professional, well-worded question about that stuff. One, I like newspapers. I'm probably a bit of an old soul, and maybe I'm stupid, but I like newspapers. I came to that conclusion at DKPittsburghSports.com. I also think there's a certain type of person who does well at sites like that ... and I'm not it. I like being a part of something bigger, like a newspaper, where you have entertainment and food writers, local crime reporters, etc. I think the whole operation is neat. As a writer, it's not too much different. DK, The Athletic and the Post-Gazette all trust the writers to good work, know their beats, etc. Deadline is a factor here, but I think we need to think beyond deadlines; hit them, sure, but also think web-first and be cognizant that most people read on their phones or tablets. So go back and re-write the FULL story instead of calling it a night at 11 p.m. or whenever your deadline is.
Erik: Derek Ryan would be a GREAT fit. Solid production, cheap, great possession guy
Jason Mackey: I wouldn't reject it. Could be interesting.
Robert SackmyMono: NO love this week?
Jason Mackey: I put it through.
Erik: Regarding Brassard, Sheary and a 2nd would make sense. OTT could retain a little money to facilitate the deal, just for this year.
Jason Mackey: Given the market, no way they'd have to do that.
Robert SackmyMono: Hi Jason!
Jason Mackey: Hi, Bob!
Mike: Is there any talk of the Pens signing Ryan Haggerty to an NHL contract before the trade deadline? If yes, would he have to clear waivers?
Jason Mackey: There's been no talk of that that I've heard, Mike. Would not have to clear waivers to go up.
Jason C: Do you think the Rangers would deal any players to the pens? And if so who would be a good fit? I like the idea of Grabner afortable has speed?
Jason Mackey: Love the idea of Grabner, and yes, I do. I think they're going into total rebuild mode, and when you do that, you don't care who gets your guys ... at least less than maybe Washington would. Only thing with Grabner, though, is he's not a center.
THE mackATTACK: Whats your favorite fast food on the road?
Jason Mackey: BBQ, hands down. Gonna get some tonight in Dallas, as a matter of fact. And seafood in Vancouver. Italian in NYC. Thank you for the non-hockey question. Love those.
Kris: Ok. I’ll give up the finger. Do we get Matt Cullen back?
Jason Mackey: I think so.
OHIO412FAN: Who are your best bargains (Third Line Center Speaking) the Pens could trade for? What about defensemen, should the Pens look for depth at that position as well?
Jason Mackey: I think they're OK on defense if they commit to keeping Ian Cole. Bargains ... hmm ... was just asked about him, but I think Derek Ryan could make sense. Maybe Desharnais, although probably more as a 4C. I don't think they do either.
Guest: how's the burger?
Jason Mackey: Terrific. All done. Angus beef, BBQ sauce, bacon, smoked gouda, some tobacco onions. Well done, Marriott restaurant.
Benny D: Not one of the NHL’s 100 greatest, seldom mentioned among the league’s elite (nationally), and even the local beat reporter, Mackey, picks Crosby to outscore him the rest of the way this season ;) Does the the lack of respect (relative to his accomplishments) motivate Geno or does he just tune it out like a professional?
Jason Mackey: Ha. Turning my answer into a criticism ... I like it. He uses it to motivate him, I'm sure. Although I'm not sure how much my answer in a chat contributed to that.
Erik: OTT would definitely do that in my opinion, PIT wouldn't and shouldn't.
Jason Mackey: Okey doke.
Erik: FYI - salary retention happens quite often to facilitate trades. The notion that "there isn't enough cap space" pending the money is relatively close, shouldn't matter.
Jason Mackey: We're not talking about close. We're talking about ~ $2 million dollars on a good, young player -- if I have the thread right -- who's reasonable.
guest: Does Crosby, Malkin, Kessel have much input with the coaches who they like /want to play with?
Jason Mackey: Some, but not all. Sullivan will listen, but all three understand it's the coach's call. They might not like it, either, but they do respect it.
FG: woukd vince trocheck be a name on the pens radar? Local product too, but would probably cost a lot.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, the cost would be high. On the radar, yes. Available, no. At least from everything I've heard.
Rich: How's that Marriott burger. that can't be a good thing.
Jason Mackey: It was a terrific thing. Bad experience with burgers at Marriotts?
guest: Hi Jason, just want to thank you for taking your personal time to do these chats as they are great! And also to let you know how much I enjoy your PG articles. Your sense of humor and perspective are great reads!!
Jason Mackey: Thank you very much! This is either my wife or one of my parents, I'm convinced of it.
Jared Werth : Any chance Sheary could be moved to open up cap space ?
Jason Mackey: I don't think so. Just not a lot of trade-able value there right now. So-so season, injury, not great defensively. Probably has greater value to the Penguins than other places.
Bill: Thoughts on Zach Aston Reese so far? Small sample definitely but future bottom 6 guy?
Jason Mackey: I've seen nothing discouraging. Do I think he's ready for prime-time right now? No. But he's a young guy, has shown some potential, a little physical at times, needs to be more assertive. A good player. Has more to work on.
Rich: Is the fatigue issue a real thing when you think about a third Cup... with the last two seasons being obviously a really long run? We hear a lot about that. What do the players think?
Jason Mackey: They think it's a load of BS. They're fine.
OHIO412FAN: Is it me, or is it that the Penguins are slowly building a plethora of talent in Wilkes Barre Scranton and a legit depth pool on the main roster? They seem to plug and play players at all positions at this time of the season. Will this depth and team coming together propel them to another cup?
Jason Mackey: Somewhat. They don't have a ton on the back end, and that's sort of an issue. But they do have a decent amount of young forwards, probably more depth than most people give them credit for.
Guest : Could the Wild trade Cullen to another team? Are they looking to trade him at all?
Jason Mackey: I think they would consider moving him. As I understand it, Pittsburgh is the only place he'd want to go.
CT: What’s the best part of being a sports writer for a specific team?
Jason Mackey: Well, I don't write for the specific team. I write for the Post-Gazette. Big, big difference there. I like the freedom it provides. I love learning things about people, reporting it out, then telling the story to yinz. I love the interaction with readers, going to cool places, the day-to-day grind of seeing the Penguins every day and finding new stuff to write about. Competing with other outlets. The fact that people care what I have to write or say about the team. A lot of stuff. I could go on and on.
CT: What’s your favorite away city that Pens play in? Where do you look forward to going?
Jason Mackey: Top five road cities would be, probably: Vancouver, Montreal, NYC, Washington, San Jose (for proximity to San Francisco).
Marc: Just getting here, sorry. Any Pens interest in Kruger, who is on waivers?
Jason Mackey: No, not that I've heard. He makes a lot of money.
GUEST : Heard you on 93.7 the Fan with Starkey and Mueller the last few weeks. You have a great rapport with them and the other on-air analysts. You think you can take Filliponi in a fight? Who's the biggest dude you fear there? Starkey, Mueller, Filliponi, Dunlap? None of the above?
Jason Mackey: Dunlap. He does CrossFit. Not Mueller or Poni. Definitely not Starkey. Thank you for listening!
NoParticipationTrophy: Going for the winner here - Reaves for Sundqvist ;-}}}
Jason Mackey: Just call a newie on the whole thing, huh?
FG: Man, Grabner would be a nice addition. Where would you slot him though?
Jason Mackey: Not sure. That's a tough one. Easier if he can play the left side. I don't know if he can or can't. Not a perfect fit.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it. Thanks, as always, for participating. I think we had a record number of questions this week. Honored that you chose to spend the time. Let's do this again in seven days.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.