Jason Mackey: Hi everybody. Thanks for hanging out with me for a bit. Let's get this thing going.

Randy from Conneaut Lake: How much do injuries to Letang, Ruhwedel, Rust affect trades in your in your opinion? Set the time frame back or eliminate potential suitors?

Jason Mackey: I think it depends who the ask is. If it's Hagelin, Cole or Sheary, I don't think it matters. They're obviously not trading Letang. ... If the team can't gain traction of this latest win, I think there will be a bigger push to do something, regardless of injuries.

Scott: What an awesome moving article about Brock...thanks for that. Any word on when we might see sprong?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Thanks, Scott. I keep saying soon. ... And we ain't getting anything. As I just typed, if they don't gain traction off this latest win, I think they will ultimately realize there needs to be changes, and that very likely could trigger a Sprong promotion.

Rahn: Checking in on if you had a chance to ask about Adam Johnson's progress. I read Dave Molinari's always-great holiday prospects piece and Bill Guerin's comments, and remember their high hopes and excitement with signing him this summer.

Jason Mackey: I have not, Rahn. I'm sorry. Lemme kick the can ahead a week, if you don't mind.

Joe: jason, do you really think the Pens will be able to complete a trade for Letang over the next few weeks that makes them a better team than before they traded him? Get real. Every GM knows his history. JR will be getting pennies on the dollar. Stupid trade to make during the season, but if they want a hockey trade for him, they'll be in a position during the off season

Jason Mackey: They're not trading Letang. Not being a jerk. I think this was asked before my story went live. But they're not trading him. I expected to get this a lot today.

Advertise with us

Joe: Looked like Rust injured his wrist again...I know injury info is like trying to open Fort Knox but are you hearing if it's the same issue he had when he was out for six weeks or so last year?

Jason Mackey: Fort Knox is correct. I haven't heard enough on it to speculate with even a sliver of accuracy.

Joe: Do you think the Pens are working on a trade with Ottawa ?

Jason Mackey: I think they'd like to. Brassard and Pageau make a lot of sense for what this team needs. Depends on the ask. But I would say that Ottawa is one of the top suitors for them right now.

Shoob: If you were head coach of the Pens, what would you do to enhance more drive in the players? From what I gather, Sully is doing his best in terms of trying to achieve consistency. Just makes me wonder what CAN be done for two time champs to raise the bar from consistently playing close/from behind games? Love reading your work, by the way!

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Thanks for the kind words, Shoob. I think the world of Mike Sullivan as a hockey coach, and boy would I come off as smug or arrogant or something like that to pretend I know more than he does. The only thing I'd like to see him -- or anyone do -- is just give these guys some consistency. We can all relate, right? You just want things to be consistent. For Crosby, let him play with the same guys for a stretch and try to build something. Sully has been trigger happy. As for the rest, I don't think they need to overreact. The starts are the only thing where I'd look for a different approach.

Rahn: I'm not one to propose trades or wildly speculate with no reporting done, but here I go: With Ottawa's struggles, their (for lack of a better word, meddling) owner and reticence to spend money, might Erik Karlsson be the kind of blockbuster that could be undertaken? The owner Melnyk might like the cost-certainty and name recognition of Kris Letang as the centerpiece coming back. So... (brace for wild speculation): Could be rounded out as as Karlsson, Mark Stone (good hands, net-front guy to replace Hornqvist if he leaves) and Colin White (young center who's plateaued a bit there and one the Pens don't have in the system and third line guy) for Letang, Rust, Sprong, Sheary and a first-rounder. Just a little fun for the holidays.

Jason Mackey: No.

Kessel's Favorite Hot Dog: In your opinion - regardless of likelihood - what teams would most be in on a Kris Letang trade, and what would the price be?

Jason Mackey: Kris Letang isn't getting traded. (I know this was asked prior. It's OK.)

Advertise with us

HB: In yesterday’s game Dubois in the shootout whiffed his shot and the puck slided to the side of Murray without Murray touching it and Dubois shot it wide if that second shot went in would it of counted?

Jason Mackey: I believe the first attempt -- to count as an attempt -- has to go in the general direction of the goaltender. Like, if he had shot and it hit the end boards, then that's it. But I think Dubois, what he did, was OK.

HB: On the broadcast they said malkin went to Florida during the break did anyone else go anywhere fun?

Jason Mackey: Nah. Sheary went home. Murray stayed. Sheahan went home. The American guys got home. Most of the rest stayed.

HB: With all the injuries to defensemen does the Ian cole trade get put on hold?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Yes. With basically three of their top six out, no way they can trade Cole right now. ... Speaking of which, earlier I mentioned Cole as a trade-now guy. That's wrong. Please disregard that. Should be Sheary and Hagelin.

HB: It’s very telling for me that with all the injuries they aren’t willing to bring up sprong and if he plays well you

Jason Mackey: Not sure what you're saying, but I'm not about to criticize the Penguins' development of young forwards. Trust them. They know what they're doing here.

HB: second part:if he plays well then you have an additional asset for the big shake up.

Jason Mackey: Sprong's value to other teams does not match his value to the fan base, trust me. If you develop him right, you have a long-term big part of the franchise and a potentially successor to Kessel. You could then flip Kessel into picks and prospects and help re-stocking the cycle. If you get antsy and trade out of need, you short-circuit that stuff.

Advertise with us

BennyD: While he has made some spectacular individual saves at times, and team struggles in general have contributed, Matt Murray has been very average. Fleury (albeit in a smaller sample size) has been stellar. Considering the Pens are in “win now” mode, is it possible they kept the wrong goalie?

Jason Mackey: I don't think so. Murray is 23 and has won two Cups. His contract is reasonable. You'd like him to stay healthy, I get that. But again, he's 23, has won two Cups and has a reasonable contract. Fleury wanted to play. I don't blame him. But I'm not going to second-guess the decision because Marc has played the way he's capable. I'm just going to be happy for Marc.

Dave: With all of these injuries, how will this restrict JR from making deals...when and if that happens?

Jason Mackey: It makes trading Cole tougher, although GMJR said Kris Letang and Justin Schultz will likely be back next week. ... Other than that, I don't think it does a ton. Getting an accurate gauge on this team -- which version are they? -- has been the more challenging thing for GMJR to wrap his head around. I still don't think he really knows.

BennyD: Great “20 Thoughts on Pens” article. Crosby’s reluctance to shoot the puck has been noticeable. I was surprised to read that Sullivan hasn’t mentioned it to Sid. It seems like he is the type of coach that is willing to address anyone... am I misreading this? Thanks— keep up the good work!

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Thanks, Benny. Sullivan loves Sid, and I get why. I think he's the best player in the world, and he has the best attitude of any pro athlete I've ever seen. That said, a couple things. One, Sully never criticizes a player publicly. So they theoretically may have talked about it; he'll never say ... which asking that question absolutely convinced me of. You're not mis-reading anything.

Hollywood: I always thought Jordan Staal's shorthanded goal against Detroit in Game 4 in 2009 was the turning point of that series. Any chance the Pens could swing a deal to bring him back to center that third line? In your view would that even be a good thing? I haven't really followed his career so not sure if he's still the high-level 2-way player he used to be.

Jason Mackey: No. No, no and no. ... One, his contract. $6 million is a lot. Two, the Canes are improving and Staal has been very good this season. They love him down here. He wasn't available when they checked over the summer, and he's definitely not available now.

Dev: Sorry if this question is beating a dead horse at this point, but I’ve had military duties to deal with and no access to internet for awhile so I’ve been out of the loop for the most part. Which Penguins players could you foresee being trade pieces?

Jason Mackey: No apologies necessary, and thank you for your service. ... Ian Cole would be trade piece No. 1, but the Penguins probably have to wait until Letang and Schultz return to the lineup to do anything. Conor Sheary would be one. Makes $3 million (reasonably). Scored 23 goals a season ago. I'd think they'd like someone to take Hagelin's two-goals-on-a-$4-million-a-year situation, and I could see them bundling Tom Kuhnhackl (solid two-way player, doesn't get much of a role here) to make something work.

Advertise with us

Rt : Do you think Duclair is a possibility for the Penguins? He name was thrown out there by Elliotte Friedman. What kind of return would the Yotes want?

Jason Mackey: I have a tough time seeing Arizona doing that. Seems to me he'd one of the pieces there. Kind of question his fit in Pittsburgh, too.

Rt : I'm not sure if there is any speculation out there, but when do you see GMJR pulling the trigger on a trade? He tends to do it a month before the deadline but is there anything that makes you think it'll be sooner than that?

Jason Mackey: If they lose tonight, I'd look for something. If they don't, I think GMJR won't mess with what they're doing right now.

BennyD: More callups from W/B but still no Sprong... a factor of his not being ready or not the right player for the role they need filled at the moment? What can you tell us about Garrett Wilson? Thnx

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Career AHLer. Tough. Goes to the net. Won't play unless someone gets hurt. Honest player. Good dressing room guy. Doesn't fit with the Penguins' style, but very good in the minors.

Guest: Pens were willing to trade Letang, found suitors, and then no one would pay the price, and then Pens told the media(You) they weren’t trading him as a pushback.

Jason Mackey: No. ... If you read my 20 Thoughts, you read that, on Tuesday, the Penguins had made no mention of a trade to Letang's camp. I said if they were actually shopping him, that would be weird given his status in the league and on the team. Nice try.

Logan: If Letang were traded, what teams do you see as suitors?

Jason Mackey: He's not getting traded.

Advertise with us

Logan: I think Mike Hoffman is a good target. Does Sprong+Hagelin+1st get him?

Jason Mackey: I don't think that's enough. Hagelin right now isn't an asset. He's an ask. You're not giving enough to balance that out.

Rose: Hi Jason really enjoy your work as WBS season ticket holder I agree totally with the organization that Sprong is not ready yet having said that do you believe they would trade him for a 3rd center?They already traded 23yr old McGuire which I was very surprised of

Jason Mackey: Hi, Rose. I think Sprong could be part of a package. I don't think he can be the focal point, for the reason that you outlined. He's not ready. He's no sure thing. He's absolutely a prospect, but there has to be something else, another ingredient.

Logan: Who is the next call up on foward? Why was Garrett Wilson called up instead of Sprong?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Sprong isn't ready. The Penguins don't want to screw his development over some inconsistent play.

Matt N.: With Rust possibly out for a long stretch, is it Sprong-time yet? We could use some more firepower as both he and Sheary haven't quite produced like they seem capable of.

Jason Mackey: You are accurate on that second point. I think we're close to Sprong time -- you'd think this kid could split the atom based on the number of questions about him -- but it's going to take a loss tonight to even make it a consideration. I know they'd rather not do it out of desperation.

Alex: Hi Jason. I know that Letang is not getting traded. However, when rumors were flying around about him and then he got hurt, it made me think. Is it possible for players to fake or exaggerate injuries in order to not get traded? (It is my understanding that a player can’t get traded while on IR?)

Jason Mackey: No player would go that far, Alex. They want to play. That said, if someone is out for a game because a mysterious lower-body injury then traded three days later? Believe that has happened before. This isn't that.

Advertise with us

Alex: Garrett Wilson over Sprong on the call up? Is Sprong really that bad defensively? He can’t really be much worse than 2x Stanley Cup Champion Phil Kessel

Jason Mackey: Phil's game has improved quite a bit this year. There's more to what's holding up Sprong than his defensive game. It's an all-around thing. Also, they're working with him on where he shoots and producing five-on-five.

Steven: With regards to the Letang not for trade comments, did a source reach out to you/Yohe/Bombulie, or did one of you seek it out? If you can't answer that, no worries.

Jason Mackey: For protection-of-source purposes, I'd rather keep that one in-house, Steven.

Logan: To backtrack on that Wilson instead of Sprong, I think Wilson is just up to sit the bench.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: You are correct.

Jason Mackey: I get the reference, Hollywood. ... I never thought of Jim as a "doddering old fool." I never thought anything of Jim, to be honest with you. When they hired him, I was surprised given how out-of-left-field it seems, but after getting to know Jim, I think he's incredibly smart, patient, funny and tremendous to cover. Has he screwed up? Absolutely. Five D, Downie/Ehrhoff/Comeau/etc. ... there have been mishaps. But the guys knows his stuff, and he's a fundamentally good human being. I consider it one of the coolest things in my career to be able to say I've covered someone like GMJR. Other beat writers are often jealous of the sort of stuff that Jim does. Other GMs aren't like him.

Jason Mackey: You can double-dip. Everyone else does. The Penguins aren't trading Kris Letang.

Jason Mackey: As I understand it, too, they were never trading Kris Letang. I've gotten no indications to corroborate Mark's report.

JV: Hi Jason. Last game's effort against Columbus is what every fan hopes to see night in and night out - a team that refuses to quit and gives a full 60+ minutes. But too often we see something less than that, and disturbing patterns begin show up, like taking whole periods (or more) off, mental errors, lack of urgency. The head coach responds with endless line combinations. And this trend predates Coach Sullivan - we saw the same thing under HC's Therrien, Bylsma and Johnston. Much of the Penguin's Stanley Cup success has come on the heels of a coaching change. Do coaches in the NHL have a shelf life, and players, no matter how talented, eventually become tone deaf to the message? And if so, how does Coach Sullivan break the cycle? Mixing up the lines has not proven successful and may have the opposite effect.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Coaches absolutely have a shelf life, but we're not in the same solar system as that right now with Sullivan. He ain't the issue. Does he need to chill out on the tinkering? Yeah, I think he does. But I'm not the coach. The struggles you mentioned, a good bit of them are real. But I'm not ready to start questioning how Sullivan does his job. If anything, I'm amazing he still has any hair left over what this team has put him through.

Chad in WV: How important is it to have Schultz back in the lineup? I know he won’t fix everything, but he seems to have become an important player since coming to Pittsburgh.

Jason Mackey: Absolutely. Gives a different look on the PP, too, allowing Maatta to only kill penalties. That pair with Ian Cole becomes a plus No. 3 pairing. He moves the puck well, adds some offense when the team could use it. Very important to get Schultz back.

NJPensFan: How serious or close do you think Rutherford is to making a deal. I think we need more help on defense than offense.

Jason Mackey: I think he's trying to gauge where his team is at results- and effort-wise. If tonight stinks, I think he'll judge that again, the Columbus win was a blip; problem isn't fixed. If they play well tonight, I think Jim will kick the can again, hoping these guys have figured something out.

Kessel's Favorite Hot Dog: Report today from Pittsburgh Hockey Now that Guentzel's name is out there. Hear anything on that?

Jason Mackey: They're not trading Jake Guentzel.

Alex: Have you heard from your sources of teams that are kicking the Pens tires and vice versa?

Jason Mackey: Do you mean teams that GMJR is talking to? He talks to a lot of teams, honestly. He had dinner with Arizona GM John Chayka when we were there. He and Ron Francis are good friends; they talk a lot. Does that mean they're making a deal, no? Would imagine given needs, etc., that VGK, OTT, EDM, TOR and COL have come up probably a bit more than others.

John: Do you think JR would trade the pens number 1 pick?

Jason Mackey: Yes.

Adam: When GMJR talks about a "shakeup," I can't really see specifically what should happen in terms of a big trade. When players are simply underperforming, where do you start? It has to be hard to diagnose from a transaction standpoint I imagine.

Jason Mackey: I think that's fair, Adam. Think of it this way: Ian Cole is an asset, one that won't be here next year. Carl Hagelin has an ugly contract. Package those two with, say, Sheary, and you see what you get. If it's good, moving three pieces who've won back-to-back Cups? That's a shakeup. Jim isn't talking about trading Sid or Geno. And of course the path of least resistance is to just play well. That happens, Jim can kick his feet up and watch.

Jonah: Seems like the last couple of years the Pens are somewhat content to play about .500 hockey during the first half of the season and bring more focus and drive during the latter half and, obviously, the playoffs. Nobody is going to admit to this of course, but with the long season - and all of the hockey they've played it's not a bad idea. Any thoughts on this?

Jason Mackey: I think being at the top of the mountain as the Penguins have been ... man, it's hard to get up for a December game against the Avalanche. Is that an excuse? No. The Penguins should have more points than they do right now; they've underperformed. But the so-much-hockey thing isn't BS, in my opinion.

John: Do you see a scenario where JR decides that the team doesn't have it this year? Maybe he decides to sell players like Hornqvist at the deadline?

Jason Mackey: If they're woefully out of it -- which I don't think will happen -- maybe. But I still think they want to take a shot at retaining Hornqvist.

Hollywood: Thanks for the chat Jason. You and the boys (and girls) make P-G the one-stop shop for Pittsburgh sports. When GMJR was first hired I watched interviews with him and thought he was a clueless, doddering old fool and that the Pens made a big mistake. Now my opinion has turned 180 degrees - he seems like the sly old fox, always two steps ahead and usually making the right deals for the right players. In interviews he seems so wise and insightful. Is my perception just being colored by winning? Is it the "Milo Hamilton Effect"? (you may be too young to catch that reference :) You seem to have a really good media rapport with him; has your perception of him changed since he started?

Jason Mackey: I get the reference, Hollywood. ... I never thought of Jim as a "doddering old fool." I never thought anything of Jim, to be honest with you. When they hired him, I was surprised given how out-of-left-field it seems, but after getting to know Jim, I think he's incredibly smart, patient, funny and tremendous to cover. Has he screwed up? Absolutely. Five D, Downie/Ehrhoff/Comeau/etc. ... there have been mishaps. But the guys knows his stuff, and he's a fundamentally good human being. I consider it one of the coolest things in my career to be able to say I've covered someone like GMJR. Other beat writers are often jealous of the sort of stuff that Jim does. Other GMs aren't like him.

Rahn: What other clubs look to be in the Penguins, Senators situation for roster movement? A look at the standings would indicate clubs like Anaheim and Edmonton.

Jason Mackey: Haven't heard Anaheim. Have heard some chats -- again, GMJR talks to a lot of GMs -- with OTT, TOR, VGK, EDM and TOR.

NJPensFan: With the pens connection to Buffalo, do you think a trade could be made for either Kane , Okoposo, or Marco Scandella.

Jason Mackey: Potentially, but Kane doesn't solve their third-line center issues, and I worry about the character fit. Don't like the other two a ton, to be honest.

SL: Do you think Schultz had some sort of setback? I had seen tweets (from you or Sam) that Schultz was on the ice skating before main practice (maybe a few days ago), and then didn't see anything about him being on ice over the days since then. Is he still skating, and still on track to rejoin the team soon-ish?

Jason Mackey: I tweeted that he skated before Wednesday's game. That was the first he had done that. I wasn't at practice yesterday, so I don't know if he skated early or not.

Guest: Other than Cole, who do you think the Pens are looking to trade? Hagelin, maybe Sheary and likely Sprong and 1st round pick would be my guesses. I really hope they don't trade Sprong or our first. We need to better develop the farm system. Have you heard any names?

Jason Mackey: Those are the ones I've heard.

Rahn: Want to make the Reaves deal seem even less popular? Wait until guys like Eeli Tolvanen (Predators pick at No. 30, if the Pens could have moved up a slot or two) and Klim Kostin (Blues pick at No. 31) are impact players in a year or two.

Jason Mackey: Is that possible?

SL: You tweeted some quotes from Corrado (he's "had all the bad nights", or something like that). Is his attitude a bit negative/unprofessional, or was that just how the quote sounded in writing?

Jason Mackey: Not negative at all. He's saying he's already had some struggles. So if he does it again, what's the big deal?

Mike Destefano: Hey jason appreciate all of your work. Sorry if u already covered this. Are you hearing any specific teams as trade partners ? I keep reading Ottawa and buffalo. I'd love to get pageau from Ottawa.

Jason Mackey: Yeah, have heard some BUF, not a ton, though. The five I've been repeating: VGK, COL, TOR, OTT and EDM.

Guest: Bascially, what you're saying is that no "shake up" trade is forthcoming, maybe more minor pieces. Is that what you think?

Jason Mackey: I don't know what I think. A lot depends on tonight and which direction they go coming off this latest Columbus win.

Guest: Do you buy JR's radio comments that getting Reaves, Sheahan, Oleksiak did not change the Pens' "speed" identity? Really seems to me they are trying to get bigger at the expense of maybe smaller, quicker players...

Jason Mackey: I don't. I like those three guys, but they've been a definite drop in speed. It's OK to admit it. I don't understand why the Penguins are so adamant about saying nothing has changed when clearly it has.

Ryan: Is it reasonable to wait and see what the team brings over the next month? I don't see any clear trade pieces that anyone outside of the Pens fan base that makes sense for both sides. Hagelin is a 4th liner and PKer and Sheary is a middle six winger at best, no one is lining up for any of those players. At this point we have to hope that we can turn the team around and work with what we have.

Jason Mackey: I think that's a smart way of looking at it. Very smart. Just have to start getting some results. Those will go a long way toward having some patience.

Russell: There's been a lot of rumblings of a big trade that will shake up the room for some time now. Now that Letang is off the table I'm having a hard time finding a big piece the Penguins have that other teams would want. I don't feel like Hagelin, Sheary, and Cole have that much value to get the 3rd Line Center the Pens need. Do you think it's just as simple as floating the 1st round pick plus some of those pieces, or will they have to trade someone like Sprong to get what they need.

Jason Mackey: If they're going to go big, and maybe try to get Hagelin's contract off the books, they probably have to trade the pick. Here's another thing with Sprong: There's a chance they're not playing him in the NHL because what if he struggles mightily? Would hurt some trade value.

Ryan: Looking at the Pens record right now, to get somewhere near the 45 win mark they’d have to win about 60% of their remaining 44 games (26 wins). With the inconsistent play so far do you see any signs of a win streak coming? Sure would be nice given about half of the remaining schedule is within the Metropolitan. Thanks Jason

Jason Mackey: I actually do. They were a defiant bunch after that last game. It was different, similar to last year. I wouldn't be shocked if they go on a bit of a run here.

Guest: I think it's ridiculous that the team is struggling to score and they won't call up their best scorer in the minors. Why? Because they don't like his defense enough. Yet I think Sheary and Kessel are playing and they aren't exactly good defensive players, and other players aren't playing defense either. Seems hypocritical to me and UI wish you would ask the Pens' brass about it

Jason Mackey: Sullivan was asked today about Sprong. I've asked Rutherford. We've relayed the answers. Do you want us to make them answer differently to give the answer you're looking for?

Chad in WV: How important will it be to have Schultz back in the lineup? He won’t fix everything but I believe he’s become a significant part of the team since he arrived.

Jason Mackey: Agree, Chad. He does a lot of different things. PP. Pairing with Cole. Adding offense. Very important.

Basil McRae: Thomas Plekanec isn’t on the Pens radar as a 3rd line center because of his contract and lack of speed, right?

Jason Mackey: Would think so, among other reasons. Haven't heard that name.

JV: Jason I know you're not a psychologist, but if you had to give an answer, why would you say so many Pens fans just assume that the other 30 teams are lining up to take our "under-performing, over-priced" players off our hands? Those teams read the stats and watch the games same as everyone else.

Jason Mackey: I couldn't begin to tell you. It's like a phrase you must memorize as a Penguins fan: "All our bad players for all of your good players."

NJPensFan: If we still had Hainsey or Daley back do you think we would have the issues we're having on defense.

Jason Mackey: I think Daley would help more than Hainsey. Daley was very good at helping them get out of their own end. ... And was probably a better defender than he got credit for. When, of course, he was healthy.

Jared werth: Besides a third line center, do you see the pensguins perhaps getting a Deffenseman who is more of a top 5 level D ?

Jason Mackey: One thing at a time, but yes, I do think they'll probably add another defenseman at some point.

Jason C: Hey Jay just wondering when do you think Pens will make a trade deal? Any perspective who the front runners are? Will we ever see Sprong this year? Is there really intrest of Letang being traded? Thank you Sir

Jason Mackey: That's like 20 questions, man. ... Kidding. ... Soon if they lose tonight. ... Brassard, Pageau, Haula, Bozak and Marchessault all make a lot of sense. ... Yes, soon, especially with a loss tonight. ... They're not trading Kris Letang. Whew.

SL: I know you asked Sullivan about whether he's talked to Crosby about shooting the puck more. Have you asked Sid about it directly (whether he's aware that he's shooting less frequently than last year, and if so, if it's something he wants to change)?

Jason Mackey: I have not. Have not a chance. I do want to, in the proper time and setting to try and get the captain's honest thoughts.

Ryan: Why are readers treating Daniel Sprong like he's the second coming of JJ#68. The guy is a disappointment, with the bottom 6 the Pens roll out on a nightly basis, he should have been on the roster from day 1. He's a prospect.....that's it.

Jason Mackey: I believe Daniel Sprong just walked on water.

THE Phil Kessel: Do I seem happier than last season? My stats are better so

Jason Mackey: Wouldn't know, sorry.

JN: Are the pens interested in Maroon or Kane? There seems to be a hole on the LW on Genos line.

Jason Mackey: I think they would consider them. Maroon is an intriguing option if they think they're going to lose Hornqvist. Balances out the depth chart a bit. ... Kane I think the cost would be too high, the personality ... not sure it fits. I think they've followed and maybe had some casual chats, but I just don't know if I see a fit.

BennyD: Purely for fun speculation: Ian Cole and Kessel for Patches and Galchenyuk... would you pull the trigger on this trade?

Jason Mackey: Yes, I would. Can you imagine Phil in Montreal? Oh, boy.

Mikey: Thanks for your insight Jason. Do you think if Leighton hadn’t been hurt he’d be the one called up instead of DeSmith? I saw the last WBS game vs Lehigh Valley and DeSmith was a HUGE difference in them not being blown out. Even the LV coach said as much. How do you think PIT views their AHL goalies?

Jason Mackey: Yes, I do. I think that's why they got Leighton, as an upgrade over DeSmith.

Adam: Why did the pens play Archibald so sparingly? Especially with Reaves playing on the 4th line. To my understanding, Reaves is basically playing as a Crosby/Malkin insurance policy, so then why play him in games against say, Arizona or Vancouver?

It's not like a game where you have Dubinsky or Wilson or Clutterbuck coming after him. It's not a rivalry...Apologies if this has been answered previously.

Jason Mackey: Good question, Adam. Not sure. Always wondered that myself. They like Reaves in the lineup, what he brings. I would have rested him against non-physical teams and given Archibald more games.

Alex: Now I’m just really confused. Matt Gatjka said Letang is being shopped. You and Josh Yohe say he’s not. How can anyone make accurate assessments when there is conflicting “source attained” information??

Jason Mackey: I can't speak for Gajtka. I can only speak for myself. I reported all along -- starting in 20 Thoughts -- that no trade had been brought to Letang's camp.

Pens Fan: This team stinks.....time to trade 87 and 71 for draft picks and fire HCMS and GMJR. The sky is falling, the sky is falling.

Jason Mackey: Seems about right. You forget that Daniel Sprong is better than Gordie Howe.

Steven: My apologizes that I wasn't clear, I didn't think it meant Letang, but rather Cole as it came on the heels of the Oleksiak deal.

Jason Mackey: Thank you for clarifying.

B: I saw a stat that the pens are 4-11 without Schultz. That's pretty telling if you ask me how important and valuable he has become. My question is, is he a #1 dman on teams?

Jason Mackey: I don't think. That's nothing against Schultz, but I think part of the reason he's been good is because he hasn't had to shoulder the No. 1 load. I like Justin a lot, but he's not Erik Karlsson or Drew Doughty. He'd probably be the first to tell you that.

JT: Speaking of GMJR, when he first arrived, the mention was a couple years...a couple years later he's still seemingly going strong. Any indications on when he'll hang it up and who would be in line to replace him?

Jason Mackey: No indications. He likes his job. His son's into it. They're winning. It's a family thing. He could be around for a bit more. Wouldn't shock me at all.

Adam: What's your favorite away city?

Jason Mackey: Top five (and thank you for asking a non-hockey question): VAN, WSH, SJ, NYR and MTL.

Hollywood: A left-handed D-man who is comfortable playing right side (Oleksiak) - that seems like a really special skill. I would think there's a good bit of technique that is different when your stick is to the ice side rather than the board side, especially if you have to switch back and forth from game to game or shift to shift. Or is it really not that big of a thing?

Jason Mackey: For some guys it is, for some it's not -- where your stick is positioned, shooting, accepting passes, etc.

SCOTT: How long does a typical trade take to complete? The GMs know what the teams need or are looking for?

Jason Mackey: There's no cookie-cutter formula, Scott. They're all different.

Jonah: I see some folks have had 3+ questions replied to - while mine from about 30 minutes ago isn't showing up. Seemed like a reasonable question to me. I guess I don't understand how this works...

Jason Mackey: Jonah, it's showing on my end that I've answered every question. If you asked it, chances are it didn't get through. Please do it again. I don't ignore any questions that are clean.

Shaffer: As we have seen, there is no market for centers. Can a Hoffman or Pacioretty fall into our lap? Are they on JR’s radar?

Jason Mackey: They are, but it's going to take a decent chunk to get the guys you're talking about. A lot could depend on the market for them and how competitive the Penguins could be.

Ron: I'll take the Hagelin, Sprong and a 1st for Hoffman posted above and change it around a little: Do you think the Penguins could pull off Brassard for that package? Brassard would probably be cheaper and easier to acquire than Hoffman I'd imagine.

Jason Mackey: Yay, more judging fictitious trade offers time! ... I don't think it's enough, FYI.

Ben: If i was interested in being a hockey writer, what are the steps to doing so? (Given that I have the hockey intelligence to do so)

Jason Mackey: Go to school for it, get a job out of college covering preps somewhere small, work you butt off, put off having a life, work your butt off more, move up, still no life, learn journalism and the importance of reporting as opposed to being a fan, still have no live, move up, keep working ... should be something like that.

Ben: Do you think now with the injuries on D that the pens will wait to trade cole? Also if you had to guess, when will a trade happen

Jason Mackey: I'll say Jan. 14. Does that sound good? Yes, I think it's hard to do it now with so many people hard.

Steven: Would it be possible for you to do some digging with Sam Ventura and do a piece on how analytics is used to evaluate players/what analytics they use? I'd be interested to see that and I think it'd be a good read given that the Penguins have pretty strong analytics despite not getting results.

Jason Mackey: I would love to. Won't happen, though. They're SO secretive with that stuff. Don't blame them, either.

Hollywood: You aren't getting off-topic questions today - I think that must mean hockey season is finally heating up!!

Jason Mackey: Daniel Sprong, fictitious trade stuff and imaginary timelines. It's what we do.

Guest: So, how do you shake anything up if you're not willing to deal anything significant and have limited cap space?

Jason Mackey: You could trade Cole. He's acquirable and would send a message.

Jim: Have you noticed some fatigue with geno? He doesnt seem like the same offensive threat as last year.

Jason Mackey: I've had zero issues with Geno's game of late.

Ryan: You're the man, get to every question and you are respectful to the readers, appreciate everything you do.

Jason Mackey: That might be going a little far, but I feel like if you guys are gracious enough to spend some time with me, the least I can do is answer.

SL: Conspiracy theory: do you think a GM would ever start trade rumors about his own player, just to get that player's attention? For example, whisper to another GM, who whispers to a Canadian media personality about Tanger, and then the Pens can come in a few days later (after the rumor has reached the player) and deny any intention to trade?

Jason Mackey: I think those are some serious mental jumping jacks, but who knows. Sometimes GMs are some odd types. I don't think that's what GMJR is doing here, I really don't.

JN: With oleksiak here, is the reaves experiment over? Would be nice to have a 4th line that actually produces. Reaves also cant do much playing only 4 minutes a game..

Jason Mackey: I don't think so. I think it could be if Oleksiak shows some muscle, plays well enough, and they get an offer. But it's too soon to say that.

Fan: Is it possible in the playoffs that reaves will only play if its a series in which we are getting physically abused like last year against columbus?

Jason Mackey: You'd think. But the way the Penguins are with him, feels like he's here. Every chance they get, they insist they're happen, all is well. Have to think it's no longer an "experiment."

JB: Not to beat a dead horse, or anything, but do you get the sense that the team regards Letang's issues this year as kind of an inevitable consequence of changing his style to play a less risky game? For me at least, he looks like a guy who's thinking too much, rather than playing instinctively, and it's still too early to tell if Letang 2.0 will be effective or not.

Jason Mackey: Nah, I don't think his issues are connected to what they've asked of him. I think they're connected to the time off, the brutal early-season schedule and the need for Letang to just get away from it. He's a bit of a mental mess right now. I'm not even sure he's hurt, to be honest with you. Just needs to get away.

NJPensFan: Sullivan has been inconsistent with the lines this year. With that said what about pairing Sid with Sheary and Guentzel. Malkin with Phil and Haglien. I say this because playing Hags with Geno would give him more scoring opportunities.

Jason Mackey: I don't disagree. I like those lines. I just think Sully needs to STICK WITH THEM for, like, more than 7 minutes.

Guest: Can you tell Crosby that I love him? Thanks!

Jason Mackey: Will make sure to do that tonight.

JT: Why on earth would a GM go to the camp of a player just to say, hey - we're thinking about trading you? We don't have anything on the table, but we're listening...

Jason Mackey: Out of respect for what the player has meant to that organization.

Matt: Favorite non Grateful Dead band? Subquestion, favorite current band?

Jason Mackey: Jason Isbell and the 400 Unit. Same answer for both. Seeing him in January at Heinz Hall. Can't wait.

JV: Follow up to NjPensFan question: has JR ever shared in one of your sit-downs that there's a player from last year that he wishes he'd held on to?

Jason Mackey: No. And he probably won't do that. I think that makes his current ones look kinda bad, don't you?

SL: I'm not sure if my prior question got through, so I'll try again. Do you think there's any chance JR started the trade rumors about Letang, just to get his attention?

Jason Mackey: No, I don't. Jim is fundamentally a good human being. Letang has a family, a kid, another on the way. That's a hell of a message to send, to scare someone like that.

JT: best "quick: just the juicy" story from the locker room. Go

Jason Mackey: I'm not sure what you're asking.

Steven: In your 20 thoughts, you talked about how Rutherford wasn't happy that Malkin, Crosby and Letang were mixing it up against Columbus as he had acquired Reaves. Was he unhappy with Reaves for seemingly not protecting them, or was he unhappy with the stars for getting engaged?

Jason Mackey: He was unhappy that much risk was being taken. There's a lot of ways to look at that. That Reaves was on the bench. That those guys are losing their minds and seemingly trying to score goals via fights. ... He was mad because he thought he solved the issue, and it was happening anyway.

H: letang is either a top 5 dman in the league when he's on and when he's not, he's awful. Do you recall any other player being so up and down?

Jason Mackey: Limas Sweed was up and down quite a bit. Great potential. Never delivered. ... Craig Wilson, too. Dude could hit it a mile but wouldn't come within three feet of a breaking ball.

JT: Apologies -just a quick funny story from inside the locker room. I always find those fascinating. The mic'd up segments, or when the cameras are rolling...is there a favorite story you have

Jason Mackey: One time during a Crosby scrum, Dan Potash was leaning on a plastic garbage can. Small one, where players throw tape and whatnot. Well, it bent, and inevitably crumpled. Potash went face-first into the middle of the scrum. Crosby lost it.

SL: Thanks again for doing this! One more question, if you have time. You said above that you weren't entirely sure that Letang is hurt, but maybe just needed to get away and get his head on straight. I had wondered if that might be the case (didn't Sully say SId had a lower body injury in order to give him a game or two off before Christmas, when Sully first joined the team)? But, with Rudy and Schultz being out of the lineup, I had thought there was no chance they'd bench Letang if he was healthy. Do you really think they might have?

Jason Mackey: Yes, I do. He needed to get away. I get questions every week about Letang's struggles. A good bit of them are fair. At times, he helped them. Other times -- remember the awful pass to Dumoulin? -- he hasn't; he's hindered them. Letting him clear his head right now is not the worst thing.

Jared werth: Do the penguins think they need more grit on the team?

Jason Mackey: Toughness, no? But a player like Bonino, Kunitz or Cullen? Guys who had "it?" Yes, I think they could use one of those types.

Steven: Would that anger indicate that there's a disconnect between what Rutherford wanted from Reaves and what Reaves can provide/how Sullivan deploys Reaves? Given Reaves' minuscule TOI, it's clear Sullivan doesn't trust him, and Sully has never been a stranger to scratching guys he thinks are underperforming (Hagelin, Sheary in playoffs last year, Cole this year). Is it possible for you to comment on whether Reaves is in the lineup on orders from above or is Rutherford a lot more hands off than that?

Jason Mackey: We're really analyzing one look of frustration here. Probably too much. I do think all parties involved want him in the lineup. How much he plays has often been handicapped by special teams games and the Penguins chasing games; the poor starts haven't helped.

Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That's it for today. Thanks, as always, for participating. Talk to yinz next week!