Pens4Life: Jason: Any more chatter in the rumor mill after the Sheahan signing? Injuries starting to pile up. Is the plan to tap into WB or is JR shopping for needs?

Jason Mackey: The rumor mill? Is this an actual place. ... Nothing much in the way of chatter. Hunwick will be back soon. Don't have enough of a grasp on Schultz; concussions make that very, very hard. But I don't think GMJR is shopping for a defenseman if that's way you're asking.

Evgeni Malkin on what he'd like to see improve

Joe: Jason, the line combinations are god awful. I don't understand why Sullivan insists on keeping Sid and the Kids line together despite the fact they've shown this early in the season to have defensive problems. They have a chance to get outworked by a heavy Winnipeg team too. Why does Sullivan refuse to see that Hornqvist is actually the best RW for Sid? I've heard Sid doesn't like playing with him. Is that true? If so, Sullivan should say too bad Sid, it's a combination that works. Also, when will he give Kessel a chance to work with Sheahan? They need to spread the offense out to three lines and Malkin and Kessel also seem like they are on different pages much of the time

Jason Mackey: Joe, I think you need to exhale, my friend. ... Let's let Sheahan play more than one game for the Penguins before we start saying he needs new linemates. 62-15-72 was fine last game, and Kessel & Malkin combined on the game-winner. I do think they'll tinker with Sheahan and Kessel together. I get what you're saying on the three scoring lines, but I don't think there's any sense of urgency there, either. You're right on Sid and Hornqvist. It also hasn't worked with Malkin. Best remaining case has Sid and the Kids or Sid, Guentzel and Rust together on the top line.

Advertise with us

Joe: I love Bengtsson's game and he has been playing real well in WBS. He's a RD who has the skill set to replace Schultz. Why wasn't he called up instead of Corrado?

Jason Mackey: They would like to see Bengtsson develop more. Corrado has more/some NHL experience. Calling up Bengtsson, when he's just going to sit, would disrupt his development.

Joe: Do you think the Pens will be in the market for another center before the deadline? Maybe one with higher offensive skills than Sheahan. I like Sheahan but he had no shots on goal the last game and that's his MO

Jason Mackey: I think they're going to wait and see. I wouldn't rule it out, but Sheahan is a project; we need more than one game to evaluate. If they're getting no bottom-six offense by the deadline ... yeah, I think they will try to upgrade the center spot, provided there are options out there.

Sarah: Future consideration, Jason

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Generally a vague term for contingency picks. For example, if Team X makes the playoffs, Team Y gets a first-rounder. If Team X misses the playoffs, Team Y gets a second-rounder. The bigger terms are generally announced. When it's, say, a seventh-rounder, it's not. Or it can be a combination of picks/players.

guest: Jason, you were so right about Ollie Matta, he is having a great season. I never understood why people have been so hard on him, he has made mistakes but so do all players. Given his young age and all he has been through, he is someone fans should be rallying behind, not criticizing and running out of town!

Jason Mackey: I'm not going to collect my prize yet, but I have said that he looks different and I'm expecting his best season since his rookie year. I think people forget that beat reporters are around these guys EVERY DAY. We don't just watch on TV. Sad it is sometimes is, this is our life. Olli is having an excellent year. Sullivan said yesterday he thinks Maatta's confidence is "at an all-time high." Heck of a statement right there.

caopall: ally

Jason Mackey: I've liked that line. I think it has some personality, and I think with Sheahan in the middle they have a chance to produce. If Hagelin keeps shooting -- his numbers are up there -- and can create some rebounds for Hornqvist, I think that line has the possibility of being very good.

Advertise with us

guest: I feel bad for Scott Wilson, he went from playing on the second line in the Stanley cup, to watching Reaves play 3 to 6 minutes a game while he was in the press box, to going to a team with no chance for the playoffs. Why did he fall so far out of favor?

Jason Mackey: Wilson had the tendency of disappearing, taking too many shifts where he did nothing. Was never sure if it was mental or physical. There would be times -- last postseason, for instance -- where he hits everything that moves. Other times where he shows some goal-scoring touch. Just too many times where he disappears. Finding consistency is so hard. And on a good team, there's rarely the opportunity to wait for guys to do it.

Dev: During the 15-16 playoffs the Pens were lethal with their breakout passes, seems like every offensive possession started with a crisp pass up center ice for a breakaway (exaggerating a little bit). The defense is similar to what it was then, but why haven’t they been able to get back to that kind of puck moving?

Jason Mackey: Interesting question, Dev. I will say I think the breakouts have been improved on the whole with Kris Letang back, but I know what you're saying: It's not what it was. ... To get back to answering, though, it's probably a combination of things. From other teams adjusting, to different personnel (I'll take a healthy Trevor Daley over Chad Ruhwedel, no offense to Chad) to consistency in their overall game, which hasn't always been there this season.

guest: Thanks so much for doing these chats, my favorite part is when you give off the ice/behind the scenes insight that fans might not otherwise hear about. Are the players close off the ice /do they tend to hang out in their free time? Who would you say are the biggest personalities in the locker room?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I love doing these. And I love when I get questions that aren't standard hockey, believe me. ... Yes, these guys do all hang out. Sometimes in weird clicks, too. Like Crosby and Maatta hang out a lot. You usually hear about Sheary, Rust, Kuhnhackl and Wilson (when he was here). Guentzel is kind of a loner. Letang's all over the place with who he hangs with. ... Biggest personalities? Reaves, Cole ... Malkin when he wants to be. Kessel is always good for a laugh.

caopall: Right out of the gate, the Sheanan, Hornqvist, Hagelin line looked like it will be an effective checking line, generally tough to play against and capable of GRINDING out some long shifts. Not sure if those long shifts will translate into more than the occasional dirty goal (Hagelin and Hornqvist just aren't that good skating with the puck). Are long shifts and the occasional goal enough for the 3rd line?

Jason Mackey: Sorry caopall, I think I answered an iteration of this before. Third line needs to score more, and I think these guys are capable. They also need to be responsible defensively, but Sullivan doesn't necessarily believe in a tradition, shutdown third line.

Guest: when you hear about trading players, Matta's name always seemed to get mentioned. Why is it him over other defensemen like Dumolin or Schultz?

Jason Mackey: No clue. I don't know why we keep hearing Maatta's name in the first place. None of the three should be traded, but that hasn't stopped people from wanting to do it.

Advertise with us

caopall: Ruhwedel stepped in and stepped up the other night. Can we expect the same from Trotman (and maybe Corrado)? What is\are Trotman's strengths? What is the scouting report?

Jason Mackey: Trotman is a bigger guy. Can hit some. Makes the safe place. An OK skater. He might mix it up some. Trotman strikes me as a bright guy. One of the things that has led to Ruhwedel's success is that he knows his limits. i think Trotman is similar. That goes along way when filling in back there -- not over-exposing yourself to anything.

TheTrout: Hey, Jason. the Corrado trade was a head scratcher for which I never heard adequate explanation. Did we really give up Eric Fehr AND Steve Oleksy AND a fourth-rounder for this guy? Is he seen as one of those unlimited-potential guys, or was JR just desperate to dump Fehr's modest salary? The two games Corrado was up last year, he looked bewildered by the sport of hockey.

Jason Mackey: I think they viewed Oleksy as expendable, and they wanted to dump Fehr's salary. In hindsight I think they would probably like to have Fehr as the 4C right now, but you do what you have to do at the time. ... I'm going to refrain calling Corrado a success or failure. I've seen him play so little. He's a young defenseman that they're trying to revive a bit. That takes time. I think we still may be in the process of that. I.e. Let's try to hold our judgement.

Guest: Do you think the Pens SHOULD try to re-sign Hornqvist before the trade deadline, and if they can't, should they move to trade him? I like him a lot and we don't have any players like him, but is he a fit on this team if he's not playing with Sid or Geno and is commanding 5+ million per year salary?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think they should try. I don't think they'll be successful. If I'm Hornqvist -- where I've scored consistently, won two Cups and can hit the market in a serious position of strength -- why wouldn't I cash in? Teams overpay for players all the time. I'm not talking about going to a junk team, but if I'm him, you better believe I'm going to see what the offers are before I commit to anything, especially if it's going to be my last big contract.

Guest: Why doesn't Sullivan try to run three scoring lines again, as he'd ideally like, by playing Hagelin-Sheahan-Kessel as the third line?

Jason Mackey: He might. Sheahan has had one game here. How much tinkering do you want him to do during the guy's first game?

OHIO412FAN: Jason, with the Pens looking very solid overall as of now, one weak spot for them is Goaltending. How will they shake that out? Will Jarry and DeSmith emerge as solid goalies behind Murray? Injuries are looking problematic for them right now. Any updates on Hunwick and g

Jason Mackey: Hunwick has been skating on his own. I'm thinking next Wednesday in Edmonton for him. Reason: Doubt they practice tomorrow. He'll need to practice, take contact and respond to gain proper clearance. Can't do that with a (possible/likely) day off, then back-to-backs and another day off. I think maybe Hunwick takes Saturday's morning skate, adds contact Tuesday at practice and returns Wednesday. Again, just my (informed) opinion.

Advertise with us

OHIO412FAN: Sorry for the typo. Are you seeing any interesting developments amongst the Pens prospect pool going on right now?

Jason Mackey: Daniel Sprong and Zach Aston-Reese. Funny how those work, huh? ZAR has been really quiet. As for Sprong, I'll have something more on him tomorrow, but he's killing it down there. To the point where, if this keeps up, then he's going to make it very tough for management in December if the Penguins are struggling to score; soon there will talk of Sprong's promotion. They are very happy with him right now.

OHIO412FAN: What do the Penguins need to do in order to achieve the quest for a three-peat? Anything you think they could improve on right now?

Jason Mackey: Sure, plenty. Backup goaltending has to be better. They need to allow fewer shots on goal, which they could do by improving their overall team defense and puck management. PK has become wobbly again. They've stunk on the second night of back-to-backs and haven't played terribly well on the road. There's a few things anyway.

HB: Well it was fun while it lasted but pens injured season is upon us I have no doubt they will overcome but it be nice if important players would stop getting hurt.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Ha. As Mike Sullivan would say, it's a belligerent game.

Carl Hagelin : I'm back, baby!

Jason Mackey: Carl, it's so good to seeeee you!

HB: It be nice if the pens had secured will butcher could of sold him on the fact with our injury luck you will be up in 2 weeks from WBS

Jason Mackey: They tried, believe me. Nothing they can do if the player wants to play right away. Butcher did. His camp denied it, but he did. Devils offered the clearest path.

Advertise with us

HB: It’s a long season but when do you think they will try sheanan with Phil so we can go back to having 3 dangerous lines

Jason Mackey: Right now they're happy with 62-15-72. ... Again, right now. If it doesn't perform, I think they will try. But we have to give Sheahan more than one game here before we want to change his line, right?

HB: When is sam getting his chat he be the second best chat at the post gazette only behind you of course

Jason Mackey: Ha. Thanks. I'm told he'll be starting a Monday mailbag.

HB: When sprong gets pulled up who’s line do you see him playing on Crosby malkin or sheanan

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Don't know yet. Maybe Malkin if Kessel and Sheahan work, just because of his shot and how much of a weapon that would be for Malkin. I'm not sure his game -- which resembles Kessel more than anyone else -- would mesh all that well with Crosby, although I could be wrong.

Greenville SC: I love this Pens team, but as presently constructed, it seems like we don't have enough margin for error to win the cup again. Goaltending may be a solvable problem in house. However,while it seems the third line can be pretty good at defense and forechecking and puck possession, I'm not sure anyone on the third and 4th lines has good enough hands to set up the bangers or put the puck in the net. What say you? Will we get enough even strength production out of the bottom 6?

Jason Mackey: I worry about the offensive production coming from the fourth line. They're not getting much -- that group has had one good game out of 10 -- but I'm not ready to punt yet and say they need to make a trade. Sheahan will be a huge upgrade at 3C. Watch this move. I think it's going to pan out very well. There's a lot inside of him that didn't come out in Detroit. Goaltending will be fine. Murray's one of the best. Jarry and DeSmith are both capable. It's more a team/defense issue ... provided you don't employ Antti Niemi.

Dave: Do the pens keep shopping for another center to anchor that 4th line? Rowney or Mckegg really don’t seem like they are up to the task. Maybe, we are spoiled from having Cullen for the past couple of years?

Jason Mackey: Well, you are spoiled from having Cullen. But GMJR is going to wait and see. No need to make a move now, but yeah, if they're not getting offense from the fourth line, expect them to do something. They know -- probably better than anyone -- how much their center depth contributed to those Cups.

Advertise with us

PENS IN SC: What do you think GMJR's long term plans are for back-up goalie?

Jason Mackey: I think he's going to keep an eye on the market. I also think it could be DeSmith or Jarry. I don't think GMJR would have a problem if, say, DeSmith came in and took the job. He gets first crack. If he doesn't get it done, they'll go to Tristan. If he doesn't get it done, they probably make a trade. Next year ... that's too far off with this team.

Charlotte John: Jason, Thanks for the chat! Love the Sheahan pick up. Looks like a backup G will be on the radar. As the team stands now (barring injuries) will the Pens need any additions at the trade deadline. Looks like this team can focus on streanthening as a team....instead of wondering who may be added/moved at some point this year. Go Pens and love the direction they are heading.

Jason Mackey: I would keep a defenseman in mind, for the reason we're seeing now; you almost can't explain it, but they always get hurt. I'd be monitoring backup goaltender and fourth-line center, in case McKegg/Rowney don't add something offensively over the next, say, six weeks.

Dave: When do the pens bring up Pedan to see what he can bring to the team?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think it's close. But right now they want to see what they have with Trotman, and they want to allow Pedan to get acclimated. I don't think it's far off.

O. Matta: I see now some are saying I am too serious and need to lighten up. You’d think I could get some slack after my excellent start? Geez

Jason Mackey: Haha. I didn't say you needed to lighten up. I said Reaves' outgoing personality was good because you need a few of those to go with the quiet guys like yourself.

Penguins defensemen discuss injuries and the schedule

Frankie C: I apparently can skate pretty well, but what else do I bring to the table?

Jason Mackey: Honestly, Frankie, I haven't seen enough of you to say.

Advertise with us

JamesinNYC: Would you like to take a bow for the Sheahan signing?

Jason Mackey: No way. I'm not a fan of celebrating myself or crowing about something. Just hoping to do good work and have yinz guys read it.

Jason Mackey: Yinz guys and gals, I should say.

Sal: Sprong is really doing well in the AHL. Why not bring him up and put him on Crosby's line instead of Sheary?

Jason Mackey: Because Sheary is second on the team in goals with four and scoring at a better clip than he did last season? He's also producing shots and shot attempts at a better rate, if I'm not mistaken. Again, they want Sprong to develop more and get his confidence. He's doing that. Just because he's scored a couple goals doesn't mean their goals change. In fact, my Friday story on Sprong focuses on an adjustment they had him make down there that explains why this move was important.

Advertise with us

Billy: Murray in net tonight?

Jason Mackey: Yes.

dave: Do you think they're going to bring in a veteran to backup Murray?

Jason Mackey: They might. I think they're going to give DeSmith and Jarry a chance to win the job first.

TK: How serious are they about signing the winger from the KHL that is friends with Malkin?

Jason Mackey: They inquired. Due diligence. I don't think anything is imminent at this point. I don't think they need him.

Glenn: Another trade coming anytime soon

Jason Mackey: I don't think so, Glenn. I think you'll see them try to find some consistency with this group here for a bit.

Nancy Selene: Hi Jason - do you expect Murray to start tonight? Go Pens!

Jason Mackey: Yep. Murray will start.

Dale: Do you think the penguins add another center down the line?

Jason Mackey: Tough to say. As I've answered, I think you need to see what McKegg and Rowney are going to give you at the 4C spot. If they don't produce, then yeah, I think that's a position they could address at the trade deadline.

Jerry: If Sullivan had total control over personnel, do you think he'd opt to have Malkin and Kessel off the team? I'm a fan of both players but sense their inconsistency at times is because they are being driven to play in a manner less suited for highly skilled forwards.

Jason Mackey: No, no and no. They present their challenges, sure, especially Phil. But there is way more good than bad here.

Cj: What ever happened to the Zaripov rumors?

Jason Mackey: They weren't rumors. They checked. They needed to see where the Sheahan deal went before they did anything, which I reported. At this point I think they view Zaripov as an unnecessary add. Would probably be better to keep the cash in hand just in case you need to go backup goaltender shopping.

Guest: Any reasonable explanation beyond body-swapping that Malkin's PIM is so low and Crosby's is so high?

Jason Mackey: Ha. The 10-minute misconduct had something to do with that, but yeah, the captain has been hit with a few. One, honestly, I think is the rules crackdown. Even refs watch Crosby more than other players. I think they're paying more attention to what he's doing out there, and it's costing him with stuff like this.

Chuck B.: As I sit at work in D.C. with my last 2 year Stanley Cup lanyards on... I am amazed that everyone is panicking so early in the year. Please tell everyone to relax. We are back to back CHAMPS for goodness sake.

Jason Mackey: Ha. Appreciate the comment, Chuck. But I'm not sure it would be a Pittsburgh sports fan base without at least some semblance of panic at all times. I love that about our town, believe me. Not knocking it. But there does always seem to be some sense of worry.

Dev: Also, it’s hard to knock a guy who’s leading the team in points, but is it me or is Malkin maybe not as good as he was the last 2 years? He seems to be turning the puck over a lot more than usual, and at points it looks like he doesn’t care to put in the effort to back check - he will just watch a guy blow right by him. It’s early and maybe it’s the typical struggles that teams and players face early on, but it’s just a thought

Jason Mackey: I don't disagree with you, Dev. I find it kind of odd that Malkin leads the team in points because by no means do I think he's been their best player. He's been a little up and down for the reasons that you mentioned. I think there's a lot more there. We see this with Malkin, though, especially early in the season. Nothing that raises alarm bells for me. It's October hockey.

Dev: This may have been answered already and I apologize if it has. But what’re your thoughts on the growth of Sprong thus far? I’m highly impressed with his ability to score from the left circle. Kind of like Ovechkin, it seems like it’s one of those things that can’t be stopped even though teams know it’s coming.

Jason Mackey: Yeah, it's definitely similar. I think a lot of Sprong. He's been working in the AHL again, refining his shot. It's truly nasty. I think he's very, very close in terms of getting promoted, but I give him credit for sort of going back to the drawing board and paying attention to stuff other than his shot to become more well-rounded.

Max: Following the Sheahan acquisition, a popular talking point both in the media and from the organization is that they have a strong record recently of rehabbing/fixing players. Justin Schultz certainly qualifies. However, Carl Hagelin often gets included on this list. While his first few months in Pittsburgh were a vast improvement, his larger sample with the Pens is...pretty much the player he's been his whole career. Did the Pens fix him then break him again? Other players often included in this narrative include Daley and Kessel, who both were pretty much played to their career norms in black and gold. Is it possible this talking point is largely overblown? The facts don't really seem to support it.

Jason Mackey: Hey Max. Couple things. One, Daley was in a bad spot in Chicago. He'd be the first one to tell you that. As for Hagelin, I actually talked to him about this the other day. He disagreed with the idea that he needed fixed when he got here, which is fair. He said he had been trending in the right direction for two weeks before the deal. As for this season, I've been impressed by Hagelin. Last year was bad, I'll give you that. But if he scores a few -- his shots and chances are up -- I'm not sure we're labeling this year as a failure.

Dev: Once again thanks for answering my questions, I look forward to these every week and I really appreciate your insight. Cheers.

TGA: If Hunwick and Schultz were to be out long-term, would the Pens move for a dman or just call players up?

Jason Mackey: My pleasure. Thanks for participating.

Jason Mackey: Hunwick is going to be out long-term, No. 1. Two, I think it's a little too premature to consider a move. They have some guys -- Trotman, Summers, Corrado, Pedan -- that they'd like to see first.

Tristan: Do the Penguins have any interest in VGK's center Shipaychov (perhaps if Vegas retains some salary)?

Jason Mackey: I haven't heard anything to substantiate that. Not to say it doesn't exist, but I haven't heard aything.

Jason Mackey: *anything

Jerry: I agree there is way more good than bad with Malkin and Kessel. My question is whether Sullivan truly believes it. The affection for the Rust - types far exceeds their talents.

Jason Mackey: I hear ya, Jerry. Know where you were going. But I think you need to have the Malkin and Kessel types to help the Rust types; the latter probably doesn't exist without the former, and Sullivan is smart enough to know that. He also knows that you're going to have to put more effort into some players than others. Part of his job.

dave: If Niemmi had cleared waivers, what do you think they would have done with him? I think sending him to WBS would have just slowed the growth of Jarry.

Jason Mackey: It wouldn't have impacted Jarry in any way, Dave. ... Unless Niemi was contagious with something. Niemi wouldn't have been taking Jarry's starts. He would have slotted into Casey DeSmith's role, and everything would have remained the same. So, yes, I think they would have sent Niemi to WBS had he not been claimed.

Brandon: Do you think Hagelin/Sheehan/Cole etc. can be as effective on the PK as Daley/Bonino/Cullen? They've seemed to accept the roll but we've seen a mixture of guys which is a little different than last year's identity of having a solid PK

Jason Mackey: Cole has been a fixture on the PK pretty much since he's been here but definitely last season. Hagelin, too. The question here is whether Sheahan will give them enough on the PK to stack up against Bonino and Cullen. I think he will. He's been very good on faceoffs, and I think his size provide an extra element, something you didn't have with the other guys. Until Rowney gets back, however, I worry more about McKegg in that other center spot.

Hollywood: Thanks for all the great Pens coverage Jason, one of the big reasons I am happy to subscribe to P-G. What is it that allows Letang to skate the crazy minutes game after game, season after season? Maniacal workout regimen? Wise use of energy during game? Gift from God? All of the above?

Jason Mackey: Thank you for your kind words. We're happy and lucky to have you. You pretty much hit the nail on the head with Letang. He's crazy about his conditioning and nutrition. He's also just a freak when it comes to his God-given abilities. Mike Sullivan also likes to talk about Letang being economical with his energy. ... Another storyline that came out this summer, with them wanting Letang to cut bait when something isn't there ... I think he's done very well with that.

Brandon: Thanks for the reply! Not sure if you remember but Rob introduced me to you and Bombulie in the office, and I said "oh yeah I've probably read your guys' stuff." I got home, followed you guys on Twitter and the rest is history.

Jason Mackey: I do remember. Vaguely. That was a couple jobs ago for me. But thank you very much for reading. It's never not appreciated, trust me.

Brandon: Thanks for the reply! I'm not sure if you remember, but Rob introduced me to you and Bombulie a couple years ago, and I said, "oh yeah I'm sure I've read some of your stuff." Went home, followed you guys and Twitter and been reading every word ever since. Anyways, I was also wondering if you think Hagelin is fine with primarily being a penalty killer. He has shown flashes of offensive prowess before, but last season was a train wreck for him offensively. You think he's okay with the PK role?

Jason Mackey: I do. He's never really been a big power play guy, and on this team, he doesn't have much of a case to be one, honestly. Especially if he has a similar conversion rate to last year. Sullivan has shown a preference toward a 3F, 2D look on that second unit. Rust, Sheary and Guentzel are all worthy and have produced. Sheahan will get a look. Just not a huge need for him to play on the PP here.

Hollywood: Do you think Pouliot will be just another "can't miss" guy that the Pens let go and don't really miss (e.g. Simon Despres et al)

Jason Mackey: From what I've seen of Derrick Pouliot in Vancouver, the Penguins are in zero dangerous of regretting the trade any time soon.

Guest: Are any refs being harder on faceoff infractions than other refs are being? Some games guys are getting kicked for barely any foot movement and in others the guy can fully turn so his foot is in the circle as the ref drops the puck and nothing is called. Have some refs started letting these infractions slide again while others haven't or am I just missing something? Saw it a few times during tuesday's penguins game even. Thanks for any clarification on this.

Jason Mackey: You're right. Was actually talking to Letang about this a week or so ago. Not necessarily about faceoffs but about the slashing crackdown. There's a tremendous amount of inconsistency from ref-to-ref. Letang actually said he's started looking at the refs ahead of time to know what kind of game it's going to be. That's not great. You should have some consistency in the approach, but that seems to be lacking at this point.

Jason Mackey: Alright folks. That does it. Thanks so much for participating. Looking forward to doing this again next week!