It appeared to be an inspired move, really.
Ray Shero, unable to persuade Jordan Staal to accept a new contract from the Penguins, dealt him to Staal’s destination of choice, Carolina, for center Brandon Sutter, defense prospect Brian Dumoulin and the No. 8 pick in the 2012 NHL draft.
Which just happened to be the one about to be made at Consol Energy Center.
Shero invested that choice in a skilled defenseman from the Portland Winterhawks, a smooth skater with impressive offensive skills and instincts.
Derrick Pouliot, it seemed, had a game that would allow him to develop into a perfect fit for the style coach Dan Bylsma wanted the Penguins to play.
Five-plus years, 67 NHL games, 14 points, a plus-minus rating of minus-11 and untold/boundless frustration and disappointment later, it was evident he would not contribute as projected.
Read More
Not with the Penguins, anyway.
Pouliot, like Shero and Bylsma, is off the Penguins’ payroll, having been traded to Vancouver Oct. 3 for defenseman Andrey Pedan and a fourth-round draft choice.
Perhaps he will perform to his perceived potential as a member of the Canucks. Pouliot, who had three assists in his first nine games in Vancouver, wouldn’t be the first player to jump-start his career by changing teams.
Or perhaps he will join the long list of Penguins’ first-round draft choices who failed to live up to expectations.
For every Mario Lemieux or Sidney Crosby or Jaromir Jagr, there has been a Robert Dome or Jamie Heward or Angelo Esposito. Or several of them.
Here’s a look at some of the franchise’s biggest first-round failures, flops and fizzles:
Joe Morrow [2011, 23rd overall] – Less than two years after picking him, the Penguins traded him to Dallas. That’s when he made his biggest contribution to the organization, since the deal netted the third-round draft choice used to draft Jake Guentzel. Morrow never played a game with the Stars, either, and was traded to Boston before joining Montreal after last season.
Beau Bennett [2010, 20th] – His solid skills set convinced the Penguins to claim him, but Bennett, now with St. Louis, gets injured so often that he should travel to road games in a MedEvac helicopter.
Angelo Esposito [2007, 20th] – The Penguins thought they caught a break when Esposito, once the top-rated prospect in his class, fell to them at No. 20, and they were right. They caught a break, all right. A bad one. He was traded to Atlanta in the Marian Hossa-Pascal Dupuis deal less than a year later, then sustained a couple of serious knee injuries and never played in the NHL.
Robert Dome [1997, 17th] – Dome was widely believed to be pretty much NHL-ready when the Penguins claimed him in the first NHL draft held in Pittsburgh, mostly because he had spent the previous season with Las Vegas of the International Hockey League. Turned out he never was NHL-ready and put up just seven goals and seven assists in 52 games with the Penguins and one with Calgary.
Craig Hillier [1996, 23rd] – General manager Craig Patrick hoped he had found the franchise’s goalie of the future, but Hillier never faced a shot in the NHL.
Stefan Bergkvist [1993, 26th] – He looked to be well worth the pick the Penguins used to get him, but a medical misadventure — Bergkvist developed a benign tumor on the hearing nerve on the right side of his head while playing for the Penguins’ farm team in Cleveland — limited him to just seven NHL games.
Jamie Heward [1989, 16th] – Heward spent three seasons in the organization, all in the minor leagues, but eventually was cut loose before logging 394 games in the NHL.
Roger Belanger [1984, 16th] – He was the third first-rounder that year, chosen after they claimed Mario Lemieux [who won’t turn up on this list] and Doug Bodger. He was projected to be a hard-nosed, blue-collar forward with a bit of a scoring touch, but injuries limited him to 44 games in the NHL and ended his career in 1988.
Rich Sutter [1982, 10th] – The Sutter brothers were hockey royalty a few decades ago, ferociously competitive guys pretty much guaranteed to make an impact — literally and otherwise. Rich turned out to be the exception before being reunited with his twin brother, Ron, in Philadelphia, as he failed to put up a single point in nine games with the Penguins.
Gordie Laxton [1975, 13th] – Yeah, predicting how goalies would turn out was tough way back then, too. Laxton appeared in just 17 NHL games over four seasons, going 4-9 with a 5.55 goals-against average.
Garry Swain [1968, 4th] – He recorded one goal and one assist in nine games with the Penguins. Not much production for a guy who selected so high in his draft class.
Steve Rexe [1967, 2nd] – Rexe was the first No. 1 choice in franchise history. And he set an extremely low bar for all who followed, since he never skated a shift in the NHL.
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.