General manager Jim Rutherford has watched his 2017-18 Penguins play 44 games.
He has seen some stuff he has liked.
He also has been underwhelmed at times.
As this group will rest for five days because of its NHL-mandated bye week, and many around the hockey world are basically assuming that one of the NHL’s itchiest trigger fingers will swing a deal, Rutherford appears to be moving in the opposite direction.
“I’m not going to say publicly everything that I know and what I feel about how we’ve lost some games, but I think I have a pretty good handle on it,” Rutherford told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette over the weekend. “Some of the things that I see, I don’t believe changing player personnel is going to do it. As a group, we have to be more consistent and do what we do best.”
2. Is Rutherford to be believed here, or is he bluffing? We may never know.
Read More
A couple factors are at play in a potential deal.
One, assets. What, realistically, do the Penguins have? Ian Cole would qualify, but what else? Carl Hagelin has eight goals in his past 104 games on a $4-million-a-year contract. Conor Sheary has scored three times in his past 24, despite seeing plenty of top-six minutes. Olli Maatta is 23, has been the Penguins’ best defenseman and makes a little more than $4 million. You keep those guys; you don’t trade them.
What about Daniel Sprong — let’s assume the Penguins would even be willing to part with him at this point — and some premium picks? OK, maybe. But a legitimate third-line center is going to bring with him a legitimate contract. Making the money work will be hard, if not impossible.
The Penguins aren’t trading Kris Letang. It’s also hard to imagine them parting with Tristan Jarry given Matt Murray’s injury history — even if they have been fluky.
Rutherford might not have another option besides sitting this one out, but obviously a few phone calls could change everything.
3. Another factor at play here is external.
There’s a ton of parity in the league right now, and hardly anybody wants to admit they’re sellers. Thus, either prices are insanely high, players are downright unavailable or both.
“I don’t have a good read on the market right now as to predict when something’s going to happen,” Rutherford said. “Certainly we’re in the mix here, talking to as many teams as we can, seeing who’s available and seeing if there’s anybody out there who can give us a better chance to win.”
“In the mix” is a term Rutherford uses often. It does not mean something is imminent. It simply means they’re monitoring the situation.
4. Jake Guentzel’s future with the Penguins remains at wing. But by giving the Penguins a competitive split at center while Carter Rowney’s out with an upper-body injury, Guentzel has enabled Rutherford to avoid paying through the nose for a center.
“We’re fortunate to have a two-position player, or I would have had to move a lot quicker on trying to get another center,” Rutherford said. “He’s capable of playing there. We’ll see how it shakes out here in the next little while.”
5. When the Penguins shifted Riley Sheahan into Rowney’s fourth-line spot last Tuesday in Philadelphia, the results were dramatic. Sheahan was tremendous, along with linemates Tom Kuhnhackl and Ryan Reaves, who both scored.
Does Sheahan’s comfortability as a fourth-line center perhaps change Rutherford’s thinking when it comes to the search for a third-line guy?
Not really, Rutherford said. They’ve been happy with Sheahan there. It’s more the overall production of the line that’s been lacking.
“I think he’s played well in the three hole, but it’s the production of the whole line, which becomes important,” Rutherford said. “You don’t need as much production from the fourth line. When you get it, it’s a bonus … if you’re getting it from your top nine. Overall, I believe [Sheahan] has played well. We’d just like a little more production from him. I can say the same about 2-3 other guys.”
6. Two or three others guys, huh?
Hagelin is a given. Sheary had 18 goals through 44 games a season ago but has dropped to 11 this season. Although he’s hurt, Bryan Rust has four goals in 38 games. He had 10 through 38 in 2016-17.
It’s somewhat unfair to expect substantive goal totals from Kuhnhackl, Rowney and Reaves, who are never, ever top-six options, but the other three have given the Penguins ample reason to expect more.
7. Rutherford has been encouraged by what he’s seen lately out of his team.
You may have heard, and will continue to hear, the Penguins talk about “sticking with the game.” Coach Mike Sullivan hit the talking point hard before and after a 4-0 win in Brooklyn on Friday. Rutherford did the same over the phone the next day.
The Cliff Notes version is this: When things don’t work out early, the Penguins need not get frustrated. They also can’t count on simply outscoring teams.
Here’s Rutherford explaining some of what he’s talking about:
“When you win a championship or you win a couple of championships, the natural feeling is you’re going to be able to turn it on at certain times in games and win those games,” Rutherford said. “Our team is good enough to do that periodically, but not on a consistent basis.
“Understanding how to win is what I’m alluding to. Sticking with the game. Whether the game’s going good or whether it’s going bad, you have to stick to it and play the game.
“If we get to the point in games where we start to cheat, or we think we can start to blow a team out, then it’s going to be difficult to do. The teams now in this league are just too close. All the teams are good. Even though you’re the champions, you can’t do that.”
8. “Sometimes I think it’s easy to forget how difficult it is to win.”
That was Sullivan after the Islanders win, and it struck me.
How in the world do you forget how to win?
But think about it this way: Say you do something over and over at work, and the majority of time do it really well. It may have even won you a few awards, brought about a raise or a promotion.
It’s probably more frustrating whenever you’re having a tough time performing that task, the emotions are quicker to take over and they’re more dramatic once they do. You should be better, right?
Posed that question to Sheary and thought his answer was tremendously insightful:
“You do think about it a little bit more,” Sheary said. “You think of how you had so much success and what it took to get to that point. When things aren’t going right, it can be hard to find that again.”
9. One last quote on this — back to Rutherford, who maintains that all of this was somewhat expected.
“Ups and downs aren’t easy when you’ve been to the top of the mountain two years in a row and when we have a team that hasn’t generated as many points as we’d all expect,” Rutherford said. “But that doesn’t mean this team won’t. We all recognize what these players have gone through over the past couple of years. It can be frustrating at times. When you sit back and think about it, it’s not a total surprise.”
10. Matt Murray has not had the start to his season that he would’ve wanted. He’d be the first one to tell you that.
As far as any organizational concern … yeah, no, there’s none of that from anyone. Murray and Rutherford are incredibly close, so much so that Rutherford bear-hugged Murray outside of the team bus in Nashville after Murray backstopped the Penguins to a second consecutive Stanley Cup.
“I don’t have any concern,” Rutherford said. “He’s a proven guy. He’s won two Stanley Cups for us. I would suspect there’s been a bit of an adjustment with the fact that he doesn’t have a veteran guy with him as a partner. We all recognize that he’s got more to give. I don’t have any concerns.”
11. The Penguins player development department deserves a ton of credit for how good Daniel Sprong has looked. If anything, you could argue they waited too long to promote him — but you’d rather have it that way than the other.
“I think what we did with him was important,” Rutherford said. “He got to play there a half season in the minors, get his confidence and come in here ready to go. He’s done it. [Dominik] Simon’s done it. It’s been good for both of those guys.”
12. Moving on, let’s talk about Patric Hornqvist. There’s nothing new on a potential extension, Rutherford said.
“Hasn’t been any movement,” he said.
Have to think Hornqvist is going to go to market and see what he can get. It won’t be a small contract.
13. Here’s an interesting wrinkle: What if Sprong is for real? You probably don’t need him and Phil Kessel — similar players, which we’ll get to — on your team. Kessel could well be coming off a career-best year, meaning the Penguins could sell high.
If the Penguins were interested in moving Kessel, and felt like they could proceed with Sprong providing a much cheaper replacement, it’s hard to see Hornqvist going anywhere. The money then becomes available. Pay him market rate and let him retire here.
14. Anytime Hornqvist is asked about playing with Sidney Crosby or Evgeni Malkin, he always repeats that he doesn’t change his game.
At some point, though, Hornqvist had to change his game, right?
I asked Hornqvist in Philly when that was for him.
“I had to get used to the small rink [in North America],” Hornqvist said. “When you play back home [in Sweden], there’s so much more space. There’s not as much of a net-front presence back home.
“I knew I had to change when I got over here. Since that day, I’ve tried to be the same.”
15. How good has Kessel been on the power play? Could watch him with the puck on endless loop, really.
Entering Monday’s games, Kessel led the NHL in power-play points (27) and power-play assists (20).
One of the many things that makes Kessel so dangerous is the pass-shoot threat. No matter what a penalty kill tries to do, Kessel can go the other route. It’s nearly impossible to successfully defend.
“He’s so calm with the puck, Hornqvist said. “He’s actually a passer out there, but he shoots it better than anybody in the league. So when he gets a chance to shoot it, he usually scores. He always looks to pass it first. That’s usually what opens up Sid and Geno on the backdoor.
“When he decides to shoot it, he can score from so far out on a wrister. Usually you see a one-time shot from there. He likes to hold onto it and shoot it. He’s been great for us making plays. He’s so calm. I think those two things are really important for him.”
16. Hope Malkin is OK.
He didn’t talk after Sunday’s win, when he scored two goals, including the overtime winner. That’s unlike Malkin or the Penguins.
His equipment was scattered in front of his stall — normally it’s put away — and as reporters gathered around, Kris Letang yelled out, “Something happened” and informed us that Malkin would not be talking.
Was certainly strange, but it also doesn’t mean anything serious. We’ll see.
17. Don’t understand for a second playing Matt Hunwick over Ian Cole. Hunwick has been minus in five of his past six games, minus-8 total.
I also like Justin Schultz a lot better with Cole versus Olli Maatta, who has actually been very pretty decent with Jamie Oleksiak.
Cole loves Pittsburgh. Loves his teammates, especially. But you have to think being a healthy scratch five times, and on three occasions, since Nov. 24, is starting to wear on one of the Penguins’ most positive players.
18. Mentioned above that Sprong and Kessel are very similar players. They might possess two of the best five pure shots in the NHL right now.
They’re also underrated playmakers — somehow this still feels like an under-appreciated aspect of Kessel’s game — and darn smart hockey players.
“That’s a pretty big compliment,” Sprong said when I suggested the Kessel comparison. “He’s a great player, has a great shot, he’s fast. He’s one of the best shooters in the game. I’m pretty honored to be compared to Phil, but I just try to play my own game and stick to what I know works best for me and just go from there.”
19. Have you looked at Sprong’s stick lately?
He has tape on the toe of it, almost like a boot. Wasn’t that way during Sprong’s first NHL stint. He said he changed it while screwing around with his equipment when he was sidelined with a shoulder injury.
“When I was injured last year, I had so much time off. I tried different things, different tape,” Sprong said. “I like this way the best. I don’t know why. It just feels good on the stick.”
20. Get the sense that Crosby really likes his new linemates, Simon and Sprong. For their speed and smarts, yes, but also how eager they are to learn.
“When a guy comes in with that urgency, you can’t replace that,” Crosby said. “I’m not getting any faster, either. It helps to have young speed, young legs.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.