Welcome back for another edition of our weekly Penguins’ mailbag. The Penguins are 12-10-3, and coming off a 5-2 win against Tampa Bay on Saturday night, a victory that ended a three-game losing skid. Any win over the Eastern Conference leaders is a good thing, but there could be some concern that the result came largely thanks to a special teams advantage, and that the Penguins may not have cured their 5-on-5 scoring issue quite yet. Their next game is Monday night against Philadelphia.

As things currently stand, the Penguins are one point out of the final Eastern Conference playoff spot, with most of their competitors holding games in hand. We’re barely a quarter of the way through the season, but it’s fair to say the Penguins are on the playoff bubble at the moment.

Remember, as always, you can submit questions for this mailbag at swerner@post-gazette.com or on Twitter @SWernerPG.

Let’s get to the questions…

Advertise with us

Casey Shaffer's Ego: What do you think is going on with Ian Cole being a healthy scratch? I haven't noticed his play being anything other than fairly solid. Is it likely to be a trade or is something else going on?

This is probably the biggest question surrounding the Penguins right now. Ian Cole has been a healthy scratch for the last two games, and appears to be one again tonight against the Flyers. When asked after the game against Boston, Mike Sullivan simply said it was a “coach’s decision” and that “performance always is the dictator.” When asked about it Monday morning, he explained a bit further … but not really.

“He has been a very important player for us, and he is a very important player for us,” Sullivan said. “Colesy and I have had a number of conversations over the last few weeks about his game and the coaches’ assessment and specific areas where we think he can help us and help improve his game. We’ve spoken about that. The specifics of those conversations, I think, are between him and the coaching staff. But certainly he is a guy that we think can really help us, as far as the type of game that we’re trying to play. He’s been an invaluable player for our team here for quite a long time and that hasn’t changed.”

That’s a lot of words to say not a whole lot. For what it’s worth, Jason caught up with Cole this morning, but he didn’t really clarify the situation too much, either, except to say he was not enjoying that healthy scratch life.

There are a couple of explanations possibly at play here. The first, and this one is probably the Occam’s razor scenario, is that Sullivan simply thinks Cole is the Penguins’ seventh-best defenseman right now. The Penguins have a deep blue line, and someone is going to be left out. Chad Ruhwedel has been really good this season, and Matt Hunwick’s return made it tough to find space for him. You don’t want to take Hunwick out, since he just missed a month, and Justin Schultz, Olli Maatta and Brian Dumoulin are all playing really well. Kris Letang has certainly been up and down, but come on, you’re not healthy scratching Kris Letang. That leaves Cole. His underlying numbers (as Jason pointed out) have been really good this year, but it’s possible that Sullivan and the coaching staff see something that numbers (and fans) miss. It doesn’t make a whole lot of sense from the outside but, hey, he’s won two more Stanley Cups than any of us.

Advertise with us

The other scenario seemingly at play would be if Jim Rutherford is close to pulling the trigger on a deal involving Cole. If two teams are on the verge of a trade, it’s not unheard of for one of the GMs to ask that the player he’s about to trade for be taken out of the lineup to avoid injury. The Penguins shipping Cole out probably makes some sense, too. Especially with Ruhwedel proving to be a reliable every-night option, they have depth at defense, and Cole is almost certainly on his way out this summer as an unrestricted free agent, anyways. Evgeni Malkin’s injury has put into stark relief the fact that they still probably need some center depth, so it wouldn’t be surprising if Cole is part of the trade to bring some in. The puzzling thing about this scenario is how long it has taken. It’s reasonable to hold a guy out for a game or two, especially given the back-to-back over the weekend, but three games? At a certain point, you need to either make the deal or not, and get back to putting your best team on the ice.

Either way, the situation seems pretty untenable long-term. My guess is you’ll see Cole either back in the lineup or on another team by the end of the week.

Carey Zivkovich: Should Murray see a few more days off? Jarry looked good vs TB and without looking the stats up Murray seems let up 4 goals a game. He needs to be the man so not suggesting full on bench him just maybe a few more nights off. Thoughts?

For the record, Murray’s goals against average is 2.94 this season, which is 21st among goalies with at least 15 starts. His save percentage currently sits at .906, which is 19th. I think you’ll probably see that number creep up a bit towards his career average of .920 as the season goes on.

But to your point about Jarry: Yeah, I think that’s certainly something worth considering. He has been good in his three starts, and seems perfectly capable of being an NHL backup goalie at this point.

Advertise with us

I’m not sure the concern is really about Murray’s performance, though. He has had five nights off so far this year. In the games following those nights off he has given up three goals, one goal, four goals and four goals. We’ll find out how he does in the fifth one tonight. It’s not like he does a whole lot better after he gets a game off (on the contrary, Murray actually tends to have his best games when he’s coming off a bad start).

I do think there’s some value in resting him, though, because even though he has been pretty durable this season, that concern is always there with him after last season. The Penguins really, really can’t afford to have Murray injured for a long period, especially in the playoffs. So minimizing his risk of injury should probably be a factor here.

All that being said, I don’t think they’re going to do it. Sullivan likes having one starting goalie who plays just about every night when healthy. He even did last year when he had Marc-Andre Fleury on the roster. Jarry will continue to get games in back-to-backs, but that will probably be just about it.

Brandon Mciver: What are your thoughts on the Bozak and Pacioretty trade rumours?

Bozak makes a lot more sense than Pacioretty. The Penguins are still pretty thin at center — and Malkin’s injury is a good reminder of that — so Bozak would make sense as a depth addition at that spot. He’s a name that has been floated in connection with the Penguins for a while now, and already has a history of playing with Phil Kessel (which is probably something any center addition is going to have to do).

Advertise with us

Pacioretty I don’t really see, unless Rutherford feels like he’s getting a value deal that he just can’t turn down. The Penguins have plenty of wingers, and if they want to try and add scoring on the wing, why not look at an internal option like Daniel Sprong first? Adding Pacioretty would require dealing away assets to add at a position you don’t really need, while a legitimate need (center) is still unaddressed. If the Penguins and Canadiens are trying to make a deal, a guy like Alex Galchenyuk might make more sense. The Habs haven’t had him at center, but the Penguins might be willing to give it a shot. Or maybe Tomas Plekanec, whose contract is up after this year, although that would almost certainly have to involve Montreal eating a whole lot of salary.

JFactor: Why are you watching Canadian football?

Because last night’s Grey Cup was awesome.

NorthPaulJ: Something that i often think about: Do players get annoyed when fans call them by their teammates pet-names? "Kuni" "Geno" "Ovi" "Alfie" "Zubie"... I mean, we haven't earned the right to call them by those names, have we?

I don’t think they mind, though it is always something I feel a bit awkward about. I generally adhere to Paul Shirley’s rule of nicknames (explained in his great book “Can I Keep My Jersey?”) If you weren’t around for the creation of the nickname, you probably shouldn’t use it. The problem in an NHL locker room is that the nicknames are ubiquitous, to the point where referring to Justin Schultz as “Justin” rather than “Schultzy” sounds more awkward than using a nickname that you might not have earned the right to use.

Advertise with us

I feel like the rule of thumb here should be you’re OK using the nicknames, as long as they’re just some boring variation of the player’s first or last name (which, let’s be honest, 99 percent of hockey nicknames are). That means Kuni, Geno, Schultzy, Rusty and Sid are all fair game.

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG