When Patric Hornqvist left early in the third period Saturday night of the Penguins’ 4-3 loss to Toronto, it forced coach Mike Sullivan to juggle his lineup a bit, with Dominik Simon moving up to Hornqvist’s place on Sidney Crosby’s wing.

The Penguins already had shaken things up early in the game after falling behind, 3-0, in the first period, with five of the eight wingers getting new centers.

That’s not exactly anything new for Sullivan and his coaching staff, though. Through the first 31 games of the season, the Penguins have been unafraid to experiment with a number of different lineups and combinations, still trying to figure out which ones they’ll be able to rely on when the games start to matter more later in the season.

“Nowadays, it’s a fine line between playing great and not playing well, so a lot of line shuffling’s going to happen,” said winger Carl Hagelin, who has played with all four of the Penguins’ centers at least.

Advertise with us

“You look around the league, it happens a lot. “

That’s one advantage the Penguins have in terms of having a decent amount of longevity and consistency in the locker room — there aren’t many players who haven’t seen at least some ice time together. So Sullivan has some options to work with.

It’s also helps the Penguins to have a number of wingers, such as Hornqvist, Bryan Rust, Conor Sheary and Carl Hagelin, who effectively can play on just about any of the four lines. There are some safe bets for the Penguins lineup on a nightly basis — Evgeni Malkin and Phil Kessel together, Ryan Reaves and Carter Rowney on the fourth line — but just about everything else is theoretically up for grabs. Heck, Tom Kuhnhackl even got a couple of games on the second line earlier this season.

“We have so many good players,” Hagelin said. “You’re just ready to play with whoever.”

Columbus Blue Jackets coach John Tortorella made some waves a month ago when he said the strategy of picking forward lines was “a bunch of [expletive].”

Advertise with us

“We try things, and if it works, it works,” Tortorella said, according to The Athletic.

Sullivan, a former Tortorella assistant, didn’t quite espouse his old boss’ line of thinking, but admitted that creating the combinations was more an art than a science.

“There’s human nature involved,” Sullivan said. “Sometimes human nature is unpredictable. For example, you can have a line together that can be dynamic for a period of time and then all of a sudden, it doesn’t work. Is there an explanation for that? I think the explanation is human nature.”

That might explain why the HBK line fizzled when reunited last season, and why the “Sid and the Kids” unit featuring Crosby, Jake Guentzel and Conor Sheary, which was on fire in the most recent postseason, hasn’t been a mainstay on the Penguins lineup card this year.

Even on this recent homestand, Sullivan kept his lineup the same for the first three games, but changed things up going into Saturday night against Toronto.

Advertise with us

“That’s why I think coaches are always tinkering with their combinations to try and take advantage of the moment and where players are at a particular point in time,” Sullivan said. “That’s the art of coaching, as opposed to the science.”

Sullivan also has some time to master the art for this specific team, as well. He toyed around just as much last year, before eventually settling on the lines that would, for the most part, stick together during the playoff run.

“I just think that’s the human element of sports, especially in instinctive games that make it a challenge,” Sullivan said. “That’s part of the most rewarding or the most fulfilling part of what we do, because when you overcome those challenges as a group and as a coaching staff, that’s how you become a team.”

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG.