Greetings, hockey fans, and welcome back for another edition of the Penguins mailbag. To set the stage, the Penguins are 9-7-3 and tied for second place in the Metropolitan Division. They’re coming off a two-game weekend back-to-back that included a 4-1 loss to Washington Friday and a 5-4 shootout loss in Nashville. The offense, though, did show some signs of life against the Predators and could be close to getting out of its funk. They’ll be back in action Tuesday night against Buffalo. As a reminder, you can submit questions for this mailbag to swerner@post-gazette.com or on Twitter @SWernerPG. And away we go…
Danielle: It’s about 20 games into the season, and the Pens STILL needs a 3C and they’re up against the cap. In your opinion, do you think GMJR will move Hags or Horny? And if not them, who?
Sam: So the first part of this question is assessing the long-term viability of Riley Sheahan as the Penguins’ third-line center. The jury is still very much out in that regard. My colleague Jason Mackey took a look last week about how Sheahan is fitting in, and a lot of what he wrote still stands. Sheahan has been OK through his first 10 games as a Penguin but hasn’t lit the world on fire. He’s killing penalties well enough and seems to be getting some offensive chances (more recently) … but at a certain point that line just has to create goals. The Penguins need to get some scoring from their third line, and that’s just not happening enough right now. I’ve been preaching patience with Sheahan for a while — it’s not only tough to switch teams, but going from a moribund Red Wings team last year to the two-time defending champs is quite an adjustment — but we’re getting to the point where the wrinkles should be ironed out.
It’s interesting that you reference the 20-game number, too. Jim Rutherford said a few weeks back that that’s how long he usually likes to take before totally assessing his team, though this year may be a bit different because of the Penguins’ brutal schedule to start. Within a couple of weeks, though, Rutherford will probably start assembling a shopping list, and it’s certainly possible that another center is on there.
As for who they’d ship out in a trade, let’s start with the names you mention. Even though Patric Hornqvist will be a free agent this summer, it’d surprise me a great deal if the Penguins moved him. He’s such an integral part of this team, and the way he plays gives the Penguins an edge come playoff time. Rutherford really values him, and I suspect he’s pretty off limits.
Hagelin, though, is another story. The issue there would more likely be whether you can find a willing trade partner. I’m sure Rutherford would be interested in getting his $4 million salary off the books (money that could go into a Hornqvist extension?), but it’s going to be tough to find someone to take on that contract given Hagelin’s subpar offensive production these past two years.
Read More
A more realistic trade chip might be a guy like Tom Kuhnhackl, who has proven he can play in this league, but might be without a lineup spot soon, especially if Daniel Sprong makes the move to Pittsburgh soon. Or if you find the right deal for Sprong, maybe that’s something to consider, as well.
Erica: After watching the Pens since Sullivan took over, it just seems that his pressure/speed system is not sustainable over 82 games in the regular system. The way he wants to play appears to require a lot of energy and is more difficult to perform well when they can’t roll four lines that are offensive threats, which they can’t so far this year. Last year they got away with not playing it well because the shooting percentage was so high. This year they are not getting that same luck. Do you agree and has anyone discussed this issue with Sullivan? Are there tweaks to his system that can be made during the regular system to conserve energy and play more structured defense until they get to March and are making a playoff push?
Sam: First off, thanks for the great question. As for shooting percentage, I tend to think there will be some improvement in that regard over these next few weeks. It might not hit the 10.1 percent they were at last year, but I’d expect it to at least get back up into the 9-9.5 range, which would lead to roughly one more goal per game, on average.
But you make a good point with regard to rolling four lines that are at least mild offensive threats. I don’t think the system is unsustainable, full stop, over the course of 82 games. But the Penguins, as currently constructed, don’t seem to be built for it as well as they were last year. Matt Cullen averaged 13:55 of ice time per game last year as the fourth-line center, while Greg McKegg is at 10:41 through 19 games this season. This not only leads to more ice time for the top two lines, but also makes the Penguins more predictable and easier to defend from a matchups standpoint.
I think what they’re trying to do now to combat that is shaking up the lines — particularly who plays with Crosby and Malkin — on a fairly regular basis. They’re fortunate to have a lot of wingers who can play there, so rotating through those spots allows guys to stay a bit fresher with a more varied workload on a night-to-night basis.
But I’m not sure that’s a long-term answer. Ultimately, If there’s one thing this team needs to figure out over the next few months, it’s how to get at least some consistent offensive production from their bottom six — whether that’s Sheahan figuring it out offensively or making some sort of move to shape up that group.
Jill: Not really a question but I’d love some kind of “a day in the life of a Penguins player” feature. I’ve seen them for other teams but never for the Penguins. I’d love to know what they normally do in a day.
Sam: The truth is probably a bit boring. Especially on game days, most guys go home and nap between the morning skate and the game. But different guys have different routines. I wrote this story last year about how a long playoff run affects guys’ day-to-day lives, so that should provide some sort of peek.
John D.: Is there any truth to the claim made on [Hockey Night in Canada] that Sid is dissatisfied with the lack of veteran replacement done this offseason? The only time I have seen Sid this disinterested is when Johnston was the coach. We saw how that played out.
Sam: Yeah, I’m not going to buy into that one too much. I think Crosby is definitely frustrated with how things have started — particularly on the offensive end — but winning back-to-back Stanley Cups should make it a little easier for him to take a long-term view of things. I also think his performance in Nashville on Saturday night should go a long way toward easing some concerns (even if he didn’t break his goal drought). So far this season, Crosby hasn’t played up to the unbelievably high standard he has set for himself, but the idea that he is somehow disinterested or disgruntled playing for a team that has won two Cups in a row doesn’t hold much water with me.
Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.