The first half of this season certainly didn’t unfold exactly the way the Penguins (and their fans) expected. With 41 games down, the Penguins sit outside the NHL’s playoff picture, a point behind the Hurricanes for the last wild-card spot.

We’ll find out in the next three months (and then some) whether this season ends in a third Stanley Cup title or a spring with no playoffs (or somewhere in between). Before that gets started, let’s take a look back and assess the first half of this season:

Top six forwards: B-

Both Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin are behind their scoring paces from last season. At the midway point a year ago, they had 45 points apiece, and Crosby led the NHL with 26 goals despite missing the first six games of the season.

Advertise with us

This year, Malkin sits at 38 points while Crosby has 36. They each have 14 goals, which puts them in a tie for 46th in the NHL. Crosby, especially, is going through probably the worst offensive season of his career. He’s averaging just 0.88 points per game, by far the lowest mark of his career. Even if he plays all 82 games for the first time, he’s on pace for some career-worst offensive numbers. Never doubt Crosby’s ability to catch fire and get these numbers up where they should be, but so far it has been a disappointing offensive season for him.

The wingers, too, have mostly underwhelmed. Jake Guentzel has just one goal in his last 14 games, and Conor Sheary only recently seems to have found his scoring touch.

There are two positives from this group, though. Patric Hornqvist is still doing Patric Hornqvist things, scoring dirty goals and acting as a net-front menace on the power play.

Phil Kessel is also having an excellent year on Malkin’s right wing and salvaging this group from being a bigger disappointment. He’s on pace for 88 points, which would be a career-high.

Bottom six forwards: C

Advertise with us

This area has gotten slightly better since the acquisition of Riley Sheahan but has still mostly underwhelmed this season. Plus, you have to take into account that the first nine games before the Sheahan trade were pretty bleak in this regard.

Even now, this is the clearest area for improvement in the second half, probably via trade. Sheahan is on pace for 30 points (Nick Bonino had 37 last year) but also just seven goals, which is well behind Bonino’s 18.

Bryan Rust is also the only “bottom-six” winger (and, really, Rust plays in the top six just as much, if not more) with double-digit points. Carl Hagelin is having an even more disappointing season than last year, with just two goals and six points (for reference, Tom Kuhnhackl is on pace for better offensive numbers). Carter Rowney is virtually a non-factor offensively, a big step back from what Matt Cullen provided as the fourth-line center the past two years.

Maybe the win in Philadelphia on Tuesday night could signal the start of a productive second half for the bottom six, but this has clearly been the most glaring weakness so far.

Defense: B

Advertise with us

Let’s start with the good. Olli Maatta is having a career year and could be the Penguins’ best defenseman right now. Justin Schultz, when healthy, has mostly justified the contract he signed in the offseason. Brian Dumoulin has been his usual steady self.

Even the new additions have mostly fit in. Matt Hunwick has been a fine third-pairing guy (though his troubles playing the right side have caused the Penguins some issues), and Jamie Oleksiak has been pretty good since coming over from Dallas, highlighted by an outstanding game Tuesday night against the Flyers.

Ian Cole has been a bit up and down, and obviously the subject of near-constant trade rumors since late November. But when he was playing consistently, Cole was mostly fine, if maybe a bit too penalty-prone.

The real issue on the blue line has been the play of Kris Letang. Letang has put up fine offensive numbers (he’s actually on pace for a career-high in assists) but has struggled with his decision-making and puck movement a lot this season, sometimes disastrously so. His minus-15 is among the worst plus-minus in the NHL, though it has leveled off a bit after a terrible start. Letang’s play has been a weak spot, but it also seems reasonable to think it’s an easy improvement in the second half if Letang gets back to his old self.

Can Kris Letang turn things around in the second half? (Peter Diana / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Goaltending: C+

Advertise with us

Matt Murray has been OK-not-great in his first year as the unquestioned full-time starter in the Penguins’ net. His .903 save percentage is fourth-worst among NHL goalies with at least 20 games played, and his .906 even-strength save percentage is well below his career average of .932. He has just one shutout on the year and has held opponents to zero or one goal in just six of his 29 appearances (20.7 percent). For comparison’s sake, last year Murray posted four shutouts and held opponents to zero or one goal in 19 of his 49 appearances (38.8 percent).

Murray hasn’t been bad, per se, especially when you consider the seemingly routine poor all-around play in front of him, but he also hasn’t been able to bail the Penguins out and steal games for them over this first half, which is something they desperately needed at times.

Behind Murray, it's really been a mixed bag. Antti Niemi was absolutely dreadful in his three starts and was unceremoniously put on waivers. Since then, Tristan Jarry has been really solid as Murray’s backup. His numbers (2.36 GAA, .922 save percentage, .923 even-strength save percentage) are better than Murray’s. He’s not going to unseat Murray from the starting job any time soon, but Jarry’s play so far should have the Penguins feeling good about their backup goaltending the rest of the way, and maybe allow Murray to rest some more down the stretch.

Management/Coaching: B

We can start with general manager Jim Rutherford’s moves, starting in the offseason. He probably didn’t have much choice in letting Bonino, Cullen and Trevor Daley walk, for various reasons. It might be worth wondering, though, if the Penguins should’ve pursued a short-term deal for Chris Kunitz, who probably could’ve added some punch to the bottom six.

Advertise with us

As far as additions, they’ve ranged from disastrous (Niemi) to mostly solid (Sheahan and Hunwick). None of the newcomers have been an absolute home run, and the most high-profile (Ryan Reaves) still seems like a work in progress as far as how he fits into the team. That’s not ideal halfway through a season.

On the bench, Mike Sullivan still seems to be finding the right buttons to push. He’s constantly tinkering with lineup combinations, to the point where it might be beneficial just to let things ride for a little bit to let some consistency develop. But Sullivan also certainly deserves some credit for navigating the team through an absolutely brutal schedule over the first two months. The Penguins have dealt with their share of injuries, too. For as much as this season has felt like a disaster, they’re still very much within striking distance of the playoffs, and Sullivan probably has a pretty big role in that.

MVP: Phil Kessel

The team’s most consistent offensive threat through the first 41 games, Kessel leads the Penguins in goals (17), assists (27) and points (44). It’s probably not a coincidence that he’s on pace for his most shots as a Penguin.

Phil Kessel has been a major bright spot through 41 games. (Peter Diana / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Most improved player: Olli Maatta

Advertise with us

Maatta’s first couple of years in the league signaled that he was capable of some high-level play, but for various reasons — injury and otherwise — he’s struggled to stay consistent the last few seasons. This year, he’s shown some good offensive instincts and has become a weapon on the Penguins’ blue lline.

Best game: Dec. 27, 2017; 5-4 win (SO) vs. Columbus

This might not have been the inflection point the Penguins hoped for in the immediate aftermath — they lost their next two games — but it was arguably the highest-level hockey they’ve played this year and ended with two points against a division rival (and possible repeat playoff opponent).

Worst game: Oct. 5, 2017; 10-1 loss at Chicago

There were a lot of candidates for this one, but let’s go with the game that was the first sign something might be seriously wrong this season. Niemi was a disaster in net, and the Penguins came out with a lethargic start that would eventually become a trademark for this first half.

Advertise with us

Best acquisition: Riley Sheahan

Sheahan hasn’t been the panacea some might have expected as the third-line center, but he’s been quietly pretty solid in his 32 games with the Penguins. They’d probably like to see him score a bit more, but he seems to be fitting into the system better and better as the weeks go by.

Worst acquisition: Antti Niemi

The Antti Niemi reclamation project never got off the ground, and he was placed on waivers three weeks into the season. He posted a .797 save percentage and 7.49 goals against average in his three games with the Penguins, three losses by a combined score of 22-6.

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG