Hello, friends, and welcome to the latest edition of the Penguins mailbag. The Penguins are coming off a 4-2 loss to Colorado Monday night, which capped off a not-great road trip out west. They also lost, 2-1, to Marc-Andre Fleury and the Golden Knights, but did manage to beat Arizona thanks to a last-minute goal from Olli Maatta.
All told, things are not looking great for the Penguins right now, even beyond that last road trip. They’re 5-5-0 in their last 10 games, and currently sitting two points outside of the playoffs in the standings. Jim Rutherford said last week he could see himself making a major trade to shake things up, and we may be getting towards that time.
Remember, as always, you can ask questions for this mailbag any time at swerner@post-gazette.com, or hit me on Twitter @SWernerPG. Away we go…
Grant: Which players do you think Rutherford considers untouchable from a trade perspective?
Rutherford is always a bit cagey whenever he’s asked this question, for good reason. No sense in upsetting a player who might consider himself untouchable by saying publicly that he’s not.
And, really, the term “untouchable” is a bit misleading, right? Pretty much everyone’s available for the right price. Some prices just might be (a lot) higher than others. For the sake of this discussion, let’s break down the Penguins’ roster into tiers of tradability, based on Rutherford’s likely reaction when given names are brought up in trade discussions:
Laugh heartily at opposing GM, hang up the phone, then laugh some more: Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin
These two guys are in a tier of their own when it comes to tradability. They’re not going anywhere, and any future moves will be based around what what’s the best fit for these guys to win another Stanley Cup.
Laugh at opposing GM, hang up the phone, maybe think about it for a second, then pass: Kris Letang, Matt Murray, Jake Guentzel
These guys are just a shade below Crosby/Malkin levels of un-tradability, but not by much. For as inconsistent as Letang has been this year, he’s still a core member of the Penguins’ franchise, and, when he’s at his best, has a higher ceiling than just about any defenseman in the league.
As for Murray, Tristan Jarry showed last month that he certainly has the potential to be a regular NHL starter down the road in his career. But he’s not there yet. And you don’t trade a 23-year-old two-time Stanley Cup-winning goalie.
Guentzel is probably a little bit more likely to be moved than the other two guys, but he still fits best in this tier as opposed to with the other young guys, thanks in large part to his contract. He’s signed on his entry-level deal (annual hit of $734,167 through 2019) and is an RFA after that. That’s just absolutely insane value for a guy who has pretty clearly established himself as a top-line winger, and it would probably take a truly massive haul for Rutherford to part with him.
No thanks, but call back this summer: Phil Kessel
Kessel gets his own tier in this one. He’s having one of the best offensive seasons of his career, so if Rutherford get an overwhelming offer where he can truly feel like he’s selling high, maybe he thinks about it. Much more likely, though, they’re going to want to keep riding this Kessel hot streak as far as they can into the playoffs, and he’ll be an integral part of this year’s team moving forward.
Long-term, though, it’s easy to see why Kessel probably won’t end his career with the Penguins. He’s under contract through 2022, with an annual $6.8 million cap hit. In the time between now and then, the Penguins will presumably have to deal with new contracts for Jake Guentzel, Bryan Rust and Justin Schultz (among others), as well as current minor leaguers such as Daniel Sprong, Zach Aston-Reese, Thomas DiPauli and a host of others. In short, it’s hard to see Phil on this team long-term, but a trade is probably not imminent.
Expiring contract, but we don't want to move him: Patric Hornqvist
Hornqvist is an invaluable part of the Penguins’ current locker room makeup and gives them a certain type of edge on the ice that other players just don’t provide. It’ll be tough for them to re-sign him this offseason, but I would expect Rutherford to make more of an effort here than he did with any of the Penguins’ UFAs this past summer. In terms of a trade, it would have to be a pretty hefty NHL-level return to get Rutherford to part with Hornqvist.
We like him long-term, but he’s available for the right offer: Conor Sheary, Justin Schultz, Brian Dumoulin, Olli Maatta
All four of these guys are signed through at least 2021 on mostly reasonable deals, so it’s fair to say the Penguins see them as long-term pieces for the future. Sheary, Schultz and Dumoulin, in particular, all re-signed this past summer. There are probably some variations within this tier (for instance, I’d say Schultz is a tad more untouchable than the other three, but all four are probably in mostly the same boat.)
Didn’t he just get here?: Riley Sheahan, Matt Hunwick
These new guys are still sort of figuring out their roles with the Penguins — Who’s Hunwick’s regular defense partner? Is Sheahan a 3C or a 4C? — but the Penguins seem to like what both have provided so far, and it’d be a surprise to see either one moved.
He’s young and due for a raise next season, but it would take a decent return: Bryan Rust, Tristan Jarry, Daniel Sprong
Rust and Jarry are RFAs after this season, so if the Penguins keep them they’ll have to give both an NHL-level contract in the summer. If the Penguins decide they can’t afford one (or both) maybe they flip them to a team that would be happy to. Both could probably provide a pretty decent return, too. Rust is a young, versatile winger who can play up and down the lineup, and Jarry has all the makings of a long-term NHL starter in net.
Sprong has yet to see the NHL this year, but, as another pending RFA, he fits in this group, too. He’s got a ton of hype and natural talent, but still seems to be putting things together in Wilkes-Barre. Sprong is a high-end prospect, but probably not an untouchable one at this point.
If the Penguins want to sell the future for a win-now trade, these guys might make sense to be included.
Can you find the right trade partner?: Ryan Reaves, Carl Hagelin
Reaves doesn’t really seem to have found a fit in Pittsburgh, but Mike Sullivan has been pretty consistent about his thoughts on Reaves’ value to the team. If someone’s willing to take him for a decent return, it’s probably not a bad idea for the Penguins to think about cutting bait on the Reaves experiment
With Hagelin, it’s more about his salary. He’s underperforming for a guy making $4 million a year through 2019, but if you can find someone willing to take that off your hands (maybe in a package with a prospect?) that would help free you up a whole lot long-term.
Would need to make the pieces work, but he can certainly be had: Tom Kuhnhackl, Chad Ruhwedel, Carter Rowney, Ian Cole
Kuhnhackl is a fourth-line winger, and Ruhwedel is a seventh defenseman. The Penguins like both guys, but you probably wouldn’t have to twist Rutherford’s arm too much to include them to make a deal work.
With Rowney, any deal would probably be contingent on getting another center, which would make him more expendable.
And as for Cole, he has reportedly been on the trading block for weeks, and it seems like a matter of time before he’s dealt.
Of course, there are plenty more prospects the Penguins could give up, guys like Zach Aston-Reese, Thomas DiPauli, Lukas Bengtsson, etc., but it’s hard to peg those guys’ value, considering their lack of NHL experience. We’ll leave them out for now, but safe to say all of them are probably on the table.
Brad: How much of the Penguins current struggles would you attribute to just being a bit unlucky as opposed to really serious problems?
This is actually a pretty valid question, and maybe one of the reasons a major trade might not be necessary for the Penguins to turn this thing around.
There’s certainly a case to be made that the Penguins are actually better than their record indicates and have been, to a large extent, unlucky this season. They have the lowest PDO (shooting percentage plus save percentage) in the NHL, and their Corsi For percentage (CF%) is a very respectable 51.79 (ninth best in the league). Both these numbers would seem to indicate that the Penguins are playing better hockey than the results should eventually follow.
Even on the micro level, there’s reason to think the answers for a turnaround are on the roster. Sidney Crosby (13.1 percent) and Evgeni Malkin (11.1 percent) are both shooting at a percentage below their career average. Malkin, especially, is well below the 17.0 clip he has been converting at over the past two seasons. Basically, at this point, the only player having an above-average (or even up-to-expectations) offensive season is Phil Kessel.
Matt Murray, too, is probably due to improve his .910 even-strength save percentage (24th among goalies with at least 20 games). He’s been pretty consistently in the low .930s over the past two seasons.
So there are plenty of reasons to think the Penguins will turn things around on their own ……… but what if they don’t?
Yes, the Penguins can make a strong case for bad luck so far this season, but at the end of the day, bad luck or not, they’re not where they want to be in the standings and heading in the wrong direction.
From a statistical point of view, looking at the Corsi, the Penguins’ overall percentage is pretty good, but their Corsi For and Corsi Against raw numbers are both in the top 10 of the NHL, which means the Penguins are, by and large, playing up-tempo, chance-for-chance games. This would seem to lend itself to a bit more unpredictability and, ultimately, make you more susceptible to some bad luck.
Also, while it makes sense to think that Matt Murray’s save percentage will increase, it’s also no guarantee. Murray (and the entire team, for that matter) has played a whole lot of hockey over the past two years, and this regression in performance could be a matter of that catching up with them.
Beyond the numbers, it’s concerning that Mike Sullivan said after Monday’s loss to Colorado that he felt the Penguins were lacking in passion and emotion. Those are the kinds of things that they’ve had in spades over the last two years (especially in the postseason) and that can be shaken up by some sort of trade or roster move.
Ultimately, yes, there’s a strong case to be made that the Penguins have been more unlucky than bad over the first 35 games of this season, but at a certain point, it doesn’t really matter. You don’t get a consolation prize for missing the playoffs due to bad luck, and given that the Penguins will be in win-now mode for as long as Crosby and Malkin are under contract, it might be time for a shake-up for shake-up’s sake.
Danielle: when do you think Sprong will be called up? Also what do you think is the root of the pens lack of consistency
If Hornqvist is out long-term, I wouldn’t be surprised to see Sprong this week. He still seems to be working through his issues with play away from the puck at an NHL level, but at a certain point you just need to see what you’ve got with him, and if he can cut it at the NHL level.
If Sprong isn’t called up this week, things sort of go back into a holding pattern with him. At that point, you take seriously the idea that he won’t be called up until he turns into the all-around player they want him to be in Wilkes-Barre.
As for the lack of consistency, I think a lot of it can be attributed to bad luck, as outlined above, but I think fatigue is probably taking its toll, too. This team has played so much hockey over the last two years, there’s a good chance it’s just all catching up to them now.
Casey Shaffer's Ego: How good has Simon been in the lineup? Is he shaking things up in the right direction?
I’ve really liked Dominik Simon’s impact over the past week or so. He seems to have brought the sort of spark that young guys like Rust, Sheary and Guentzel have brought in the past. He also fits really well with Sidney Crosby as a winger who plays a simple, direct game, and one who’s real smart both with the puck and away from the puck.
I don’t think Simon is going to provide the type of major shake-up this team might need, but he’s certainly warranted a longer look as a potential full-time NHL guy.
Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.