Greetings and welcome to the inaugural Penguins mailbag. We’ll be doing this every Monday for the rest of the regular season and playoffs, however long they may go. I can’t do this without you the readers, so I’ll be calling on you for questions, thoughts, concerns or comments on the local hockey club. Feel free to email me at swerner@post-gazette.com or hit me on Twitter at @SWernerPG.
To set the scene, the Penguins are 8-6-2, sitting in third place in the Metropolitan Division. They’re coming off a 1-3-1 swing through Minnesota and Western Canada, which is certainly not ideal, but are still staying afloat in the standings despite a -16 goal differential.
Let’s dive into the questions ...
Brandon Povilitus: Is this Hornqvist’s last season as a Pen?
My Magic 8-Ball says…”Probably.” As background, Hornqvist makes $4.25 million this year, and will become an unrestricted free agent after this season. He’ll turn 31 later this season, and hasn’t shown any signs of starting to wear down. It’s probably a safe bet that, barring injury, he’s on track for another 20-25 goals and 20-30 assists.
Based on those numbers and Hornqvist’s relentless style of play, there’s likely to be a pretty strong market for him in free agency this year — especially if the Penguins make another deep playoff run. As we saw with Nick Bonino and Trevor Daley last offseason, other teams are willing to sweeten the pot for guys who are coming from successful teams. There’s a good chance someone offers more than the Penguins can.
The Penguins also won’t have a whole lot of money to play with this offseason. Last summer, they had Chris Kunitz and Marc-Andre Fleury coming off the books, which opened up some wiggle room. This year, they’ve got Hornqvist, Ian Cole and Ryan Reaves as UFAs, with RFAs like Bryan Rust, Tom Kuhnhackl and Tristan Jarry to (presumably) re-sign.
So logic says it’ll be tough to bring Hornqvist back, but I can’t help shake the feeling that he might be a bit different than your run-of-the-mill UFA for Jim Rutherford. His style of play makes him a really, really tough guy to just go out and replace, and I wouldn’t be surprised if Rutherford at least made a push to sign Hornqvist this offseason. Ultimately, it’ll come down to how much the Penguins are willing to pony up and, probably more so, whether Hornqvist is ready to forgo one last big NHL contract to stay where he won two Stanley Cups. If I had to bet, I’d wager that he’s playing somewhere else next season, because that's how these things usually play out, but I don’t think it’s a foregone conclusion.

Jim R.: What’s going on with the even-strength offense?
It's not scoring enough goals, Jim.
As for why that’s the case, I’d probably have to lean towards just plain bad luck right now. Early on in the road trip, against Minnesota and (especially) Winnipeg, the Penguins weren’t generating chances and weren’t playing with the commitment — Mike Sullivan word there — that they usually do on the offensive end. But by the end of the trip, against Calgary and Vancouver, that had picked up.
They got 44 shots on the Flames, and probably would’ve won that game were it not for a stellar night from Mike Smith. The game against the Canucks seemed like just one of those games, where the team played well but just didn’t get the bounces. That’s why they play 82 of these instead of just 16. These things will even out over time.
The mood around the locker room after Monday’s practice was noticeably different from the team I left in Winnipeg midway through last week. The prevailing wisdom now is that they’re playing well, and just need to be patient and let the goals come.
Tuesday night against the Coyotes should be a good benchmark. Arizona is a bad, bad hockey team. If the Penguins have truly turned a corner and are ready for the dam to burst offensively, it should happen against the Coyotes. If they struggle to score Tuesday, that might raise some red flags, especially with a road trip to Washington and Nashville looming.

Eric Bouchard: Whats going on with 87? Not a dynamic player like he use to be. Taking bad decisions, not shooting the puck, not skating, liable in defensive zone.
On the list of things that would concern me about this year’s Penguins, the play of Sidney Crosby thus far is pretty low on the list. Like, we’re talking Page 12, right after whether Brian Dumoulin is adequately filling his role as locker room DJ (he is).
Has Crosby been dynamic this year? No, not recently. He has no goals in his last eight games, and just three assists in that stretch. He did have two seven-game goal droughts last year — including one in the playoffs — and that year ended just fine for him and the Penguins.
But I think those numbers, as well as the words you used in your question, are reflective of the Penguins as a whole, and not just Crosby. The 5-on-5 offense has been pretty bad team-wide recently, though it showed signs of life towards the end of the Western Canada trip.
Part of the issue is also that Crosby’s linemates have been shuffled around a decent amount over the past few weeks. Even he and Jake Guentzel, one of the pairs Mike Sullivan generally likes to keep together, have been split up. Crosby is obviously good enough to play with just about any of the wingers the Penguins put him with, but some consistency in that regard could help him out.
It’s also worth pointing out that, for as much as he seems like a hockey-playing robot at times, Crosby is human. He’s coming off a two short summers, as well as back-to-back Stanley Cups. His work ethic and ability to self-motivate on a daily basis are, according to coaches and teammates, second to none. But human nature is human nature, and it’s probably not easy to be laser-focused for every second of an early November game against the Canucks.
With Crosby and the rest of the team, as long as they stay in position to make the playoffs, it’s tough to really get to concerned about some ups and downs on a night-to-night (or even week-to-week) basis early in the season.

Brandon Povilitus: Is fair to assume they re-sign Rust to a Sheary-esque deal? (3yrs x 3-3.5mil?)
Two questions for Brandon in the first mailbag! Congratulations, sir.
Coming into the season, I probably would've put Rust’s value just a tad lower than Sheary’s, maybe in the $2.5 million/year range. His quick start to the season made me rethink that, though he has come back down to earth a bit in recent weeks (though, once again, he’s not the only one struggling with offense recently).
You'd like to see some more goals out of Rust this season, but his absurdly low shooting percentage (3.7 percent) makes you think those will come. He’s on pace for 41 assists right now, which is probably a bit high.
Assuming Rust gets back on track when the Penguins figure out their even-strength offense, it’s not unreasonable to set 20 goals and 30-plus assists as the goal for him, which is right around where Sheary was last year.
If that’s the case, Sheary’s deal is probably a good framework for what the Penguins hammer out with Rust this summer.
Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.