Jason Mackey: Sorry for the delay folks. The Penguins practice here in Toronto, and I have a bunch to write. I'm trying to get something online about Evgeni Malkin but will try to tackle some of these, too, at the same time. I appreciate, as always, you thinking enough of me and the Post-Gazette to spend some time here.
Jason C: Thank you for taking questions on Thursdays it unique and awesome of you to do. Do you think GMJR will get a 3rd line Center and a back up goalie sooner rather than later? Who do you think he is Targeting?
Jason Mackey: Hi Jason. Thanks for the kind words. Second part first. Backup goalie he's going to wait and see. Not if he doesn't have to. As for 3C, yes, I do think Jim will upgrade that position. Probably related to the Cole deal. Something sneaky to watch out for, though, could be upgrading a wing spot on the third line. Heard Patrick Maroon's name tossed out in that regard today. It's interesting.
Jason C: Wow the Devs look like they could be a serious contender with this trade, does this make GMJR land a trade soon or maybe a bigger name?
NJDevils have acquired defenseman Sami Vatanen and a conditional third-round pick from Anaheim. New Jersey sends forwards Adam Henrique, Joseph Blandisi and a 2018 third-round pick to the Ducks.
Jason Mackey: I don't think GMJR is going to feel pressure at this point to play one-ups-manship with the Devils, although it does look like Ray Shero is serious.
Read More
Dave: Was hoping JR would deal Maata and not Cole, but if that’s what it will take to inject some life into this team then have at it. What is JR hoping to address; depth scoring, 3rd line center, defense, back up goalie, could go on allllll day long?
Jason Mackey: He's looking to address depth scoring with a better third-line center option. The sleeper could be a winger who has a history of putting up points. But I think the Penguins would like to get a 3C with more offensive upside than Sheahan.
Jeff: Is Chad Ruhwedel's play surprising to you at all? Do you think that he's a Dumo 2.0 (in the sense that he stepped up into the hole that Paul Martin left) or just playing well at the moment and will regress back to his expected position as 7th D? If the latter, this has to complicate the possibility of a Cole trade, right?
Jason Mackey: I think it's independent of that, Jeff. I think Ruhwedel has been good, not great. He plays the minutes he should, on the pairing he should. And he's smart. You'll never see Ruhwedel try something he's incapable of doing. Have to respect that about him.
OHIO412FAN: Jason, with the Penguins battling up and down play, is this team still capable of three-peating? Does this roster have enough depth and skill to grt
Jason Mackey: Yes. I have no questions whether or not they have the talent to threepeat. Can they put that all together? There's your question. But there's enough talent there.
Dave: Who is the next potential piece that JR is considering to move?
Jason Mackey: They shopping/listening to offers for Ian Cole. Doesn't mean GMJR will do anything, but there's definitely a sense that something will happen sooner rather than later.
OHIO412FAN: jason, with the Penguins season being most disappointing and up and down thus far, is this team still capable of three-peating? Does this team have the depth and skill to pull it through? Why not call up Sprong and Aston-Reese? At this point in the season, what needs to be improved most on for this team?
Jason Mackey: They need more depth scoring. Aston-Reese isn't at all ready. He's only a name most fans remember from the preseason, so that's why they want him up here, but he's not ready. Sprong's a little bit different. Dude can score. They need scoring. I'm surprised they haven't gone that route yet.
OHIO412FAN: Will JR make anymore trades? I know they are trying to trade Cole, what are they looking for in return for him? A Center? Forward? Depth?
Jason Mackey: I don't have a crystal ball, nor would I know what to do with one if I did. But I think, as I said, that GMJR will consider what he can get for Cole. He's doing that right now. If it's good, he'll move him for someone who can address their depth scoring issues.
Dave: Doesn’t trading Cole now go against JR’s win now mantra? Depending on what they get back and considering his last two attempts Sheahan and Pidan looks like JR is trending in the wrong direction? In Pidan’s defense, he really hasn’t gotten a look so I will give him a pass till I see some of his work.
Jason Mackey: I don't think so, Dave. It's all about appropriating assets, right? They have Ruhwedel. They can afford to move Cole. They wouldn't trade, say, Rust because they don't have anyone else who can score right now among the bottom-six. I like Ian Cole a lot as a player and a person. But he's a UFA after the season. It's not a great situation between him and Sullivan. Cole's attractive to other teams. So see what you can get for him. It's not waving the white flag.
Cosmo: I've heard tv announcers mention the "off wing", what does that mean?
Jason Mackey: If a player is a right-handed shooter playing on the left side or vice-versa.
Cosmo: Since the penguins rarely retire #s, should they have a hall of honor similar to what the Steelers have set up? There are many deserving players who could be recognized.
Jason Mackey: I believe they have something similar, although it's probably not as formal. But believe me, with the history the Penguins have, I would be completely on board with celebrating it more in an organized fashion. But I think they do do a tremendous job with past players, past teams, etc., how much they pay tribute to that stuff.
Pens4Life: I've always been curious about how trades work. Does JR confer with Sullivan before pulling the trigger on a deal? For example, did he get coach's input before bringing Reaves here? Or does he just do what he thinks is best for the team without consulting the coaching staff because he's the GM?
Jason Mackey: They talk. Jim, like Mike, gathers input. But Mike knows that Jim has the final cal. Jim also talks to his staff -- Guerin, Karmanos, Ventura, etc. ... This has been put to me many times as one of Jim's biggest strengths: his ability to seek input from all sides, then arrive at a decision. Definitively, too. That's an important trait to have.
Pens4Life: Shopping for another goalie, or do we ride DeSmith for the time being and hope he works out?
Jason Mackey: The latter.
Pens4Life: In this era of 'fake news' claims, how do reporters like yourself deal with presenting facts you get from sources, while there is denial from key players in the organization. Perfect example is the impending trade of Cole, which has been confirmed by several reputable reporters, but Head coach MS continues to claim they're not true?
Jason Mackey: I know where I got the stuff on Cole. Sullivan can say what he wants publicly. I'm tremendously confident in who told me what. Again, nothing I wrote said a trade was imminent. Just that they were trying to do.
Pens4Life: I've always enjoyed your reporting and have wondered - have there ever been difficult personalities in any locker room you've covered? I know there are some athletes who hate talking to reporters and are generally unfriendly anyway. If so, any chance I could persuade you to name any?
Jason Mackey: No. Honestly, hockey players are some of the best humans you'll encounter. Do they all love talking to the media? Heck no. I'm not stupid. But they're all respectful of our jobs, and that is very much appreciated. Especially the Penguins. Bunch of very, very good guys. Quiet, some of them. But very good human beings.
Pens4Life: Saw Starkey's column yesterday about resigning Hornqvist immediately. Any chance that's possible, or will he be too expensive?
Jason Mackey: If I was Hornqvist, I would want to go to July 1 and see what I could get. If I was GMJR, I'd want to do it now to avoid that. I do think they'll make an effort. Whether they can pull it off or not is tough to say.
Pens4Life: Given the Cole situation and the talk of his departure due to salary cap issues, does the possibility of Kessel being shopped emerge this offseason as well? Sure hope not. He's been amazing.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, that's an interesting one. It might depend on Sprong. And coming into this season, I said a lot that it would make sense to explore dealing Kessel after this season. After how good and consistent Kessel has been, I might walk that one back.
HB: im going to miss ian cole was one of my favorite defeseman on the team even if we werent going to resign him he helps on pk that doesnt really kill anything.
Jason Mackey: We're all going to miss Ian Cole.
Alex: So what is the absolute minimum a team would have to give up for Kessel?
Jason Mackey: I'm sorry, Alex. I don't have a strong sense of the market for Phil, simply because the Penguins are absolutely not trading him right now. In the offseason, I suppose, but again, with the way he's playing, that's going to be tough to do.
HB: people want JR to trade for another 3rd line center but if they do complete that trade would it include or exclude riley shenan
Jason Mackey: Exclude. Sheahan would be your 4C -- and actually a really good one -- and Rowney would move to wing, probably sending Kuhnhackl, Reaves or Hagelin to the bench. Hagelin could also be involved in the trade. I guess Kuhnhackl, too, for that matter.
Alex: Are there any religious/spiritual people on the team? I know Archibald had is child baptized in the Stanley Cup (which was amazing and hilarious)
Jason Mackey: Yes, Josh is, but other than that, I can't give you a definitive answers. Religion, much like politics, is rarely discussed in hockey dressing rooms. Just not part of the sport's culture.
LN: Hi Jason, the Pens would be crazy to trade Cole. Not only is he the most physical defenseman they have, but it would hurt their defensive depth and remove yet another key vocal leader from the locker room. If this is a personality issue with Sullivan, that sends a bad message that if you don't get along with the coach then you are gone. Not good for moral.
Jason Mackey: Thanks for your input, LN. All reasonable points made here.
Alex: So reportedly, Sprong isn’t ready to make the jump. Heard any specifics on why?
Jason Mackey: His play away from the puck and how infrequently he hits the net with his shot. Those are the two I've heard most commonly. Oh, and five-on-five production. He's been real good on the PP, but hasn't produced as much 5v5.
guest: It was really sad to see Kunitz in a Tampa uniform the other night. I think they made a big mistake in not signing him for his leadership alone and I wonder if the Pens now realize he was more valuable than they thought and regret not keeping him. I think the team is missing all of the lost leadership.
Jason Mackey: I wonder that sometimes, too. $2 million plus incentives? Seems like a bargain to me. Depth scoring would be improved, you'd think. That's probably the one thing they did/didn't do this summer that I just can't wrap my head around. If Kunitz got like 3 years, $9 million, I'd get letting him walk. Not for $2 million for one; he's worth that.
caopall: I really like how Rowney has meshed with Hagelin and Rust. Do you think the Pens will keep those three together when Geno returns?
Jason Mackey: I do not. Rowney centered the fourth line today with Kuhnhackl and Reaves.
HB: why do penguin "fans" turn on their goalies after they win cups, first fleury then murray and they wanted to replace him with fleury now they want to replace murray with jarry, im sure jarry will win the cup this year and we can all hear about how we should trade him.
Jason Mackey: People are turning on Murray? Um, people. Might want to pump the brakes there.
HB: I want to thank you for answering my questions Ed never answers my questions even tho they are just as good.
Jason Mackey: Ha. No worries, HB. I'm sure Ed gets a lot more than I do. He's Ed. I wouldn't take it personally.
Dan: Jason if Ian Cole is indeed traded are the coaches that confident in the next guy up ? Injuries are part of the game and are they comfortable with Corrado Trotman etc?? Is Tinordi a possibility?
Jason Mackey: If they trade Cole, which I think they'll do, I think they would look to acquire a 6/7 D man who can hit a little bit as some sort of insurance. Not sure any of those three are going to get extended NHL minutes any time soon.
caopall: Sports writers seem convinced that the Pens are shopping Cole. Sullivan treats the story as fake news. Seems like a lot of downside for Sullivan if he indeed knows that Cole is trade bait yet denies it so strongly to the press. What is really going on?
Jason Mackey: I reported what's going on. Then Elliotte Friedman and Bob McKenzie -- two of the heaviest hitters in our business -- confirmed it. As I said earlier, I know where I got what and stand by everything. Sullivan can downplay it all he wants. In his defense, what else is he supposed to say?
Mike Sullivan: Oh, Mackey, not how I envisioned the start of this season. Is my "just play the right way" mantra turning on deaf years? What do we need to do to get better via trades?
Jason Mackey: You get to get more than eight combined goals from your bottom-two lines. Those guys aren't scoring. Need to go get someone who will.
Ian Cole: Why Pens no like me no more? I keep hearing rumors I'm being shopped around. What gives?
Jason Mackey: Ian, I'd avoid signing that long-term lease.
Guest: Could the Pen's and JR really be dumb enough to move Cole?? Finding another Left handed defenseman who moves the puck, blocks a ton of shots and plays physical is slim and none. They can't afford to lose Cole. "PERIOD"
Jason Mackey: They were going to after this season. I like Cole a lot, but how well Ruhwedel has played has been a pleasant surprise.
Bugs Bunny: Eh, what's up, doc?
Jason Mackey: Nothin'. Chillin'.
Avi: Ian Cole for Marc-Andre Fleury. Thoughts on chances?
Jason Mackey: Zero point zero zero.
Avi: Should the Pens have signed Bonino?
Jason Mackey: No way. Not for that money and term. Good for Nick, getting the deal he did.
Avi: Is Matt Murray injury prone or unlucky?
Jason Mackey: Unlucky, I think. Voracek does that to 30 other goalies, the same thing would happen to all of them.
Avi: Is Sheahan turning a corner?
Jason Mackey: I don't know. Is he driving?
Avi: Over/under # of Stanley Cups appearances/wins if Staal never left?
Jason Mackey: 2
Avi: Should Pens fans be angry that Staal left to play with his Bro, only to see Eric say "Nah, I'm going to Minny."
Jason Mackey: Maybe. But perhaps the two post-Staal Cups they've won could assuage any negative feelings.
Avi: Jason, your chat rules!!!!!
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Avi.
Biff Zifferduffer: Have not cared for Rutherford's moves this year. Niemi should never have been an option with his decline and disaster of a season last year. Reaves doesn't add anything IMO. Hunwick, meh. Sheahan, only goal an empty netter (I felt Scott Wilson is an upgrade over Sheahan). McKegg not the answer at 3C. Clearly, the losses of Cullen, Bonino and Kunitz have hurt their depth scoring. What would a smart move or two be to get this team back on track? Sprong in the lineup can be no worse than the players on the 3rd/4th line now.
Jason Mackey: It sounds like GMJR should ask you for a smart move, Bill, not me. Just messin' with you. Said earlier about Patrick Maroon. Edmonton needs a D. Cole for Maroon as the centerpiece of a package. That would be intriguing.
Avi: You got Hags as the poster boy for this chat....Conveniently falling. Was there meaning behind this pic? Thoughts on how to get him off of the books or trade bait?
Jason Mackey: I don't set up the chat. One of my bosses does that. He needs to score first. Unless, of course, some team is high on Cole, and they can try to package Hagelin with Cole.
Michael : I think you noted awhile back, you don't like to talk about "windows of opportunity" for teams, but realistically, what is the window left with this core? 3-5 years, or are we looking at less?
Jason Mackey: I know you don't like to talk about ________ ... so here, let me ask you about _______. Think I'm going to try that one with my wife. ... I would say 3-5 years is fair, although you can't predict the future.
Mike Lange: Did you call Arnold Slick from Turtle Creek? He's looking for you.
Jason Mackey: Mikey! Miss having you around on the road.
Tina: What is your all-time favorite Air Supply song?
Jason Mackey: Whatever one is the shortest in duration.
Bill: I do not understand why no penalty for running in to the goalie Murray was not called. No pen player push him.
Jason Mackey: Fair, Bill. Got an email about that. Not sure I understand it, either.
Joe: What is the benefit to keeping Maata vs Cole?
Jason Mackey: Maatta is under contract, at a very good rate, for a couple years. Cole is out the door after the season ... so you can get something for him if you have the means to get by without him. Clearly the Penguins feel they're going to be able to do that.
Joe: What is the benefit of keeping Maata vs. Cole? Maata would attract a higher end 3rd line center while keeping Cole would help the hurting defensive blue line. Maata's missed presence would not compare to Cole. Cole could be re-signed to what Maata makes. Again all contingent on the relationship of the coaching staff and Cole
Jason Mackey: Believe I just got this one, Joe.
Ian Cole: How long will it be until Jim trades me?! I'm too good of a hockey player to be scratched day after day.
Jason Mackey: You're playing Friday, looks like.
Mickey H: Sugaree or Althea?
Jason Mackey: Ooooh, that's tough. Sugaree. But it's close.
pghgolfgirl: It looks like MAF is still out with his concussion. Any idea whether he has reached out to Sid regarding treatment, etc? Also, since MAF is gone who is Sid's seat partner on the flights?
Jason Mackey: Good question. I don't know that one. Will have to find out. I do know Reaves has started playing cards. Learned that today. With Geno, Phil and ... actually I don't know who else plays. Reaves spends a lot of time with Sid, Geno and Phil.
Sulley: How silly will my Cole rant look if GMJR trades him tomorrow? Will GMJR keep me appraised of the situation, or keep his two-time Stanley Cup winning coach in the dark? Please advise.
Jason Mackey: Might look a little weird, but Sullivan also might've been speaking on the idea that the relationship between him and Cole had been strained. He didn't specify.
Avi: Here we go Steelers, Here we....oh wait, this is a Pens chat. Lets do this Jason!!!
Jason Mackey: You got it. Although I don't actually do anything for the team, other than cover it.
HB: in regards to the joe starkey article about patric hornqvist i would love to keep him but the price ranges he thinks we can get him for is a little low i feel like people would love to throw money at him what do you feel?
Jason Mackey: I agree. I think he's already priced himself out of Pittsburgh if he gets to July 1.
HB: We lost alot of character but if you look around the league i feel like in the league you see alot of insane young talent but not alot of young character guys and i know character is built through experience but you identify mcdavid as the next crosby but you cant really identify the next hornqvist if you understand what i mean?
Jason Mackey: I do. Which is why it's that much more important to sign Hornqvist to an extension. Aren't a lot of those dudes around.
Sarah in Philly: Hi Jason, love your work and following my hometown teams while living over here on the "other" side of the state. Question about the Pens core of Sid, Geno, Phil, and Letang who are all 30 or 31 currently. With the way the game is being played now - more speed, fewer dirty/dangerous hits, what is a reasonable expectation for how long these guys might play? Obviously major injury or multiple minor ones can shorten the window, but have these 4 ever said or indicated how long they want to play? Could you imagine them hanging around (and producing) until Jagr age?? haha just kidding about that one... sort of...
Jason Mackey: HI Sarah. Thanks for the kind words. Appreciate you hanging out. They have not said. I think Sid could pull a Jagr. He loves hockey that much. If Letang could stay healthy, maybe he would. I don't know if I see Phil or Geno sticking around that long. Either way, I don't think we're at the end-of-the-career spot yet, nor do I think we're even close to it.
RPK: I don't see much out of #15. Does not use his size or have a finishing touch. Your thoughts?
Jason Mackey: Not enough, anyway. I like his D zone play, faceoffs, PK, all that's great. Responsible player. Won't embarrass himself. Has fit in nicely to the team. Just not enough offense.
JP: If the Pens move Cole, what do you see them getting back? Would it be a RHD, a 3C or a depth scoring player?
Jason Mackey: 3C or depth-scoring player. If they get a D, that might be a part, but it wouldn't be the primary component.
Paul: GMJR recently stated he's concerned with the offensive production of the third line (rightfully so), but downplayed the production of the fourth line. A big reason for winning back-to-back was the depth and production of all four lines. Do you think it's time to bring in some more talent for the fourth line? Maybe swap out McKegg and Kuni with some WBS Pens with some more offensive upside?
Jason Mackey: I don't, Paul. And here's why: They don't have anyone ready to fill those roles. Sprong is the closest, but he's not a fourth-line guy. We saw that with Mike Johnston. He needs to play with other talented players. As for someone like, Teddy Blueger, who profiles more as a bottom-six guy in the NHL, he's simply not knocking down the door yet.
JP: Part 2: I would think Bozak as that C, Maroon as the depth scoring or Gudbranson as RHD. Anything on those players or others? Thank you :)
Jason Mackey: I like all three, believe me. If their current teams are willing to deal for a reasonable rate, I'd say go. Last I heard Toronto wanted Dumo. That's not happening.
RPK: Will the defense step up and play more physical in front of 2 very inexperienced goalies? They tend to do a lot of chasing when applying the body would slow opposing forwards.
Jason Mackey: I think this could be interesting. Wouldn't be the first time a change in goal spurred a team to play a more responsible brand of hockey. Could happen here.
Cbash: Is Malkin close to playing again?
Jason Mackey: He should be back Friday.
Bruce: Do you see the Penguins shopping Hagelin as well? With possible Hornqvist extension and Rust raises upcoming, 4 million could be used elsewhere.
Jason Mackey: Absolutely. But who is gonna pay $4 million for seven goals in 86 games? Nobody.
JohnJaso2: Why do the Yinzers on this board constantly complain about Reaves. The bottom 6 forwards all have produced little goal output. Reaves was not acquired to score 10-15 Goals. He was acquired to provide some Grit and Pushback. Based on the games I have watched you have not seen as many vicious hits to smaller players (Sheary,Rust,Letang) that have caused them to miss games. It would seem to me Reaves is producing what is asked of him. What say you.
Jason Mackey: I like what Reaves brings. I do hear from a lot of folks who think that's a wasted spot. I sort of get it. What I don't understand is why they continue to play him against skating teams, games where maybe you don't need him. I also find the complaining futile. Rutherford and Sullivan -- and the players -- love the guy. Nothing's changing here.
Jeff: How hard do you think Rutherford/Pens pursue a re-sign with Hornqvist? I can see the arguments that his playstyle doesn't lend itself well to a lengthy contract extension, but a lot of stock is placed on his energy and competitiveness.
Jason Mackey: I think they pursue one, as long as what Hornqvist's camp is asking for isn't outlandish. I honestly don't know of the ask on that side.
Cbash: What is the correct pronunciation of Jarry? I noticed the Tom and Jerry cartoon characters on his helmet, so is it pronounced Jerry? Or are the characters for some other reason?
Jason Mackey: JAR-ree. Like a Jarry of peanut butter.
Mike B: Hi Jason - I doubt it since it would be within the division, but were the Pens in on Henrique at all?
Jason Mackey: I've heard no indications that they were.
Paul: Daniel Sprong has solid numbers down in WBS (9 goals, 14 points in 17 games played). But he's also one of only four players on the team with a negative plus/minus rating. Do you feel he will play a role for Pittsburgh this year, or do you feel someone like Simon, Dea or Blueger have a better chance of being called up?
Jason Mackey: I think Sprong will play a role. If they don't start scoring more goals, it would be soon.
Bill S: Why was there no penalty for running into the goalie (Murray)? It appear no pen player push or touch him.
Jason Mackey: I don't know. I've been asked this. I don't have an answer for you. It looks like a blown call to me, too. Unfortunately the NHL doesn't let us ask officials why they do or don't do certain things. Would love to hear an explanation, too.
Kevin : Hey Jason, if the Pens can't find an immediate trade for Ian, do they start playing him again especially with the goalie issue? Can't imagine the Pens would want worse defense in front of less experienced goalies.
Jason Mackey: Yes, that's part of it. I also think it's best for everyone involved for Cole to play and for everyone to try to pretend this doesn't exist -- until a move is made. But he's absolutely been one of their best defensemen. Numbers prove that. He should be playing regardless.
John: What do you make of Cole being paired with Schultz at practice today? Do you think they are showcasing him by pairing him with his most comfortable d partner?
Jason Mackey: Could be. I also think that's how you get the most out of him. I think they want to move past this, and that probably affords the easiest way of doing it. Until the deal, of course, not move past and act like it never happened. I still believe they're at least aggressively exploring their trade options with him.
Konstantin Koltsov: What do you think a realistic return on Ian Cole would be? Love this chat by the way!
Jason Mackey: Thank you! They should be able to get a third-line player, preferably center, under club control for a couple years at a reasonable rate. One who can score, too. Cole is a really good player. Players like him are in demand. He can afford to be a little choosy.
Paul: By going back-to-back, some of the players have to be a little burnt out. When a slight injury occurs (think Malkin), do you think the team is more likely to prolong the recovery time and allow the player to get the rest while they can? Thanks for the chat Jason!
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think you might be onto something Paul. We're seeing it with Sid, Letang and Phil skipping morning skates. There does seem to be a tacit understanding that they've played a lot of hockey, and they're going to try and get some rest any way they can. This injury for Malkin in the playoffs ... yeah, he's playing.
Chad: Jason, has there been any interest at all with evander kane? Seems like he could be a solid fit on the wing. Character concerns might be why we’d be hesitant to inquire.
Jason Mackey: Ding, ding, ding.
alan smith: Pens need a center but they still seem loaded for another cup run. Rust and others are difference makers. They score 4 the Pens score five. Love the offense and they are the best ever at it! Go Pens!
Jason Mackey: Thanks for chipping in, Alan.
Constantino: Is there a sense of urgency starting to permeate the team? A third of the way through the season, they're a game north of seventh place in the division (by points percentage).
Jason Mackey: I think there's a sense of being a little pissed off they're not better. Maybe that's urgency. Maybe that's taking pride in what you do.
John: You mentioned Marron earlier, Does a Maroon for Cole trade make sense to you?
Jason Mackey: It does. So long as Maroon can skate. But the dude produced with McDavid last season. Can't be that bad, right?
alan smith: The Pens are coming on every game. Crosby has no match! As long as he plays they will always be contenders. They can't play at the same level as Cup play demands. Broken hands, destroyed bodies and blood! The team will be there when it counts!
Jason Mackey: I'm OK with the odd comment here and there, but dude, you're hijacking my chat.
RandomHockeyGuy: You've touched a little on the WBS callup aspect. What about Thomas DiPauli? Penguins seemed to like his speed and defensive work, and he's off to hot start scoring wise in WBS. Would seem like a good LW/C callup for the 4th line. As for Sprong, not sure I agree he's ready for a try. He was leading the AHL in scoring to start the season, but has been pointless for a good number of games now. He also had 5 of his 9 goals on the powerplay, which he is doubtful to get much PP time on this team.
Jason Mackey: Good point on Sprong. That worries me, too. And you're right on Di Pauli. I'd counter with this: If Archibald isn't playing -- and they're similar players -- what does Di Pauli bring that Archibald doesn't? Maybe scoring, but Archibald hasn't even gotten the chance.
Dave: What would it take to get Maroon?
Jason Mackey: Maybe Cole and a prospect/pick?
Constantino: What's the team's view of Murray's performance? The numbers are below league-average, but the way the team's played in front of him would seem a big asterisk affixed to those stats.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think that's fair. I think Murray certainly has played better, but you gotta cut the kid some slack. They've had some really bad defensive efforts in front of him.
JamesinNYC: Just performance with Cole or some other problem?
Jason Mackey: It ain't even close to performance.
RandomHockeyGuy: What's your take on Ryan Reaves? I was a fan of the trade when it happened. Didn't expect him to magically make cheap shots disappear by being dressed, but thought he could help the team. It seems either he hasn't lived up to the skillset the Penguins thought he had, or Sullivan isn't keen on dressing him. Based on production and usage, seems he should be more in a rotation rather than every game starter.
Jason Mackey: Wouldn't be a Thursday chat without Ryan Reaves questions. I like Reaves. I think he adds something to the team. I'd play him more 9-10 minutes. And if he sucked, then I'd bench him. And I'd have a clear reason why. I don't understand dressing a guy if you're going to play him 3-5 minutes. That's a wasted spot.
Next Man Up?: If they trade Cole and insert Ruhewedel full time who would be the next Ruhwedel (7th defenseman)?
Jason Mackey: They'd probably go get someone. I don't think it would be anyone from WBS, at least not for any extended stretch or if that guy had to play.
Joe: think we'll ever see flower in a pens uni again? i say yes as a backup one more ride for the cup? your input
Jason Mackey: How are they going to fit $5.75 million in salary? Plus, he's even playing for Vegas right now!
Carl: An chance the pens look at Evander Kane as a trade target?
Jason Mackey: I don't think so. Character issues.
JamesinNYC: Do you think the Pens can "turn it on" during the playoffs? I sort of understand the lackluster play after 2 cups though I am sure they want to win a 3rd.
Jason Mackey: I think it's early. I don't think we need to worry about "turning it on" quite yet. They're working on their game, building it, correcting things.
HB: turned is a strong but if you have ever looked at the pens sub-reddit they think we should of kept fluery gave away murray.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I won't be checking out the Pens sub-reddit, whatever that means. Too much of an old soul for that one.
Ryan Reaves: Was I worth bringing in and will I even finish the season as a Penguin? Or, will I simply be a healthy scratch during the entire playoff run?
Jason Mackey: Not sure, Ryan. Sully and Jim love you, though. Seems like you're good.
Matt: If the pens do trade Cole, what are the odds someone like Hagelin is included that deal?
Jason Mackey: I think there are odds, but I don't know how great. Don't know if Cole is enough of an incentive for someone to take that contract. Maybe the Oilers would be, with how much they need defensemen.
Mario Lemieux: Do you think my 5 goals 5 different ways edged out Bobby Orr's Cup Clinching OT goal in voting?
Jason Mackey: It should.
guest: If Jarry plays as well as he did against Tampa while Murray is out, do you think a goalie controversy could develop?
Jason Mackey: It's interesting, isn't it? You don't often remove the hot hand. I wouldn't call it a controversy. I think what they would do would be to be a little bit more free in how they used Murray. I.e, not a traditional starter/backup split.
Chad: Ideal target for this team
Jason Mackey: I still think Tyler Bozak. But it depends on what you would have to give up.
MM: Did you ever find out why I always refer to you as Mackie on the air?
Jason Mackey: I did not.
James: If the pens were to trade Hagelin now, would they have to add a draft pick in order for a team to be willing to take him?
Jason Mackey: They'd have to add a lot more than a draft pick.
Jasom: Why people think we will 3-peat with this current line up of mediocre offense is beyond me.
Jason Mackey: There's a lot of time between now and April. It will change.
Jim Rutherford: Who should I trade cole for?
Jason Mackey: A third-line center or someone who can address your depth-scoring issues.
Evander Kane: any chance I end up in a penguins uniform? I hear the Sabres don't love me no more and will retain salary
Jason Mackey: I don't think so, no.
Guest: Is there a chance the Pens make a deal to acquire a Top 6 winger? Crosby staying with Sheary and Hornqvist. Malkin with Rust and the new player and Kessel with Guentzel and a potential new 3C or Sheahan. Or is that type of deal not very likely for the Pens?
Jason Mackey: It's not very likely. They have guys to fill those spots.
Mario: Wait we need a 3rd line center? Let me see if my sweater still fits.
Jason Mackey: You'd still score 20-30 goals.
staalout: Given that San Jose made a run with Thorton and Marleau two seasons ago, wouldn't it seem reasonable that the Pens window for Sid and Geno could be similar to the one San Jose has experienced?
Jason Mackey: Sure, absolutely. But I hate windows.
RPK: Will there be another check in the defensive zone after Cole is traded?
Jason Mackey: Ha, yes. They'll get someone who plays a little more physical. Andrey Pedan is one to watch. He plays that game. Might not be ready, though.
Doug: Hey Jason I really like Greg McKegg's two way game, any chance Sully would play him on the wing with Rowney and Kuhnhackl?
Jason Mackey: Possibly. Gives Sullivan a backup center, which he likes.
Chad: Flyers are trending down. Could you ever imagine a scenario where we’d be trade partners? Simmonds maybe? The exact winger the pens could use
Jason Mackey: That won't happen. Very rare for teams to trade inside the division.
L: How much is the "in the room"/personality/leadership/morale side of things considered in trade/signing decisions? Just thinking about that regarding Cole and especially Hornqvist (really liked Starkey's column yesterday!) and how much the Pens have lost on that side of things lately. (There was an interesting article from a Caps reporter about their players lobbying to resign Oshie helping sway mgmt to do so, wondered how uncommon that was.)
Jason Mackey: It's taken into consideration, but GMs are ultimately going to do what's best for their team, in their minds, not what the players necessarily want. But it is a factor. Just depends on how much of one.
HB: im surprised that cole and sullivan butt head since cole seems like a good solider doing the jobs that have little glory and more bad press if they play bad.
Jason Mackey: Cole isn't afraid to speak his mind. On anything. I don't think that sits terribly well with Sully. Just a hunch I have.
Jason: How people think the Pens can 3-peat with this mediocre offense is beyond me,what say you?
Jason Mackey: I think the offense will look drastically different in a couple months with a trade, maybe two and Daniel Sprong.
Dave: Why not just buy out Hag
Jason Mackey: I think there's a belief that he'll start scoring. You might disagree with that, and I understand why. But sort of a holding-out-hope thing so they wouldn't be paying money for nothing ... while also not getting any chicks for free.
CC: Jason. the penguins showed some interest in Evander Kane before he went to buffalo. Word is buffalo is looking to trade him and willing to retain. What are the odds that the pens trade Cole to buffalo?
Jason Mackey: I don't think very good. I keep getting asked this, but I see no way this works money-wise. I also worry about what I've been told character-wise. Not sure there's a fit there. But yes, they did like him as a player.
guest: If the Pens desperately need the cap space and cannot find a trade partner, could they just cut Haglin to save the money? Not ideal but could use that elsewhere.
Jason Mackey: They could buy him out, but the hope is that they wouldn't have to do that.
Constantino: On Evander Kane, "ding ding ding" that Pens have inquired, or that character stuff would preclude it?
Jason Mackey: That character stuff would probably preclude it.
Jason: What do you think Cole and Sprong would fetch a great return? Not convinced Sprong is as good as people claim..
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I'm not sure its worth it to deal Sprong at this point. The return doesn't outweight the potential loss.
Papa John: What sort of Centers are available that we could we could get in return for Cole?
Jason Mackey: Have heard COL, TOR and VGK. Maybe Bozak? Haula?
guest: why not wait until closer to trade deadline to trade Cole?
Jason Mackey: They could. But there's also off-the-ice stuff to consider and how much longer both sides wanted this to continue. The Penguins also could use a spark of some sort right now, specifically an offensive spark.
Brian: Im just joining now so if this was already asked my bad. When do you think cole will be traded and what are the penguins looking to get?
Jason Mackey: Soon and a 3C/depth-scoring option.
Kevin: Do you think GMJR would reconsider keeping Kunitz or bonino if he had a mulligan for this past offseason?
Jason Mackey: Kunitz yes, Bonino no. Bonino got too sweet of a deal for the Penguins to reasonably match.
Bob: Are the pens gonna try and get a bottom 6 centremen soon?
Jason Mackey: Yes, talks are ongoing now, I believe, as they relate to the Penguins shopping Cole.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it. Have a bunch more to write and drive to Buffalo. Thanks for participating!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.