The Penguins have not been very good at coming back in games this season — they’ve been pretty dreadful at it, really.

So when they fell behind by two goals in the first period against Columbus Wednesday night, it seemed like another version of the same script: Fall behind early, show some flashes, but ultimately come up short.

Instead, the Penguins wrote a new story, one they hope will define the remaining three-plus months of their season.

They beat the Blue Jackets, 5-4, in a shootout, in a victory coach Mike Sullivan called “the biggest character win” the Penguins have had all season.

Advertise with us

“I thought it was the most resilient that this group has been all year long,” Sullivan said. “Just kind of a never-say-die attitude, a stick-to-itiveness and just staying with it. We were down two goals a couple of times in the game, but we just stayed with it.”

The Penguins trailed by two goals on three separate occasions, to be precise. They were down 2-0 at the first intermission, 3-1 at the second intermission and 4-2 midway through the third period.

The first two times, they pulled one goal back before the Blue Jackets countered with another score of their own. The third time was the charm, though, as Evgeni Malkin and Jake Guentzel scored third period goals to force overtime, and Matt Murray stopped the Blue Jackets’ first two shootout attempts.

“It’s huge,” defenseman Ian Cole said. “We’re going to see these guys again. Being able to come back and have a statement win for our team like that, showing these guys that, hey, we’re not going to go down easy. They’re a team that battles hard, and we battled right there with them the whole time. I think we’re all pretty happy with that.”

Last year, the Penguins had an uncanny knack for being able to answer back when an opponent scored first. That “pushback,” as Sullivan often called it was a reliable and important factor in their run to a Stanley Cup. In games where their opponent scored first last season, the Penguins were a remarkable 20-11-4.

Advertise with us

Wednesday’s win moves their record in such situations this year to a still-dismal (but slightly improved) 4-13-1.

“That resiliency that we need in a season and obviously to go far in the playoffs, that’s something that we have to do,” Cole said. “I think too often we’ve been not as resilient as we should be, or maybe a little shellshocked or whatever you want to call it. Tonight, I think, was good, and hopefully we can do that more often.”

Sullivan called that resiliency “a part of the fabric” of the Penguins’ team identity, and it showed up in spades Wednesday night.

Both of Artemi Panarin’s goals could’ve been absolute back-breakers for the Penguins. In other games this season, goals like that have been. He scored late in the second and midway through the third — both times shortly after the Penguins had cut the lead to one goal, and both times mostly against the flow of play.

Cole admitted that ability to come right back from a goal like that to continue dominating play and possession was something the Penguins were really good at last year, and have struggled with for most of this season.

Advertise with us

“This team is capable of coming from behind, regardless of how many goals we’re behind,” Sullivan added. “We have the firepower to do it, we have plenty of history and plenty of evidence that I think is suggestive that we’re capable of that. It’s a matter of making sure that we stay in the moment, and we stay determined. I thought we did that tonight.”

Maybe the biggest key for the Penguins, though, will be making sure this win means something beyond just two points in the standings on a Wednesday night in late December.

After all, it was just six days prior they were sitting in the dressing room, after a comeback shootout win against Columbus, talking about how it could be a jump-start for the thus-far disappointing season.

Two nights later, they put together one of their worst performances of the season in a 4-0 loss to Anaheim.

“We didn’t follow up our emotional win last time against Columbus,” defenseman Brian Dumoulin said. “We kind of had a let-down there against Anaheim, but obviously we get another chance to go out there and prove this wasn’t a one-time thing."

Advertise with us

So, yes, there are plenty of reasons for the Penguins to feel optimistic after this win. But the ultimate story of this game — season turning point or temporary blip on the radar — will be written over the coming weeks.

“I think it depends what we do with it here,” Sidney Crosby said. “We’ve had really good games and looked to build off them. Tonight I thought we rallied. Some guys left the game. We hung in there. We didn’t feel sorry for ourselves.

“We’re going to need more of that mindset moving forward here. It’s going to be a battle until the end of the year. You know what? Those are big points, and we have to find ways to do that every night.”

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG