Welcome to another edition of the Penguins mailbag. The Penguins are coming off a decidedly ‘meh’ five-game homestand. They went 2-3-0 during that stretch, ending things with a disappointing 2-1 loss to Colorado Monday night. Next up, the franchise’s first ever game against the Vegas Golden Knights, with familiar face Marc-Andre Fleury between the opposing pipes. As a reminder, if you want your question answered in these mailbags, leave it on Twitter @SWernerPG or email me at swerner@post-gazette.com. Away we go…

Danielle: this is very broad, but what do you think is going on with the pens? whats their major weakness and do you think it could be fixed with a (possible) trade?

The biggest issue the Penguins have right now is that it’s not just one problem that’s causing them to struggle. Over the past few weeks, they’ve basically been playing Whac-A-Mole with a different underlying issues. First, it was their 5-on-5 scoring. They fix that, and their penchant for having terrible first periods pops back up. Correct that, then they’re suddenly not getting any offensive production from the bottom six once again. Riley Sheahan and Carl Hagelin score a couple of goals, but then they have another awful start against Toronto. They have a better start against the Avalanche, but then they can’t score again all of a sudden.

Combine all of this with the fact that they’re playing a rookie backup goalie who was probably starting to wear down a bit in the final couple of games (though Tristan Jarry looked good against the Avalanche) and it’s a perfect recipe for a maddeningly inconsistent homestand, even if it doesn’t lend itself to a quick fix.

Advertise with us

If there’s one area the Penguins could correct, though, I’d make it 5-on-5 scoring. That would obviously help them win games like Monday’s against Colorado, but also give them a boost when they’re deficient in other areas. Against Toronto, for instance, one more even-strength goal could’ve forced overtime and gotten the Penguins at least a point.

It starts at the top, too. Sidney Crosby is averaging 0.22 even-strength goals per game after putting up 0.4 per contest last season. Similarly, Evgeni Malkin has dipped from 0.35 5-on-5 goals per game a year ago to just 0.14 this season. The only player who has significantly improved his even-strength scoring from a year ago is Phil Kessel (0.18 per game to 0.34).

And while it’s easy to point to the loss of bottom-six centers Nick Bonino and Matt Cullen, it doesn’t look like that’s where the production has been sapped from. In fact, Sheahan is averaging only a shade fewer even-strength goals per game (0.13) than Bonino did last season (0.14). Rather, most of the production seems to be lost from the Penguins’ top-six wingers. Conor Sheary (0.34 to 0.22), Jake Guentzel (0.38 to 0.22) and Bryan Rust (0.26 to 0.03) have all seen drop-offs in their 5-on-5 scoring, with Rust being obviously the most noticeable.

It’s always easy to suggest some sort of trade as a way to inject some life into a struggling team, but I feel like it might make sense for the Penguins now, too. The numbers above could indicate that maybe it would make sense to bring in a scoring winger, in addition to their search for center depth.

But more than any logistical concerns, a trade could also go a long way towards shaking up a team that just seems sort of stale right now. I don’t know exactly what the trade would be that makes it work — and Jim Rutherford would not make a trade just for the sake of making a trade — but the Penguins have plenty of on-ice issues to address, and could use a general locker room jolt, as well.

Advertise with us

DP: If the Senators do start a fire sale, do you think the Pens try and go after someone like Pageau or Smith.. or any other Sens player?

Pageau is the guy that makes the most sense for the Penguins to try to go after, but he would probably require a relatively hefty asking price. He’s just 25 and under contract at a reasonable cap hit ($3.1 million) until 2020. He’s solid defensively, and could provide an immediate upgrade to the Penguins’ third-line center spot (moving Riley Sheahan down to the fourth).

The problem, though, is what it would take to get him. Even if the Senators are desperate, it’s probably not wise to just assume they’re going to do something dumb (though NHL teams will often surprise you in this regard!) and assume that any trade is going to sting a little bit. It would probably take giving up a guy like Bryan Rust to get this deal done, and I’m not sure selling low on Rust is the direction the Penguins want to go at this point.

An interesting subplot to any trade negotiations, too, is Daniel Sprong’s internal and external value. It’s starting to become a bit telling that Sprong has not been called up to the NHL yet this season, while a guy like Dominik Simon got a chance (and looked pretty good) this week. Sprong has put up numbers in Wilkes-Barre, but most of them are on the power play, and by most accounts he’s still got some work to do on his overall game. It’s possible that if the Penguins get a deal they like for Sprong, they pull the trigger on it, despite his goal-scoring potential. After all, as I’ve said before, the Penguins’ top priority by a country mile is winning another Stanley Cup this year. If they think swapping, say, a draft pick and Sprong for Pageau does that, they should go for it.

Michael M.: Should Jarry see more work even when Murray comes back? Never understand why Sullivan refuses to play the backup goalie more.

Advertise with us

Let’s start with the question of will Tristan Jarry see more work when Matt Murray comes back, because that’s an easy one to answer. No, he probably won’t. As long as he has been with the Penguins, Mike Sullivan has been pretty reluctant to give his backup goalies any games not in back-to-back scenarios.

Anecdotally, yes, it’s easy to look at Murray’s injury history and say you should rest him and try and keep him fresh for the playoffs, and maybe there’s some truth to that.

But at least within the season, there’s not a whole lot of statistical evidence that Murray does a whole lot better when he’s coming off rest versus when he’s, say, playing in his third or fourth consecutive game. Murray has played in at least three consecutive games on five occasions this year, and in all but one, he’s done better in the last one than he did in the first one.

So I could see the argument that you want to do everything possible to make sure Murray’s healthy come playoff time, but the Penguins aren’t in a position where they can exactly afford to give games away right now, so that means having their best goalie in net just about every night.

Brian: Which Penguins player would you want to co-own a fantasy team with?

Advertise with us

Good question, Brian! Based on my story today about the Penguins’ locker room fantasy league, the first guy I’d rule out is Phil Kessel, because you’ve got to be able to make trades.

And as much as I would enjoy owning a team with fellow Notre Dame graduates Ian Cole, Bryan Rust or Riley Sheahan, I’m not sure how far a Deshone Kizer, Theo Riddick and Golden Tate combination would get us in a fantasy league.

I’m also going to have to pass on Massachusetts natives like Conor Sheary and Brian Dumoulin. Having Tom Brady on your team is generally good, but how much fun is rooting for the Patriots?

Honestly, based on my interviews for that story, I might have to go with Olli Maatta. Him and Justin Schultz are having a down year this year, but it sounds like Olli does a good job putting in the work and research necessary leading up to draft day, which is something I really respect.

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG