Welcome back for our first December edition of the Post-Gazette Penguins mailbag. Things are looking up for the local hockey club, as the Penguins are on a season-long four-game winning streak and Sidney Crosby appears to have remembered how to score goals. The Penguins took advantage of an easy schedule last week with games against Philadelphia and Buffalo, but things will get tougher over the next few days with the Rangers, Islanders and Maple Leafs coming to town.

Remember, you can submit questions for this mailbag on Twitter @SWernerPG or email me at swerner@post-gazette.com. Away we go…

Jess: When you look at the guys the Penguins lost in free agency lost in the summer, it seems like their on-ice talent would be pretty easily replaceable (Cullen was a fourth-line center, Kunitz a grinding winger, Daley and Hainsey mid-level defensemen, etc.) but their locker room presence would be tougher to replace. Through two months, how have the Penguins done in replacing the leadership and veteran presence they lost this offseason?

Sam: Hey Jess, thanks for your question, it’s a good one. You hit the nail on the head in terms of how much locker room leadership the Penguins lost this offseason, and I think replacing it has been one of the under-the-radar story lines of these first couple of months.

Advertise with us

The Penguins will never lack for leadership as long as Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang are on the roster. Those three set the tone, and that’s no surprise. Any discussion about leadership starts with those guys.

But, to dig a bit deeper, guys such as Matt Cullen, Chris Kunitz, Nick Bonino, Trevor Daley and, heck, even Ron Hainsey were important figures on the team during last year’s Stanley Cup run.

The Penguins have done their best to fill the holes on the ice (though third-line center still seems to be a work in progress), but the intangible stuff tends to be a bit tougher.

Fortunately for the Penguins, they’ve got a good crop of young players who seem to really be finding their footing as NHL regulars, both on and off the ice. The two guys that come to mind, specifically, are Conor Sheary and Brian Dumoulin. Neither one is a “veteran presence,” but both got new contracts this offseason, and (probably as a result) seem a bit more confident and comfortable as slightly more established NHL players.

The other two guys who are important in this discussion are Patric Hornqvist and Matt Murray. Hornqvist is obviously an important presence on the bench and in the locker room, as Jason Mackey detailed. He provides an energy that not many other players can, which is a big reason why Joe Starkey wrote a persuasive column last week on why the Penguins would be wise to re-sign him long-term if possible. Hornqvist is a different type of leader than most, but an important one nonetheless.

Advertise with us

When it comes to Murray, I get the sense he has really embraced the role of No. 1 goalie, even if he won’t say so publicly. The last couple of years have been a bit awkward for him with the whole Marc-Andre Fleury situation, so he seems to have really settled into his role this year, recent injury notwithstanding. He’s still just 23, but I have to imagine he’ll be a very important figure in the Penguins’ locker room both this year and for years to come.

Amie: Last two games Schultz has played the least TOI amongst the D. Anything going on with him?

Sam: I don’t think so. It’s probably a combination of factors. First, Letang seems to have regained his role on the top power-play unit, so that will take some ice time away from Schultz. Second, these last two games against Buffalo weren’t really in doubt in the third period, so I’d bet the coaching staff saw it as an opportunity to more evenly distribute the minutes and get the guys who normally get a ton of ice time (Schultz included) some rest.

But looking a bit more broadly at the Penguins’ usage of their defensemen this season is interesting. Here’s a chart, courtesy of hockeyviz.com of defensive time on ice over the course of the season:

Penguins defensemen 2017-18 TOI (hockeyviz.com)

The minutes (Letang excepted) are converging over the past few games. Honestly, even Letang is coming down a little bit. It almost looks reminiscent of last year’s playoff run, when the Penguins had six defensemen playing essentially even minutes throughout the course of the postseason. The equation is obviously different with a guy like Letang in the lineup, but it certainly looks like Mike Sullivan and company are trending back toward evenly spread defensive minutes, which I know they saw as a distinct advantage last spring.

Advertise with us

Brandon Mciver: Hey would you think the Penguins are maybe looking at an experienced back goaltender like Curtis Mchelhinney or maybe Eddie Lack or even Michael Hutchinson?

Sam: If you ask Jim Rutherford, he’s not looking to acquire a backup goalie right now. And as things stand, why should he? Tristan Jarry has been really good in Murray’s absence and seems more than capable as a backup when Murray returns.

The only real complicating factor would be if the Penguins wanted Jarry to get regular action in Wilkes-Barre rather than sporadic time as Murray’s backup, but I don’t sense that’ll be the philosophy. The Penguins are very firmly in win-now mode, and if you have capable backup goaltending on your roster, why would you give up assets to go get someone else? Even if it’s maybe not ideal for the future, Jarry seems like he’s the best goalie they can get to be Murray’s backup right now, and that’s the most important factor.

Now if Jarry starts to struggle or if another injury hits, then sure, maybe Rutherford goes goalie shopping. There’s also the possibility that Jarry looks so good in his NHL action, he becomes a trade chip the Penguins could shop for some help up front. But other than those scenarios, I don’t think the Penguins are looking for a goalie.

Jack: What’s the latest on Ian Cole’s situation? Is he off the trading block or just back in the lineup?

Advertise with us

Sam: Well, he’s definitely back in the lineup. I don’t get the sense he’s entirely off the trading block, though. Whatever the issue was that made him a healthy scratch last week appears to have been resolved, but it still wouldn’t be surprising if the Penguins tried to move him at some point. He’s a free agent after this year, and the Penguins almost certainly won’t be able to re-sign him. Rutherford was never going to trade him just for the sake of trading him, but if the right offer comes along, he still could pull the trigger.

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG