Sidney Crosby is on just about every short list of the world’s finest hockey players.
Right at the top of many, for that matter.
But does that mean he was an All-Star during the first three months of the 2017-18 season?
That depends on what one believes an All-Star should be.
There’s no questioning Crosby’s credentials as an elite talent. It’s tough to argue with a matching set of Conn Smythe trophies as Most Valuable Player in the playoffs, two scoring titles and a pair of Hart trophies as regular-season MVP, among numerous other individual achievements.
And, oh yeah, captaining three Stanley Cup champions.
Read More
But even though Crosby is assured a place in the Hockey Hall of Fame someday — he could have begun crafting his acceptance speech years ago — should he have been a lock for a spot on the Metropolitan Division roster for the NHL’s All-Star weekend Jan. 27-28 in Tampa?
Probably not, based solely on the numbers from the first three months of the season.
On the day the balance of the four divisional rosters, as chosen by the league’s Hockey Operations department, was announced — the captain of each club had been picked earlier, by fan voting — Crosby was tied for 17th in scoring, with 43 points.
That left him six spots behind teammate Phil Kessel, who had 47 points and was widely regarded as the Penguins’ most effective player to that point, and well back of Philadelphia’s Jakub Voracek, who was tied for sixth in the league with 51.
Neither of those two made it onto the 11-man Metropolitan roster.
Crosby will be joined in Tampa by Penguins defenseman Kris Letang, who possesses Norris Trophy-caliber skills, but who was, to put it charitably, inconsistent through the first half of the season.
When the rosters were announced, Letang’s plus-minus rating of minus-13 was the second-worst among the 27 skaters who had dressed for the Penguins, and the 10th-worst among all NHL defensemen.
By comparison, Washington’s John Carlson was minus-2 and the second-leading scorer among NHL defensemen, with 34 points. He won’t be in the All-Star Game.
Mind you, Letang’s plus-minus wasn’t even close to the worst among defensemen selected as All-Stars.
That distinction belonged to Arizona’s Oliver Ekman-Larsson, whose minus-34 [yes, that was his plus-minus, not the predicted high temperature in Winnipeg] wasn’t sufficiently bloated to keep him off the Pacific Division squad.
And since that number wasn’t bad enough to get Ekman-Larsson the weekend off, it’s logical that Ottawa’s Erik Karlsson [minus-16 when the rosters were announced] is getting an all-expenses-paid trip to Tampa, too.
Now, filling out the All-Star rosters can be challenging, in part because every team must have at least one representative and players must compete for the division in which their franchise is based.
Get past those details and the most important criterion for getting into the game, at least when the league is doing the choosing, might be a player’s ability to lure TV viewers.
Selling tickets for All-Star games never is a problem — heck, host teams routinely use them to spur season-ticket sales — but attracting eyeballs is.
Letang, Karlsson and Ekman-Larsson are well-known by people who follow the game, and understandably so, given their career achievements. They surely will get some folks to tune in.
Crosby takes that concept to another level.
He’s one of the sport’s few figures with a chance of drawing casual fans — the kind who might identify Connor McDavid as a member of the European Ryder Cup squad — which means the league likely would have felt hard-pressed to justify allowing Crosby to spend All-Star weekend on a beach somewhere.
Regardless of how the numbers added up.
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.