Greetings, friends, to another edition of the Post-Gazette Penguins mailbag. As I write this, things are looking up for the local hockey club. They’ve won four games in a row — most recently against the Rangers on Sunday night — as they head out to the West Coast for their three-game California road trip. The superstars have come alive, as Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Phil Kessel have largely powered the recent wins, but the Penguins have truly started to get contributions from up and down their lineup. Dare I say it, they look like the old Penguins again.
As always, you can submit questions for this mailbag on Twitter @SWernerPG or via email at swerner@post-gazette.com.
Away we go...
Laura Craska Cooper: How long do you think the Guentzel-at-center experiment will last?
Sam: The simple answer is “until the Penguins have a better option,” but the full story is a bit more complicated than that.
The Penguins have made no secret they prefer Guentzel on the wing. Specifically, they would probably prefer him back on Sidney Crosby’s left wing. It was nice for Dominik Simon to get a goal Sunday, but, in a lot of ways, Simon is a poor man’s Guentzel. Hard not to think Mike Sullivan and Jim Rutherford have images of a Guentzel-Crosby-Sprong top line at some point over the next few months.
Read More
Anyways, back to Guentzel at center. The Penguins are in a bit of a tricky spot right now, though it’s really a good problem to have. They’re probably going to make a move for a new, full-time third-line center at some point over the coming weeks, but they’re also playing really well right now, and probably don’t want to mess up whatever they have going (hockey folks tend to be pretty superstitious in that way), which makes an imminent trade a bit less likely. So really, Rutherford has to weigh not wanting to screw up whatever the Penguins have going right now versus how much he wants to get Guentzel back to the wing.
The other complicating factor is that Guentzel has been pretty good as the third-line center. His offense has taken a bit of a hit (no points in the five games since he has moved to center), but it’s not for lack of trying; his shots per game is right around his season average.
But he has been good when it comes to doing third-line center things. He’s averaging 1:20 of penalty kill time in these five games and has won a respectable 47.2 percent of his faceoffs. He has also been really, really good defensively (which you maybe wouldn’t expect playing on a line with Phil Kessel and Conor Sheary). They spent a lot of the game matched up against the Rangers’ Vesey-Desharnais-Buchnevich line and completely shut them down. Sheary and Guentzel were tied for the fewest Corsi Against by a Penguins forward Sunday night with two.
I asked Sullivan last week if Guentzel plays any differently at center than he does at wing, and here’s his full response:
“I don’t think it’s different. I think Jake’s the player that he is. He’s a cerebral player, he sees the ice pretty well. He’s pretty solid at both ends of the rink. He makes pretty good decisions with the puck, he has good awareness. I think the challenge at the center ice position is it’s a little bit more demanding because you’re being asked to play goal line to goal line, and so there are certain defensive responsibilities that are associated with the center ice position that can be more demanding, physically and other wise. Jake’s game is Jake’s game, whether he play the wing or he plays center. He’s going to bring his strengths to that position.”
It’s telling that Sullivan references Guentzel’s hockey IQ, and that’s really probably what allows him to adapt to both positions relatively seamlessly.
So, overall, I don’t get the sense Guentzel’s success as the third-line center has changed their long-term plan to have him on the wing, but it’s a heck of a stop-gap measure until they add someone else.
Nancy S: Which player currently on the roster will be with the Penguins the longest? It’s easy to say Sid, but could some of the younger guys outlast him.
Sam: Interesting question. Crosby is certainly the safest bet to finish his career in Pittsburgh, obviously, but he’s already 30. He turns 38 the summer after his current contract expires (2025) so let’s just say that’ll be when he calls it a career. Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang are around the same age, so they’ll probably be hanging it up around then, too.
The question, to oversimplify it, is will any players on the current roster be on the 2025-26 Penguins roster. The three guys that stand out to me as having the best chances are Matt Murray, Olli Maatta and Jake Guentzel, all of whom will be turning 31 in 2025 and have the potential of being a franchise cornerstone kind of guy. I guess you could throw Tristan Jarry in the mix, too, since he’s even younger. Daniel Sprong has a shot too, since he’s not even 21 yet.
Of that group, I’d probably put my money on Guentzel to be here the longest. He’s a restricted free agent in 2019, and at that point I’d expect the Penguins to lock him up relatively long-term. The other guys all have contract expirations at some point in the next five years which give them potential exit points.
Bill B.: What’s going on with Ian Cole? Are you surprised he hasn’t been traded yet?
Sam: To be frank, yes. If you had asked me in late November/early December if Cole would still be a Penguin on Jan. 16, I would’ve said no way. But the Penguins got hit with a rash of injuries along the blue line and he was called back into duty.
Now, though, they’re finally (almost) completely healthy — Chad Ruhwedel should be back soon — which reopens the door for a Cole trade. The problem is finding a trade that meets the Penguins’ needs and gives them fair value for Cole. He’s on the outs in Pittsburgh right now, but he’s still a more-than-capable NHL defenseman, and Rutherford isn’t going to trade him just for the sake of trading him.
It does seem all but certain the Penguins will make some sort of move within the next few weeks, and I would be surprised if Cole wasn’t a part of it.
Gregg Lorenz: When Seattle or Houston join the NHL in 2/3 years, will the rules for protected lists be the same? It seems Las Vegas became a Cup contender on the first day of their existence, as the rest of the NHL’s franchises became weaker. Was that a good idea?
Sam: The Vegas thing seems to have been just a totally perfect storm. They got some good players in the draft, took advantage of other GMs way overthinking things and (this part always seems to be underrated) got a better coach than an expansion team really has any right to in Gerard Gallant.
But remember, even coming out of the expansion draft, a lot of really smart hockey people thought the Golden Knights were going to be dreadful this season. Their roster, while certainly better than most expansion teams, wasn’t one you looked at in September and said, “Yep. Cup contender.”
The Golden Knights are the best story in hockey, and I think the NHL is probably over-the-moon about how this has played out. So yes, I would fully expect them to follow the same rules for any Seattle/Houston expansion draft down the road. Maybe that team doesn’t totally strike gold the way Vegas has, but they should be able to at least put a competitive team on the ice, which is really what’s best for the league and sport.
Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.