There are many theories as to why the Penguins have been so inconsistent this season and they all seem to be at least somewhat valid. The Penguins have looked mentally and physically fatigued at times.  The roster certainly has a few shortcomings, specifically a third center and at least one defenseman. And the team’s stars have not played to their capabilities for too many chunks of the season.

All of that doesn’t seem to add up to a third Stanley Cup. Yes, there is enough time for the Penguins to recover, but the season is more than half over. There are definitely a few changes to the roster that need to be made as it isn’t good enough as constituted.

That doesn’t mean there aren’t some signs that the Penguins can turn things around, and most of them were on display Sunday in the Penguins’ thrilling 6-5 win against the Bruins.

The Penguins have not gotten enough from Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin, and Matt Murray has been wildly inconsistent. Kris Letang has just not been close to the player he should be. But in the past two games — wins against the Islanders and Bruins — we’ve seen that when Crosby and Malkin are at the top of their game, they are still the best duo in the NHL. Crosby has seven points in two games, and Malkin has four.

Advertise with us

Murray has been a bit streaky in his career. His inconsistency should not be surprising, but when he is on, he is as good as any goaltender in the league. There were some rumblings of a brewing goaltender controversy as Tristan Jarry was outplaying him and earned a few extra starts lately. Sunday against the Bruins, though, Murray saved the day as Jarry gave up five goals. Murray replaced him in the second period and shut the Bruins out. His signature moment came with about a minute left with the score tied when he stopped a penalty shot by Brad Marchand. That enabled the Penguins to get to overtime and win.

If the stars play well, and if Murray finds his game, the Penguins are still one of the best teams in hockey. They are not the best, though, and that is where the genius of Jim Rutherford comes in. The Penguins don’t need a major overhaul, but they do need a little bit of a face lift. Rutherford has been a master of making the right moves the past two seasons, and there is no reason to believe he won’t perform his magic and change the roster for the better.

The other reason to believe the Penguins will make a run is Mike Sullivan. He is the best coach in the NHL right now. Like Rutherford, Sullivan seems to have a magic touch when it comes to making personnel decisions and changes. Sullivan has changed the line combinations a number of times in recent weeks in order to find a spark.

His latest moves seem to be paying off in a big way as he moved youngsters Daniel Sprong and Dominik Simon to the first line with Crosby. That has paid immediate dividends, as has Sullivan moving Phil Kessel and Conor Sheary to the third line to play alongside the newest third-line center, Jake Guentzel. The Penguins have scored 10 goals in two games, which is a bad sign for the rest of the league.

“[Sprong and Simon] are quick,” Crosby said. “And that energy and excitement, that urgency is there. We need that every night, and we have found that a bit, but those two certainly bring that.”

Advertise with us

Sullivan may have even gotten Murray going by giving Jarry more starts. Competition is an incredibly powerful motivator. The idea that everybody must earn his job every day is too. As long as Sullivan is in charge, nobody on that roster should feel comfortable when they aren’t playing well because he has proven he isn’t afraid to make moves.

The Penguins have a long way to go to convince anyone they are a Stanley Cup contender. They have to string together a lot more games than two before it’s time to declare they are turning it around. The reality, though, is that as long as Sullivan and Rutherford are in charge and Crosby, Malkin, Letang and Murray are healthy, there is reason to believe the Penguins will be a major factor in the playoffs again.