Welcome back for another edition of the Post-Gazette Penguins mailbag, Thanksgiving week edition. The Penguins are 11-8-3, tied for first place in the Metropolitan Division. They are coming off a 2-1 loss to Chicago Saturday, their first regulation defeat on home ice this season. They still have a very friendly stretch of schedule coming up, with eight of next 10 games at PPG Paints Arena starting Wednesday against Vancouver.
Remember, as always you can drop your questions at swerner@post-gazette.com or on Twitter @SWernerPG. Away we go…
Jim F.: What’s the deal with the penalty kill recently? I know they had to work some new guys in there this year, but it seems like they’re giving up multiple power-play goals on a nightly basis.
Well it seems that way, Jim, because they are. The Penguins have given up two power-play goals in four of their last five games. Against Chicago, it was all the offense the Blackhawks needed to come away with a win.
Perhaps the strangest thing about the penalty-killing issues is that it doesn’t seem to really be a personnel problem, per se. Yes, losing guys like Nick Bonino, Matt Cullen, and Olli Maatta necessitated some new faces stepping in at the beginning of this season, but up until this recent stretch of poor play, the penalty kill had actually been OK. Not great, mind you, but 81.5 percent over the first 17 games is fine. Keep that up over the course of the whole season, and you’re probably looking at a kill percentage ranked in the top 12-ish of the NHL.
The Penguins weren’t particularly good on the penalty kill last season, finishing 20th in the league at 79.8 percent, so it’s not like they need to become a shut-down unit to be a successful all-around team. The Penguins really just need to get their penalty kill to “not giving up multiple goals a game” status, and they should be fine.
Read More
In that regard, there might be a part of Mike Sullivan that knows he doesn’t necessarily have the pieces or system to become a top-flight short-handed team, and so the solution — and he always brings this up when talking about the penalty kill — is simply taking fewer penalties. If the Penguins are killing penalties at only 75 percent, taking three penalties a game as opposed to five works out to one fewer power-play goal against per game. Now, obviously they’d like that kill percentage to be higher, but staying out of the box serves the same purpose, and might be the easier solution for this team.
That all being said, it also could help getting Matt Hunwick and Carter Rowney back into the mix as well. Those are two guys experienced on the penalty kill who should help shore up some minutes there.
Jeremy J.: What is with Ryan Reaves getting so much playing time? He doesn’t bring anything to the lineup, and hardly seems to have worked as a deterrent against dirty play on Malkin and Sid. Josh Archibald brings more and should be playing or, better yet, time to get Sprong up from Wilkes-Barre!
I wouldn’t hold your breath on Reaves coming out of the lineup any time soon. Based on practice today, it looks like Archibald will get a crack at some ice time against Vancouver Wednesday, but it will probably come at the expense of Tom Kuhnhackl, not Reaves.
Look, I get that Reaves is a controversial figure among the Penguins fan base, but the Penguins like what he has brought to their lineup so far. I think part of the problem with Reaves is he’s one of the guys who gets hurt the most when the Penguins spend half the game on the penalty kill. The fourth line is getting limited minutes as it is, but since he’s a guy that doesn’t kill penalties (that experiment seems to have been aborted) that takes away some of his already sparse shifts.
I actually think the fourth line in general has had some nice games over the past week or so. They’ve been sustaining some offensive zone time and, maybe more importantly, not getting beat the other way for goals against. The other positive trend for Reaves, specifically, is that he has stayed out of the box in recent games (only one minor penalty in his last seven).
This fourth line is a different looking fourth line than the Penguins have had under Mike Sullivan. That was probably always going to happen with the departure of Matt Cullen, but the addition of Reaves made it a certainty. Sullivan spoke a few games back about the importance of this line finding its own identity within the Penguins’ system, and that’s still probably a work in progress. It’s a change — and when you’re coming off back-to-back titles, it’s certainly fair to question and/or criticize that change — but it still seems a bit premature to write it off as a complete failure.
Richard L.: Daniel Sprong is absolutely tearing up the AHL. Any rumblings on when we could see him up in the big leagues?
The time is probably coming up pretty soon.
The easy comparison is to look back on how the Penguins handled Jake Guentzel last season. They recalled Guentzel from Wilkes-Barre/Scranton on Nov. 21, 2016 (one year ago tomorrow #tbt), at which point he had 17 points (7G, 10A) in his first 16 AHL games. Sprong, for comparison’s sake, has 14 points (9G, 5A) through 14 AHL games so far this season.
Realistically, you’re probably going to see Sprong in Pittsburgh as soon as a top-nine winger gets injured. As much as the Penguins could use an injection of offense right now, it’s probably a bit unrealistic to expect them to make Carl Hagelin a healthy scratch just to call up Sprong (as much sense as that might make right now).
It’s also probably important to temper expectations a bit when it comes to Sprong. Yes, he has the raw talent, but I think the longevity of the hype (basically since he played in the NHL two years ago) plus Guentzel’s meteoric success last year might have the bar a bit too high. He has the talent to be a really good NHL scoring winger, but he’s not going to immediately cure the Penguins’ offensive woes as soon as he comes up. It’s more likely the guys currently on the roster figure their problems out and start scoring more goals than it is a 20-year-old comes in and lights the world on fire.
Dawn R.: Where do things stand with the goalie situation? Is the plan to just keep Jarry as Murray’s backup for the rest of the season?
That’s probably the most likely plan right now, but it doesn’t mean that’ll be the case a month or two months from now. As soon as the Antti Niemi experiment went up in flames, Jim Rutherford seems to have conceded that the goaltending situation will be pretty fluid for the rest of the year. If Jarry keeps playing well — and he has so far — he could certainly stay up as the backup (with maybe a few stints for Casey DeSmith thrown in, as well). But if Jarry starts to struggle, or if the Penguins decide they want him to get back to consistent playing time, I wouldn’t rule out a move for a veteran backup.
The former seems like it would necessitate a move more than the latter, though. The Penguins’ primary objective is winning the Stanley Cup this year, full stop. If Tristan Jarry is the best backup goalie they can get, he should be their backup goalie, even if it means deviating from his planned developmental schedule.
Perhaps the toughest part of this season for the Penguins has been the reality check of just how lucky they were the last two years. Now, they’re basically a normal NHL team, in that if their starting goalie gets hurt going into the playoffs, they’re in a whole lot of trouble. There’s no move they can make that would land them a goalie capable of winning two playoff series (well, maybe unless it’s the Capitals again. Because Capitals). Welcome to the real world.
Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.