Exactly one year ago Tuesday, Mike, Sally and Ryan Guentzel were sitting around appetizers and drinks Downtown before a Penguins game that night at PPG Paints Arena against the New York Rangers.

Ryan turned to his dad, a longtime hockey coach, and asked what he thought reasonable expectations were for younger brother Jake’s NHL debut later that night.

“Well hopefully he plays about 10 minutes, doesn’t make a mistake,” Mike responded. “Maybe get an assist because he’s playing with Phil and Malkin.”

Not quite.

Advertise with us

Tuesday marked the anniversary of Jake Guentzel’s unforgettable first big-league game, in which he scored two goals on his first two shots. In the year since, he established himself as a top-flight goal-scorer, challenged the rookie record for goals in a postseason and, oh yeah, won a Stanley Cup.

“Kind of a crazy year,” Jake, typically understated, said Tuesday. “A lot of nerves and excitement of course. That whole [first] day was kind of a blur, you don’t really remember much. But a dream come true and cool to look back now.”

It all started on a Sunday afternoon in November 2016. Ryan was at home in Minnesota watching football, when he saw an incoming call from Jake’s phone.

“I look at my phone and I’m like, ‘Why is Jake calling me?’” Ryan said. “He never really calls, he just texts. I was kind of like, ‘What’s going on?’ He let me know that he was getting the call up and he was heading to Pittsburgh that afternoon. You could just tell in his voice that he was really excited about the opportunity.”

As Jake made the drive west across Pennsylvania, his family scrambled for a flight. Mike, an assistant at the University of Minnesota, let his team know he wasn’t going to be at practice that Monday, and Sally booked the first flight she could for Pittsburgh that next morning.

Advertise with us

The three met up with Jake before the game and went down to the arena with him. As they were killing time before the game started, they got a call from Jake’s other brother, Gabe, who plays professionally in Germany. He said he was going to stay up to watch the game, and offered up a more prophetic prediction:

“You know what? Jake’s going to get a goal.”

Even that wasn’t exactly accurate. He got two. In his first NHL period, on his first two NHL shots.

Ryan had his phone out to capture Jake’s first shift on Snapchat, and after the video stopped recording, he watched the play develop on his phone. Trevor Daley recovered a puck in the neutral zone and fed it ahead to Phil Kessel. Kessel slid it to Guentzel on the left wing. Guentzel fired a low shot from the left faceoff dot.

“Not thinking much, maybe get a rebound, and all of a sudden it’s in the back of the net,” Ryan recalled. “Our reactions got the best of us I think.”

Advertise with us

That’s for sure. The video of the three reacting in the stands quickly spread like wildfire on social media.

“It was just one of those experiences,” Ryan said. “You’re hoping that he does well, you’re not planning for anything big to happen and you kind of let your emotions get the best of you. My dad was shocked, I was just pure joy and I don’t think my mom knew how to react.”

Ryan said his phone quickly started blowing up with texts from friends who had seen his reaction. Jake saw the video in the first intermission when a teammate showed him on Twitter.

“I don’t know who it was between periods came up to me and just said, ‘Your brother’s going all over Twitter right now,’” Jake said. “I was like, ‘Oh no.’ The first time you see it, it’s kind of embarrassing, but then you realize how excited and proud they are. It was definitely a cool moment for my family.”

He added his second career goal later in the first period. That time, his family’s reaction was a bit more measured. They acted like they had been there before.

Advertise with us

Jake was hardly done there, though. In the months that followed, he scored 14 more to give him 16 in 40 NHL games. He added 13 more in the playoffs, one shy of breaking Dino Ciccarelli’s rookie record.

“It’s crazy because he’s always been my little brother,” Ryan said. “You’re always hoping as a brother that he would make it to the NHL, he had that potential. But, one, to get there and then to back it up and have the performance that he did last year, through the playoffs.”

Now, Jake is a mainstay in the Penguins’ top six forwards, usually on Sidney Crosby’s left wing. He has six goals through 22 games, and there’s no reason to think that pace shouldn’t pick up once the Penguins offense gets clicking. Guentzel has been every bit the goal-scorer he showed on that first night in the NHL.

“That’s not a bad way to start,” coach Mike Sullivan said. “I’m sure it was a thrill for him and his family, when you have the start of your NHL career like that. That’s a great memory for him, and certainly he hasn’t taken any steps back. He continues to get better, and he’s had pretty good success from that point on. We’re hoping that he can continue to be that player for us.”

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG.