Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Greetings from the North Shore. Let's do this, then I'm going to get on my way to snowy Brooklyn. (Well, sort of. But that direction.)

Guest: Jason, why is no one blaming our goal tending for the position we are in. They just aren' t making the saves as last year,would like to hear your take.

Jason Mackey: My thoughts would be that, no, they aren't making as many saves. Looking at their 5v5 SV%. It was .927 last year. It's .903 this season. That's a significant drop. ... Do I think that's gonna hold? No, I don't. Murray is a lot better than he's shown, and it's somewhat skewed by some early-season blowouts. But I think there are many more issues than just goaltending that have led to a frustrating first 41 games.

Guest: Jason, do the Pens really have the disposable assets to trade for a more offensive 3C and move Sheahan to 4C? With all the defensemen injured, they can't really afford to move Cole now. JR doesn't want to move an unprotected (lottery) first round pick. Sprong has looked good so far and is cheap. No other GM wants to take on Hagelin's salary. Is there really a move out there that JR can make that would improve the team?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: You're bringing up a very good point. I'm starting to have my doubts. (Because, if there was, wouldn't Jim have done it by now?) You could counter by dangling Conor Sheary, but I'm not sure if teams are stumbling all over themselves to get a guy who -- let's be honest -- is a bit undersized, has three goals in 21 games or something similar and has gone through some significant slumps recently. The easiest fix might be for Guentzel to work out in that 3C spot.

Jason Mackey: For anyone who hasn't seen it, this is the reference: "8. Quote of the Week, from an anonymous GM: “God, I hope no one helps Pittsburgh get better.” I think he’s tired of seeing them win." ... My thoughts: This is hardly surprising given who we're dealing with. But do I blame them? Not really. They're humans. Who wants to see the same team or person win everything all the time?

Guest: What do you make of the "anonymous GM" comment in Friedman's 31 Thoughts saying that he hopes other teams won't go out of their way to help the Pens by trading them players?

Guest: Do you think Sullivan with all his line shuffling has been part of the problem this year? Do you think there are any changes Sullivan can and should make to the way the Pens play that would help the team pick up more wins? For example, since they appear to be much slower now than many other teams, perhaps they should play a trap in the neutral zone and/or a more conservative defensive system?

Jason Mackey: Mike Sullivan has been the furthest thing from a problem for this team. Could he have a little more patience with his lines? Probably. But he's trying to affect change. Hard to crush a guy for that or to spin that into being the issue. And no, absolutely not on your second point. Please, God, no trap, no being more conservative. You think Crosby, Malkin, Kessel and Letang want to play a more conservative game? Mike Johnston tried it. How did that work out?

Advertise with us

Joe: Sid looks slow out there, without his usual burst. Has anyone discussed his playing weight with him? It looked to me like he bulked up a little over the off season likely to withstand the punishment of he season, but it may be affecting his speed. Do you think he should take off some weight, as Ovie did, to improve himself performance?

Jason Mackey: I see Sid every day, in person. If he gained weight, it's nominal, hardly an issue in his performance. I thought Crosby was terrific against Philly. I'll agree, he's had his head-scratchers, but hardly alone in that regard. And it's sure not because he's fat or too muscular or whatever you're suggesting.

OHIO412FAN: Jason, could we finally be seeing this team coming out of it’s dark phase? It seems to me that the roster atonement and alterations are working slowly and surely in place with getting Letang and Murray back, as well as calling up Simon and Sprong. What do you think this team needs to do to get hot?

Jason Mackey: Couple things. And I think you're right. One, to get some bounces the way they did against Philly. Were that as good as 5-1? Probably not. But they got some puck luck. They've had nothing even close this season. Two, they need better goaltending. They got it against Philly. Three, they need scoring from more places. Whether it's the fourth line or Sprong, someone or something needs to consistently help Crosby, Malkin and the big boys.

OHIO412FAN: Looking back on that dreadful 2017 part of season, what really went wrong with this team? Any close up analysis or scoop on the inconsistency and frustration? What do you think went wrong? Like lack of scoring, PK, PP, etc?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Ha. No scoop here. Generally don't save the scoops to bury in my chat. But I think what you saw was a combination of subpar performance from notable players (Letang, Murray and, to a lesser degree, Crosby) combined with a brutal schedule, a little bit of hangover and some incredibly bad luck.

Jason Mackey: On the ice, they struggled with several parts of their game (PK, rush chances, puck management) in not small ways, to the point where they became even more pronounced because of the other stuff.

OHIO412FAN: This team is known for being closers and finishing strong. After talking with other fellow Yinzers, they say they are not worried since they know the Pens always find a way. What’s your take?

Jason Mackey: I think they'll make the playoffs. I think they'll turn it around. Will they threepeat? I'm a little scared to go there. It's been a lot of hockey, and Tampa looks really good. But I do think they'll be much better over the final 41 games.

HB: I thought Sheahan looked really good with the fourth line wingers so that trade for another 3rd line center could really help the scoring.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: It could. I like Sheahan a lot as a 4C. Maybe Guentzel's the answer, who knows? But, yeah, I would try and keep Sheahan in the No. 4 spot and try to get more offense -- however you can -- on the third line.

HB: This might be a dumb question but is there any concern with the medical staff seems we lead the league every year with games lost to injured?

Jason Mackey: Nope. They've addressed it some, but I wouldn't say "concern." They're confident with how they do things and view a lot of this stuff as unpreventable. Can't say I disagree, honestly.

HB: Especially after rowney went down I notice the pens used Crosby a lot with his wingers and guentzal and sprong you think we see more of the double shifting even with 4 healthy centers?

Jason Mackey: I would avoid double-shifting guys at all costs. With all the hockey this team has played over the past two-plus years, I don't think it's the best way of doing business, if you can avoid it.

Advertise with us

HB: Bad time for this question after the 4th lines great game but I felt in the pass two years Sullivan would run all 4 lines consistently even if they were losing, is that right or I’m I over romanticizing the past two years?

Jason Mackey: No, that's fair. But that's because past fourth lines have been more of a threat to score.

ProcolHarum: I think Ryan Reaves' off ice contributions to the team are of more value than his on ice work. I also don't feel that's a good reason to keep playing him. What do you think?

Jason Mackey: Whiter Shade of Pale, huh? ... I'm not sure what you're suggesting, but if it's to sit Ryan Reaves and have him be some sort of cheerleader, that's not going to happen. Feel free to clarify.

DrColg8: Am I the only one being driven mad by Malkin's pterodactyl with a full belly skating and him being a turnover machine? He's got goals, sure but his game stinks. Also, playing zero forechecking style allows opponents too much time to cream players like Jake. When will they watch tapes of how they won last year and start making it hard to play the Pittsburgh Penguins?? We gotta hit so we can score. Thanks Jas

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: This is the first time you've noticed Malkin is prone to the odd stupid turnover and doesn't forecheck a ton?

guest: There seem to be so many issues this year, at what point do they say the team just does not have it this year and that the off season signings or lack of signings (Kunitz, Daley) were not good and have hurt this team beyond repair?

Jason Mackey: It has to get a lot worse than this, trust me. I think they feel they found something against Philly, but you bring up a good point. At some point, if things don't improve, they do have to realize when to cut bait. That's not now, though.

Bill: Do you think the Penguins will actually make it *two* wins in a row tonight? Dare to dream!

Jason Mackey: One my favorite lines in Juno: "Whoa, dream big!" (And don't you dare make fun of me for liking that movie.)

Advertise with us

Dave: While Murray has been anointed as the number one goalie, he also appears to be the second coming of Beau Bennett (read the team has to hold its collective breath every time he laces up his skates for fear he might pull something or tweak something and go down for an extended period). At what point does management have to look at his ability to be able to only play a small percentage of what a number one goalie is expected to play? And yes, I know he is young and he has 2 cups and this is his first year as a number 1, blah blah, blah...but come on now he really needs to prove he is a legitimate number 1.

Jason Mackey: Sounds like you need to take a deep breathe, Dave. ... I don't think Murray needs to prove he's a No. 1 goaltender; I think he needs to prove he can stay healthy. Nobody in their right mind should question his ability when he's in there. I know he hasn't played great, but the kid has never ended an NHL season with anything other than a Stanley Cup. That's pretty good. ... I also don't know what they could do to address some of the stuff he's incurred. There aren't many goalies who could withstand that Voracek play and be fine.

Matt: I know we signed Hunwick this past summer, but is it possible he is on the trade block now? Considering he was a scratch the other night and presumably would have been tonight had dumo not been injured.

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think if the Penguins got something they liked, they could move him. He can't play the right side, simple as that. With Dumo and Olli, there's only one job open there, and that probably means you have to scratch Cole. If both are healthy, right now, I'm taking Cole 100 times out of 100.

Joe: Does it make sense for JR to trade away future assets when he doesn't even know if this team will make the playoffs?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: No, it doesn't. But there's no guarantee that says they won't. They have a chance to win now. Simple as that. Rutherford isn't in the business of punting on seasons, nor do the Penguins want him to be.

Patrick: Any chance the Pens are interested in sending a package to OTT for Hoffman? There’s been mention of it in the media and I think he’d be a good fit

Jason Mackey: What would that package be, Patrick? Hoffman is 28. He's scored 26, 29 and 27 goals the past three seasons. He makes $5,187,500. Ottawa isn't going to give him away. One, you have to send out enough money to fit him. Two, you have to give up attractive assets, and Carl Hagelin is not that right now. I just don't see any way it would work.

Joe: Why can't the pens top 6 score 5 on 5 goals?

Jason Mackey: It's a heck of a question. If I had some sort of magic answer, I would sell it for money, believe me. Some of it is bad luck. Sometimes it's types of shots, a willingness to go down low, etc.

Advertise with us

Dave: It seems Sergei Gonchar is to hockey what Ray Searage is to baseball. Do you think that position coaches at the professional level really have that much impact on a players game? What really could Oleksiak have learned in 2 weeks?

Jason Mackey: A lot, honestly. And sometimes with these guys -- Oleksiak is one -- it's all mental. What a new staff thinks of you. What a new system looks like. ... Gonchar is really good. I think he'll fix Oleksiak. It's something just taking a new approach to something and working on the weak spots of your game with a fresh set of eyes.

Mackie: Is 3rd line Center the true need for the Penguins? Or is it just to have 3 scoring lines? As wingers are more commonly available and cheaper to acquire, wouln't adding a scoring winger balance out the forward depth just as well as a center?

Jason Mackey: Three scoring lines is what they want, but it usually requires a center with some semblance of offense. I like Riley Sheahan, but he's somewhat limited in that regard.

Steven: As per Craig Custance in the Athletic, Anthony Duclair has asked for a trade out of Arizona. Do the Pens have any interest in acquiring him to your knowledge or is this a recent revelation?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Not to my knowledge.

JT: Thoughts on what it would take to get Evander Kane? Botterill knows our prospects more than anyone and surely has his favorites, no? And do you think he is enough of a playmaker to mesh with Sid?

Jason Mackey: Probably more than the Penguins have. Cole, Sheary plus something? I don't think it's workable, nor do I think it is to their benefit, given some of what I've seen about Kane the person. Doesn't strike me as a Sully sort of player.

RandomHockeyGuy: Will lack of high-end assets prevent the Penguins from making a substantial trade? Cole, Hagelin, and possibly Sheary seem like the only pieces on the current roster they may be open to moving. Sprong and Jarry are really the only top prospects they have. Anything I am missing beyond those pieces and picks that other teams are going to ask for in any potential trade?

Jason Mackey: No, you're pretty much on. The only thing you probably forgot is Ian Cole. The Penguins don't really have many assets, unless they want to do something nuclear and, say, trade Phil. I don't think they're going to do that, but it would open up a lot of space cap-wise and put on the market a player other teams would theoretically wany.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: want*

ben: weve heard about hagelin, sheary, and cole as trade bait....any off the radar roster player u think could get moved?

Jason Mackey: I've said Kuhnhackl a couple times. I think he's a tremendous player who might bring something more to a team with a little more opportunity for him.

Geoff: Do you think GMJR was planning on Vegas as his fallback to get the 3rd line C? How big of a wrench has their success thrown into teams around the league??

Jason Mackey: I wouldn't call it a fallback, but do I think those are guys Jim had identified who might not be available now? Yeah, probably. Guessing it's that way for a lot of teams, but they're not the only third-line centers in the league.

Advertise with us

Eric: Why is everyone (fans and media) in such a hurry to move Sheary? Just signed a new contract this offseason. His numbers are down this season, but aren't everyones?

Jason Mackey: A little bit. I think one of the reasons, Eric, is because he's one of the few attractive assets the Penguins could move, get something for and still cover with depth -- I.e. they have a few young and talented forwards.

Wade D.: With total hindsight, would you have kept Fleury and traded Murray this offseason? Murray isn't much cheaper than Fleury now and he is not showing good signs of a workhorse starter. But this question is more about the kings ransom that Murray would have fetched in a trade. It would have filled some roster holes and infused at least one top prospect/pick into the system. Plus we know Fleury/Jarry would be a more than adequate goalie tandem throughout 87/71 primes.

Jason Mackey: Absolutely not. I think the world of Fleury, but you have a two-time Cup-winning goaltender who's 23 and makes $2 million less ($5.75 compared to $3.75 million). You keep him every time. ... This is only being asked because Murray has struggled some, and you can't think like that as a GM. They made the smartest move they could at the time. ... Go the other way, if Fleury would look God awful in Vegas, would we be rethinking the "king's ransom" that Murray could have fetched? Probably not.

mark: What do you think about Anthony Duclair as a reclamation project trade?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: That's not the type of player they need. I'm sure he'd be fine, but he doesn't address their needs.

Sean: If the team starts winning games, do you see a reason to make a major move?? The team looks pretty good on paper especially with Sheahan on the 4th line now,

Jason Mackey: No, I don't. Likely neither does Rutherford. So long as they're getting scoring from their third line. That has always been his preference. GM's would much rather just have their guys play really well, so they can sit back and watch. Never happens, but they'd like it to.

JAGR68: Am I comin back?

Jason Mackey: I wish, Jags.

Advertise with us

Ellen: 2 successful Stanley Cup runs - and more hockey than any other team in the NHL - over the last 2 seasons must be incredibly draining. I know the Penguins are pushing for a threepeat and goodness knows if anyone can do it, it's them - but do you think the team's elite would actually benefit more in the long run from a season where they aren't in contention? They can't exactly take a sabbatical, after all.

Jason Mackey: I don't think so, Ellen. These guys are what they are because they want to do this every year. You couldn't tell me Sidney Crosby would say, 'Nah, let's just be OK this year, miss out and go get 'em next year.' It would probably help their legs, sure, but nobody wants it.

Jtown: Do you think Rutherford is realizing no team with center depth is willing to trade with and make the two time defending champs better? Teams without depth are not going to trade there top 2 centers, they don’t grow on trees. Should have signed Bonino.

Jason Mackey: Should have signed Bonino for $4 million over four? No thanks. And it's not so much about making the two-time champs better. It's about making your own team better. Can the Penguins offer players who would make another team better? I have my doubts.

Jason Mackey: What's up, Jason?

Jason Mackey: Howdy, self.

Tom Brady: I feel these next two games are critical where the Pens need to get at least three points if they want to get back in this thing. Do they roll the dice and bring up a few additional WBSers to see what they got?

Jason Mackey: No. Absolutely not. Play the guys who won in Philly, fill in the blank spaces and hope to do it again. It's not like if they call up Teddy Blueger they're going to get spotted a two-goal lead.

Jennifer Aniston: Do you think Sid is injured or maybe dissatisfied with the coaching/shuffling of linemates? He just seems off this year.

Jason Mackey: No on all accounts, and I asked him directly about the last one. ... I think he's getting frustrated a bit because he's not converting at his normal clip. There's probably more to the linemate thing than he's letting on, but I don't think it's played a huge factor.

Jack be Nimble: Do you still think Pens make playoffs?

Jason Mackey: Yes, I do.

BennyD: In past chats you have suggested the timing wasn’t good for a Kessel trade because his value wasn’t high enough— if that’s the case wouldn’t now be the ideal time to cash in on his hot streak this season? In order to make a substantial difference in a trade the Pens will need to give up some value to get some in return. Thoughts?

Jason Mackey: I agree with you. The question you now have to ask is, "Is it the right time to trade the guy who has been our best player?" And, also, "How will our guys respond to that?" ... But in terms of what I said about his value, now would be the time to do it, to maximize return. Plus, looks to me like Sprong can fill that role just fine.

Foghorn Leghorn: Boy, I say, boy, it's sooooooooo cold out there my gibblets are frozen solid. What dy'all think the Pens will do this month as far as record, my good man?

Jason Mackey: They play 12 games in January. I think they'll win at least seven.

Doley: What did you see from Guentzel during his (very) limited time at center earlier this season?

Jason Mackey: I've liked it a lot. He looks very natural. I think it might be something to benefit him, too. It would be a non-traditional construction for a third line, but I definitely think it could work. ... Smart player, active defensively, excellent passer. ... Interested to see how much he's able to set up Sprong tonight.

Mike Sullivan: Mackey, I need some advice. Do I stop the constant line shuffling, or do I keep mixing it up like cake batter in a blender?

Jason Mackey: Put down the blender, Mike.

dave: If the team is not higher in the standings at the trade deadline, do you think GMJR would consider this a lost season and refrain from making any trades?

Jason Mackey: Yes, I do. At some point you need to call a spade a spade and don't throw good money after bad. (How's that for a combined cliche?) If they're significantly out of it by the trade deadline, I think GMJR would hold pat.

guest: what are you wearing for 70s night tonight? I am going to my first game tonight and hope to see you in a fine outfit!

Jason Mackey: Ha. I'm not going tonight. I'm driving to Brooklyn for the game tomorrow, giving myself some extra time because of the snowstorm.

Mike in Kennedy: It appears Pens can no longer out-speed most teams. Stars Crosby and Letang are disappointingly deep in minus territory. A significant shakeup of some type is necessary to get them going. Can't fire the coach. Big trade may not be possible. How about a system change? Try trapping and scoring on turnovers. Maybe not so exciting, but neither is losing. Worked for Jersey.

Jason Mackey: Jersey doesn't have Crosby, Malkin, Kessel and Letang. Not to mention Guentzel, Schultz and Sprong. The Penguins are built to play offense, not trap.

Jared werth: Have you heard anything more about the Penguins interest in reacquiring matt callen?

Jason Mackey: I never heard of interest in the first place. I wrote something saying they should inquire, but I put in there that there's been no indication that they actually had done so. I do think Cullen would help them a great deal.

RandomHockeyGuy: Rowney out at least 4 weeks. Rust is still out for awhile. Is it a little odd Penguins haven't recalled a forward with only 12 healthy on the roster right now. There was a report from Dan Kingerski that Adam Johnson was going to be recalled, but that hasn't happened.

Jason Mackey: It is a little odd but not unprecedented. If something would happen, someone could double-shift, and they could easily go 11-7.

Mickey: Do you think there is a real chance that Letang gets traded this year?

Jason Mackey: Absolutely not. Not happening.

Steven: In regards to taking Cole 100 times out of 100 over Hunwick, I think you're a little off base. They're pretty much inseparable analytically, with Cole giving up more high danger scoring chances per 60 than Hunwick, but Hunwick having some more turnovers. They're very similar players, except Hunwick fits the system a little better because better with the puck and better at skating.

Jason Mackey: You can go with analytics all you want -- Hunwick, by the way, is allowing 8.3 scoring chances per game five-on-five compared to 6.9 for Cole -- but Cole has played an integral role on two consecutive Cup teams. Great guy, a personality this team needs. Can't quantify that.

guest: Kessel and Malkin need to stop trying to pass to each other and just shoot, that is the problem with playing them together, they seem to like to pass it to each other. Why do they seem to do that? They are both super stars

Jason Mackey: All superstars can tend to overpass. You take the good with the bad. I know what you're talking about, and someone needs to take the lead. You'd like it to be Phil, but I think you need to let those guys go sometimes, too.

Chad in WV: Going back to the idea of Guentzel as the 3rd line center. Sheahen could center the 4th line, and you could put Sprong/Sheary with Sid and the other in the 3rd with Simon until Rust is back. Not trying to play coach, but could that be a decent option for the team at this time?

Jason Mackey: I agree with you, Chad. All of this is contingent on the Penguins liking Guentzel as a third-line center option, of course.

J. Isbell: Glad to hear you like my work, but I’m not exactly the leader of a jam band. Are you saying that you have varied musical tastes?

Jason Mackey: I do. And I can't wait to see you and the 400 Unit at Heinz Hall later this month. Yinz are awesome.

guest: So did Dumo/Sheary pull out the fantasy football win? Or did the Swedes pull an upset!

Jason Mackey: I'm not sure. We need to ask Sam and find out.

How about defense from defense: Do you believe, as I do, that if Crosby and/or Malkin were playing for a team with quality defensemen, or Nashville's specifically, they'd have overwhelming leads in the scoring race? Might having to shovel pucks out from behind their own goal on virtually every shift due to subpar (though expensive) defenseman be draining the team's top six forwards?

Jason Mackey: You're gonna make fellow Penguins fans throw up in their mouths, suggesting Crosby and Malkin playing for Nashville. I get the defensemen haven't been up to their standard, but I think we're overstating things a bit here. It's not the defensemen's fault that Crosby and Malkin are off pace when it comes to their scoring numbers.

Rahn: This squad is slower than the Cup-winning team due first to departures and compounded by some additions they've made. Any idea why they have gone away from what was such a strength? To me that was their "hard to play against" factor, rather than a gritty, physical brand that got the Bylsma team a Cup.

Jason Mackey: Not sure, Rahn, but I know what you're saying. Adding Oleksiak, Reaves and Sheahan is definitely different than what they've done over the past two seasons. I think they feel they had to get a little tougher. I think it's also tough to find the speed the Penguins did, which is one of the reasons why it worked as well as it did.

D. Godchaux: Your opinion of my contributions to late 70s shows? Frankly, I was so whacked I don’t have much recollection.

Jason Mackey: Not a huge fan, to be honest.

Ellen: Thanks for answering, Jason! Here's the really big question though - how the heck does Reaves make that goal noise? That's just not right! Lol

Jason Mackey: Good question. You have to be all in.

RandomHockeyGuy: A bit of a forward looking question, beyond this season. Crosby, Malkin, Letang, and Kessel are all part of the Penguins core, and are all over 30 years old. The league is getting younger and faster every year. At what point do the Penguins consider moving a Malkin, Letang, or Kessel to bring in some younger assets? Seems any of those 3 playing out their contracts would give them minimal value in a trade, but we see right now how thin the Penguins are in young, promising assets beyond Sprong and Jarry.

Jason Mackey: I think Kessel is the only one they'd consider, because Sprong can do a lot of what he does with the shot, producing on the PP, etc. They're not trading Letang, as we've been over. Malkin has a full NMC; he'd have to agree, and I really doubt he would. ... Kessel would fetch a decent return how high his stock is right now.

CA_Steeler_Fan: I only saw the Philly game but Sprong didn't show me much. Is he the real scoring machine he is supposed to be?

Jason Mackey: Yes, he is. Limited opportunities for him. Sprong looks like the real deal to me.

CA_Steeler_Fan: I watched Mario play a long time. He never had problems scoring. Why does Crosby go through so many slumps?

Jason Mackey: Mario never had a scoring slump? Um ... I'm pretty sure every place who has ever played has endured a scoring slump.

Mike in Kennedy: Canadiens of '70's under Bowman with many stars won many Cups playing trap. Devil's had stars and won 3 Cups. Pens shift to trap in 92 Playoffs resulted in Cup. Who says you can't trap when you have multiple offensive stars?

Jason Mackey: I can. Sullivan can. Rutherford can. All three would, too. Mike, you really want the Penguins -- the Penguins! -- to play a trap, to slow it down and win games, 2-1? C'mon, man. Some stuff has been rough in the first half, but it's not this bad.

Karl: Hi Jason! With Rowney out, do you think there is a call-up coming? Blueger?

Jason Mackey: That's the route that I would go. I watched Rust skate this morning. He did not look close. I'm sort of confused why they haven't made a move already, although they've played games with 12 forwards before.

Steven: In base scoring chances, Hunwick is worse, but in high danger scoring chances per 60, it's 12.82 for Hunwick and 12.8 for Cole. Analytically, there's very, very little between them. Cole's also taking a pretty ridiculous rate of penalties. Hunwick also generates more offensive chances than Cole. Using 'per game' is analytically ineffective because Cole skates the least ice time at 5 on 5 of the 7 D who've skated 100+ minutes for the Pens.

I'm not suggesting Cole is a bum or anything, but he's a bottom pairing guy, as is Hunwick. They're analytically similar, with Hunwick providing more high danger scoring chances with Cole being slightly better defensively. Cole has the lowest high danger scoring chance for% on the team.

Given he's a UFA who you're not re-signing, and Hunwick was seemingly signed to replace him as 3rd pairing LD after this year, I don't see why you'd pick Cole 100 times over Hunwick. There's not much between them, and Hunwick's better with the puck and a better skater.

Jason Mackey: OK, so you're stating -- and supporting -- the case that they're equal. Let's go with that. Why I'd play Cole is exactly what I typed before: "Cole has played an integral role on two consecutive Cup teams. Great guy, a personality this team needs. Can't quantify that." ... I would play Cole because, while I understand, like, respect and try to use analytics, they're not everything. Hockey isn't a math problem. There's a human element. Play Cole because teammates respect his [guts] in tossing his body in front of pucks, and he's one of them. Play Cole because it enhances Schultz's value. Play Cole because he's a much better PK guy. Play Cole because his voice is much stronger means a ton more given what he's meant to this team over the past two years. Again, if everything else is equal.

Steven: Further to Cole's integral use in the playoffs, he skated the lowest TOI in both playoff runs of regular D, and gave up the most high danger chances against per 60 in 16-17 and the 3rd most to Schultz and Daley in 15-16. He's very good on the PK, but to define him as integral when he performed as poorly as he did comparatively to the rest of the D isn't an accurate use of integral.

Jason Mackey: Thanks, Steven. I respect your opinion, and I think you've outlined your argument very well. We seem to disagree. That's OK. Good, healthy discussion.

Yinzer in NYC: Jason, thanks for doing the chats! It's a good way for me to keep tabs on my boys from here in the Big City. I'm curious how you think Mark Recchi and Mike Buckley are performing as coaches this year. It was no secret that there was tension between Sid and Recchi when they played on the same team together...and Murray's play has fallen off a bit this year while Bales has obviously helped Cam Ward. Could these changes in the coaching staff correlate with some of the Pens' problems so far this year?

Jason Mackey: I don't think. Sid and Recchi have been fine. That was a long, long time ago. Sid's a big boy, too. That he hasn't produced as many goals as he has the past two seasons ... yeah, I'm not blaming that on Recchi. ... Same for Murray and Buckley. A coach can only do so much. These guys are well-coached. They've simply performed below what we're used to seeing from them. It does happen.

fred: Hi Jason! Re the human element: Boston Garden 1966-7, I saw Bruin toughguy Ted Green get a NYRanger forward (Jeffrey?) flat down on the ice and pound him unconscious. I was shocked that no one intervened.Clear memory of Green getting up and skating off leaving a motionless form on the ice. Pretty primal stuff... Maybe that colors my view, but I feel there is real value in having someone like Reaves (and now maybe Oleksiak too) in the mix, value that goes well beyond offensive stats. Would you agree, or am I overly impacted by that scene from long ago?

Jason Mackey: You're not overly impacted by that at all, Fred. Talk to some of these guys, and they absolutely want that element. Some fans, especially those big into analytics, will disagree, and I try to see their side, too. But the fact of the matter is, Rutherford and Sullivan feel a certain way about having Reaves -- believing they're doing the best thing for their players -- and his presence isn't going to change. I get having him on the team. What I don't understand is hardly using him. If he has a roster spot, play him 9-10 minutes a night and find a way to make him useful.

guest: I know it's been talked about, but i wonder if our screwy schedule has been having a more negative effect than people realize. I mean: 3 games in 4 nights starting today, then off until next Saturday? these guys are creatures of habit and crave routine. hard not to feel mad at the NHL for scheduling us dirty like that. thoughts?

Jason Mackey: Well, this is the CBA-mandated bye week. Nothing anybody could do here. Every team deals with it. Their early-season schedule, though, absolutely helps explain some of what we're seeing now. It has, in no way, been easy, I'll agree with that.

Steven: Yeah, well, I respect your opinion too and think you've got a different insight on the human effect of Cole because you're in the room and I'm not. But for the sake of appearances, you smell and I think your subjective opinion is objectively wrong.

Jason Mackey: I showered this morning, I swear.

Jason Mackey: On that note, folks, I'm off to Brooklyn. Enjoy the game tonight. Let's do this again next week!